AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 (hereinafter referred
  • Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998.
  • Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Regularisation Rules,
  • Rule 4 (1) of the Regularisation Rules
  • provisions of the Service Rules. (4)
  • Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Rules
  • provisions of sub-rule (1),
  • Rules. Rule 4
  • sub-rule (4)
  • sub-rule (1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 (hereinafter referred
  • Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998.
  • Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Regularisation Rules,
  • Rule 4 (1) of the Regularisation Rules
  • provisions of the Service Rules. (4)
  • Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Rules
  • provisions of sub-rule (1),
  • Rules. Rule 4
  • sub-rule (4)
  • sub-rule (1)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (IG Registration Bunch)

Factual and Procedural Background

These writ petitions (grouped as the "IG Registration Bunch") concern whether the petitioners, who were appointed as Registration Clerks on a daily wage basis, were entitled to be regularised in service in accordance with directions given by the Supreme Court in Khagesh Kumar and Ors. v. Inspector General of Registration, U.P. and Ors. and whether they were entitled to continue on daily wages until regular selections were made in light of I.G. Registration v. Avdhesh Kumar.

It was common ground that petitioners had been appointed as registration clerks on daily wages pursuant to annual sanction by the Governor, with the practice that such appointments would not exceed three years in a financial year. The petitioners had preferred representations for regularisation pursuant to the Supreme Court directions; those representations were rejected by the Inspector General of Registration (I.G. Registration), and these rejections are impugned in the writ petitions.

The petitions were heard together because of common questions of law and identical facts. The I.G. Registration recorded factual findings in each case that the petitioners had not completed three years of continuous service for the purposes of Rule 4(1)(iii) of the Relevant Regularisation Rules; illustrative factual findings for two petitioners (Bhupendra Singh Bhadauria and Mayashanker Vishwakarma) are described in the impugned order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners were entitled to be regularised as Registration Clerks pursuant to the directions of the Supreme Court in Khagesh Kumar and Ors. v. Inspector General of Registration, U.P. and Ors., in particular with respect to the computation of three years' continuous service under Rule 4(1)(iii) of the Regularisation Rules.
  2. Whether petitioners who were appointed on a daily wage basis were entitled to continue on daily wages until regular selections were made pursuant to the directions in I.G. Registration v. Avdhesh Kumar.
  3. Whether the Uttar Pradesh Regularisation of Daily Wage Appointments on Group 'C' Posts (Outside the Purview of Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998 (notification dated July 9, 1998) provide a basis for regularisation of the petitioners.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The I.G. Registration misconstrued the Supreme Court's directions in Khagesh Kumar — petitioners' counsel argued that the Supreme Court's observation that "period of break in service which was longer than three months has to be excluded" meant that even breaks of more than three months should be ignored when computing continuous service (i.e., such long breaks would not result in discontinuity).
  • The petitioners claimed entitlement to benefit under the Uttar Pradesh Regularisation Rules, 1998 (notification dated July 9, 1998), which they submitted had overriding effect and could entitle daily rated employees on Group 'C' posts to regularisation if they fulfilled the stipulated conditions.
  • The petitioners asserted that they were entitled to continue on daily wage basis until regular selections were made in view of the Supreme Court's directions in I.G. Registration v. Avdhesh Kumar.

Respondent (Inspector General of Registration) — Position Reflected in the Opinion

