The Court/Registrar/Commissioner may, if it deems appropriate, direct use of video conferencing in accordance with guidelines issued by Court, from time to time, for conduct of court proceedings between Court(s) and remote site(s). Guidelines presently enforce are incorporated by inclusion in these Rules and annexed hereto as Annexure B.
Chapter XII
COMMISSIONS
1. Commissions. Court may issue commission(s) from time to time, inter-alia, for
(i) making local investigation;
(ii) scientific investigation;
(iii) performance of a ministerial act;
(iv) sale of movable or immovable property;
(v) examination and/or adjustment of accounts;
(vi) recording evidence;
(vii) carrying out partition of immovable property;
(viii) carrying out partition of movable assets;
(ix) carrying out search and seizure orders; and
(x) any other purpose considered appropriate by the Court.
2. Order to be sent to Commissioner. Where commission has been issued, the order appointing him shall be sent to him at the earliest and no later than seven days from the date of such order.
3. Power of Commissioner to serve. Where a Commissioner has been appointed by the Court for local investigation, search, seizure, taking inventory or for carrying out any other act/assignment in accordance with the order of the Court, for proper elucidation of any matter in dispute and the defendant has not been served, the Court may, in addition to the other modes of service, direct the Commissioner to serve the summons on the defendant along with plaint, documents, interlocutory application and copy of the orders of the Court, with a further direction to mention such service in his report. Such report of service would be deemed as sufficient service of the concerned person.
4. Execution of Commission. The Court may, if it considers appropriate, in such order, issue directions, as may be necessary, for execution of the commission, including directions to Commissioner to take copies of documents; take custody of documents, books of accounts, balance sheets etc.; to release the goods, documents on superdari to a named person/party. Such documents/copies shall be placed before Court alongwith the report of the commission. If Court considers appropriate, it may treat such documents as evidence, after giving opportunity of objection(s) to opposing party(s).
5. Disclosure of conflict of interest. Commissioner shall make a disclosure that he does not have any conflict of interest with any of the parties or the lawyers/law firm involved in the matter.
6. Fee of the Commissioner. (a) The Commissioner shall be paid the fees and in such manner as may be ordered by Court.
(b) The Court or the Registrar, as the case may be, may order that such amount, as it or he considers proper, be deposited in Court in advance towards fee payable to Commissioner or paid directly to the Commissioner, together with expenses for execution of the commission, within seven days of the grant of commission or letter of request or within such further time as may be allowed. In default, the matter shall, unless otherwise ordered, for reasons recorded in writing, be fixed for further proceedings.
(c) If at any subsequent time, the Court is satisfied that the deposit made under these Rules is not sufficient to cover remuneration of the Commissioner, it may, after notice to parties or their Advocates, order such further amount, as it considers proper, be deposited in Court or paid directly to the Commissioner, within seven days from the date of such order or within such further time as the Court may allow. In default, the procedure prescribed in these Rules shall be followed.
(d) The fees directed to be paid by the Court shall not be varied or altered by the Commissioner even with mutual consent of parties.
7. Database of Commissioner(s). The name(s) of persons appointed as Commissioner(s) together with details of cases in which they have been appointed; their dates of appointment(s); schedule of fee ordered to be paid and received by the Commissioners and whether such commissions are pending or completed shall be maintained in the database.
Commission to Examine Witnesses
8. Commission to examine witness. (i) The court may pass orders for appointment of Commissioners in order to expedite the recordal of evidence. The Court shall, at the time of appointing a Commissioner for recording evidence, give such directions as may be considered necessary for this purpose, including in relation to manner of recordal, making available judicial record, timings for recordal of evidence, manner of recordal of objections, outer time limit for conclusion of oral evidence, imposition of time limits for cross examination, fee to be paid, party who should pay the fees for the Commissioner etc. The Court while appointing a Commissioner for recordal of evidence, would consider the number of cases already pending before the said Commissioner for recordal of evidence.
Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in these Rules, the Court may, in its discretion, order recording of evidence by commission at any stage of proceedings. Such order shall be passed by the Court after hearing the parties concerned.
(ii) The Commissioner shall ordinarily not adjourn recording of evidence for a period beyond one week. Upon receipt of a request for a longer adjournment, the matter shall be forthwith placed before the Court for appropriate orders.
(iii) The Commissioner shall follow the procedure prescribed by the Code, Indian Evidence Act, 1972 and these Rules, for recording of evidence.
(iv) The Commissioner shall record all objections raised during recording of evidence and shall not delay or adjourn the recording of evidence on that ground. All such objections shall be decided by the Court at the time of the final hearing 27[or at such time as the Court considers appropriate].
(v) If the Commissioner is of the view that a party is unduly, unreasonably or unjustifiably prolonging examination/cross examination of a witness; the Commissioner shall record the same and immediately bring it to the notice of 28[Court/Registrar] for appropriate orders.
(vi) The Commissioner shall file his reports and record of proceedings on a hearing-to-hearing basis. The Commissioner shall in his record of proceedings/order sheet, mention the time at which the proceedings commenced; the times at which the examination-in-chief, cross examination, and re-examination, if any, respectively, commenced and concluded. In such record the Commissioner shall also mention the time at which commission proceedings closed on the said date.
(vii) The Commissioner shall obtain signatures of witness on every page of his testimony. In case of failure of witness to affix signature, the Commissioner shall make an endorsement to this effect on the statement of the witness.
(viii) Where evidence is to be recorded, the Commissioner shall, to the extent possible, make himself available for recording evidence throughout the working hours of the Court and endeavour to record evidence on a day-to-day basis, except for the reasons to be recorded in writing.
