AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 25 of Societies Registration Act
  • Section 107/116 and 145, 146, Cr. P.C
  • Order 40, Rule 4, C.P.C
  • Order 40, Rule 1, C.P.C
  • Section 92 C.P.C
  • Rule 3(d)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 25 of Societies Registration Act
  • Section 107/116 and 145, 146, Cr. P.C
  • Order 40, Rule 4, C.P.C
  • Order 40, Rule 1, C.P.C
  • Section 92 C.P.C
  • Rule 3(d)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by Sri Dilip Kumar Sharma (claiming to be Secretary/Pradhan Mantri of the Committee of Management of Sri Giriraj Sewak Samiti, Bara Bazar, Goverdhan, Mathura) and Sri Devendra Kumar Sharma seeking quashing of the plaint in Original Suit No. 332 of 1999 and certain orders of the trial Court, including the appointment of a receiver and orders excluding non-Gudhania Brahmins from participating in auctions (thekas) of temple income. They also sought directions to permit both Gudhania and non-Gudhania Brahmins in future auctions as per the society by-laws.

Background facts in the petition: the Giriraj Ji Maharaj Temple was built and historically managed by heirs of Sri Sankatha Baba, an Adivasi Brahmin. Temple management and income were divided into four thoks. A registered society with a 21-member management committee was in place, including representatives from the thoks and nominations. Disputes about rights to manage and share temple income led to earlier litigation (Original Suit No. 44 of 1970 — Har Prasad v. Giriraj) which was dismissed in 1977 and whose appeal was dismissed in 1981; a second appeal (No. 649 of 1982) is pending before the High Court.

Elections for the committee and office-bearers took place in various years (1998, 1999, 2000, 2001) with competing claims about validly elected office-bearers and related registration/refusal by the Deputy Registrar and findings by the prescribed authority under Section 25 of the Societies Registration Act. Original Suit No. 332 of 1999 was filed by Sri Govind Prasad Purohit seeking injunctions related to administration, management and operation of temple accounts. Interim injunction initially rejected, then remanded by the appellate court with direction to maintain status quo; this Court affirmed that remand but left open points to be raised before the trial Court.

The trial Court, instead of promptly deciding the injunction application on remand, appointed a receiver on 8-11-2002 (Dr. Rajesh Singh, a serving judicial officer) to manage the temple and its accounts, permitted the receiver to auction monthly thekas and to spend funds. Subsequent interim orders restricted participation in auctions to Gudhania Brahmins only, pending disposal of objections. The receiver auctioned the theka for 23-1-2003 to 22-2-2003 which was approved by the trial Court. Later, the first receiver resigned and the trial Court appointed Sri Vineet Narain as receiver without issuing notice to the defendants; the present writ petition challenged the plaint and the orders appointing receiver and excluding non-Gudhania Brahmins from auctions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court erred in appointing a receiver (initially a serving judicial officer) and continuing appointments and auctions without first deciding the injunction application and the question of the plaintiff's right to represent the society.
  2. Whether a serving judicial officer can properly be appointed or continue as a receiver in court proceedings concerning private disputes over management of society/temple property.
  3. Whether the trial Court's interim decision excluding non-Gudhania Brahmins from participating in thekas was justified in the circumstances.
  4. Whether the High Court should interfere with the appointment of the subsequent receiver (Sri Vineet Narain) given the procedural history and objections.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Defendants in suit) Arguments

  • The plaintiff/respondent (Sri Govind Prasad Purohit) has no right to represent the society: the elections he relied upon were not accepted by the Prescribed Authority (order dated 11-2-2000) and no successful challenge to that order has been shown.
  • The suit filed by respondent is not maintainable because returns regarding elections in 1999, 2000 and 2001 were not submitted and the Deputy Registrar refused registration of certain election returns.
  • The trial Court proceeded to appoint a receiver and permit auctions instead of deciding the injunction application on remand, thereby acting illegally and against judicial norms.
  • A serving judicial officer (Dr. Rajesh Singh) was improperly appointed as receiver; his appointment exposed him to potential personal liability and was inappropriate.
  • The receiver exceeded authority by conducting religious functions and excluding non-Gudhania Brahmins from participating in the thekas.
  • The subsequent appointment of Sri Vineet Narain as receiver was made without notice to the defendants and was done to circumvent the High Court's earlier observations; the new receiver is said to be close to the plaintiff-respondent.