  • The I.G. Registration rejected the representations for regularisation on findings of fact that the petitioners did not complete three years of continuous service as required under Rule 4(1)(iii) — specific findings detailed days/periods of work for petitioners in the impugned orders (for example, days worked in specific years and periods during which work occurred pursuant to interim orders).
  • By virtue of those factual findings, the I.G. Registration treated certain re-appointments after breaks greater than three months as fresh appointments, excluding the intervening break from computation of continuous service.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khagesh Kumar and Ors. v. Inspector General of Registration, U.P. and Ors., JT 1995 (7) SC 542 : (1996) 1 UPLBEC 23 (SC) The Supreme Court held that registration clerks appointed on or before 1.10.1986 on daily wages, given Governor's sanction, would be deemed ad hoc appointees within the Regularisation Rules; and provided guidance on excluding periods of break in service when computing three years' continuous service under Rule 4(1)(iii). The court relied on Khagesh Kumar for the legal test of eligibility for regularisation and for the interpretation that breaks in service longer than three months must be excluded from computation and result in discontinuity; applied the Supreme Court's directions to conclude petitioners had not established three years' continuous service.
Bhagwati Prasad v. Delhi State Mineral Development Corporation, JT 1989 (4) SC 541 Authority for the proposition that a gap of more than three months between termination and re-appointment may be excluded in computation of continuous service; used as precedent on treatment of breaks in service. The court referenced this decision when explaining Khagesh Kumar's guidance that breaks exceeding three months must be excluded from computation of continuous service; used to support the conclusion that re-appointment after such a break is to be treated as fresh appointment.
I.G. Registration v. Avdhesh Kumar, JT 1996 (5) SC 365 : (1996) 3 UPLBEC 1744 (SC) The Supreme Court extended the directions in Khagesh Kumar to some daily rated registration clerks appointed after 1.10.1986, directing that such appointees would continue till regular selections were made; later clarified that continuation applied only to those working on the date of the judgment (referenced dates in the opinion). The court applied Avdhesh Kumar to address the petitioners' claim for continuation on daily wages until regular selections: it interpreted the scope of that decision (noting the later clarification limiting benefit to those continuing on the date of the judgment) and found petitioners could not prove they were working on the relevant date, so they were not entitled to continuation under Avdhesh Kumar.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by (a) identifying the operative Supreme Court precedents and the relevant statutory/regulatory framework (including Rule 4(1)(iii) of the Regularisation Rules and the 1998 Uttar Pradesh Regularisation Rules), and (b) applying those principles to the factual findings recorded by the I.G. Registration in the impugned orders.

Key steps in the court's analysis:

  1. The court accepted the factual findings recorded by I.G. Registration that petitioners had not completed three years' continuous service within the meaning of Rule 4(1)(iii). The opinion gives an illustrative factual recitation for specific petitioners showing scattered days of work across years and periods of service granted by interim orders.
  2. On the petitioners' primary legal contention (construction of Khagesh Kumar), the court rejected petitioners' counsel's interpretation that the Supreme Court intended to ignore breaks longer than three months when computing continuous service. Instead, the court interpreted Khagesh Kumar to mean: a break of less than three months will not interrupt continuity; a break longer than three months results in discontinuity, and the period of break must be excluded from computation (and a re-appointment after such a break is to be treated as a fresh appointment).
  3. Applying that interpretation, the court concluded that the I.G. Registration did not misconstrue Khagesh Kumar and had correctly applied the law in rejecting the petitioners' claims for regularisation based on the recorded periods of service.
  4. The court considered the petitioners' reliance on the Uttar Pradesh Regularisation Rules, 1998 (notified July 9, 1998). It examined the Rules' conditions and noted that eligibility under those Rules required that the daily rated employee "was directly appointed on daily wage basis on Group 'C' post in the Government service before June 29, 1991 and is continuing in service as such on the date of commencement of these Rules." The court observed that nothing on record prima facie established that the petitioners were continuing in service as daily rated Registration clerks on July 9, 1998. Because the Rules were notified during the pendency of the writ petitions, the court permitted the petitioners to press any claim under the 1998 Rules and directed the I.G. Registration to take appropriate decision in law if such claims were made.
  5. On the claim for continuation on daily wages until regular selections (relying on Avdhesh Kumar), the court relied on the clarified position that continuation would be available only to those working on the date of the Supreme Court's judgment (references in the opinion include the dates of the Avdhesh Kumar judgment and the subsequent interlocutory clarification). The petitioners failed to prove that they were working on the relevant date (the opinion refers to inability to establish they were working as on 12.4.1996), and therefore the petitioners were not entitled to continuing on daily wages under Avdhesh Kumar.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

DISMISSED. The petitions fail and are dismissed subject to the observations made in the opinion.

