AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Sharma, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are employed as daily-wagers/muster-roll employees in the Forest Department of the Government of Uttar Pradesh for periods ranging from about three to twenty years (in some cases more than twenty years). They filed writ petitions seeking a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to regularise their service and to pay them the same salary paid to regular employees belonging to Class III and Class IV.

Several related proceedings are referenced and consolidated for decision by a common judgment:

  • Writ Petition No. 23091 of 1995, Sheo Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh — allowed by a Single Judge on 25 August 1995; Government filed Special Appeal No. 90 of 1996 and an application to recall the order which was rejected on 2 October 1996; Special Appeal No. 628 of 1996 was also filed by the Government.
  • Writ Petition No. 15302 of 1993, Putti Lal v. State of Uttar Pradesh — a Single Judge passed an interim order directing the State Government to formulate a scheme for regularisation/absorption; Special Appeal No. 653 of 1995 was filed against that order.
  • Other prior writ petitions (e.g., Jai Ram Chaudhary v. State of Uttar Pradesh — W.P. No. 6588 of 1977; Pan Bai v. State of Uttar Pradesh — W.P. No. 38151 of 1995) were cited to illustrate duration of service of certain petitioners.

The Government filed counter-affidavits in some of the writ petitions; petitioners filed rejoinder affidavits. Because the controversy and relief sought were substantially similar across matters, the court decided them by a single, common judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Government can operate the Forest Department primarily by employing daily-wagers/muster-roll employees at Class III and IV level for long periods without giving them job security and without paying wages equivalent to regular employees in corresponding cadres.
  2. Whether employment of persons for a considerable long time on meagre wages without regularising their service is unfair, arbitrary and unreasonable in light of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
  3. Whether regularisation of daily-wagers' service is permissible in the absence of available posts/vacancies (as addressed in Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar), and how that principle applies to the present cases.
  4. Whether the directions issued in Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh (Writ Petition No. 15627 of 1988) — directing payment of wages equivalent to minimum pay and framing of a scheme — are to be confined to the petitioners in that case or extend to other similarly placed daily-wagers across the State.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Keeping employees on daily wages for long periods is unfair, arbitrary and unreasonable; their service ought to be regularised and they should be paid the same pay as regular employees in Classes III and IV.
  • The respondents are bound by the Single Judge's judgment dated 25 February 1993 in Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which directed payment to daily-wagers at the rate equivalent to the minimum pay-scale of regular employees in corresponding cadres and directed framing of a scheme for regularisation/absorption.
  • Because this Court has in other matters directed regularisation of service in similar circumstances, the present petitioners—being similarly placed—are entitled to similar relief.
  • The learned counsel also raised subsidiary points in support of the main submissions (the judgment states it is not necessary to refer to them in view of the order proposed).

Respondents' Arguments (as represented by the Additional Advocate-General)

