AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order II, Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Sec. 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act
  • provision in Fundamental Rule 54
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order II, Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Sec. 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act
  • provision in Fundamental Rule 54
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a Train Clerk in the Northern Railway, was suspended on 22nd October, 1955, and subsequently removed from service by an order dated 29th December, 1955. He filed an appeal against the removal order which remained undecided for some time. Consequently, on 10th April, 1957, the petitioner filed a writ petition in the Punjab High Court seeking to quash the removal order. On 26th November, 1959, the Punjab High Court declared the removal order void, illegal, and inoperative. Despite this, the petitioner was not paid arrears of salary for the period from 22nd October, 1955, to 1st April, 1960, when he was formally reinstated. He then approached the Payment of Wages Authority under Section 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act, seeking payment of withheld wages and compensation. The application was resisted on grounds including that the absence was treated as leave and that the application was time-barred. The Payment of Wages Authority rejected the claim on the basis that the absence was treated as leave. On appeal, the Additional District Judge held the application was barred by time, relying on Section 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act and a precedent from this High Court. The petitioner then filed a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, which was referred to a larger Bench for reconsideration in light of Supreme Court observations in a related case.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner’s application to the Payment of Wages Authority was barred by the six-month limitation period under Section 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act, considering the date of limitation should commence from the date of the writ court’s declaration rather than from the date of removal or suspension.
  2. Whether the Payment of Wages Authority has jurisdiction to determine the legality or validity of the order of removal or dismissal of a civil servant.
  3. The applicability of paragraph 2044(2) of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Volume II, in cases where an order of removal is declared void, illegal, and inoperative by a civil court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner could not approach the Payment of Wages Authority before the Punjab High Court declared the removal order void, illegal, and inoperative, making the limitation period start only from the date of that judgment (26th November, 1959).
  • The application was made within six months of the High Court’s decision and therefore was within time.
  • The precedent relied upon by the Additional District Judge (Sheo Prasad’s case) was under special appeal and thus not authoritative.

Respondent’s Arguments (Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway)

  • The petitioner’s absence was treated as leave under paragraph 2044(2) of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, and thus no wages were due.
  • The application was barred by the six-month limitation period, which should run from the date of removal or suspension, as the petitioner treated the removal as void but should have applied month by month.
  • The Payment of Wages Authority would have considered the legality of the removal order had the petitioner applied earlier.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sheo Prasad v. Additional District Judge, Moradabad Limitation period for wages claim runs from date of suspension or removal, not from date of civil court decision. The court noted this decision but distinguished it on the basis that the special appeal was pending and that the petitioner was justified in waiting for the writ court decision.
Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, Allahabad v. Pushkar Datt Sharma, 1967 14 I.F and L.R 204 Limitation for claim under Sec. 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act must be within six months of accrual of cause of action; cause of action arises only when dismissal is declared void by a competent court. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the petitioner’s cause of action arose only on the High Court’s declaration, making the application timely.
Divisional Superintendent Northern Railway v. Nandlal Dubeys, 1962 A.L.J 872 Paragraph 2044 of Indian Railway Establishment Code does not apply where removal is declared void by civil court. The court accepted this view as applicable to the present facts.
Devendra Pratap Narain Rai Sharma v. State of Uttar Pradesh Corresponding provision in Fundamental Rule 54 is not applicable where removal is declared void by civil court. Supported the court’s view on non-applicability of paragraph 2044 in such cases.
A.V D'costa v. B.C Patil, A.I.R 1955 S.C 412 Payment of Wages Authority has limited jurisdiction as conferred by the Act. The court reaffirmed the limited jurisdiction of the Payment of Wages Authority.
Shri Ambica Mills Co. Ltd. v. Shri S.B Bhatt, A.I.R 1961 S.C 970 Scope and limitation of Payment of Wages Authority’s jurisdiction regarding incidental questions. Used to emphasize that the Payment of Wages Authority cannot decide the legality of dismissal or removal orders.
Viswanath Tukaram v. General Manager, Central Railway, A.I.R 1958 Bom III Payment of Wages Authority has no jurisdiction to decide validity of termination of service. Supported the court’s conclusion on jurisdictional limits.
Eastern Railway v. Additional District Judge, 1968-II, L.L.J 582 Payment of Wages Authority cannot ignore a valid order of reduction in rank or similar orders by competent authority. Reinforced the principle of limited jurisdiction of the Payment of Wages Authority.
P.J Lartious v. Superintendent, Printing and Stationery U.P, 1965 A.L.J 292 Application to Payment of Wages Authority for arrears may be barred by Order II, Rule 2 of CPC if not made in a suit challenging dismissal. Distinguished on facts as the petitioner’s removal was quashed by writ petition, not civil suit.
Davendra Pratap v. State of Uttar Pradesh Order II, Rule 2 of CPC may not apply to writ petitions under Article 226. Supported the court’s view on maintainability of the petitioner’s application.
Noor Ali v. Kanpur Omnibus Service Ltd., A.I.R 1955 Alld. 707 Cause of action for recovery of wages during suspension accrues from date of suspension, not reinstatement. Considered in relation to limitation period but distinguished due to writ petition facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the applicability of the limitation period under Section 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act, emphasizing that the cause of action to claim wages arises only when the removal order is declared void, illegal, and inoperative by a competent civil court or in a writ petition. The court relied on Supreme Court precedent in Divisional Superintendent Northern Railway v. Pushkar Datt Sharma to support this interpretation, holding that it was justifiable for the petitioner not to approach the Payment of Wages Authority before the writ court’s decision. The court also clarified that the Payment of Wages Authority has limited jurisdiction confined to claims arising out of deductions or delays in wages and cannot adjudicate on the legality of removal or dismissal orders, which involve constitutional and service law interpretation. The court rejected the applicability of paragraph 2044(2) of the Indian Railway Establishment Code in situations where the removal order is quashed by a civil court. It held that the application before the Payment of Wages Authority was not barred by limitation and that the order treating the petitioner’s absence as leave was illegal. The court distinguished earlier decisions that relied on civil suits and procedural bars, noting the writ petition context of the present case.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final ruling was to quash the orders of the Payment of Wages Authority and the Additional District Judge, Saharanpur and to remit the case back to the Payment of Wages Authority for disposal on the basis that:

