AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 28(5) of U.P State Universities Act, 1973,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 28(5) of U.P State Universities Act, 1973,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (G.P. Mathur, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This set of three Special Appeals arises out of Writ Petition No. 41814 of 1999 filed by Dr. Arvind Kumar Kankane. The dispute concerns the procedure for admission to Post-Graduate medical courses in U.P. under a multi-stage counselling system: a first counselling where candidates are allotted seats according to merit and option, and a subsequent counselling intended to fill seats vacant after the first round (including vacancies caused by non-joining or resignation).

Dr. Arvind Kumar Kankane (the writ petitioner) appeared in the U.P. Post-Graduate Medical Entrance Examination and obtained 179th rank. At the first counselling (17-8-1999) he was allotted an M.D. seat in Gorakhpur and joined on 24-8-1999. A second round of counselling was advertised for 6-7 October 1999 but limited participation to candidates who had not been allotted or had not opted for any seat in the first round. The petitioner was therefore excluded from the second counselling and filed the writ petition seeking quashing of the condition that excludes candidates already allotted seats from the second counselling and seeking his inclusion in the second round according to merit.

A learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition by order dated 30-9-1999 and issued directions (summarized in the opinion) to permit those allotted seats in earlier counselling to appear on a reserved first date of subsequent counselling to change seats where vacancies had arisen. Aggrieved parties who were not parties to the writ petition filed a recall application (rejected on 11-11-1999) and then filed the present Special Appeals (Nos. 1282, 1301 and 1374 of 1999) challenging the Single Judge's principal order and the clarification.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether candidates who were allotted seats in the first round of counselling may be permitted to participate in subsequent counselling rounds to change their seat/subject/college where vacancies have arisen.
  2. Whether the Single Judge's directions (dated 30-9-1999) that allow earlier-allotted candidates to present themselves on a reserved first date of subsequent counselling and change seats are consistent with the Government policy, information brochure conditions, and established legal principles concerning finality of allotment and timely commencement/completion of postgraduate medical courses.
  3. Whether the impugned directions should be set aside because they would cause disruption of the admission process, public expenditure and the schedule fixed for postgraduate courses under Medical Council of India guidelines and prior case law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Counsel for the appellants and for the Director General of Medical Education and Training submitted that the Government Order of 30-3-1994 and the information brochure made the allotment of subject and college on the basis of option exercised by a candidate final; no candidate may change subject or college after allotment.
  • They argued that a candidate who does not opt during counselling is placed on the waiting list and only waiting-list candidates should be permitted to fill subsequently falling vacancies strictly in merit order.
  • They contended that the Single Judge's directions are contrary to the Government Order and the information brochure and would frustrate the scheme by reopening allotments, causing uncertainty and delay in starting the course.

