Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Mushtaq Ahmad, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff consigned three bales of cotton piece goods by the East Indian Railway on 23 September 1943 from Unao (E.I.R.) to Mohammedabad Gohna (O.T.R.). The consignment reached destination on 2 October 1943. On attempting delivery the plaintiff found two bales tampered with and portions of cloth removed. The plaintiff demanded "open delivery" by a registered letter on 7 October 1943 and repeated this demand by registered notices dated 22 October, 15 November and 4 December 1943. After more than three months the Railway Company permitted open delivery and the plaintiff recorded shortage in the Delivery Book.

The plaintiff sued for Rs. 1,513-4-0 as damages, composed of: (1) Rs. 352-4-0 for missing goods; (2) Rs. 44 as profits; (3) Rs. 700 for loss due to fall in price after delayed delivery; and (4) Rs. 417 as "presumptive" profits.

The defendants pleaded that the consignment was booked under Risk Note Form A and that no loss occurred from their negligence; they advanced alternate explanations for the shortage (loose/slack packing, wet bales at weighment, weak covering causing drying/weight loss). The trial court found tampering and misconduct by the Railway servants and entered a decree for Rs. 687-1-0 (Rs. 352-4-0 on the first count and Rs. 334-13-0 on the third). On the defendants' appeal, the lower appellate court reversed and dismissed the suit, holding that the plaintiff had not discharged the burden of proving Railway misconduct because of the Risk Note Form A and finding no refusal by the defendants to permit delivery. The plaintiff appealed to the court presided over by Mushtaq Ahmad, J.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Risk Note Form A (the printed "Risk Note A") exempts the railway from liability for loss caused by pilferage, disappearance, or failure to deliver part of a consignment (i.e., whether the Note applies where part of the goods have actually disappeared rather than merely deteriorated in condition).
  2. What burden of proof applies in a case of shortage/pilferage in transit where the consignor has executed Risk Note Form A — specifically, whether the plaintiff must prove misconduct by the Railway servants before liability can be imposed.
  3. Whether, on the facts (tampering during transit, requests for open delivery refused for over three months), the Railway Company is liable under Section 72 of the Railways Act read with the bailment provisions of the Indian Contract Act and the evidentiary presumption in Section 106 of the Evidence Act.
  4. Whether the defendants refused to give open delivery and, if so, whether that refusal or delay contributed to the plaintiff's claimed losses (including loss due to fall in price).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The lower appellate court erred in applying Risk Note Form A to this case because the plaintiff's complaint concerned an actual reduction in quantity (shortage/pilferage) and not deterioration in the "condition" of goods on delivery.
  • The shortage resulted from tampering while the goods were in defendants' possession; therefore liability exists under the statutory and bailment principles regardless of the Risk Note's wording.
  • The defendants unreasonably refused to permit "open delivery" for over three months despite repeated registered demands, which shows a refusal/delay contributing to loss and contradicts the lower appellate court's finding of no refusal.