  • There are neither vacancies for regularisation of the petitioners' service nor funds to create regular or supernumerary posts for their absorption.
  • The directions in Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh should be confined to the members of the petitioners in that case and similar benefits should not be extended to other daily-wagers even if similarly placed.
  • Directions given in other writ petitions are confined to the parties to those petitions; persons who were not parties cannot be regularised or paid salary equivalent to regular employees based on those judgments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar [(1977) 2 S.C.C. 1] Service of daily-wagers cannot be regularised unless posts/vacancies are available for their absorption. The court acknowledged this settled principle but explained that the present issue is broader than mere regularisation: it questions whether the Government may run the department primarily by long-term daily-wagers without job security or equivalent pay.
E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu [(1974) 4 SCC 3 : A.I.R. 1974 S.C. 555] Equality is antithetic to arbitrariness; Article 14 strikes at arbitrariness. The court relied on this principle to support the proposition that unfair or arbitrary State action (such as prolonged engagement of daily-wagers without security or parity) would violate Article 14.
Smt. Menaka Gandhi v. Union of India [(1978) 1 SCC 248 : A.I.R. 1978 S.C. 597] Article 14 requires reasonableness and fairness in State action; procedure must meet the test of reasonableness under Art. 21 as well. Used to reinforce that employment practices must be reasonable and non-arbitrary; prolonged casual employment for permanent needs offends constitutional guarantees.
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India [1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : A.I.R. 1993 SC 477] The doctrine of equality is dynamic; Articles 14–18 should be read in light of Directive Principles (Part IV) aimed at equality of status and opportunity and minimising inequalities. Invoked to situate Articles 14–16 within broader constitutional goals (adequate means of livelihood, minimising inequalities) and to underline the State's obligations in employment matters.
Chief Conservator of Forests v. Jagannath Maruti Kondhare [(1996) 1 L.L.N. 475] Employment of employees on casual/temporary basis for several years (5–6 years in that case) amounts to "unfair labour practice"; the Supreme Court rejected the financial inability argument to deny regularisation. The court cited this decision to show that sustained casual employment can constitute unfair labour practice and that the plea of financial burden is not necessarily a bar to regularisation; the case treated the Forest Department as an industry and casuals as workmen under the Act.
Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh (W.P. No. 15627 of 1988) Single Judge directed payment to daily-wagers at rates equivalent to the minimum pay of regular employees in corresponding cadres and directed the Government to frame a scheme for regularisation within six months. The court held that the directions issued by the Single Judge are not confined to members of that association and that benefits of that judgment must extend to all similarly placed daily-wagers; the Government is bound to pay in terms of that judgment and to frame a scheme.
Jai Ram Chaudhary v. State of Uttar Pradesh (W.P. No. 6588 of 1977) and Pan Bai v. State of Uttar Pradesh (W.P. No. 38151 of 1995) These prior writ petitions were cited as factual precedents showing long periods of service by certain petitioners (dates and posts listed). The court used these earlier petitions as factual support demonstrating that many daily-wagers have worked for long durations (some since the 1960s/1970s) without security of tenure.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by first outlining the factual matrix: two categories of daily-wager employees are employed in the Forest Department (monthly-paid against vouchers and muster-roll daily-wage paid workers), but both perform almost similar work and discharge similar duties. The factual material included data (particularly for the Bundelkhand division) showing that regular Class III and IV cadres were far smaller in number than the corresponding daily-wager strength, indicating that the department was being run largely through daily-wagers.

The court then addressed the applicable legal principles:

  • It recognised the settled principle (Ashwani Kumar) that regularisation requires available posts/vacancies, but emphasised that the present controversy was wider — namely whether the Government may run the Department primarily by prolonged casual employment without job security or pay parity.
  • The court analysed the matter through Articles 14 and 16 (equality before the law and equal opportunity). It invoked E.P. Royappa and Menaka Gandhi to stress that equality forbids arbitrariness and requires reasonableness and fairness in State action.
  • The court further situated Articles 14–16 in the framework of Part IV Directive Principles (citing Indra Sawhney), noting State obligations such as securing adequate means of livelihood and minimising inequalities.
  • The court held that daily-wagers are meant for unexpected or temporary workload, not for permanent or semi-permanent needs; prolonged employment of daily-wagers for long periods (in some cases over 20 years) indicates a permanent or semi-permanent requirement, which ought to have been met by regular appointments rather than continued casual engagement.
  • The court referred to the Industrial Disputes Act (definition of "unfair labour practice") and the Kondhare precedent to note that sustained casual employment can be unfair labour practice and that financial constraints do not automatically absolve the State from obligations to regularise where justified.
  • With respect to the Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre judgment, the court rejected the Government's contention that that judgment's directions were confined to the petitioners in that case. The court emphasised that the State cannot give different treatment to similarly placed employees without plausible justification; no such justification had been shown, and the benefits of that judgment must therefore extend to all similarly situated daily-wagers.

The court noted limitations in the record: the Bundelkhand data was available, but there was insufficient material for other divisions, so it relegated further fact-finding and detailed scheme formulation to the Government. The court also observed that while certain Government-proposed schemes had been submitted, they were inadequate and showed a lack of considered application of mind.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Writ petitions and the appeals are partly allowed. The impugned judgments in the appeals were set aside to the extent indicated by the court's order.

Direct remedies and directives issued by the Court (as the operative consequence):

  • The Government of Uttar Pradesh is directed to constitute a committee within one month of production of a certified copy of this judgment before the Secretary, Forest Department. The committee must consist of the Secretaries of the Finance and Forest Departments and the Legal Remembrancer or their nominees.
  • The committee will consider framing a scheme for regularisation/absorption of the petitioners and other similarly placed employees working in the Forest Department and the schemes undertaken by that Department. The committee must pass a speaking order and submit its report within three months of its constitution.
  • The association/union of the petitioners may make representations to the committee containing their grievances; if such representations are made, the committee must decide them by speaking order within the same three-month period.
  • After receipt of the committee's report, the Government will pass an appropriate order taking the report and material on record into consideration within one month of receipt of the report.
  • The entire exercise by the committee and the Government is to be completed within six months from the date of production of the certified copy of the judgment before the Government. Till then, parties shall maintain status quo.
  • The court expressly held that the benefits of the Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre judgment (payment at rates equivalent to minimum pay-scales of corresponding regular cadres and framing of a scheme) must extend to all similarly placed daily-wagers, and that the Government is bound to pay in terms of that judgment.