Writ Petitioner's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The writ petitioner's counsel contended that the Government policy has the effect of benefiting less meritorious candidates because a lower-ranked candidate might obtain a seat that was unavailable to a higher-ranked candidate at first counselling but became available later; thus the policy is unfair to higher-ranked candidates who accepted other seats earlier.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dinesh Kumar v. Moti Lal Nehru College, Allahabad, 1987 (4) SCC 459 : AIR 1987 SC 2396 Direction that a uniform practice should be followed with regard to duration of Post‑Graduate course throughout the country and a time schedule was fixed. Used to emphasise need for adherence to a fixed schedule for commencement and completion of courses so as to prevent disruption caused by repeated counselling.
State of Bihar v. Dr. Sanjay Kumar Sinha, (1990) 4 SCC 624 : AIR 1990 SC 749 Reiteration of the requirement that courses must commence and be completed within the schedule; warning against violation of Court's order. Relied upon to stress that departures from schedule will be viewed seriously and to support the conclusion that the impugned directions risked violating time schedules.
Ajay Pradhan v. State of M.P, (1988) 4 SCC 514 : AIR 1988 SC 1875 Principle that no admission should be granted in the midst of the academic session; student-teacher ratio and syllabus negate right to mid-session admission. Invoked to show that allowing repeated re-allotments would effectively permit mid-session admissions/changes contrary to this principle.
Subodh Nautial v. State of U.P, 1993 Supp (1) SCC 593 : AIR 1991 SC 1131 Emphasis on time schedule and timely completion of courses. Used with other authorities to underline that admission processes must respect the fixed schedule and avoid disruptions.
State of U.P. v. Anupum Gupta, 1993 Supp (1) SCC 594 : AIR 1992 SC 932 Support for the importance of adhering to prescribed schedules and course completion timelines. Relied on to reinforce the need for finality in admissions and proper timing of courses.
Indu Kant v. State of U.P, 1993 Supp (2) SCC 71 : AIR 1993 SC 1215 Similar emphasis on schedule and completion of courses within fixed time. Considered by the Court as one of the authorities supporting finality and prevention of mid-session changes.
Anand S. Biji v. State of Kerala, 1993 (3) SCC 80 Introduced the system of counselling for postgraduate admissions and held that allotment made will be firm and final; public interest requires seats not be left vacant. Placed at the centre of the Court's reasoning to support the proposition that first-counselling allotments should be final to avoid repeated counselling and vacancies.
Sandhya Kabra v. University of Delhi, AIR 1993 Delhi 40 (Full Bench) Held that no change of course or hospital is permissible for candidates already admitted; wait-listed candidates may be allotted subsequently in order of merit. Cited as persuasive authority supporting finality of first-counselling allotments; the Court expressly agreed with this Full Bench view.
Dr. Veena Gupta v. University of Delhi, AIR 1994 Delhi 108 (Full Bench) Examined situation where a seat omitted from first counselling must be offered to wait-listed candidates (not by reopening counselling to all participants), to avoid chain reaction. Relied upon to demonstrate that mistakenly omitted seats should go to wait-listed candidates and not be put back to all who participated in the first counselling.
Anil Jain v. The Controller of Examinations, 1998 (3) ESCC 2016 (Full Bench — Punjab & Haryana High Court) Held that allowing repeated re-allotments would unsettle admissions; endorsed finality of first-counselling allotment and disapproved contrary Division Bench views. Relied upon by the Court to support the conclusion that the impugned Single Judge directions are unsustainable because they undermine finality and completion of courses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a step-by-step analysis, applying the statutory framework, the Government notifications/information brochure conditions, Medical Council of India recommendations and precedents to the facts:

  1. The statutory and regulatory framework: The Governor's notification (under Section 28(5) of the U.P. State Universities Act, 1973) and subsequent amendments set out merit-cum-option based selection and a scheme governing admissions. The information brochure explicitly stated that "Candidate once allotted a seat for any course/college shall not be allowed to participate in any subsequent counselling" and that those who write "Not Opted" are eligible for subsequent counselling.
  2. Nature of postgraduate medical training: The Court noted the pedagogical and administrative realities—student-teacher ratio of 1:1; requirement of working as resident doctors with clinical responsibilities; thesis work; fixed residency allowances; and the public expense involved in running medical institutions. These factors weigh in favour of finality and timely commencement/completion.
  3. Precedents requiring adherence to schedule and finality: The Court reviewed Supreme Court authority emphasising that postgraduate courses must commence and finish on schedule and that admissions should not disrupt this schedule (citing Dinesh Kumar, State of Bihar v. S.K. Sinha, Ajay Pradhan, and other decisions). Anand S. Biji was cited for the proposition that allotments should be firm and final.
  4. Practical consequences of the Single Judge's directions: The impugned directions permitting candidates already allotted seats to re-exercise option in subsequent counselling would set up a "chain reaction": seats vacated by earlier-allotted candidates would generate further counsellings ad infinitum (second, third, fourth...), causing perpetual vacancy-filling cycles. This would delay the start and completion of courses, waste time and public money, disrupt teacher-student assignments, and conflict with the need for a fixed time-schedule.
  5. Reliance on High Court Full Bench authority: The opinion accepted and followed the approach of the Delhi High Court Full Bench (Sandhya Kabra, Dr. Veena Gupta) and the Punjab & Haryana Full Bench (Anil Jain) which disapproved any mechanism that would unsettle first-counselling finality and create repeated rounds of counselling to the detriment of the course schedule and public interest.
  6. Conclusion of legal incompatibility: Given the statutory scheme, brochure conditions, MCI recommendations and precedents, the Single Judge's directions were found to be impracticable and legally unsustainable. The Court held that the Single Judge's order would defeat the object of a final and timely admissions process and thus must be set aside.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Special Appeals are allowed; the impugned judgment and orders of the learned Single Judge dated 30-9-1999 and the clarification dated 11-11-1999 are set aside and the writ petition is dismissed.