Respondents' (Defendants') Arguments

  • The consignment was booked under Risk Note Form A and, therefore, the consignor (plaintiff) assumed the risk; no liability arises unless the plaintiff proves loss due to misconduct of Railway servants.
  • The shortage could be explained by weak or loose packing, wet condition at weighment, or drying/weight loss during transit rather than theft or tampering attributable to Railway servants.
  • There was no refusal by the defendants to permit delivery, and accordingly no damages on account of delay in delivery.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Governor-General of India-in-Council v. Firm Bishundayal Ram Gaurishankar, A.I.R. 1948 Pat. 48 States that Risk Note A has no application to cases of failure to deliver or pilferage; a thing never delivered cannot be said to have been delivered in any condition, so loss cannot be said to arise from condition on delivery. The Court invoked this authority to support its conclusion that Risk Note Form A does not cover pilferage or loss by disappearance of part of a consignment.
Bengal North-Western Railway Co. v. Firm Dassundhi Mal-Bishambar Das, A.I.R. 1928 Lah. 166 Risk Note A exempts liability only for the "condition" of the goods at delivery and cannot shield the railway from liability for loss due to fall in prices from undue delay or disappearance/theft of goods. The Court relied on this statement to distinguish deterioration-in-condition cases from disappearance/pilferage and to hold the Risk Note inapplicable to the present shortage.
Bengal and North-Western Railway v. Munna Lal, Bishambhar Nath, A.I.R. 46 All. 844 Decision dealing with Risk Note Form A (cited as authority consistent with the view that the Risk Note does not cover loss by disappearance). The Bench noted that this Court had followed the decision and treated it as part of the line of authority supporting the inapplicability of Risk Note A to pilferage/shortage.
Governor-General in Council v. Gopali, A.I.R. 1944 Oudh 81 Holds that Risk Note Form A does not, by its terms, absolve defendants of liability for loss of part of a consignment. Cited to support the proposition that Risk Note A cannot be used to deny liability where part of a consignment is lost.
Secretary of State v. Rup Ram Audh Behari Lal, A.I.R. 1931 All. 135 Previous single-Judge decision involving missing goods from consigned bales (relied upon by the lower appellate court). The Court observed that the lower appellate court relied on this decision but held that the distinguishing reasoning (the present case's distinction) was not considered by that judge; thus the reliance was misplaced for present purposes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began with a textual and contextual analysis of Risk Note Form A. The Note's operative language concerns the "condition in which the goods may be delivered" and speaks to losses "arising from misconduct on the part of the Railway administration's servants" in respect of that condition. The judge reasoned that the form is thus directed to cases where a consignment has arrived but exhibits deterioration in condition; it does not sensibly cover instances where part of the goods has actually disappeared or where there is a failure to deliver a whole package or part of a package.

On that interpretation the court concluded that where there is a shortage in quantity or disappearance of a package or part of a package, one cannot say the "goods have arrived" in any condition that would attract the Risk Note's protection. The court further supported that textual reading by reference to prior authorities (quoted and tabulated above) which had taken a similar approach — notably the observation that Risk Note A "has no application at all to cases of failure to deliver, or pilferage."

Having held the Risk Note inapplicable, the court turned to statutory and common-law obligations. Section 72 of the Railways Act imposes on a railway administration the responsibility of a bailee as defined under the Indian Contract Act (Sections 151, 152 and 161). Although subsection (2) of Section 72 can limit responsibility where a valid written agreement in a Government-approved form exists, that limitation did not apply because the Risk Note was found inapplicable.

Applying Section 151 of the Contract Act, the court reiterated the bailee's duty to take as much care as a man of ordinary prudence would take of his own goods of similar bulk, quality and value. The court also invoked the principle in Section 106 of the Evidence Act: because the Railway Companies had special means of knowledge about what had happened to the goods in transit, silence or lack of explanation by the defendants justified an adverse inference. The defendants produced only a single witness (the Goods Clerk at dispatch), whereas the plaintiff called several witnesses describing the condition on arrival.

The court additionally rejected the lower appellate court's finding that there was no refusal to give open delivery. The judge emphasized that the plaintiff had repeatedly demanded open delivery by registered notices and that the defendants refused the request for over three months, permitting open delivery only belatedly; that refusal was unjustified and supported the plaintiff's claim of improper conduct or at least unreasonable withholding of delivery.