  • The petitioner’s application was not barred by the six-month limitation period under Section 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act.
  • The order treating the petitioner’s absence as leave under paragraph 2044 of the Indian Railway Establishment Code was illegal.

The parties were directed to bear their own costs. The decision directly affects the petitioner by allowing reconsideration of the wage claim on merits without limitation bar and clarifies the limited jurisdiction of the Payment of Wages Authority. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles.

    Ram Kishore Sharma v. Additional District Judge, Saharanpur

    Lokur, J.:— The petitioner, who was a Train Clerk in the Northern Railway, was placed under suspension on 22nd October, 1955, and was later removed from service by an order dated 29th December, 1955. He filed an appeal against his order of removal, which was not disposed of for sometime. Thereupon, he filed a writ petition in the Punjab High Court on 10th April, 1957, seeking to quash the order of his removal. On 26th November, 1959, the Punjab High Court declared the order of removal of the petitioner from service as void, illegal and inoperative. As the petitioner was not given the arrears of his salary for the period between 22nd October, 1955, and 1st April, 1960, on which date he jointed the service on formal reinstatement, he moved the Payment of Wages Authority under Sec. 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act for a direction, commanding the Divisional Superintendent Northern Railway, to pay to the petitioner an amount of Rs. 9,179/- towards the wages withheld for the aforesaid period, and an amount of Rs. 91,790/- by way of compensation for the deducted wages. The application was resisted by the Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, on various grounds. It was contended, inter alia, that the period of the petitioner's absence from duty was treated as leave by the Competent Authority and the application was barred by time. The Payment of Wages Authority held that the petitioner's application was not barred by time but rejected the application on the ground that he was not entitled to any wages as the period of his absence from duty was treated as leave by an order passed under paragraph 2044(2) of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Volume II, the propriety of which could not be determined by him. In appeal, the Additional District Judge, Saharanpur, held that the aforesaid paragraph 2044(2) had no application where the removal is declared to be void, illegal and inoperative; the learned Judge, however, held that the application was barred by time as it was presented beyond the period of six months prescribed by Sec. 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act. According to him, the petitioner had not submitted to the order of removal and regarded himself as continuing in service and hence the wages became due to him on various dates from 22nd October, 1955 to 1st April, 1960. He fortified himself in this view by the decision of a Single Judge of this High Court in Sheo Prasad v. Additional District Judge, Moradabad.1

    2. Aggrieved by the rejection of his application, the petitioner filed this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. The petition was originally heard by Beg, J. who referred the case to a larger Bench as he felt that the decision in Sheo Prasad's case requires reconsideration in the light of certain observations made by the Supreme Court in Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, Allahabad v. Pushkar Datt Sharma . 1967 14 I.F and L.R 204..