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion directs concrete administrative steps (committee formation, speaking orders, timelines) and requires the Government to consider uniform treatment for similarly placed daily-wagers in line with the court's reading of prior rulings. The judgment does not purport to lay down any novel legal doctrine beyond its application of existing precedents and constitutional principles; the primary effect is the directed administrative process and extension of the Kumaun judgment's benefits to similarly situated employees.

Disposition: Appeals and writ petitions partly allowed.

    State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others v. Putti Lal And Others

    Sharma, J.:— The petitioners are working as daily-wagers/muster-roll employees in Forest Department of the Government of Uttar Pradesh for the last several years ranging from about 3 to 20 years. They have filed these writ petitions seeking writ of mandamus directing the respondents to regularise their service and to pay them the same salary which is being paid to the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV.

    2. One of these Writ Petition No. 23091 of 1995, Sheo Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh was allowed by a learned Single Judge on August 25, 1995, with direction to regularise the service of the petitioners therein in terms of the earlier judgment of this Court in Writ Petition No. 26925 of 1990. Against this judgment Special Appeal No. 90 of 1996 has been filed. The Government applied for recall of the said order, dated 25 August 1995. This application was rejected by the learned Single Judge vide order, dated 2 October 1996. While rejecting that application the learned Judge also directed for regularisation of the service of the petitioners therein within one month failing which to face the contempt proceeding. Against the said order another Special Appeal No. 628 of 1996 has been filed by the Government. In another Writ Petition No. 15302 of 1993, Putti Lal v. State of Uttar Pradesh a learned Single Judge passed an interim order directing the State Government to formulate a scheme for regularisation/absorption of the employees working as daily-wager/muster-roll employees. Against the said order Special Appeal No. 653 of 1995 has been filed.

    3. The controversy involved in these writ petitions and special appeals being the same, they are being decided by a common judgment. The Government has filed counter-affidavit only in some writ petitions and the petitioners have filed rejoinder-affidavit in reply thereto.

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioners have made three submissions in support of the writ petitions, viz.:

    (i) keeping the employees for a long period on daily wages is highly unfair, arbitrary and unreasonable. The petitioners' service is, therefore, liable to be regularised and they are also entitled to be paid the same pay which is being paid to regular employees belonging to Classes III and IV:

    (ii) the respondents are bound by the judgment, dated 25 February 1993, Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh [Writ Petition No. 15627 of 1988], whereby this Court directed them to pay to the daily-wager/muster-roll employees the wages at the rate equivalent to the minimum pay-scale of the regular employees in corresponding cadres and also to frame scheme for regularisation of their service; and

    (iii) as this Court has allowed a number of writ petitions earlier directing regularisation of service of the petitioners therein, the present petitioners are also entitled to the similar direction, because they and the petitioners in earlier writ petitions which have been allowed, are similarly placed. In support of the above three main points some subsidiary points have also been raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners, but it is not necessary to refer to them in this judgment in view of the order which is proposed to be passed in these cases.

    5. On the other hand, learned Additional Advocate-General, who represents the respondents, while disputing the contentions of learned counsel for the petitioners, has made three submissions, namely:

    (1) there are neither vacancies for regularisation of the petitioners' service nor the Government has funds to create regular or supernumerary posts for their absorption;

    (2) the directions given by this Court in the case of Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh (vide supra), have to be confined to the members of the petitioners therein and similar benefits cannot be given to other daily-wagers/muster-roll employees even if they belong to the same class to which the members of the petitioners therein belong; and

    (3) directions given in other writ petitions are also to be confined to the petitioners who filed those petitions and service of the persons who were not parties in those writ petitions cannot be regularised and for the same reason they cannot be paid salary equivalent to the salary which is paid to the regular employees of the department belonging to Class III and Class IV

    6. According to the affidavit of Sri P.L Punia, Principal Secretary, Forest Department, Government of Uttar Pradesh in Forest Department of this State two types of daily-wagers have been employed, viz.:

    (1) those who are paid fixed wages on monthly basis against vouchers. They are called daily-wagers paid against vouchers; and

    (2) muster-roll employees who are paid on daily-wage basis.