Implications (as articulated by the Court in the opinion):

  • The admitted principle of finality in allotments at the first counselling is upheld; candidates allotted seats in the first counselling are not to be permitted to participate in subsequent counselling to change their seat/subject/college.
  • The decision preserves the schedule for commencement and completion of postgraduate medical courses, prevents a fracturing chain of repeated counsellings, avoids waste of public time and money, and protects the integrity of medical training (including student-teacher assignments and clinical responsibilities).
  • The Court relied on and followed earlier authorities (Full Benches and Supreme Court decisions) and applied those principles to set aside the Single Judge's directions; the immediate effect is that the earlier allotments remain final and the writ petition for reopening the counselling was dismissed.

This summary is limited to and strictly derived from the information contained in the provided opinion. No outside facts or inferences beyond the text have been added.

    Dr. Naveen Jamval And Others v. Dr. Arvind Kumar Kenkane And Others

    G.P Mathur, J.:— All the three Special Appeals arise out of Writ Petition No. 41814 of 1999 filed by Dr. Arvind Kumar Kankane and, therefore, they are being disposed of by a common order.

    2. The controversy involved in the appeals relates to admission in Post Graduate courses in the State Medical Colleges. Under the current system an entrance test is held and separate merit list of general and reserved category candidates is prepared. The candidates are then called for a counselling strictly according to their ranks in the merit list. They are shown the list of the seats which are available in different Medical Colleges. The candidate may opt for one of the available seats in which case the slot chosen by him gets closed for the candidates who are lower in rank. A candidate has the option not to opt for any seats, which is available at the time of the counselling, and in such a case he is kept in the waiting list. A candidate opting to remain in the waiting list is not considered again in that round of counselling. Sometimes the candidates after haying opted for a seat do not join the course or leave the course within a short time. The seats left vacant after the first round of counselling and also such seats which have fallen vacant on account of non-joining or leaving of a candidate are determined. In order to fill in these vacant seats, a second round of counselling is held in which candidates lower in rank than the candidates who had been given opportunity in the first round of counselling and also those candidates who had opted for being kept in the waiting list are allowed to participate in order of their rank in the merit list. However, those candidates who had opted for a seat in the first round of counselling are not allowed to appear in the second counselling.

    3. The writ petitioner Dr. Arvind Kumar Kankane appeared in U.P Post-Graduate Medical Entrance Examination, which was conducted by Medical College, Meerut, on 10-1-1999. The result of the said examination was published on 1-4-1999 in which the petitioner secured 179th rank. The appellants of Special Appeal No. 1282 of 1999 viz. Dr. Naveen Jamval, Dr. Prakash Kumar Khaitan and Dr. Km. Sudha Yadav secured 86,215 and 238 rank respectively. The writ petitioner wanted admission in Master of Surgery Course (M.S) but by the time his turn came in the first counselling held on 17-8-1999, the seats in the said course had already been allotted to those candidates who had secured higher rank in the merit list. He, therefore, opted for admission to Doctor of Medicine Course (hereinafter referred to as M.D) and was given admission in Medical College, Gorakhpur where he joined on 24-8-1999. About a month thereafter, an advertisement was issued on behalf of Director General, Medical Education and Training, U.P notifying that a second round of counselling would be held in Medical College, Meerut on 6th and 7th of October, 1999 and only such candidates who had not been allotted or had not opted for any seat in the first round of counselling would be allowed to participate. In view of the aforesaid condition, the petitioner was excluded from consideration in the second round of counselling. He then filed the writ petition praying that the condition which prohibits those candidates who had already been allotted seats in the first round of counselling from consideration in the second round of counselling be quashed and he may also be considered for allotment of seat in the second round of counselling according to his rank in the merit list.