Immediate implications for the parties:

  • The court upheld the I.G. Registration's factual determinations that the petitioners had not completed three years' continuous service as required under Rule 4(1)(iii), and therefore the petitioners are not entitled to regularisation on that ground.
  • The court rejected the petitioners' interpretation of Khagesh Kumar — holding that breaks in service longer than three months cause discontinuity and re-appointments after such breaks are treated as fresh appointments for the purpose of computing continuous service.
  • The petitioners failed to establish entitlement to continue on daily wages until regular selections were made under Avdhesh Kumar because they could not show they were actually in service on the date required by the Avdhesh Kumar decision.
  • The court allowed the petitioners an opportunity to make claims under the Uttar Pradesh Regularisation Rules, 1998 (notification dated July 9, 1998) and directed the I.G. Registration to decide any such claims in accordance with law; this is a procedural relief permitting further consideration under the 1998 Rules but does not itself grant regularisation.

The opinion does not purport to lay down any new binding precedent beyond application of the cited Supreme Court authorities and the 1998 Rules to the facts; no broader legal doctrine beyond those applications is articulated.

    Ajai Kumar Misra And Ors. v. Secretary Of Institutional Finance, U.P. Shasan And Ors.

    1. The question that stems for consideration in these petitions listed for admission under the heading "IG Registration Bunch, is as to whether the petitioners were entitled to be regularised in service as Registration Clerk qua the directions given by the Supreme Court in Khagesh Kumar and Ors. v. Inspector General of Registration, U.P. and Ors. JT 1995 (7) SC 542 : (1996) 1 UPLBEC 23 (SC). In some of the writ petitions, a further question has been brought to bear that in any case the petitioners were entitled to continue on daily wages till regular selections were made in the light of the directions given by the Apex Court in I.G. Reg v. Avdhesh Kumar JT 1996 (5) SC 365 : (1996) 3 UPLBEC 1744 (SC). Since the petitions are knit together by reason of common question of law being involved therein and also by reason of the facts being identical these petitions were grouped together and heard accordingly for a convenient disposal by a common judgment.

    2. It brooks no dispute that the petitioners were appointed registration clerk on daily wages on the basis of sanction given by the Governor each year subject to the postulates that the appointments would, in no case, exceed three years during the course of a financial year. Earlier when the matter came up before this Court at the instance of a large number of Daily rated Registration clerks, seeking regularisatioin, the High Court held that Daly rated employees were not entitled to consideration for regularisation under the provisions of the U,P Regularisation of the Adhoc Employees on Posts (Outside the Purview of the Public Service Commission) Rules, 1979 (hereinafter referred to as the "Rules") as the Rules and amended from time to time. Disagreeing with that view taken by the High Court, the Apex Court held in Khagesh Kumar (supra), that in the fact-situation of the case, the Registration clerks appointed on or before 1.10.1986 on daily wage basis in view of the sanction given by the Governor for such posts, would be deemed to be ad hoc appointees within the meaning of the Rules aforesaid. The Apex Court, however, held that while counting three years continuous service for the purposes of regularisation, artificial break in service for short period/periods created by the employer would be ignored but "if three is a gap of more than three months between the period of termination and re-appointment, that period may be excluded in the computation of three months 'period as held in Bhagwati Prasad v. Delhi State Mineral Development Corporation, JT 1989 (4) SC 541. In view of the said decision, it was categorically held by the Apex Court in Khagesh Kumar (supra), that "for computing three years period of corrtinauus service for the purpose of Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Regularisation Rules, the period of break in service which was longer than three months has to be excluded and only the period during which the petitioners actually worked can be counted." It was further held that in case any of the petitioners was employed as a registration clerk on Daily wage basis prior to October 1, 1986 and after excluding the periods of breaks in service which are longer than three months, he has put in three years service he would be entitled to seek regularisation under Rule 4 (1) of the Regularisation Rules provided he fulfills the requirements of clause (ii) of the said Rules. The Apex Court observed that for this purpose, the candidate may move the appropriate authority for such regularisation. The authority was directed to pass appropriate orders after checking on the correctness of the claim of such individual. It was pursuant to the said directions that representations were preferred by the petitioners seeking regularisation and which representations came to be rejected by orders impugned in these writ petitions. In I.G. Registration v. Avdhesh Kumar, JT 1995 (5) SC 365 : (1996) 3 UPLBEC 1744 (SC), the Apex Court extended the benefit of the directions given in Khageh Kumar {supra), even to those daily rated registration clerks who were appointed subsequent to 1.10.1986 and directed that such appointees would continue till regular selections were made in the light of the directions given in Khagesh Kumar's case. Subsequently however, it was clarified by the Supreme Court that directions to continue till regular selection could be availed of only by those who were continuing on the date of judgment in Avdhesh Kumar's case (supra), i.e. on 12.6.1996.