    Difference between the two classes is only of the modes of payment; while former are paid on monthly basis against vouchers, the payment to the latter is made on daily-wage basis. But they perform almost similar work and discharge similar duties. Some of these workers are working in the Forest Department itself, while others are working in various schemes undertaken by that department and if any such scheme has been completed or given-up they have been transferred from one scheme to another. All these workers have been engaged by Forest Department and are paid their wages by it. According to the Government there are about 20 thousand such employees in Forest Department but, according to the petitioners there are about 55 thousand, employees of this nature working in the department. These employees are working in the Forest Department for the last several years ranging from 3 to 20 years. In some cases such employees are working in the department for more than even 20 years. In this connection reference may be made to Writ Petition No. 6588 of 1977, Jai Ram Chaudhary v. State of Uttar Pradesh, in Para. 2 of which the years from which the petitioners therein are working have been given. Said Para. 2 is reproduced below:

    “2. That the services rendered by the petitioners are as follows.

    Name/Post Working since Place Qualification 1. Jairam Chaudhary Barrier Muharrir 1970 Pharenda IX Pass 2. Shyam Dhar Pandey Barrier Muharrir 1973 Pakari Range High School 3. Sri Rajesh Pathak Watcher 1987 Laxmipur Range Intermediate 4. Sri Niwas Watcher 1987 Pharenda Range VIII Pass 5. Gaj Raj Watcher 1982 Pakari Range V Pass 6. Palak Dhari Protection Watcher 1979 Pakari Range V Pass 7. Sukhey Yadav Protection Watcher 1976 Pharenda Range VIII Pass 8. Parikhan Yadav Protection Watcher 1984 Pakari Range VIII Pass
    9. Govind Prasad Range Clerk 1962 Pharenda Range VIII Pass 10. Sri Ghisiyavan Wireless operator 1977 Pakari Range VIII Pass 11. Daya Ram Ahir Dakiya 1983 Pakari Range High School”

    The Writ Petition No. 38151 of 1995, Pan Bai v. State of Uttar Pradesh is also relevant in this regard, in Para. 2 of which years from which the petitioners therein are working, have been mentioned. The same is reproduced below:

    “That the period of service the petitioners have rendered in the Forest Department and their respective ranges where they have been working is being stated as below:

    Sl. Name of Petitioner Year Range Post 1. Pan Bai 1964 Gauna Sweeper 2. Smt. Genda Rani 1975 Gauna Sweeper

    It is thus apparent that most of the petitioners have spent cream periods of their lives in the Forest Department working on meagre wages without security of tenure.

    7. There is another important factor which needs to be mentioned. In Writ Petition No. 15302 of 1993 Putti Lal v. State of Uttar Pradesh (vide supra), data compiled in the book form has been filed by the petitioners which has been taken on record. This contains the following details of permanent staff and daily-wagers working in Bundelkhand Division/Circle consisting of five Districts, namely, Banda, Hamirpur, Jhansi, Lalitpur and Orai:

    “Bundelkhand Forest Circle (Banda, Jhansi, Hamirpur, Lalitpur, Mahoba and Oral Divisions.

    Compartive study of permanent and fixed wagers staff as per Government Affidavit

    8. Class 3 and Class 4 post only.

    Name of division Permanent staff D. Wager Banda 70 316 Hamripur and Mahoba 51 303 Jhansi 69 270 Lalitpur 91 237 Oral 61 148 Total 342 1274

    What appears glaring from the data is that the Government is almost running the Forest Department at the level of Class III and IV posts primarily through daily-wager/muster-roll employees who have spent major parts of their lives in Forest Department earning meagre wages without security of tenure. The learned counsel for the petitioners, in this connection, have also, highlighted the fact that the strength of regular cadres of Class in and IV in the Forest department has not been increased by the Government for the last several years, because the Government does not consider it necessary to do so, as the department is being run at the Class in and IV level through daily-wagers on payment of meagre wages.

