Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 203 and 204 Cr. P.C shows that Section 203 Cr. P.C
  • provisions of Section 204 Cr. P.C
  • Sections 420, 467 and 468 IPC.4.
  • Section 204 Cr. P.C Section 204
  • Section 190 Cr. P.C Clause (a)
  • CI. (2) of Section 397 Cr. P.C
  • Section 239 or 240 Cr. P.C
  • Section 239 Cr. P.C
  • Section 204 Cr. P.C
  • Section 397 Cr. P.C
  • Section 203 Cr. P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 203 and 204 Cr. P.C shows that Section 203 Cr. P.C
  • provisions of Section 204 Cr. P.C
  • Sections 420, 467 and 468 IPC.4.
  • Section 204 Cr. P.C Section 204
  • Section 190 Cr. P.C Clause (a)
  • CI. (2) of Section 397 Cr. P.C
  • Section 239 or 240 Cr. P.C
  • Section 239 Cr. P.C
  • Section 204 Cr. P.C
  • Section 397 Cr. P.C
  • Section 203 Cr. P.C
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision under Section 397 Cr. P.C. was preferred against the order dated 9-2-1999 passed by the 1st Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Meerut in Criminal Case No. 305 of 1999. A charge sheet was submitted on the basis of an FIR lodged by opposite party No. 2 for offences alleged under Sections 420, 467 and 468 IPC. On the basis of that charge sheet, the Magistrate registered the case and issued a non-bailable warrant summoning the applicant, returnable on 9-2-1999. The applicant challenged that order by filing the present revision. The court heard learned counsel for the revisionist and the learned A.G.A.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the revision is maintainable given the contention that the order of summoning was interlocutory and therefore barred by Clause (2) of Section 397 Cr. P.C.;
  2. Whether the Magistrate had to apply his mind and record reasons when issuing process under Section 204 Cr. P.C., i.e., whether a detailed inquiry or recording of reasons is necessary at the stage of issuance of process on a police report.

Arguments of the Parties

Revisionist's Arguments

  • The order summoning the applicant was passed without application of mind as to whether any offense had been committed.
  • Before issuing process the Magistrate must be prima facie satisfied that an offence is made out; such satisfaction is a pre-condition to taking cognizance and issuing process.
  • The order does not show that the Magistrate applied his mind to determine whether there was sufficient ground to proceed under Section 204 Cr. P.C.

Opposite Parties' Arguments

  • The impugned order is interlocutory; accordingly the revision is not maintainable and is covered by the mischief of Clause (2) of Section 397 Cr. P.C.
  • By implication, the opposite parties relied on the position that an order of this nature should not be assailed by revision under the cited provision.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Umakant Pandey v. Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Karvi, Banda, 1996 ACC 879 Held that the order of summoning is not an interlocutory order (principle on maintainability of revision against summoning orders). The court accepted the principle laid down by this Division Bench case and treated the revision as maintainable.
"Madhulmaya" (Hon'ble Supreme Court) — (case name cited; specific citation not provided in the opinion) The opinion of the Supreme Court in "Madhulmaya" was considered on the question of maintainability of revision; the Division Bench decision referred to had taken that principle into account. The court noted that the Division Bench had considered the principle laid down in "Madhulmaya" and other cases; this influenced the court to accept that the order was not interlocutory and the revision was maintainable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two broad stages: (A) maintainability of the revision; and (B) merits regarding the requirement to record reasons when issuing process under Section 204 Cr. P.C.

(A) Maintainability: The court considered the contention that the impugned order was interlocutory and hence revision under Section 397 Cr. P.C. was not maintainable. The counsel for the revisionist cited the Division Bench decision in Umakant Pandey which, after considering the Supreme Court's decision in "Madhulmaya" and other cases, held that an order of summoning is not interlocutory. The court accepted the principle from the Division Bench authority and concluded that the present revision is maintainable.

(B) Merits — statutory framework and required scrutiny at different stages:

  • The court reviewed the statutory provisions governing cognizance and issuance of process: Sections 190, 200–204, 239–240 and 248 Cr. P.C., distinguishing between complaint cases and cases instituted on police report. It noted that Section 190 Cr. P.C. contains clauses (a) and (b) regarding cognizance on complaint and on police report respectively.
  • It identified three stages in a criminal prosecution (as articulated in the opinion):
    1. Stage of issue of process under Section 204 Cr. P.C.;
    2. Stage before framing of charge (Section 239 Cr. P.C.);
    3. Stage after recording the entire evidence of prosecution and defence (culminating in judgment under Section 248 Cr. P.C.).
  • On the proper standard of scrutiny at these stages, the court reasoned:
    • At the stage of issuance of process under Section 204 Cr. P.C., a detailed inquiry into merits is not required. The submission of a charge sheet by the police may be considered sufficient ground to proceed, subject to the caveat that the Magistrate should examine whether the complaint is barred by any law (for example, lack of sanction for prosecution or limitation).
    • If the complaint is not barred by law at the Section 204 stage, the court held that the Magistrate is not required to consider evidence in detail nor to record reasons for issuing process, because Section 204 contains no express requirement to record reasons (in contrast to Section 203, which requires reasons when dismissing a complaint).
    • At the stage under Section 239 (or 240) Cr. P.C., the Magistrate may consider the evidence more closely and can discharge the accused after considering the police report, documents and the accused's statement; however, even at that stage the court said only a brief consideration of evidence is required and meticulous evaluation and detailed reasons are not mandated.
  • The court contrasted Section 203 (which commands that reasons must be recorded for dismissal of a complaint) with Section 204 (which contains no such requirement) and concluded that the absence of recorded reasons for issuing process under Section 204 does not render the order illegal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's final decision was to dismiss the revision. The core ruling is expressed as: REVISION DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The revision against the Magistrate's order dated 9-2-1999 has been dismissed and the order issuing process (summons/non-bailable warrant) remains effective as challenged. The court explicitly found no illegality in issuing process under Section 204 Cr. P.C. without recording reasons.
  • Broader implications: The opinion accepted the Division Bench principle that a summoning order is not interlocutory for purposes of maintainability of revision (citing Umakant Pandey). The opinion did not purport to set a new legal precedent beyond applying established principles; it did not articulate any novel, broader rule beyond its interpretation of the required standard of scrutiny at the stage of issuance of process under Section 204 Cr. P.C.