    4. A learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petition by the judgment and order dated 30-9-1999 and the operative part of the order in which certain directions were given to the authorities is being reproduced below:—

    “Wherever after first counselling any subsequent counselling is decided to be held by the respondents for allocation of remaining seats as well as the seats which have been fallen vacant subsequent to the first counselling because of candidates who were allotted seats during first counselling refusing or failing joining, the respondents will issue a public advertisement at least in one daily newspaper, which in any case is normally done for every counselling. The advertisement will disclose the seats which have fallen vacant out of seats which were allotted during first counselling. A copy of the said advertisement may also be transmitted to each of the Medical Colleges which are covered by combined entrance test and copy of the same will be pasted on the notice board of the college for information of the students of that college. The first date of each subsequent counselling will be reserved for the candidates who were allotted seats at the earlier counselling and who wish to change their seats. It will not be necessary for the respondents to notify each candidate, who has opted for a seat during first counselling, individually. Out of the candidate, who were allotted seats at the first counselling, who turn up for subsequent counselling on the first date which is reserved for such students, distribution of seats which have fallen vacant subsequent to first or earlier counselling will be done according to merit. The change of seat to these students who have been allotted seats during first or earlier counselling will be permitted only in respect of seats which have been fallen vacant after first counselling and not of the left over seats.”

    5. The appellants of Special Appeal No. 1282 of 1999, who were not parties to the writ petition, but felt aggrieved by the judgment and order of the learned single Judge moved an application for recalling of the judgment but the same was rejected with certain clarification on 11-11-1999. Special Appeal No. 1282 of 1999 has been filed by them challenging the main judgment and order dated 30-9-1999 of the learned single Judge and Special Appeal No. 1301 of 1999 has been filed challenging the order dated 11-11-1999 passed on the recall application. The Director General of Medical Education and Training, U.P has also preferred Special Appeal No. 1374 of 1999 against the judgment and order dated 30-9-1999 by which the writ petition was disposed of.

    6. In order to appreciate the contention raised at the bar, it is necessary to notice the relevant provisions laying down the scheme for admission to Post-Graduate Courses in Medical Colleges. In exercise of power conferred by Section 28(5) of U.P State Universities Act, 1973, as amended from time to time and other powers enabling him in this behalf, the Governor of U.P issued a notification on 9-10-1990 for implementation of Junior Residency, Senior Residency and Dental Residency Scheme and also laid down the policy and procedure for filling in the seats, and also specifying the number thereof, in various Degree and Diploma Courses in all the Government Allopathic Medical Colleges, Dental College and K.G Medical College, Lucknow. Clause 8 of the notification provides that a competitive entrance examination shall be held every year for registration and residency admission to three years' Post-Graduate Degree Courses and the said examination shall be held for 75 per cent institutional seats after excluding 24 per cent seats specified for All India Entrance Examination. It further provides that department wise selection and registration of Residents in the colleges under the scheme shall be made on the basis of merit-cum-option and the said merit shall be determined on the basis of marks obtained in the competitive examination. The scheme was amended by notification dated 30-3-1994 and the amended clause Gha and Anga reads as follows:—

    7. The Meerut Medical College, which had been nominated by the Government for conducting the competitive Entrance Examination for admission to Post-Graduate Courses, had issued an information brochure along with the application form. This contains the details regarding Eligibility Criteria, scope of examination, evaluation and certain other conditions. Condition C (iii) relating to Eligibility Criteria reads as follows:—

    “(iii) A candidate who is already admitted to any post-graduate course will not be eligible to appear in the U.P.P.G.M.E.E 99 for admission in any other specialty till he/she completes the course and passes the examination.”