Respondent (Plaintiff in suit No. 332 of 1999) Arguments

  • Respondent contends he was elected as President/Mantri (dates asserted) and that returns and election validity are matters under challenge before the High Court (Writ Petition No. 9601 of 2000); he denies elections in 2000–2001 as alleged by petitioners.
  • In earlier suit No. 44 of 1970, courts below found that only Gudhania Brahmins had the right to manage and take part in the thekas; those findings are recorded in the earlier litigation and second appeal is pending.
  • The receiver (initially appointed) was appointed with consent of parties in the trial Court and no objection was taken to the receiver's day-to-day management at the trial Court stage; Sri Vineet Narain was presented as a public-spirited person and the defendants had not objected before the trial Court to his appointment.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court reviewed the procedural history and the trial Court's conduct and reached the following core analytical conclusions (based entirely on the text of the opinion):

  1. Trial Court's priorities were misplaced: the trial Court "completely misdirected itself" by taking an extraordinary interest in appointing and empowering a receiver and organizing the monthly thekas instead of deciding the injunction application which had been remanded for fresh consideration by the appellate Court and affirmed by the High Court. The High Court emphasized that the injunction application necessarily required consideration of the plaintiff's right to represent the society and thus should have been decided first unless delay would cause irreparable harm or waste.
  2. Effect of prior litigation and prima facie res judicata: the Court noted the earlier suit (Original Suit No. 44 of 1970) and subsequent dismissals on appeal, with a second appeal pending. The earlier findings—particularly that the society's constitution and management rights were in respect of Gudhania and Kuchania Brahmins to the exclusion of non-Gudhania Brahmins—were described as prima facie operating as res judicata between the parties and therefore material to the trial Court's consideration of the injunction and the right to manage the temple.
  3. Statutory framework for receivers: the Court explained the statutory scheme for appointment of receivers under Order 40, Rules 1–4, C.P.C — a receiver may be appointed where just and convenient for management, protection, preservation or improvement of suit property; remuneration, security and liabilities are governed by the Rules, including liability for loss by willful default or negligence enforceable under Rule 4 (attachment and sale of personal property) and possible criminal proceedings.
  4. Unfitness of serving judicial officers to act as receivers: the Court held that serving judicial officers should not be appointed or should not accept appointment as receivers in private disputes of this character. The reasons given (as stated in the opinion) include:
    • Judicial officers hold positions that require unimpeachable fairness and impartiality; their conduct is subject to higher standards and Conduct Rules.
    • Appointment as receiver exposes them to risks of civil liability (attachment and sale of personal property under Rule 4), enforcement of accounts, and potential criminal proceedings arising from alleged mismanagement; this is undesirable and may subject them to scrutiny and embarrassment.
    • In private disputes, allegations against a receiver may lead to awkward scrutiny by fellow judicial officers of different ranks, creating institutional discomfort and practical difficulties.
    On this ground the Court strongly directed that henceforth no serving judicial officer of any rank should be appointed or continued as receiver by any subordinate Court and ordered that a copy of this direction be sent to the Registrar General for communication to all District Judges in the State.
  5. Treatment of the specific appointment(s): although the Court found that a judicial officer should not have accepted appointment and took strong exception to the appointment of Dr. Rajesh Singh as receiver, it declined to set aside the subsequent appointment of Sri Vineet Narain as receiver at that stage because the Court had already granted liberty to the petitioners to object to his appointment in the trial Court and because the record showed police proceedings and reports (under Sections 107/116 and 145/146 Cr.P.C) indicating tensions arising from theka allocations. The Court therefore did not interfere with the appointment of the current receiver.
  6. Directions to the trial Court: given the trial Court's failure to decide the injunction application on remand, the High Court directed the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Mathura to decide the pending injunction application in Suit No. 332 of 1999 expeditiously — preferably within two months — and to determine whether plaintiffs have a prima facie case, the balance of convenience, and hardship to parties. The trial Court was instructed to take into account prior findings in earlier litigation and the society constitution when deciding who has the right to manage the temple.