    9. The position in law, a regards the regularisation of daily-wagers/muster-roll employees, is settled, according to which there cannot be regularisation of their service unless there are posts/vacancies. It is not necessary to ate all the cases in this connection and it will be sufficient to refer to Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar [(1977) 2 S.C.C 1], only wherein the Supreme Court has laid down that service of the daily-wagers cannot be regularised unless the posts/vacancies are available for their absorption. But in the present cases the issue is not simply that of regularisation of service of the daily-wagers. The real question is whether the Government can run it department primarily by daily-wagers/muster-roll employees at Class III and Class IV level without giving them job security and without paying them the wages/salary equivalent to that which is paid to the regular employees belonging to those classes. Interlinked with this question is the question as to whether employment of persons for considerable long time on meagre wages without regularising their service is unfair, arbitrary and unreasonable. The answer of the respondents to these questions is simple namely, there are not many posts/vacancies available for regularisation of service of daily-wagers and the Government has no funds for creating extra regular or supernumerary posts for their absorption/regularisation. However, it is not the case of the respondents that the appointments of the petitioners were void or illegal. The petitioners were appointed as per normal practice prevailing at the time of their appointments.

    10. Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution guarantees equality before the law and the equal protection of the laws. Supreme Court in E.P Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu [(1974) 4 SCC 3 : A.I.R 1974 S.C 555], has laid down that:

    “equality is antithetic to arbitrariness. In fact equality and arbitrariness are sworn enemies,

    one appeals to the rule of law in a republic, while the other, to the whim and caprice of a absolute monarch. Where an act is arbitrary, it is implicit in it that it is in-equal both according to political logic and constitutional law and, therefore, violative of Art. 14.”

    In Smt. Menaka Gandhi v. Union of India [(1978) 1 SCC 248 : A.I.R 1978 S.C 597], Supreme Court has reiterated the same rule holding as under:

    “Article 14 strikes at arbitrariness in State action and ensures fairness and equality of treatment. The principle of reasonableness, which legally as well as philosophically, is an essential element of equality or non-arbitrariness pervades Art. 14 like a brooding omnipresence and the procedure contemplated by Art. 21 must answer the test of reasonableness in order to be in conformity with Art. 14. It must be right and just and fair and not arbitrary, fanciful or oppressive, otherwise, it would be no procedure at all and the requirement of Art. 21 would not be satisfied.”

    Articles 14 and 16 ensure fairness, reasonableness and non-arbitrariness in the Government actions. Article 38 of the Constitution places legal obligation on the State to strive to promote the welfare of the people by securing and protecting “social order in which justice, social, economic and political shall inform all the institutions of the national life.” The State is also required to minimise the inequalities in income and statutes. Article 39 mandates the State to ensure that all citizens have the right to an adequate means of livelihood and there is equal pay for equal work for both men and women. Article 39A has provided that the State shall secure that the operation of the legal system promotes justice on a basis of equal opportunity. Article 41 ensures right to work, to education and to public assistance in cases of unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement. The Supreme Court in Paras. 4 and 5 of its judgment in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India [1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : A.I.R 1993 SC 477], has, in this connection, laid down as follows

    “The doctrine of equality has many facets. It is dynamic, and an evolving concept. Its main facets, relevant to Indian society, have been referred to in the preamble and the articles under the sub-heading ‘Right to equality’” —(Articles 14 to 18). In short, the goal is ‘equality of status and of opportunity.’ Articles 14 to 18 must be understood not merely with reference to what they say but also in the light of the several articles in Part IV (Directive Principles of State Policy) ‘justice, social, economic and political’ is the sum total of the aspirations incorporated in Part IV.

    Article 14 enjoins upon the State not to deny to any person ‘equality before the law’ or ‘equal protection of the laws’ within the territory of India.

    The content and sweep of these two concepts is not the same though there may be much in common. The content of the expression ‘equality before the law’ is illustrated not only by Arts. 15 and 18 but also by the several articles in Part IV, in particular, Arts. 38, 39, 39A and 46. Among others, the concept of equality before the law contemplates minimising the inequalities in income and eliminating the inequalities in status, facilities and opportunities not only amongst the people, securing adequate means of livelihood to its citizens.”