Weighing these factors together — the textual inapplicability of Risk Note A to pilferage/shortage, the statutory bailee duty, the evidentiary posture (defendants' silence, plaintiff's supporting witnesses), and the refusal/delay of open delivery — the court concluded that the defendants were responsible for the loss and that the trial court's findings of misconduct were sustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is ALLOWED. The decree of the lower appellate court is set aside and the decree of the court of first instance is restored, with costs to the plaintiff throughout.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The plaintiff's judgment at trial (decree for Rs. 687-1-0) is restored and the plaintiff is entitled to costs against the defendants.
  • On legal principle: The court affirms that Risk Note Form A does not apply to cases of failure to deliver or to pilferage/shortage of part of a consignment — the form addresses losses arising from deterioration in the condition in which goods are delivered, not disappearance of goods. Accordingly, where part of a consignment is missing, the railway's liability is to be assessed under the general bailment principles (Section 72 of the Railways Act read with the Indian Contract Act) and ordinary evidentiary rules (including Section 106 of the Evidence Act) rather than under the protective scope of Risk Note A.
  • No new legal principle was invented; the court found that the "concensus of authority" supported its interpretation and applied established statutory and evidentiary rules to the facts.

Appeal allowed. Decree of the lower appellate court set aside; trial court decree restored with costs to the plaintiff.

    Qadir Salamat Ullah v. Governor-General-In-Council

    Mushtaq Ahmad, J.:— This is a plaintiff's appeal in a suit for recovery of Rs. 1513-4-0 as damages for loss of a part of the consignment sent by the plaintiff by the East Indian Railway. The consignment was made on September 23, 1943 from Unao (E.I.R) to Mohammedabad Gohna (O.T.R). It consisted of three bales of cotton piece goods. On October 2, 1943, the consignment reached its destination, but when the plaintiff went to take delivery of the same he found two of the bales having been tampered with and some cloth pieces removed therefrom. On October 7, 1943, the plaintiff demanded ‘open delivery’ by a registered letter. Apparently, this was not allowed, and the demand was repeated by three other registered notices, the 1st dated the 22nd October, the 2nd 15th November and the third the 4th December, 1943. Eventually, after more than three months had elapsed from the arrival of the bales, the Railway Company did give an ‘open delivery’ to the plaintiff who made a note on the Delivery Book that there was a shortage. On these facts the plaintiff claimed the amount already mentioned, which consisted of four items: (1) Rs. 352-4-0 for the goods missing, (2) Rs. 44 as profits, (3) Rs. 700 as loss due to fall in the price after the defendants' failure to deliver the goods and (4) Rs. 417 as ‘presumptive’ profits, total Rs. 1513-4-0.

    2. The defendant companies pleaded in defence that the consignment having been booked under the Risk Note Form A and no loss having occurred due to their negligence, the plaintiff was not entitled to any damages. They further pleaded that one of the bales had been losely packed and the other two were “slack” without water-proof, all of them being wet at the time of weighment when consigned. It was further averred that the covering was weak and it had consequently got worn out during transit and that the shortage was due to the goods getting dried, there having been possibly some leakage due to loose packing and weak covering. The trial court found that two of the bales had been tampered with and cloth had been removed therefrom, while they were in the defendants' possession. It also found that the loss was due to the misconduct of the Railway Companies. On these findings it passed a decree for Rs. 687-1-0, that is, Rs. 352-4-0 on the first count, and Rs. 334-13-0 on the third. On appeal by the defendants, the lower appellate court dismissed the entire suit on the finding that the plaintiff had failed to discharge the onus of proving that the loss was due to the negligence of the Railways. This finding was based on the learned Judge having enforced the provisions of the Risk Note Form A against the plaintiff. There was a further finding by him that the plaintiff was not entitled to any damages on account of delay in delivery, as the defendants had never refused to allow the same.

    3. Learned counsel for the plaintiff-appellant has strenuously argued that the lower appellate court erred in applying the provisions of Risk Note Form A in the present case. That form provides:—

    I the undersigned do hereby agree and undertake to hold the said railway administration over whose railway the said goods may be carried in transit harmless and free from all responsibility for the condition in which the aforesaid goods may be delivered……to the consignee at destination and for any loss arising from misconduct on the part of the Railway administration's servants.