Holding and Implications

WRIT PETITION PARTLY ALLOWED.

Direct holdings and immediate consequences (as stated in the opinion):

  • The High Court partly allowed the writ petition, principally because the trial Court misdirected itself by appointing and empowering a receiver and allowing the thekas to continue without deciding the injunction application remanded by the appellate Court and affirmed by the High Court.
  • The Civil Judge (Senior Division), Mathura is directed to decide the pending injunction application in Suit No. 332 of 1999 expeditiously, preferably within two months, considering prima facie case, balance of convenience, hardship, prior findings between the parties, and whether any party has the right to manage the temple under the society's constitution. There shall be no order as to costs.
  • The High Court issued a general directive: henceforth no serving judicial officer of any rank should be appointed or continued as a receiver by any subordinate Court. A copy of this direction is to be sent to the Registrar General for communication to all District Judges in the State.
  • The High Court declined to interfere with the appointment of the current receiver (Sri Vineet Narain) given that the petitioners had been given liberty to object in the trial Court and because of the contemporaneous police proceedings and tensions relating to theka allocations.

Broader implications:

  • The Court's directive against appointment of serving judicial officers as receivers constitutes a clear administrative/judicial instruction to subordinate courts in the State; it is framed as a rule of institutional propriety to avoid subjecting judicial officers to personal risk and to avoid institutional embarrassment. This is an explicit policy direction contained in the judgment.
  • If adopted by other courts or applied consistently, this direction will restrict the pool of persons subordinate courts may consider for appointment as receivers in private disputes concerning management of society/temple property.

If any specific subsequent orders or appellate outcomes are relevant, they were not set out in the provided opinion.

    Dilip Kumar Sharma And Another v. Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Mathura And Others

    1. By this writ petition, Sri Dilip Kumar Sharma, claiming himself to be Secretary/Pradhan Mantri of Committee of Management, Sri Giriraj Sewak Samiti, Bara Bazar, Goverdhan, Mathura (in short ‘Society’), and Sri Devendra Kumar Sharma have prayed for a writ of certiorari for quashing the plaint of Original suit No. 332 of 1999 pending in the Court of Civil Judge, (Senior Division), Mathura; orders dated 8-11-2002 appointing Dr. Rajesh Singh as receiver; and orders dated 20-12-2002 and 21-1-2003 by which the trial Court has denied non-Godhania Brahmins of Bara Bazar, Goverdhan, Mathura, from making bid at the auction of income of Thakur Giriraj Ji Maharaj Temple (in short Temple). They have also prayed for a direction to respondents 1 and 2 to hold auction of the temple permitting both Gudhania and non-Gudhania Brahmins in all future auctions of Tekas as per by-laws and to issue any other writ, order or direction.