    8. The relevant part of conditions G (iv) and (vii) relating to Result and Selection read as follows:—

    “G(iv)—……………………………………At the time of counselling the available seats in the different courses and colleges shall be displayed. According to their merit the candidates shall have to choose any one of the available seats. The same will be allotted to them. Candidate once allotted a seat for any course/college shall not be allowed to participate in any subsequent counselling.

    G(vii)— Those candidates who, do not wish to opt for a seat in any course/college, amongst the seats available at their merit, can write ‘Not Opted’ and they will be eligible for allotment in subsequent counselling.”

    9. Sri Ashok Bhushan, who has appeared for the appellants in Special Appeal No. 1282 of 1999 and Sri Ashutosh Srivastava, who has appeared for Director General, Medical Education and Training, have submitted that under the Government Order issued on 30-3-1994, it was clearly provided that the allotment of subject (specialty) and college of study made on the basis of option exercised by a candidate is final and no candidate can be permitted to change the subject or the college. A candidate who does not exercise his option in the counselling will be kept in the waiting list and if at any subsequent stage a seat falls vacant the same shall be allotted on the basis of the option exercised by those who are in the waiting list and the same will be done strictly in accordance with the merit secured in the entrance examination. The information brochure contained the same conditions which was binding upon all the candidates who had appeared in the entrance examination. According to the learned counsel, the writ petitioner Dr. Arvind Kumar Kankane had exercised his option and was allotted M.S Course in Gorakhpur Medical College and, consequently, he could not be permitted to take part in the second counselling. It is urged that the direction given by the learned single Judge is contrary to the Government Order and also to the conditions of examination. It would completely frustrate the scheme framed by the Government and is bound to result in reopening of the entire allotment done at the time of first counselling leading to uncertainty and delay in starting the course. Sri Ashok Khare, learned counsel of writ petitioner has on the other hand submitted that the policy of the Government has the effect of giving benefit to a less meritorious candidate as a person having lower rank gets a chance to get admission in a subject or College which was denied to a candidate who had higher rank in the first counselling as the same was not available at that time but became available later on.

    10. The Post-Graduate Medical Courses are conducted in various Medical Colleges in association with the hospitals on the recommendation of Medical Council of India. They stipulate that the Post-Graduate student will be under the direct supervision of a Post-Graduate Teacher in the specialty concerned and student teacher ratio in such courses will be maintained at 1:1. He is to prepare a thesis under the guidance of his teacher. A Post-Graduate student is required to work as a regular doctor in the institution/hospital and has to attend to patients in the particular department pertaining to his course of specialty. The recommendation of Medical Council further stipulates that in service, training should be given to the candidates who has to be a resident in the hospital campus with responsibility of management and treatment of patients. He is paid a residency allowance of Rs. 11,800/- per month, which increases, to Rs. 12,700/- by the 3rd year. In Dr. Dinesh Kumar v. Moti Lal Nehru College, Allahabad, 1987 (4) SCC 459 : (AIR 1987 SC 2396) the Supreme Court directed that a uniform practice should be followed with regard to duration of Post-Graduate Course throughout the country and a time schedule was fixed. The emphasis on time schedule was reiterated in State of Bihar v. Dr. Sanjay Kumar Sinha, (1990) 4 SCC 624 : AIR 1990 SC 749, Dr. Ajay Pradhan v. State of M.P, (1988) 4 SCC 514 : AIR 1988 SC 1875, Dr. Subodh Nautial v. State of U.P, 1993 Supp (1) SCC 593 : AIR 1991 SC 1131; State of U.P v. Anupum Gupta, 1993 Supp (1) SCC 594 : AIR 1992 SC 932 and Dr. Indu Kant v. State of U.P, 1993 Supp (2) SCC 71 : AIR 1993 SC 1215. It was laid down in these cases that the courses must commence on schedule and must be completed within schedule. In fact in State of Bihar v. Dr. S.K Sinha supra, a warning was given that a serious view would be taken if there was violation of Court's order. In Dr. Ajay Pradhan v. State of M.P (supra), the Apex Court ruled in clear terms that no admission should be granted in a midst of the session by making the following observations at page 1879:—