    4. As just mentioned, the lower appellate court, relying on the concluding portion of this Note, placed the burden on the plaintiff of proving that the loss in this case had been due to the misconduct of the Railway's servants, and, holding that the plaintiff had failed to discharge that onus, it dismissed the entire suit. A critical examination of the provisions of this Note would, in my opinion, tend to take the present case entirely out of its scope. What has to be noticed in this document is that the complaint of the plaintiff claiming damages must have reference to the “condition” in which the goods have arrived, that the loss thereby suffered by the plaintiff must have originated directly from that condition and that it is in respect of such loss that the burden is on the plaintiff to prove the same being due to the misconduct of the Railway servants. Where, therefore, there is a shortage in the quantity of the goods arrived or there is a loss of a complete package or complete packages, it would not be a case covered by this Risk Note Form A at all, for the simple reason that it cannot be said that the “goods” have arrived or the “goods” have been delivered at the destination point. The Risk Note would obviously apply to cases and only to such easels where the plaintiff has suffered some monetary loss due to some deterioration in the condition of the goods and not to a cutting away of a portion of the goods owing to theft or pilferage. In the latter case, there would be no question of any loss due to a deteriorated condition. It would be a loss due to an actual disappearance of a portion of the goods, and this would hardly be consistent with the “goods” having arrived or having been delivered.

    5. This interpretation of the Risk Note Form A does not appear to have entered into the consideration of the lower appellate court at all. That court apparently assumed that the plaintiff's allegation of a loss was one with reference to the ‘condition’ in which the goods had arrived. It was in fact nothing of the kind. He had nothing to say against the condition in which the goods had arrived or the consequent monetary loss which had accrued to him. His case was one of a virtual redaction in the quantity of the consignment when it had arrived, that having nothing to do with the point of the “condition” in which it had arrived, nor had it any reference to any monetary or pecuniary loss which the plaintiff alleged having incurred as due to a deterioration in that condition. As we know, the plaintiff's case was that a portion of the contents of each of two out of the three bales had been actually removed, thereby involving a reduction of the weight of the bales and also necessarily of their market value. All this obviously had nothing to do with the connection of the word “condition” mentioned in the Risk Note. The lower appellate court, unmindful of this position and without applying its mind to the context in which the relevant words in this Form had been used by the Legislature, simply assumed that the plaintiff having executed the form had taken upon himself the burden of proving that the loss was due to the misconduct of the Railway servants before he could be entitled to any damages from the Railway Companies. In Governer-General of India-in-Council v. Firm Bishundayal Ram Gaurishankar A.I.R 1948 Pat. 48. which also was a case of the Risk Note Form A, it was observed:

    The Risk Note A has no application at all to cases of failure to deliver, or pilferage, because a thing never delivered cannot be said to have been delivered in any condition, and, therefore, no question arises of any loss arising from the condition in which the goods were found on delivery.

    6. Again, in Bengal North-Western Railway Co. v. Firm Dassundhi Mal-Bishambar Das A.I.R 1928 Lah. 166. it was held that

    Risk Note A confers exemption from liability only in respect of the “condition” of the goods at the time of the delivery at destination. It cannot confer immunity from liability for loss due to other causes, e.g, loss due to fall in prices resulting from undue delay in transit, or loss due to disappearance of goods due to theft etc.

    7. The Bench delivering the judgment had followed a decision of this Court in Bengal and North-Western Railway v. Munna Lal, Bishambhar Nath A.I.R 46 All. 844. which also was a case of the Risk Note Form A. In Governor-General in Council v. Gopali A.I.R 1944 Oudh 81. also it was held that

    The Risk Note above referred to (Form A) does not by its terms absolve the defendants in respect of their liability for the loss of a part of the consignment.