    2. Brief facts as set out in the writ petition are stated as follows: Sri Giriraj Ji Maharaj Temple was constructed at Danghati, Goverdhan, by Sri Sankatha Baba, a Adivasi Brahmin of Goverdhan. After his death his heirs continued to manage the temple and perform sevapuja and bhograj which was subsequently divided into four different parts known as ‘thoks’, namely Udho thok, Madho thok, Murali thok and Narain thok. In the year 1957, a society was registered with a constitution including the representatives of all the aforesaid thoks. A twenty one members committee is provided under the by-laws consisting of 6 : 3 : 4 : 4; representatives of the aforesaid thoks and these 17 representatives nominate 4 members. The members of the Committee of Management include both Gudhania and Non-Gudhania Brahmins of Bara Bazar. It appears that some disputes arose between the members and an Original Suit No. 44 of 1970; Har Prasad v. Giriraj was filed, in which rights of the parties to have a share in the management and the income of the temple was in issue. The suit was dismissed by order and decree dated 15-9-1977 against which a Civil Appeal No. 281 of 1977 was filed. The appeal was also dismissed on 13-11-1981. A Second Appeal No. 281 of 1977 was filed. The appeal was also dismissed on 13-11-1981. A Second Appeal No. 649 of 1982 against the aforesaid judgment and decree has been filed and is pending before this Court in which no interim orders have been passed. Elections to elect 17 members of the committee of management were held in the year 1998. These members nominated four members in accordance with constitution. Thereafter the election of the office bearers of the committee of management were held on 15-4-1998 in which Sri Jamuna Prasad Kaushik was elected as President and Govind Prasad Purohit as Mantri. It is alleged that fresh elections were held for election of members of the committee of management on 24-4-1999 in which petitioner was elected as Mantri/Pradhan Mantri and documents were sent to Deputy Registrar. Firms and Societies Chits, Agra for registration and were registered on 6-11-1999. Sri Govind Prasad Purohit filed writ petition No. 48227 of 1999 which was disposed of with direction of Registrar to refer the matter under Section 25 of the Act. The Prescribed Authority by his order dated 11-2-2000 recorded finding that the elections were invalid. Aggrieved Govind Prasad Purohit has filed writ petition No. 9601 of 2000 which is still pending and no interim orders has been passed. It is contended that elections were also held in 2000 and in these elections also petitioner Dilip Kumar Sharma was elected Mantri/Pradhan Mantri. The documents sent for registration, however, were refused by the Deputy Registrar. It is further contended that in the year 2001 once again petitioner was elected but the list of newly duly elected members of the committee was not accepted by the Deputy Registrar.

    3. Original Suit No. 332 of 1999 has been filed by Sri Govind Prasad Purohit claiming to be Mantri/Pradhan Mantri of the Samiti for permanent injunction restraining defendants from interfering in the rights of the plaintiff's society in administration and management of the temple and specially operation of accounts by Govind Prasad Purohit Mantri, Bara Bazar, Goverdhan and for holding meeting, Bhent, thoks and for any other benefits which the Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case. An application for interim injunction was initially rejected. A Misc. Appeal No. 19 of 2000 was filed which was allowed and the matter was remanded back and in the meantime the parties were directed to maintain status quo. Aggrieved against the order petitioner filed writ petition 6162 of 2001 which was dismissed by this Court on 26-6-2001. A contention was raised by petitioner in the said writ petition that during the pendency of the suit fresh elections have been held and that appellate Court was not justified to grant any injunction. This Court while dismissing the writ petition make it open to petitioner to raise these points before the Court concerned which has to consider the matter afresh in pursuance of the order of remand by appellate Court.

    4. On 27-2-2001, the defendants informed the Court that the High Court has decided the matter on 26-2-2001. It was pointed out to the Court by the plaintiff that the defendants want to adjourn and delay the matter to continue to receive the offerings in the temple. The defendants offered to give statement of account with effect from 16-10-2001 provided plaintiff also gives statement of account up to 16-10-2000. Counsel for the plaintiff agreed to give the accounts provided the account books which have been kept by the Station House Officer Goverdhan under lock in temple area given to him, and requested that the Station House Officer may be required to produce account books. The trial Court directed that plaintiff shall produce the accounts up to 16-10-2000. A direction was issued to the Station House Officer Goverdhan to submit his report whether the account books are under his lock and key. By the same order dated 27-2-2001, defendants were also directed to submit account book on 26-10-2000. On 28-3-2001, the trial Court found from the report of the police that no such lock, as alleged by plaintiff, has been put by police on the temple and that the police has no control over the temple premises and the record room. Both the parties agreed that senior Advocate Sri Lalta Prasad Garg, may be appointed to prepare a list of documents. With the consent of parties, Sri Garg was appointed as Commissioner to prepare the list of account books with regard to realization from 10-5-1999 to 16-10-2000 and to produce them in Court and also permit both the parties to put their locks on the room.