    3. On the findings of fact recorded by the I.G. Registration in each case, it is evident that the petitioners failed to make out a case for regularisation within the meaning of Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Rules in that they could not complete three years period of continuo service. To exemplify, in Writ Petition No. 4894 of 1998, Bhupendra Singh Bhadouri and Ors. v. State of U.P. and Ors., the representation preferred by the petitioners seeking regularisation in terms of the directions contained in Khgesh Kumar (supra), came to be rejected by the Inspector General of Registration Uttar Pradesh vide impugned order dated 31.12.1997.The finding of the fact recorded in the impugned order is that Bhupendra Singh Bhadaura, petitioner No. 1 worked on Daily wage basis for 48 days in the year 1.985, 48 days in 1986, 55 days in 1987, 33 days in 1988, and 44 days in 1990-91. Similarly the 2nd Petitioner Mayashanker Vishwakarama worked for 44 days in 1986, 58 days in 1987, 20 days and 41 days in 1990-91. In addition to the service so rendered on Daily wage basis, petitioner-Bhupendra Singh Bhadauria worked from May,. 1991 to 16.4.1994 and Maya Shanker Vishwakarma from May, 1992 to 6.1.1994 on the dint of the interim orders passed by this Court. Similar findings have been recorded in other cases as well.

    4. The learned Counsel, appearing for the petitioners canvassed that die orders passed by the Inspector General, Registration proceed upon misconstruction of the directions given by the Apex Court in Khagesh Kumar (supra),. The learned Counsel urged that the observations "period of break in service which was longer than three months has to be excluded" made by the Supreme Court in Khagesh Kumar (supra), is intended to mean that even if the break of service was more than three months it will not result in discontinuity in service for such break in service is to be ignored for the purposes of computing three years period of service. I am afraid the submissions made by the learned Counsel has no substance. In my opinion, what is meant by the observation "period of break of service which was longer than three months, has to be excluded" made by the Supreme Court in Khagesh Kumar (supra), is that any break in service for a period less than three months at a time between termination and re- employment will not result in discontinuity in service but break in service for a period longer than three months will result in discontinuity and -appointment after break in service for a period longer than three months would be treated to be a fresh appointment and the appointee would not be entitled to get benefit of previous service rendered by him for the o purposes of computing three years period of continuous service referred to in Rule 4 (1) (iii) of the Rules. In my opinion therefore, it cannot be countenaneed that the I.G. Registration has misconstrued and misapplied the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Khagesh Kumar (supra) and I am of the considered view that on the findings of fact recorded by the I.G. Registration in the orders impugned in respect of the total period of service tendered by the petitioners, case for the regularisation under Rule 4. (1) (iii) of the Rules is not made out.

    5. The learned Counsel for the petitioners then submitted that the petitioners are entitled to be regularised in view of the latest notification dated July 9, 1998 issued by the Governor making Rules known as the 1 Uttar Pradesh Regularisatio of Daily Wage Appointments on Group 'C Posts (Outside the Purview of Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998 in exercise of power under Article 309 of the Constitution. The Rules have overriding effect and Daily rated employee working on group 'C posts would be entitled to be regularised notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in. any other rules or orders in case, they fulfill the requisite conditions of regulsisatiion stipulated in the Rules. Rule 4 in so far as it is relevant may be abstracted below :

    "4. (1) Any person who-

    (i) was directly appointed on daily wage basis on Group 'C' post in the Government service before June 29, 1991 and is continuing in service as such on the date of commencement of these rules and

    (ii) possessed requisite qualifications prescribed for regular appointment or that post at the time of such appointment under the relevant service Rules on daily wage basis, shall be considered for regular appointment on group 'C' post in permanent or temporary vacancy as may be available on the date of commencement of these Rules on the basis of his record and suitability before any regular appointment is made in such vacancy in accordance with the relevant service rules or orders.

