AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922,
  • Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, upon provisions
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 3. Sub-rule (1) of rule 3
  • Act. Rule 2(h) of the U.P Sales Tax Rules
  • rule 41(5) of the U.P Sales Tax Rules,
  • provisions of the U.P Sales Tax Act.
  • rule 81 of the U.P Sales Tax Rules.
  • section 21 also. Section 2(a)
  • rule 6 read with rule 3(3)
  • Sub-rule (3) of rule 3
  • U.P Sales Tax Act,
  • Rule 2(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922,
  • Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, upon provisions
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 3. Sub-rule (1) of rule 3
  • Act. Rule 2(h) of the U.P Sales Tax Rules
  • rule 41(5) of the U.P Sales Tax Rules,
  • provisions of the U.P Sales Tax Act.
  • rule 81 of the U.P Sales Tax Rules.
  • section 21 also. Section 2(a)
  • rule 6 read with rule 3(3)
  • Sub-rule (3) of rule 3
  • U.P Sales Tax Act,
  • Rule 2(c)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee traded in cloth and was ordinarily liable for assessment by the Sales Tax Officer (S.T.O.), Sector I, Kanpur Circle under the U.P. Sales Tax Act. Assessment proceedings for the year 1953–54 were pending under rule 41(5) of the U.P. Sales Tax Rules when the Commissioner transferred the assessee's case to the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, under rule 81. The Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, completed an assessment on 23 April 1965, determining the turnover of imported cloth at 365 bales.

Subsequently information indicated the assessee had imported 450½ bales. Reassessment proceedings under section 21 (for escaped turnover) were initiated by the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I. The assessee appealed, contending that after the Commissioner had transferred the case to Sector VI there was no jurisdiction in Sector I to undertake proceedings under section 21. The Judge (Appeals) Sales Tax allowed the appeal and annulled the reassessment on the ground that S.T.O. I had no jurisdiction after transfer. The Commissioner applied in revision; the Judge (Revisions) Sales Tax dismissed the revision, agreeing with the Judge (Appeals). The Judge (Revisions) referred the following question to this Court for opinion: whether, under the circumstances, jurisdiction in proceedings under section 21 vested with S.T.O. Sector VI (to whom the assessment case had been transferred) or whether S.T.O. Sector I could have assumed jurisdiction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after the Commissioner transferred the assessee's assessment case for the year 1953–54 from S.T.O. Sector I to S.T.O. Sector VI under rule 81, jurisdiction to institute and complete proceedings under section 21 (reassessment of escaped turnover) vested in S.T.O. Sector VI or whether S.T.O. Sector I could assume jurisdiction to reassess under section 21.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The assessee contended that because the Commissioner had transferred the case for the assessment year 1953–54 from S.T.O. Sector I to S.T.O. Sector VI, S.T.O. Sector I no longer had jurisdiction to take proceedings under section 21 and could not reassess the turnover.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any specific arguments advanced by the Commissioner of Sales Tax or by S.T.O. Sector VI responding to the assessee's contention; the record shows only that the Commissioner applied in revision and that the Judges below accepted the assessee's contention.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Govindarajulu Iyer v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1948] 16 I.T.R. 391 Proceedings under the corresponding income-tax provision were regarded as one proceeding which can include supplemental or reassessment; an artificial separation between original assessment and reassessment is not justified where they relate to same assessee and period. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that reassessment under section 21 of the U.P. Sales Tax Act is a proceeding in the same assessment case and thus falls within the jurisdiction of the officer to whom the case has been transferred.
Commissioner of Income-tax v. Burmah Oil Co. Ltd. [1963] 47 I.T.R. 25 Held that escaped income assessed under the relevant provision is part of the same income for the same year and is to be treated as one assessment; the escaped income is added to the original total income and reassessed. Used to illustrate that escaped income and original assessment form one assessment for the same year and, by analogy, that reassessment under section 21 should be treated as part of the same assessment case under the U.P. Sales Tax Act.
Madhavjee Damodar Thackersay v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1935] 3 I.T.R. 457 Referenced as supporting the proposition, relied upon by other courts, that assessment of escaped income constitutes a continuation of the same assessment for the same assessee and year. Referred to in support of the line of authority treating reassessment as part of the original assessment; the Court relied on this line of authority by analogy.
Krishna Hydraulic Press Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1943] 11 I.T.R. 504 Demonstrated that original and escaped income assessments are one assessment, whereby the escaped income is added back to the original total and a new computation is made. Cited to show that reassessment operates by addition of escaped turnover to the original assessment and thus forms part of the same assessment process; relied on by analogy to U.P. Sales Tax reassessment under section 21.
Mukherjee v. Commissioner of Income-tax (Patna High Court) Adopted the same view as Govindarajulu Iyer — that reassessment is part of the same assessment proceeding under the relevant income-tax provisions. Referenced to show consistency in income-tax jurisprudence that reassessment is part of the one assessment, and used by analogy to support the conclusion under the U.P. Sales Tax Act.
In re Satyendra Mohan Roy (referenced) Referred to by the Calcutta High Court in articulating that escaped income assessment relates to the same income for the same year. Mentioned within the chain of authority relied upon to establish that reassessment is not to be artificially separated from the original assessment; the Court cited this to bolster the analogy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise statutory and analogical analysis:

  1. Statutory definitions and administrative scheme: The Court examined the statutory definitions: “assessing authority” (section 2(a)) and the definition of a “Sales Tax Officer” (rule 2(h)), together with rule 2(c) and rule 3. It emphasised that sub-rule (3) of rule 3 empowers the Commissioner to determine respective jurisdictions of multiple Sales Tax Officers within a circle, which in practice led to division of a circle into sectors (Sector I, Sector VI) and conferral of exclusive jurisdiction by sector.
  2. Transfer power under rule 81: Rule 81 authorises the Commissioner to transfer any case or class of cases at any stage from one assessing authority in a circle to another assessing authority in the same or another circle. The Court treated the Commissioner’s transfer of the assessee’s case from S.T.O. Sector I to S.T.O. Sector VI as exercising that power.
  3. Nature of proceedings under section 21: The Court analysed section 21 and observed that the “assessing authority” contemplated by section 21 is the assessing authority having jurisdiction to assess the dealer. It explained that where an original assessment has occurred and a proceeding is taken under section 21 in respect of escaped turnover, that proceeding is properly regarded as one of reassessment — i.e., it reopens the original assessment and reassesses the turnover.
  4. Scope of the transfer: The Court observed that the transfer order did not limit the transferee’s jurisdiction to only the original assessment. In the absence of any express limitation, the transferee S.T.O. (Sector VI) must be regarded as the assessing authority for all purposes under the Act in relation to that assessment year, including reassessment under section 21.
  5. Analogy to income-tax jurisprudence: To support the statutory interpretation the Court relied on established income-tax decisions (Govindarajulu Iyer, Krishna Hydraulic Press, Burmah Oil, Madhavjee, Mukherjee, and related authority) that treated reassessment of escaped income as part of the same assessment proceedings. The Court held that these authorities, though decided under the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, apply by analogy to the corresponding provisions of the U.P. Sales Tax Act.
  6. Conclusion of jurisdiction: From the above premises the Court concluded that when an assessment case is transferred from one Sales Tax Officer to another under rule 81, the transferee enjoys jurisdiction both to complete the original assessment and, if occasion arises, to reassess under section 21. Hence the reassessment initiated by S.T.O. Sector I after transfer was without jurisdiction.
  7. Costs: The Court noted that the assessee was entitled to costs and assessed them at Rs. 100; counsel's fee was assessed at the same figure.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Jurisdiction vested with the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI (the transferee); S.T.O. Sector I did not have jurisdiction to initiate reassessment proceedings under section 21 after the Commissioner transferred the case to S.T.O. Sector VI.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The reassessment proceedings taken by S.T.O. Sector I were held to be without jurisdiction. The assessee succeeded and was awarded costs of Rs. 100 and counsel's fee of Rs. 100.
  • Precedential scope: The Court applied existing income-tax authorities by analogy to interpret the U.P. Sales Tax Act; the opinion describes that ordinarily a transferred assessment case confers on the transferee authority both to complete the original assessment and to conduct reassessment under section 21. The opinion does not purport to establish a broader departure from existing authorities beyond this interpretation and does not record any distinct rule-setting beyond the application of the cited authorities to the facts of this transfer.