    5. On 7-11-2002, the trial Court considered the application of the defendants dated 28-10-2002 with a prayer to appoint any senior judicial officer as receiver of the temple. The plaintiff did not object to the application. On this application, the trial Court directed that the parties may approach the District Judge, Mathura for appointment of any judicial officer as receiver. The District Judge nominated Dr. Rajesh Singh, Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (Railways), Mathura and on his nomination, with the consent of parties, the Civil Judge appointed him on 8-11-2002 with the condition that his appointment may be approved by the High Court on the next date. On 13-11-2002, the trial Court passed an order that the receiver will take entire charge of the temple from Naib Tehsildar, Mathura including books and accounts and is permitted to spend up to Rs. 10,000/- for the management of the temple. He was permitted to take co-operation of one or more persons for management and will be authorised to auction the theka for every month and deposit the amount in the bank account of the temple.

    6. Thereafter it appears that several orders were passed with regard to giving permissions to the receiver for management of the temple and its properties and for causing necessary repairs for purchase of pumping sets etc. and to pay salaries to a teachers of college run by Society. The trial Court did not take any interest in disposal of application for injunction, in pursuance of the remand order passed by appellate Court and affirmed by this Court. On 20-12-2002, an objection was taken by Gudhania Brahmins that non-Gudhania Brahmins do not have a right to participate in the auction as customary auction can be settled only in favour of Gudhania Brahmins. The trial Court found that since only Gudhania Brahmins have been taking theka in the past, as an interim arrangement, only they will be allowed to participate and fixed 24-12-2002 for disposal of the application. Thereafter it appears that the said interim arrangement continued on 21-1-2003. The receiver auctioned the theka for the period 23-1-2003 to 22-2-2003 for Rs. 7,78,000/-. The said theka was approved by the trial Court. On 30-1-2003, the trial Court granted permission to receiver to purchase certain articles of silver and idols and to install them after the religious ceremonies. It is at this stage that the defendants have filed this writ petition to quash the plaint and the orders for appointment of receiver and for allowing only Gudhania Brahmins to participate in the theka.

    7. On 17-2-2003 while issuing notice this Court observed as follows:

    “It is not desirable for a sitting Judicial Officer to be appointed as a ‘Receiver’ on account of the fact (a) that he is answerable to the Court, which is the Court of coordinate jurisdiction in the same district; and (b) that he can also be subjected to criminal liability and his personal properties can be made liable in case he fails to submit accounts or fails to pay the amount or to any loss to the property by his wilful default or gross negligence, as provided under Order 40, Rule 4, C.P.C The parties shall address the Court on the question whether a sitting judicial officer can be appointed as a ‘Receiver’ in any Court proceedings.”

    8. When the matter came up today, it was found that no reply has been filed by the receiver. Both the parties are not interested in making submissions on the question whether a sitting judicial officer can be appointed in the Court proceedings. Both of them pointed out that Dr. Rajesh Singh awaiting transfer orders, has resigned and that in the meantime one Sri Vineet Narain, Senior Journalist of Hawala fame, has been appointed by the trial Court as receiver on 26-6-2003. Sri B.D Madhyan counsel for petitioner made an application dated 7-7-2003 stating that Sri Vineet Narain has been appointed receiver without issuing notice to the defendants. It is contended that the resignation of Dr. Rajesh Singh has been accepted and Sri Vineet Narain has been appointed receiver without issuing notice to defendant only to circumvent the order of this Court and that no notice was issued nor any opportunity was given to make objection to such appointment. It is contended that new receiver has no concern with the temple and is the own man of respondent No. 3 and has been appointed as receiver for their own personal benefits. The orders dated 26-6-2003, annexed to the application, shows that the trial Court accepted the resignation of Dr. Rajesh Singh and a cheque of Rs. 1,100/- as donation to the temple and accepted the application for appointment of Sri Vineet Narain as receiver, on his own offer. He was permitted to spend Rs. 5,000/- per month for maintenance of temple. He was appointed on the ground that Sri Vineet Narain is senior journalist residing at Vrindavan and is editor, Kalchakra, Investigative, News Bureau.

    9. This Court disposed of the aforesaid application vide its order dated 14-7-2003 giving liberty to the defendant-petitioner to take objection with regard to appointment of Vineet Narain as receiver as may be open to him in law.