    3. It was argued before us by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner could not approach the Payment of Wages Authority until the Punjab High Court declared the order of his removal from service as void, illegal and inoperative, that accordingly the starting point of limitation would be the 26th of November, 1959, the date of the judgment of the High Court, that the application was made within six months of that date and was hence within time. It was also pointed out that the decision in Sheo Prasad's case was taken up in special appeal which was still pending and could not be regarded as an authority.

    4. Learned Counsel for the Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, fairly conceded before us that, as held by the learned Additional District Judge, Paragraph 2044 of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Volume II, is not applicable to a case of the present nature. That paragraph applies only where an order of removal or dismissal is set aside by a departmental authority and the employee concerned is reinstated; it does not apply to a case where the order of removal or dismissal is held by a civil court or in writ petition to be void, illegal and inoperative. Such a view was taken also by a learned Single Judge of this High Court in Divisional Superintendent Northern Railway v. Nandlal Dubeys 1962 A.L.J 872.. The Supreme Court too has expressed the same view in connection with the corresponding provision in Fundamental Rule 54 in Devendra Pratap Narain Rai Sharma v. State of Uttar Pradesh.4

    5. The only question that, therefore, survives is whether the application presented by the petitioner before the Payment of Wages Authority was within time. The first proviso to Sec. 15(2) of the Payment of Wages Act requires the application to be made within six months from the date on which the deduction from the wages was made or from the date on which the payment of wages was due to be made. It his been contended before us by the learned Council for the Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, that the petitioner, having treated the order of his removal as void, should have made the application month after month after the date of the order of removal; it is pressed, on the other hand, by the learned counsel for the petitioner that so long as the order of removal stood, it was futile to make the application month after month, since the Railway authorities could not be compelled to pay the wages in the face of the order of removal.

    6. In Sheo Prasad v. Additional District Judge, a Single Judge of this High Court has held that even where an order of removal is declared void by the civil court, the starting point of limitation would be the date of suspension or perhaps the date of removal and not the date of decision by the civil court. Reliance was placed upon another decision of a Single Judge of this High Court in Noor Ali…Plaintiff-Applicant; v. Kanpur Omnibus Service Ltd.…Defendant-Opposite Party. A.I.R 1955 Alld. 707. that, for purposes of institution of a suit for recovery of wages, where an employee is suspended from service but is later on reinstated, the cause of action for recovery of wages for the period of suspension accrues from the date of suspension and not from the date of his reinstatement. It is significant that in Sheo Prasad's case, it was recognised that it was not practicable to put forward the claim for wages until a decision from the civil court declaring the order of removal as void was obtained. The Special Appeal against the decision was disposed of on other grounds and the question about the commencement of the period of limitation was not decided.

    7. Our attention has been drawn to certain observations made by the Supreme Court in Divisional Superintendent Northern Railway v. Pushkar Datt Sharma. In that case, the employee was dismissed on 23rd December, 1947, and he challenged the validity of the order of dismissal by a civil suit. The suit was decreed on 31st March, 1951, as a result of which his dismissal was declared void. On appeal the decree was set aside and the employee's suit was dismissed on 14th August, 1952. The employee went in second appeal to the High Court and he succeeded, with the result that the decree passed by the trial court in his favour was restored on 9th January, 1962. A Special Appeal against this order was also dismissed on 16th September, 1964. The employee made an application on 7th July, 1962, before the Payment of Wages Authority for past wages due to him between 24th December, 1947 and 6th July, 1962. The Supreme Court, holding that the employee was entitled to all wages due to him, observed:

    “It may be that a claim for payment of wages has to be made within six months from the date when the wages fell due and in that sense, an application under Sec. 15(2) must be made within six months of the accrual of the cause of action from month to month; but in the present case, when the Appellate Court dismissed the respondent's suit on August 14, 1952, it was not open to the respondent to apply under Sec. 15(2) because the appellate court had held that his dismissal was justified and valid. It was only when the second appeal was allowed on January 9, 1962, that the respondent had a cause of action.”