    The Government works through its servants whose conditions of service including the pay-scale are regulated by it statutory rules and/or by administrative orders subject to Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution. The strength of the service in the Government department is fixed and is also increased according to the requirement of work. In the present case the strength of Class III and Class IV in the Forest Department has been increased and the Department has undertaken various schemes. It appears that all the schemes are not of permanent nature, but the daily-wagers have not been appointed scheme-wise. They have been employed by the Forest Department and if a scheme has been completed or abandoned they have been transferred to other scheme. It is obligatory for the Government to pay salary to its employees according to prescribed pay scales. It is not open to it to pay them less than what has been fixed. The daily-wagers are appointed to meet the unexpected or temporary increased work load. No such appointment can be made when the need is permanent or semi-permanent to last for long period except for a short period by way of interim arrangement. The Government cannot take advantage of prevailing unemployment in the society by employing daily-wagers even when the need is of permanent or semi-permanent nature. To meet such needs regular appointments are required to be made. The fact that daily wagers are working for considerable long time, in some cases even for more than 20 years, demonstrates that the requirement of the additional hands in the department was of permanent or semi-permanent nature and the Government in such situation should have taken steps for making regular appointments. But that has not been done. Instead daily-wagers have been appointed who are working on meagre wages. May be that through this method the Government can employ persons on meagre wages, but such a course is not permissible in view of the underlying principle contained in Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

    12. The observations made above are based on the data relating to Bundelkhand division, supplied by the petitioners. There is no material on the record as regards other circles/divisions in the State. As we are relegating the matter to the Government it is to consider the whole issue after collecting necessary materials from all the divisions/circles of the State.

    13. In this connection reference may also be made to the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), S. 2(ra) of which has defined “unfair labour practice” as under:

    “2(ra)” unfair labour practice means any of the practices specified in the Fifth Schedule.”

    Serial No. 1 of “unfair labour practice” contained in Fifth Schedule appended to the Act, being relevant, in this connection, is reproduced below

    “10. To employ workmen as ‘badlis,’ casuals or temporaries and to continue them as such for years, with the object of depriving them of the status and privileges of permanent workmen.”

    By the said provision employment of persons as badlis, casual or temporary for years has been declared to be “unfair labour practice.” “Almost similar definition of ‘unfair labour practice’” contained in Maharashtra Act came up for consideration in Chief Conservator of Forests v. Jagannath Maruti Kondhare [(1996) 1 L.L.N 475], wherein the Supreme Court affirmed the decision of Industrial Court holding that employment of the employees on casual or temporary basis for several years (5 to 6 years in that case) amounts to unfair labour practice. The Supreme Court also rejected the Government's plea about its inability to regularise the service of daily-wagers on account of paucity of funds holding as under, in Paras. 28 and 29, at pages 481 and 482:

    “28. In so far as the financial strain on State exchequer is concerned, which submission is sought to be buttressed by Sri Dholakia by stating that in the Forest Department itself the casual employees are about 1.4 lakhs and if all of them were to be regularised and paid at the rate applicable to permanent workmen, the financial involvement would be in the neighbour hood of Rs. 300 crores — a very high figure indeed. We have not felt inclined to bear in mind this contention of Sri Dholakia as the same has been brought out almost from the hat. The argument relating to financial burden is one of despair or in terrorem. We have neither been impressed by the first nor frightened by the second inasmuch a we do not intend that the view to be taken by us in these appeals should apply, proprio vigore, to all casual labourers of the Forests Department or any other department of the Government.

    29. We wish to say further that if Sri Bhandare's submission is taken to its logical end, the justification for paying even minimum wages could wither away, leaving any employer, not to speak of model employer like the State, to exploit unemployed persons. To be fair to Sri Bhandare it may, however, be stated that the learned counsel did not extend his submission this far, but we find it difficult to limit the submission of Sri Bhandare to payment of, any fair wages, as distinguished from minimum wages. We have said so, because if a pay-scale has been provided for permanent workmen that has been done by the State Government keeping in view its legal obligations and must be one which had been recommended by the State Pay Commission and accepted by the Government. We cannot deny this relief of permanency to the respondent workmen only because in that case they would be required to be paid wages meant for permanent workers. This right flows automatically from the relief of regularisation to which no objection can reasonably be taken, as already pointed out. We would, however, observe that the relief made available to the respondents is not one which would be available ipso facto to all the casual employees either of the Forests Department or any other department of the State. Claim of casual employees for permanency or for higher pay shall have to be decided on the merits of their own cases.”

    In the aforesaid case the Supreme Court held that Forest Department is an industry and casual/daily-wagers are workman under the Act.