    10. Sri B.D Madhyan appearing for petitioners, who were defendants in suit, submits that plaintiff-respondent No. 3 has no right to represent the society. The elections set up by respondent No. 3, have not been accepted by Prescribed Authority vide order dated 11-2-2000 and there is no order passed in the writ petition against the order of the Prescribed Authority under Section 25 of Societies Registration Act as amended in U.P He has not submitted any returns with regard to elections in the years 1999, 2000 and 2001 and thus the suit at his instance claiming to be Mantri of the Society is not maintainable. Respondent No. 3 has no right to represent the society and its affairs, Sri Madhyan further submits that instead of deciding the injunction application, in pursuance of the remand order of the appellate Court as affirmed by this Court, the trial Court proceeded to appoint receiver and acted illegal and against the judicial norms in appointing a sitting judicial officer as receiver of the temple. He submits that the receiver started acting illegally and against his authorization in giving theka and carrying out religious functions for which he had no authority. He excluded non-Gudhania Brahmins from participating in the theka, and after this Court raised objection with regard to appointment of judicial officer as receiver, the resignation of Dr. Rajesh Singh was accepted and Sri Vineet Narain appointed without issuing notice or inviting objection from petitioner, who is the Secretary of the Society. According to Sri B.D Madhyan, petitioner is validly elected General Secretary of the Society, and has right to manage and administer the affairs of the society and the temple.

    11. Sri Manish Kumar Nigam appearing for Sri Govind Prasad Purohit, plaintiff-respondent No. 3, submits that respondent No. 3 was elected as President on 30-4-1999. His return was wrongly accepted by the Deputy Registrar and that the order of Prescribed Authority is still under challenge before this Court in writ Petition No. 9601 of 2000. He denies that any election were held in 2000 and 2001 in which petitioner was elected as Mantri. No election took place as alleged on 1-4-2001 and for office bearers on 8-4-2001. It is submitted by him that in suit No. 44 of 1970 issues were framed between the parties to the effect whether plaintiff Har Prasad and others had a right to share in the management and the income of the temple and whether the Brahmins of Gudhania and Kunchangia set alone have a right to manage and share in the offerings. The suit was dismissed. An appeal was also dismissed and the Second Appeal No. 639 of 1982 is pending. According to Sri Nigam, findings was recorded by both the Court below in the said suit that only Gudhania Brahmins had a right to manage and take part in the thekas. He submits that receiver was appointed with the consent of the parties and that no objection was taken to the management by the receiver. According to Sri Nigam Sri Vineet Narain Senior Journalist of Hawala fame is public spirited person. The defendants have not taken any objection to the appointment as receiver before the trial Court.

    12. After hearing counsel for parties and perusing the record, I find that the trial Court has completely misdirected itself and took extra-ordinary interest to appoint receiver and to continue theka without making any effort to decide the application for interim injunction which includes the right of the plaintiff to represent the society and to file a suit. There have been certain disputes with regard to rights of the parties in the past belonging to Gudhania and non-Gudhania Brahmins. The original suit No. 44 of 1970 filed by Late Sri Har Prasad and others was dismissed and the judgment and decree was affirmed in appeal. The issues with regard to the rights of different sets on the management were subject matter of consideration and decided in the said suit. It was held that the constitution of the society in the year 1977 was in respect of Gudhania and Kuchania Brahmins alone and it was only they had right to the exclusion of that non-Gudhania Brahmins. The constitution of the society dated 14-3-1997 was upheld by the Court. The non-Gudhania Brahmins were not held to have a right for realising of amount. Section 92 C.P.C did not operate a bar to the institution of the suit. These findings are still subject matter of second appeal. Prima facie these findings operate as res judicata between parties for managing the affairs of the temple.