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (3) For the purpose of sub-rule (1) the appointing authority shall constitute a Selection Committee an accordance with the relevant provisions of the Service Rules.

    (4) The appointing authority shall, having regard to the provisions of sub-rule (1), prepare an eligibility list of the candidates arranged in order of seniority as determined from the date of order of appointment and if two or more persons are appointed together, from the order in which their names are arranged in the said appointment order. The list shall be placed before the selection committee along with their character rolls and such other records, pertains to them as may be considered necessary to assess their suitability.

    (5) The Selection Committee shall consider the cases of the candidates on the basis of their records referred to in sub-rule (4) and if it considers necessary, it shall interview the candidates also to assess their suitability."

    6. It is evident from the provisions aforestated that in order to get benefit of the regularisation Rules,' a daily rated employee must have been directly appointed on Group 'C ' post in the Government Service "before June 29, 1991 and is continuing in service as such on the date of commencement of these Rules, and must also possess the requisite qualifications prescribed for regular appointment for the post at the time of such appointment under the relevant Service Rules on daily wage basis, Rules were notified on July 9, 1998 i.e. during the pendency of the writ petition. The petitioners were no-doubt appointed before June 29, 1991, and in view of the findings of fact recorded by I.G. Registration it is evident that the petitioner Bhupendra Singh Bhaduaria worked from May 1991, to 16.4.94 and Maya Shankar Vishuvarama from May 1991 to 6.12.94 on the basis of interim orders passed by the Court, but prima facie, nothing has been brought on record showing that the petitioners were continuing in service as daily rated Registration clerk on the date of commencement of the Regularisation Rules, 1998 i.e. July 9, 1998. However, since Rules aforestated were made during the pendency of the writ petition. I consider it appropriate to leave it own to the petitioners to stake their claims regularisation, if so advised, on the basis of the Uttar Pradesh Regulation of Daily Wages Appointment on Group 'C' Posts (Outside the Purview of the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules, 1998. In case, any such claim is made, the I.G. Registration shall take appropriate decision in the matter in accordance with law. In so far as petitioners, claim regarding continuance on daily wage basis till the regular selections are made, in the case aforestated was decided by the Apex Court vide order dated November.8, 1996 passed on Interlocutory Application No. 6 of 1996 in Civil Appeal No. 7500 of 1996, I.G. Registration and Anr. v. Avdhesh Kumar and Ors., which reads as under :

    "While disposing of the appeal on April 12, 1996 we had directed that though their appointments were not valid in law and cannot be regularised, all the working daily wage employees working would be continued termporarily all the regularly selected candidates are appointed. This order would be applicable to those candidates who would be working on daily wage basis on the date. It is seen on the facts in this case that the respondents were continuing on the day when the High Court had passed the order. When the matter was being disposed of by this Court finally, they were terminated. We have clarified on the earlier occasion than in the event of their succeeding (sic) in the main matter their cases would be considered as we have already directed that temporary candidates containing as on the date of the order will continue on daily wage basis till regularly selected candidates are appointed. The benefit of the order would also go the respondents.

    The IA is accordingly clarified and this order of benefit will not be applicable to Any other person."

    7. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners failed to make out a case for continuance on daily wage basis till regular selections are made inasmuch as it could not be established that the petitioners were, in fact, working as on 12.4.1996.

    8. In the result, the petition fails and is dismissed subject to course, to the observation aforestated.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajai Kumar Misra And Ors. v. Secretary Of Institutional Finance, U.P. Shasan And Ors.
    (Nov 27, 1998)