    14. In pursuance of the directions issued by this Court pending these cases the Government of Uttar Pradesh has submitted more than one scheme for regularisation of the petitioners, but those schemes hardly contain any hope, for their regularisation. It has been stated therein that the petitioners can be considered for regularisation against available vacancies after amending service rules. Available vacancies being few no substantial help can be expected from them. That apart, the Government while framing those schemes has not applied its mind to the questions dealt with herein above. These are aspects which are to be considered by the Government before framing scheme for absorption of the petitioners. In the present case the appropriate pleadings are also not there, so as to declare the employment of the petitioners as daily-wager for considerable long period as “unfair labour practice.” We are, therefore, not expressing any final opinion on this question also. The questions dealt with herein above are to be considered and decided by the Government before framing the scheme for regularisation/absorption of the petitioners and other similarly placed employees.

    15. As regards the second submission advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners it may be noted that the Writ Petition No. 15627 of 1988 was filed by an association known as Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre and a daily-wager seeking writ of mandamus directing the respondents therein namely, State of Uttar Pradesh Secretary Forest, Lucknow, and Additional Chief Conservator of Forest Kumaun at Nainital, to frame the scheme and to pay the petitioner 2, and other similarly placed employees the wages at the rates equivalent to minimum pay in the pay-scales of the regularly employed workers in the corresponding cadres. The learned Judge while allowing the writ petition did not confine his judgment to the petitioners members only but issued general directions to the respondents therein for payment of wages/salary and for framing the scheme for regularisation. Relevant extract of the judgment of learned Judge, is reproduced below:

    “… But the petitioners have certainly made out a case for issuance of a direction to the respondents to pay to petitioner 2 and other similarly circumstanced daily-rated labourers/workers under the control of the respondents, the wages at the rates equivalent to the minimum pay in the pay scales of the regularly employed workers in the corresponding cadres but without any increments with effect from 19 August 1988 on which date the writ petition was filed in this Court together with corresponding dearness allowances and additional clearness allowances, if any payable thereon, with a further direction to the respondents to frame a scheme within a period of six months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order before the Secretary, Forest Department, Government of Uttar Pradesh and the Chief Conservator of Forest Department, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow.”

    The submission of the learned Additional Advocate-General to the effect that the directions given by this Court in the case of Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre v. State of Uttar Pradesh (vide supra), should be confined to the members of that Association, cannot be accepted for another reason, viz., it is not open to the Government to pay different pay-scale and give different treatment to the similarly placed employees working in the State unless there is plausible justification for such a treatment. In the instant case no such justification has been demonstrated by the respondents. Therefore, benefits of the said judgment of the learned Judge have to go to all the daily-wagers/muster-roll employees. It is admitted by the respondents that the pay at the rate as directed by the learned Judge in the said case, is being paid to those daily-wagers who are members of Kumaun Van Shramik Sangh Centre and such payment is not being made to any other daily-wager working anywhere in the State including Kumaun hills. It is also admitted that the scheme as directed by the learned Judge has not been framed by the Government so far. The judgment of the learned Judge is binding on the Government and its functionaries. They are, therefore, bound to pay in terms of the said judgment to every daily-rated labourers/muster-roll employees and the Government is also bound to frame scheme of regularisation of their service.

    16. As we are sending back these cases to the Government for consideration of all the questions, it is not necessary to deal with the third point raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners.

    17. For the reasons given above, these writ petitions and the appeals are partly allowed. The judgment impugned in the appeals were set aside. The Government of Uttar Pradesh is directed to appoint a committee consisting of Secretaries of Finance and Forest Departments and the legal remembrancer or their nominees within a month of production of certified copy of this judgment before the Secretary, Forest Department, Uttar Pradesh. The committee so appointed will consider the question of framing scheme for regularisation/absorption of the petitioners and other similarly placed employees working in the Forest Department and the schemes undertaken by the said department. The committee will pass speaking order and will submit its report within a period of three months of the date of its constitution by the Government. It will be open to the Association Union of the petitioners to make representation containing all their grievances in this regard before the committee and if such a representation is made the same shall also be decided by speaking order by the said committee within the same time specified above. The Government will thereafter pass appropriate order taking into consideration the report of the committee and material available on the record, within one month of the receipt of the report of the Committee. The whole exercise by the committee as well as by the Government should be completed within six months from the date of production of certified copy of this judgment before the Government. Till then the parties shall maintain status quo.

    Appeals and writ petitions partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others v. Putti Lal And Others
    (Dec 10, 1997)