    13. A receiver can be appointed under Order 40, Rule 1, C.P.C where it appears to be just and convenient, whether before or after decree for management, protection, preservation and improvement of the suit property. Remuneration has to be fixed under Rule 2 and its enforcement is provided under Rules 3 and 4. Receiver, however, should not be appointed without ascertaining the right of plaintiff to file a suit. Where right of the plaintiff to maintain the action and his locus standi to represent the society is in question, the trial Court must decide the same before appointing a receiver, unless the trial Court finds that the delay in such disposal will defeat the purpose or will result into waste or gross mismanagement. In the present case, the application for interim injunction was rejected. The appeal was allowed and remanded for deciding injunction application afresh. This Court affirmed the order. The trial Court as such ought to have first decided injunction application. Both the parties could not show the reasons as to why the trial Court instead of deciding injunction application, which necessarily required him to consider the right of Sri Govind Prasad Purohit to represent the society, proceeded to appoint a receiver. The record shows that after appointment of receiver, the Trial Court did not take any steps in fixing the application for interim injunction for hearing and got busy in deciding applications moved by the receiver from time to time and in arranging for monthly thekas. He did not even care to decide the application/objection for giving rights to non-Godhania. Brahmins for participating in thekas.

    14. Before concluding the matter and issuing orders for deciding injunction application, it is necessary to consider petitioner's objections of the plaintiff with regard to appointment of a sitting judicial officer as receiver in respect of a dispute relating to the management of the society or temple. Although in the present case, the receiver was appointed on the application of plaintiff to which no objection was filed by the defendant, a judicial officer should not have been appointed and should not have accepted the office of receiver. A judicial officer is not only a government servant under the administrative control of the High Court, but he also holds a position of status and responsibility which requires him to maintain absolute fairness and impartiality. His conduct both inside and outside the Court should be above board. He is bound by the Conduct Rules applicable to government servants. He, has to discharge greater sense of responsibility in performance of duties. His actions and demeanour should be impeccable. He cannot be permitted to act in positions where his actions may be subjected to scrutiny, contempt or objected to by any of the parties. The nature of duties of receiver as enjoined by Rule 3 requires him to furnish security if any Court deem fit. He is required to submit accounts of such periods and in such forms as the Court directs and pay amount due from him as the Court may direct. Rule 3(d) holds him responsible for any loss occasioned to the property by his wilful default or negligence. These duties can be enforced under Rule 4 by attachment and sale of his personal properties. Apart from the attachment and sale he can also be held liable for his actions by taking criminal proceedings. Although a Collector has been provided to be appointed as receiver under Rule 5, where an property is land paying revenue to the Government, a judicial officer should not submit himself to such unwanted risk of making him subject of scrutiny, criticism, recovery or criminal liability. In case of private disputes allegations may be easily levelled against the receiver. In such cases his conduct in discharge of his duties will become subject matter of scrutiny by an officer of either same rank or of higher or lower rank. In the said event it will be embarrassing from a brother judicial officer to examine his conduct. It is, therefore, in the interest of justice and fair play that a serving judicial officer should not be appointed as a receiver by any Court of law. In the present case Dr. Rajesh Singh, Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (Railway) Mathura was appointed as receiver. This Court takes strong exception and directs that in view of the aforesaid discussion henceforth no serving judicial officer of any rank should be appointed or continued as receiver by any subordinate Court. A copy of this order may be given to the Registrar General for communication to all the District Judges in the State:

    15. In the present case since this Court has already given opportunity to the counsel for defendant to object to the appointment of the receiver Sri Vineet Narain no further orders require to be passed in respect of his appointment. The averments in paragraph 27 of the Counter affidavit of Sri Govind Prasad Purohit shows that on account of theka given to non-Gudhania Brahmins some tension was prevailing and proceeding under Section 107/116 and 145, 146, Cr. P.C were initiated. Notices were sent and police report was obtained on 2-8-2002. In the circumstances the Court does not propose to interfere with the order of appointment of receiver.

    16. For the aforesaid reasons, the writ petition is partly allowed. The Civil Judge (Senior Division), “Mathura” is directed to decide the pending injunction application in suit No. 332 of 1999 as expeditiously as possible preferably within two months.

    17. In deciding application, he will decide whether the plaintiffs have any prima facie case and shall also consider the balance of convenience and fact of hardship to any of the parties. He will take into account the findings given by the Courts between the parties in previous litigation and also consider whether any of the parties has a right to manage the temple under constitution of the Society. There shall be no order as to costs.

    18. Petition party allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dilip Kumar Sharma And Another v. Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Mathura And Others
    (Aug 1, 2003)