    “……………The syllabus prescribed by the Medical Council of India for the Post-Graduate Course in M.D/M.S as also the student — teacher ratio of 1 : 1 virtually negate the right to admission to a seat falling vacant in the midst of or towards the end of the academic year to which it pertains.”

    11. In Anand S. Biji v. State of Kerala, 1993 (3) SCC 80, the Apex Court introduced the system of counselling for giving admission in a particular subject and in a particular college on the basis of Post-Graduate Entrance Examination keeping in view the suggestion made by the Medical Council of India and other authorities. It was clearly laid down in this case that allotment made will be firm and final. It may be noticed that there is acute shortage of trained and qualified doctors and public interest requires that seats should not be left vacant and as far as possible effort should be made to fill in all the available seats in the Post-Graduate Courses.

    12. The direction given by learned single Judge permits those candidates who have already been granted admission to again exercise their option in the second counselling. The result of such a course of action will be that the seats, which had been allotted to them in the first counselling, will fall vacant and it will inevitably result in holding of a third counselling. This will virtually set a chain reaction in motion and the candidates who had participated in the second counselling would like to participate in the third counselling which would again create vacancy in the seats allotted to them in the second counselling. This will probably require a fourth counselling and the completion of the admission process would take a very long time. This will naturally disturb the entire schedule and the courses will never be completed within a period of three years as laid down by Medical Council of India and emphasized in several decisions of Supreme Court. The period spent while studying a particular course would be completely wasted and the time devoted by a teacher to a student will also be wasted on account of change of subject or college by him. This kind of a system would inevitably result in loss of public money and a complete disturbance in the working of a Medical College.

    13. The rationale behind the policy of not permitting a candidate who has been allotted a seat in the first round of counselling to participate in the second round is to attain finality to the admission process and to commence the course on the scheduled time. It may no doubt have the effect of depriving a candidate to opt for seat which may have fallen vacant subsequently on account of non-joining of a candidate. But in the matter of admission to a post-graduate course in a medical college, the rights of a candidate have to be judged along with other equally important factors viz. that the Government has to incur huge expenditure in maintaining and running of the medical colleges and hospitals, that a ratio of 1 : 1 is to be maintained between a student and a teacher, that a good salary is paid to a teacher from the public exchequer and that the candidate himself is paid sizable residency allowance and he is not just an ordinary student. No one can be permitted to exercise his rights in such a manner, which seriously affects the working of the system itself or tends to destroy it. The rights of an individual must give way to larger public interest.

    14. The scheme of admission and the conditions imposed therein which is subject matter of challenge in the writ petition giving rise to the present appeals is exactly similar to one in force in University of Delhi and a similar challenge was considered by a Full Bench of Delhi High Court in Dr. Sandhya Kabra v. University of Delhi, AIR 1993 Delhi 40. It was held that no change of course or hospital is permissible to the candidates who have already secured admission and further a candidate who during counselling expresses his desire to be placed on the waiting list and not to be allocated any subject will be free to choose any of the subject or institution which may become available subsequently in order of merit. In Dr. Dr. Veena Gupta… v. University Of Delhi…., AIR 1994 Delhi 108 (FB), the Court examined the position where a seat though available but was not offered to the candidates at the time of first counselling on account of some fraud played by a person in authority. The contention that the seat should be offered to the candidates called in the first round was repelled with the following observations:—