    8. Though the employee was dismissed on 23rd December, 1947, the Supreme Court did not consider that the Payment of Wages Authority should have been approached within six months of that date; nor did the Supreme Court consider that the employee should have approached the Payment of Wages Authority within six months of 31st March, 1951, when the suit was decreed by the trial court; the Supreme Court observed that it was only when the second appeal was decided in his favour that the employee had a cause of action. In view of the above observations of the Supreme Court and the implications thereof, we are of the opinion that in the present case the petitioner was justified in not moving the Payment of Wages Authority until his removal was declared void by the Punjab High Court in his writ petition. The declaration in favour of the petitioner was made by the Punjab High Court on 26th November, 1959, and the application to the Payment of Wages Authority was made on the 28th of April, 1960, i.e within six months of the decision in his writ petition. That being so, the application was within time.

    9. It was urged on behalf of the Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, that had the petitioner applied to the Payment of Wages Authority soon after his removal, that authority would have also considered the question whether the order of removal was legal or illegal and would have given relief to the petitioner if the order were found to be illegal. This argument raises the question of jurisdiction of the Payment of Wages Authority. It is well settled now that the Payment of Wages Authority has limited jurisdiction—only to the extent conferred by the Act itself: Vide A.V D'costa v. B.C Patil A.I.R 1955 S.C 412.. In Shri Ambica Mills Co. Ltd. v. Shri S.B Bhatt A.I.R 1961 S.C 970., the Supreme Court defined the limited jurisdiction of the Payment of Wages Authority in the following words:—

    “In dealing with claims arising out of deductions or delay made in payment of wages the authority inevitably would have to consider questions incidental to the said matters. In determining the scope of these incidental questions care must be taken to see that under the guise of deciding incidental matters the limited jurisdiction is not unreasonably or unduly extended. Care must also be taken to see that the scope of these incidental questions is not unduly limited so as to affect or impair the limited jurisdiction conferred on the authority………… in our opinion, it would be inexpedient to lay down any hard and fast or general rule which would afford a determining test to demarcate the field of incidental facts which can be legitimately considered by the authority and those which cannot be so considered.” (pp. 974 and 975).

    10. The question whether an order of removal or dismissal of a civil servant is valid or otherwise is a complicated question involving interpretation and application of the provisions of the Constitution and, to our mind, such a question is not incidental to a claim arising out of deductions or delay made in payment of wages and the Payment of Wages Authority cannot consider the question. We respectfully agree with the observations of the Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in Viswanath Tukaram v. General Manager, Central Railway A.I.R 1958 Bom. III. that the Payment of Wages Authority has no authority to decide whether the services of an employee have been rightly or wrongly terminated or whether the dismissal is lawful or unlawful. A division Bench of this High Court has also held in Eastern Railway v. Additional District Judge 1968-II, L.L.J 582. that it was not open to the Payment of Wages Authority to ignore an order of reduction in rank made by a competent authority and to hold that the order was not good for sufficient reasons. Accordingly, the petitioner was not bound to apply to the Payment of Wages Authority for his wages as long as his removal was not declared void by a civil court or in a writ petition.

    11. In P.J Lartious v. Superintendent, Printing and Stationery U.P 1965 A.L.J 292., a Single Judge of this High Court has held that an application to the Payment of Wages Authority for arrears of salary would not be maintainable in view of Order II, Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure if that claim is not made in a suit challenging the order of dismissal. But that decision has no application to the facts of this case as the order of removal of the petitioner was declared void in a writ Petition and not in a civil suit. In Davendra Pratap v. State of Uttar Pradesh it has been held that the bar of Order II, Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure may not apply to a petition for a high prerogative writ under Article 226 of the Constitution. (P. 1337).

    12. For all these reasons we are of the opinion that the petitioner's application before the Payment of Wages Authority was maintainable. We hence quash the order of the payment of Wages Authority and that of the Additional District Judge, Saharanpur, and remit the case back to the Payment of Wages Authority for disposal on the basis that the application is not barred by time and the order treating the absence of the petitioner as leave under paragraph 2044 of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Volume II, is illegal. In the circumstances of the case we direct the parties to bear their own costs.

    Case remanded.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Kishore Sharma v. Additional District Judge, Saharanpur
    (Dec 10, 1968)