    8. The lower appellate court relied on a single Judge decision of this Court in Secretary of State v. Rup Ram Audh Behari Lal A.I.R 1931 All. 135. which undoubtedly was a case of some goods missing out of bales consigned. It would be enough to say that the distinction which I have drawn between the present case and cases truly covered by the Risk Note Form A which distinction was also clearly emphasised in the rulings I have referred to above, was not considered by the learned Judge in this case at all. I am, therefore, definitely of the opinion that the concensus of authority is in favour of the view I have expressed on the point. Accordingly, I hold that the Risk Note executed by the plaintiff in this case has no application at all in determining the liability of the defendant-Companies in respect of the claim preferred.

    9. Eliminating this hurdle from the way of the plaintiff, the position, so far as the said liability is concerned, becomes simple enough. Section 72 of the Railways Act provides:

    The responsibility of a railway administration for the loss, destruction or deterioration of animals or goods delivered to the administration to be carried by railway shall, subject to the other provisions of this Act, be that of a bailee under Sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

    10. No doubt, Sub-section 2 restricts this responsibility where there has been an agreement purporting to limit the same and reduced to writing, signed by or on behalf of the person sending or delivering to the railway administration the animals or goods, and is otherwise in a form approved by the Government. The form in this case was Risk Note Form A, which, I have already held, had no application to this case at all. The restriction which would thus have limited the responsibility of the railway administration did not come to affect the position in this case in the least, and the general provisions contained in Sub-section (1) of this section remained unaffected. Section 151 of the Contract Act enjoins that in all cases of bailment the bailee is bound to take as much care of the goods bailed to him as a man of ordinary prudence would, under similar circumstances, take of his own goods of the same bulk, quality and value as the goods bailed.

    11. In the present case admittedly the goods arrived in a damaged condition. There is no Suggestion by the defendants that the goods even when consigned from Unao, were in the same quantity or of the same value as those found when they arrived at the place of destination. Indeed, it is admitted that there was a removal of a portion of the contents of two of the bales. This happened when the goods were in the possession of the Railway Companies and under the control of their servants. Applying the normal rule as embodied in Section 106 of the Evidence Act it was only the Railway Companies which could have special knowledge of the manner in which the goods got missing in transit: the consignor, the plaintiff in this case, could possibly have no inkling, either of the place where, or the manner in which, this had happened, the Railway Companies being the only persons able to throw light on the same. The defendants in this case kept significantly silent so far as that matter was concerned. They produced only a single witness, the Goods Clerk, to whom the consignment had been entrusted for despatch at Unao. The plaintiff, on the other hand, examined a number of witnesses deposing to the actual condition in which the goods had arrived. Even if the burden lay on the plaintiff, and I have already held that it did not lie on him, of proving the loss being due to the misconduct of the Railway administration, such an inference could be legitimately drawn from the admitted facts which I have just mentioned of course, the lower appellate court got over the point simply by holding that the plaintiff, in spite of having executed a Risk Note Form A, had not discharged the onus of proving the loss being due to the misconduct of the Railway administration. I have already said that there was no such burden on him, and I also affirm that, whether there was any such burden or not, even the admitted facts proved to the hilt that the servants of the defendant Companies had been guilty of misconduct in causing a loss to the plaintiff in this case.

    12. The lower appellate court then held that there was no refusal to give delivery by the defendants. I have already mentioned that for over three months there was no willingness to allow an open delivery for which the plaintiff had persistently requested the defendants through successive registered notices. That the defendants did eventually give such delivery shows that they had no justification in refusing it at the outset when the plaintiff had first demanded it. How it could in such a case be conceived that there was no refusal on the part of the defendants to give such delivery, I cannot tell. I should think that, in the circumstances, it was impossible to hold I that the defendants had not refused to allow I open delivery to the plaintiff, thereby protecting themselves against a demand for damages to be made by the owner of the goods. On this point also, I am unable to agree with the learned Judge. On these considerations, I have come to the conclusion that this appeal must be allowed. Accordingly, I allow the appeal, set aside the decree of the lower appellate court and restore that of the court of first instance with costs to the plaintiff throughout.

    13. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Qadir Salamat Ullah v. Governor-General-In-Council
    (Sep 12, 1950)