    “Any seat which is available and which has not been included in any of the three counselling by mistake should be filled in, in order of merit amongst the wait listed candidates. Normally, when a seat is available, the same should be included in the initial counselling. If by mistake a seat is not included in the initial counselling then the effect is that nobody opts for the same. If now the said seat is sought to be offered to all the candidates for counselling, the result would be that all the candidates who took part in the first counselling, should be given a chance, in order of merit, to opt for the same seat. This will start a chain reaction and ultimately there will be one seat more, which would become available for the second counselling. There again a chain reaction will start leading to the third counselling. The effect of putting the seat back for counselling for all candidates would, therefore, be to upset the entire counselling which had already taken place. As such, even though it may seem unfair, there is no alternative, apart from leaving the seat unfilled, but to offer the said seat to the wait listed candidates.

    Those candidates who have not been offered any seat or who have not accepted the allotment of any seat during the earlier counselling will, of course, be regarded as candidates who are wait listed. But there are cases where a candidate had accepted a seat during counselling and paid the fees but thereafter had not joined the course. It is to be seen that at a short notice, a candidate has to make up his mind during counselling as to which seat to accept. He is thereafter given 15 days time to join. It is possible that even though a candidate may have accepted a seat, thereafter for reasons best known to him, he may decide not to join course which he has-selected. It will be unjust, unfair to punish such a candidate and not to consider him in future counselling if he has chosen not to join and has expressed his desire to be on the waiting list. Of course, if a candidate joins the course and thereafter chooses to resign or abandon then the said candidate cannot be placed in the waiting list. It is only those candidates who do not join any postgraduate course for any reason whatsoever, either because of not being offered, have not accepted or have not joined, who may be regarded as being on the waiting list.”

    15. The scheme in the State of Haryana also provided that those candidates who had been given admission in any course or institution on the basis of option exercised by them would not be considered in the second counselling which may be held on account of some seats falling vacant. A Division Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court took the view that it would be in the interest of justice and fair play that the advantage of the seats, which have fallen vacant on account of fortuitous circumstances be offered to all the students on merit. This decision was reversed by a Full Bench in Anil Jain v. The Controller of Examinations, 1998 (3) ESCC 2016 and it was held as under:—

    “If the view taken by the two Division Benches in the cases mentioned above are adopted, it will unsettle the admission given to the students at the first counselling. As and when vacancies arise in each discipline, it will have to be put to all the candidates. If one, on higher rank wants to change his discipline and opt for the vacant seat, he has to be accommodated. Seat left by him in the discipline in which he was already admitted should again be thrown open to others. This process will continue for an indefinite period and that will adversely affect the course of study. To prevent such a tendency and to have a finality to the process of admission, their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Anand S. Biji's case (supra) observed that the allotment of seats made to candidates in the first counselling should be firm and final. Views expressed by the Division Benches of this Court referred to earlier are, therefore, unsustainable and we disapprove the same.”

    16. We are in respectful agreement with the view taken in the two Full Bench decisions of Delhi High Court and the Full Bench decision of Punjab and Haryana High Court. The procedure laid down by the learned single Judge in the impugned judgment and order is not a workable one as it will set-up a chain reaction of holding several counsellings resulting in loss of public time and money and considerable delay in the completion of the course. Such a course of action would also be in violation of the directives emphasized by the Apex Court in several decisions. The impugned judgment and order dated 30-9-1999 therefore cannot be sustained and has to be set-aside. The order dated 11-11-1999 merely clarified the judgment and order dated 30-9-1999 and, consequently, the aforesaid order also deserves to be set aside.

    17. In the result, all the three Special Appeals succeed and are hereby allowed.

    18. The impugned judgment and orders of the learned single Judge dated 30-9-1999 and 11-11-1999 are set aside and the writ petition is dismissed.

    19. Appeals allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Naveen Jamval And Others v. Dr. Arvind Kumar Kenkane And Others
    (Feb 11, 2000)