    Commissioner Of Sales Tax, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow v. Kakaram Magharam

    Pathak, J.:— The assessee carried on business as a dealer of cloth, and was ordinarily liable to assessment under the U.P Sales Tax Act by the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I, Kanpur Circle. Assessment proceedings for the assessment year 1953–54 were pending under rule 41(5) of the U.P Sales Tax Rules, when the Commissioner of Sales Tax transferred the case of the assessee to the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, in the same circle under rule 81 of the U.P Sales Tax Rules. The Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, made an assessment order dated 23rd April, 1965, determining the turnover of imported cloth at 365 bales. Subsequently, upon information received that the assessee had imported 450 ½ bales and not merely 365 bales, proceedings were initiated under section 21 of the Act for assessing the escaped turnover. The reassessment proceedings were taken by the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I. Against that assessment the assessee filed an appeal, and contended that the case having been transferred to the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, there was no jurisdiction in the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I, to take assessment proceedings under section 21 and reassess the turnover. The appeal was allowed by the Judge (Appeals) Sales Tax, and upholding the contention of the assessee he annulled the reassessment. He pointed out that “the record of the case shows that the case for the year 1953–54 was originally transferred to S.T.O VI, Kanpur. It is evident that S.T.O I had no jurisdiction after the transfer of the case.” The Commissioner of Sales Tax now applied in revision. The Judge (Revisions) Sales Tax, agreeing with the Judge (Appeals), dismissed the revision application. At the instance of the Commissioner, the Judge (Revisions) has referred the following question for the opinion of this court:

    “Whether under the circumstances of this case jurisdiction in proceedings under section 21 vested with the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, to whom the assessment case for the year 1953–54 had been transferred or the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I, could have assumed jurisdiction?”

    2. It will be noted that the question referred proceeds upon the basis that the case for the assessment year 1953–54 had been transferred by the Commissioner from the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I, to the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI. The point in issue is whether the case so transferred comprehended the original assessment only or could in law embrace within it an assessment under section 21 also. Section 2(a) defines an “assessing authority” as “any person authorised by the State Government to make any assessment under this Act”. Rule 2(h) of the U.P Sales Tax Rules defines a “Sales Tax Officer” as the Sales Tax Officer of a circle appointed by the State Government to perform the duties and exercise the powers of an assessing authority in such circle. Rule 2(c) defines a “circle” as a sales tax circle notified under sub-rule (1) of rule 3. Sub-rule (1) of rule 3 empowers the State Government to fix the limits of a circle and to appoint officers to the circle. Sub-rule (3) of rule 3 declares that where there are more than one Sales Tax Officer in a circle, the Commissioner of Sales Tax shall determine their respective jurisdictions within such circle. It is apparently in the exercise of that power that a circle has been divided into sectors and different Sales Tax Officers have been conferred exclusive jurisdiction in respect of different sectors. Rule 6 sets out a number of rules on the basis of which it can be determined whether an assessee falls within the jurisdiction of one Sales Tax Officer or the other. It is by reference to rule 6 read with rule 3(3) that the assessee was ordinarily liable to be assessed by the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I. Although an assessee may, by virtue of rule 6, ordinarily be liable to assessment by a particular Sales Tax Officer, nevertheless the Commissioner of Sales Tax may transfer his case from that Sales Tax Officer to another Sales Tax Officer. That power is contained in rule 81, which declares:

    “The Commissioner, Sales Tax, may transfer any case or class of cases at any stage from one assessing authority in a circle to another assessing authority or to any officer subordinate to him having the powers of the assessing authority in the same circle or in any other circle in Uttar Pradesh.”

    3. After the transfer of the case, the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, completed the assessment under rule 41(5). When proceedings for reassessment under section 21 were contemplated, could they be taken by the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I? Section 21 provides:

    “If the assessing authority has reason to believe that the whole or any part of the turnover of a dealer has, for any reason, escaped assessment to tax for any year, the assessing authority may, after issuing notice to the dealer, and making such enquiry as may be necessary, assess or reassess him to tax:

    Provided that the tax shall be charged at the rate at which it would have been charged had the turnover not escaped assessment, or full assessment, as the case may be.”

