Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 11(3) of the U.P Sales Tax Act
  • Sec. 4 of the U.P Sales Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 11(3) of the U.P Sales Tax Act
  • Sec. 4 of the U.P Sales Tax Act

    Commissioner Of Sales Tax v. Bishram Tiwari

    Gulati, J.:— At the instance of the Commissioner of Sales Tax, U.P Lucknow, the Additional Revising, Authority, Sales Tax, Varanasi, has submitted this statement of the case under Sec. 11(3) of the U.P Sales Tax Act for the opinion of this Court on the following question of law:—

    “Whether in view of the above facts and in the circumstances ‘sprayers’ will be treated as agricultural implement in view of the notification Nos. ST-911.X dated 31-3-1956 or they are machinery as provided under notification No. ST-1367.X-1045 (19)-60, dated 5-4-1961?”

    2. The assessee carries on business in brass syrenges and agricultural sprayers. In respect of the assessment year 1963-1964 the assessee claimed exemption from tax on his turnover of sprayers on the basis of notification No. S.T-911.X dated 31-3-1956. The sales Tax officer did not accept the assessee's claim. On appeal the appellate authority held that sprayers were agricultural implements but since they were not included in the articles enumerated in the notification their turnover was not entitled to exemption. The Judge (Revisions) before whom the assessee went up in revision allowed the assessee's claim holding that the sprayers being agricultural implements were covered by the notification even though they were not included in the argicles enumerated in the notification. In his opinion the notification was not exhaustive.

    3. The Notification Nos. S.T-911.X dated 31-3-1956 is a notification under Sec. 4 of the U.P Sales Tax Act and exempts from the tax certain articles mentioned in the two lists attached to that notification. Item No. 1 of List II reads:

    “Agricultural implements worked by human or animal power, namely, Khurpi (Hoe), Dibber, spade, Hansia (Sickle), Garden Knife, Axe, Gandasa, Chaff-cutter, Shears, Secateurs, rake, shovel, ploughs and accessories thereof, water lifting leather buckets (pur and mhot) and accessories thereof and Rahat and Persian wheel and accessories thereof.”

    4. It does not appear to have been disputed on behalf of the Sales Tax Department that a sprayer is an agricultural implement. However, the case of the Department appears to be that ‘sprayers’ are not covered by the notification of March 31, 1956, because they do not find a place in the list of the articles mentioned therein. According to the Department, the turnover of sprayer would be taxable under Notification No. S.T-1367.X-1045 (19)-1960, dated April 5, 1961 as falling in the category of ‘machinery and spare parts of Machinery’. Thus the real dispute appears to be as to whether the list of agricultural implements mentioned in the notification of March 31, 1956 is exhaustive.

    5. The notification seeks to exempt agricultural implements worked by human and animal power and contains a list of certain agricultural implements which are so worked by human and animal power. The list is preceded by the word ‘namely’. According to the New English Dictionary, the word ‘namely’ has the following meanings:

    (i) Particularly, especially, above all,

    (ii) Carefully, precisely,

    (iii) By name, individually,

    (iv) At least, at any rate,

    (v) To wit, that is to say, videlicet.

    6. It is thus clear that the word ‘namely’ has got no fixed meaning. Depending upon the context, it may mean the things which have been named or it may mean ‘for example’ or ‘such as’ or ‘atleast’.

    7. A perusal of the notification shows that the intention was to divide all the agricultural implements into two divisions viz. (i) the implements driven by human or animal power and (ii) mechanised implements or those driven otherwise by human and animal power. It does not appear to have been the intention to exempt only some of the agricultural implements driven by human and animal power and to leave out others. The idea seems to have been to exempt all agricultural implements driven by human or animal power and to tax only those agricultural implements which are worked otherwise than by human or animal power.

    8. As regards the question as to whether ‘sprayers’ would fall in the category of machinery, the same in our opinion does not arise out of the order of the Judge (Revisions), because we find no mention of that point in the revisional order. In any case ‘machinery’ is a generic name and some of the agricultural implements might well be termed as machinery. But when ‘agricultural implements’ have been specifically dealt with in the notification of March 31, 1956, their taxability would be determined with reference to that notification on the principle that specific over-rides the general.

    9. We accordingly answer the question by saying that ‘sprayers’ have lightly been treated as agricultural implements falling under the notification of March 31, 1956. The assessee is entitled to the costs which we assess at Rs. 100/- Council's fee is also assessed at the same figure.

    Question answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Sales Tax v. Bishram Tiwari
    (Feb 8, 1971)