Order: The revision had no force and was dismissed.

    Raj Kumar Agarwal v. State Of U.P.

    1. This revision under Section 397 Cr. P.C has been preferred against the order dated 9-2-99 passed by the 1st Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Meerut in Criminal Case No. 305 of 1999.

    2. I have heard the learned counsel for the revisionist and the learned A.G.A

    3. It appears that a charge sheet was received against the applicant, which was submitted on the basis of the F.I.R lodged by opposite party No. 2 for the offences under Sections 420, 467 and 468 IPC.

    4. On the basis of that charge sheet by the impugned order the case was registered and the applicant was summoned by non-bailable warrant returnable by 9-2-99. Aggrieved by it, the present revision has been preferred.

    5. The contention of the learned counsel for the revisionist is that the order has been passed without application of mind for the fact whether any offence has been committed. That before the issue of process, there must be prima facie satisfaction of the learned Magistrate regarding commission of offence, which is a pre-condition for taking cognizance and issue of process.

    6. It is contended by opposite parties that the order is interlocutory and therefore, the revision is not maintainable and is covered by mischief of CI. (2) of Section 397 Cr. P.C Regarding this the learned counsel for the revisionist has referred to the Division Bench case of Umakant Pandey v. Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Karvi, Banda, 1996 ACC 879. This was a complaint case. After considering the principle Laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of “Madhulmaya” and in other cases it was held that the order of summoning is not an interlocutory order. There is no hesitation in accepting the principle Laid down by this Division Bench case and therefore, I find that the revision is maintainable.

    7. Now coming to the merits, the learned counsel for applicant has referred to the provisions of Section 204 Cr. P.C which empower the Magistrate to issue process and provide that if the Magistrate is of the opinion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding, he may issue process. It is contended that the order does not show that the Magistrate has applied his mind to find whether there is sufficient ground to proceed.

    8. The cognizance of the offences are taken by the Magistrate under Section 190 Cr. P.C Clause (a) provide for the cognizance on receiving a complaint and clause (b) provide for cognizance upon a police report. The procedure for taking cognizance upon complaint has been provided in Chapter-XV under Sections 200 to 203. A complaint may be dismissed under Section 203 Cr. P.C after recording the reasons for doing so. If the complaint is not dismissed u/S. 203, the process are issued under Section 204 Cr. P.C Section 204 is in a different Chapter-XVI, but applies to complaint cases as well as to the cases instituted on police report, and this is the only provision under which the process are issued by the Magistrate in a case after taking cognizance. The procedure for trial of warrant cases has been provided in Chapter-XIX. In the present case the cognizance has been taken upon a police report and therefore, I confine myself to the cases instituted on a police report. Under Section 239 Cr. P.C the Magistrate after considering the police report and the documents and after recording the statement of the accused and hearing the prosecution and the accused, can discharge the accused. If the accused is not discharged, the charge is framed u/S. 240 Cr. P.C and after the evidence of prosecution and accused the final judgment is pronounced u/S. 248 Cr. P.C As such there are three stages of a case. The first is under Section 204 Cr. P.C at the time of issue of process, the second is under Section 239 Cr. P.C before framing of the charge and the third is after recording the entire evidence of the prosecution and the defence. The question is whether the Magistrate is required to scrutinise the evidence at all the three stages and record reasons of his satisfaction. If this view is taken, it will make speedy disposal a dream. In my opinion the consideration of merits and evidence at all the three stages is different. At the stage of issue of process under Section 204 Cr. P.C detailed enquiry regarding the merit and demerit of the cases is not required. The fact that after investigation of the case, the police has submitted the charge sheet, may be considered as sufficient ground for proceeding at the stage of issue of process under Section 204 Cr. P.C however subject to the condition that at this stage the Magistrate should examine whether the complaint is barred under any law, for example, it is barred for want of proper sanction for prosecution or is barred by limitation etc. At the stage of Section 204 Cr. P.C if the complaint is not found barred under any law, the evidence is not required to be considered nor the reasons are required to be recorded. At the stage of charge under Section 239 or 240 Cr. P.C the evidence may be considered very briefly, though at that stage also, the Magistrate is not required to meticulously examine and to evaluate the evidence and to record detailed reasons.

    9. A bare reading of Sections 203 and 204 Cr. P.C shows that Section 203 Cr. P.C requires that reasons should be recorded for the dismissal of the complaint. Contrary to it, there is no such requirement under Section 204 Cr. P.C Therefore, the order for issue of process in this case without recording reasons, does not suffer from any illegality.

    10. The revision has, therefore, no force and is hereby dismissed.

    11. Revision dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raj Kumar Agarwal v. State Of U.P.
    (Mar 24, 1999)