    4. The “assessing authority” contemplated by section 21 is the assessing authority having jurisdiction to assess the dealer, and the assessing authority empowered to assess the dealer was, upon transfer of the case, the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI. The order transferring the case to him did not expressly limit his jurisdiction to the original assessment proceeding. Had that been so, the position would have been quite different. In the absence of any indication to that effect, the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, must be taken to be the assessing authority in respect of the dealer for all purposes under the Act. If he had jurisdiction to complete the original assessment proceeding he had also jurisdiction to reopen that proceeding and make a reassessment. It must not be forgotten that where an original assessment has already taken place and a proceeding has to be taken under section 21 in respect of a turnover which has escaped assessment, the proceeding under section 21 is in its true nature one of reassessment. The original assessment is reopened, as it were, and the turnover is reassessed. Ordinarily, the Sales Tax Officer who had the jurisdiction to make the original assessment would have the jurisdiction to assess again. What was transferred to the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, was the case of the assessee for the assessment year 1953–54. In the absence of a specific definition specifying what a “case” is under the U.P Sales Tax Act, an assessment case would refer to a proceeding for determining the turnover of the dealer for a particular assessment year and computing the tax liability on such turnover. In that sense every proceeding taken, either initially or subsequently, by the Sales Tax Officer for determining the turnover and computing the tax liability of a dealer for that assessment year would be a proceeding in the case. It would include a proceeding upon an application under section 30 for reopening the assessment as well as a proceeding under section 22 for rectification of the assessment. There is no reason why a proceeding for reassessment under section 21 should not also be a proceeding in the case.

    5. In a case under the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, upon provisions which are somewhat analogous to those under the U.P Sales Tax Act, it has been held to include a reassessment of an assessee. In Govindarajulu Iyer v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1948] 16 I.T.R 391., the Madras High Court observed:

    “Essentially the proceedings under section 34, whether partially or totally, relate to the same proceeding which must be deemed to have commenced with the publication of the general notice under section 22(1). In some respects and in some cases it may lead to a supplemental assessment. In other cases it may result in assessment for the first time, as in this case where there has not been any assessment before. We do not find any justification for the artificial separation of a proceeding under section 34 from a proceeding relating to the original assessment or to proceedings which started before a notice under section 34, so long as they all relate to the same assessee and the same period……….”

    (Emphasis mine*).

    6. The same view was adopted by the Patna High Court in Mukherjee v. Commissioner of Income-tax. In Commissioner of Income-tax v. Burmah Oil Co. Ltd. [1963] 47 I.T.R 25, 41., the Calcutta High Court, after referring to the observations of the Bombay High Court in Madhavjee Damodar Thackersay v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1935] 3 I.T.R 457., and its own observations in In re Satyendra Mohan Roy4, said:

    “But then subject to that limitation the whole purpose and object of assessment of escaped income under section 34 show that it is one income for the same year of the same assessee which is being assessed…”

    7. And, further in the same case, after referring to its decision in Krishna Hydraulic Press Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1943] 11 I.T.R 504., it observed:

    “That shows that it is one assessment, the original and the escaped income being one. In fact, the escaped income is added back to the total income of the original assessment and then a new rate and a new slab of taxation are worked out.”

    8. Reference was also made to Govindarajulu Iyer6. Judgments in the aforesaid cases which were decided in relation to the provisions of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, apply with equal force to a case under the corresponding provisions of the U.P Sales Tax Act. To my mind, ordinarily when an assessment case of a dealer in respect of a certain assessment year is transferred from one Sales Tax Officer to another, the latter enjoys the jurisdiction not only to make the original assessment but also, should the occasion arise, to reassess that dealer for the said assessment year, and all the proceedings so taken must be considered as proceedings in that case.

    9. In this view of the matter, the case of the assessee having been transferred from the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I, to the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, jurisdiction to take the proceedings under section 21 vested in the Sales Tax Officer, Sector VI, and not in the Sales Tax Officer, Sector I. I would answer the question referred accordingly. The assessee is entitled to his costs which I assess at Rs. 100. Counsel's fee is assessed in the same figure.

    Gulati, J.:— I agree.

    10. Reference answered accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Sales Tax, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow v. Kakaram Magharam
    (Nov 12, 1969)