(ix) The Commissioner shall complete recording of evidence, within the time stipulated by the Court and in any case within six months from the date first fixed before him. In case the recording of evidence cannot be completed within the timeline fixed by the Court, the Commissioner shall furnish a report explaining reasons for delay and direct parties to seek appropriate orders from Court. The Court, in its discretion, upon examining the report of the Commissioner, may grant a further period within which the commission is to be completed or pass such orders as it considers appropriate.
9. Examination de bene esse. Notwithstanding anything contained in these Rules, commissions for examination of parties and/or witness de bene esse may be issued at any time where the Court considers it not possible for such examination to be conducted by Court.
Commissions for Accounts Etc.
10. Commissioner for taking accounts etc. The Court may appoint a suitable person as Commissioner for taking accounts, making local investigations and effecting partition of movable/immovable property.
11. Registrar to send necessary proceedings to Commissioner. The Registrar shall furnish to the Commissioner with such part of the proceedings as may be necessary.
12. Commission for taking accounts how executed. (a) The Commissioner shall fix the period within which the statements of accounts and objections thereto are to be filed by parties concerned.
(b) The statement of account shall be in the form of a debtor and creditor account and shall be verified by the party concerned or his agent. The items on each side of the account shall be numbered consecutively and a balance shall be shown.
(c) The statement of objections shall specify the items to which objections are taken by reference to their numbers in the statement of account.
(d) The statement and objections shall also state,
(i) the grounds of each objection, and
(ii) the balance, if any, admitted or claimed to be due: and it shall be verified by the affidavit of the party concerned or his agent.
(e) If any party fails to file his statement of account or objections within the period allowed, the Commissioner shall report the fact to Court.
(f) When the case before him is ready for hearing, the Commissioner shall, after reading the statements filed before him and after examining the parties, if necessary, ascertain the points on which the parties are at issue and require them to produce their oral and documentary evidence on such points. (g) After the evidence has been duly taken and the parties have been heard, the Commissioner shall submit his report together with the entire record and a statement in the form of diary of the proceedings before him. The report shall state:
(i)The contested items allowed or disallowed by the Commissioner;
(ii) The reasons for allowing or disallowing the above;
(iii) The amount found due;
(iv) The name of the party to whom it is due; and
(v) The name of the party by whom it is due.
13. Notice of filing of report; filing objections thereto. (a) On receipt of the report of the Commissioner, other than the report forwarding deposition of a witness recorded by him, the Registrar shall give notice to parties to suit or matter of filing of the report.
(b) Any party desiring such report to be set aside or varied shall, unless the Registrar otherwise directs, within ten days from date of service of such notice on him, file his objections thereto and serve a copy of the same on other parties to the suit or matter. After objections have been filed as aforesaid, the suit shall be set down for hearing of such objections. If any party, after having filed objections, abandons or does not proceed with them, any other party having the same interest, shall be at liberty to proceed with such objections.
(c) Notwithstanding anything elsewhere provided in these Rules, the pendency of any objection to reports furnished by the Commissioner shall not delay the progress of the trial.
14. Foreign Commissions. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Chapter, Commissions and Letters of Request for examination of witnesses in foreign countries, will be governed by directions issued by the appropriate authorities from time to time.
Chapter XIII
ADJOURNMENTS
1. Adjournments to be to a day certain. All adjournments shall be to a day certain. No suit or matter shall be adjourned sine die except for reasons recorded in writing. No adjournment shall be granted except on good cause and in exceptional and unavoidable circumstances. Consent of parties by itself shall not be a good cause for seeking adjournment. An adjournment shall be on such terms as ordered by the Court/Registrar, including imposition of exemplary costs as provided in Chapter XXIII of these Rules.
Chapter XIV
COMPROMISE IN PAUPER SUITS, HEARING IN FINAL MATTERS, PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS, JUDGMENTS AND DRAWING OF DECREES
1. No compromise without leave of Court in pauper suits. Where a plaintiff has been permitted to sue in forma pauperis, the suit shall not be compromised without leave of the Court.
2. Hearing in final matters. (a) All final arguments matters shall be paginated by the Registry at least one week before they are listed before Court as a final matter.
(b) It will be duty of Advocates for parties to exchange, at least one week before the date fixed for final arguments, their respective list of judicial precedents to which they are likely to refer.
(c) Advocates for parties shall, at least two days before the date fixed for final arguments, submit a short synopsis, running into, as far as possible, not more than five pages, arranged issue wise, giving the details of oral and documentary evidence relied upon, to prove issues giving reference to relevant pages. In addition, they shall also file compilation of judgments with an index on each point of law that they wish to submit before Court.
3. Recording of time during final hearing. At the hearing of a suit or other original proceedings in Court, the Court Master shall make a note of the times at which each hearing commenced and terminated respectively on each day on which it was heard. The same shall be recorded as part of the record of proceedings for the day.
4. Written judgment of one or more Judges how pronounced. (1) Judgments may be either oral or written;
(2) When the Court delivers an oral judgment, it shall be taken down by the shorthand-writer. A transcript shall then be prepared for correction by the Judge or Judges who delivered the judgment. A fair copy of the transcript so corrected shall be signed by the Judge or Judges and dated with the date of delivery and shall be the record of the judgment.
5. When any suit or matter is heard by two or more Judges
(i) If they have agreed to a written judgment and signed it, one of them may pronounce the judgment in the absence of the other or others;
(ii) if any one or more of them have written separate judgments, one of them may pronounce the judgments written and signed by the other or others in his or their absence.
6. Findings of Court to be read out. Where a written judgment is to be pronounced, it shall be sufficient if findings of Court on each issue and the final order passed in the case are read out. It shall not be necessary for Court to read out the whole judgment. However, a copy of the whole judgment shall be made available for perusal of parties or their pleaders immediately after the judgment is pronounced.
7. Payment of costs - a condition precedent for bringing a fresh suit. When a suit is allowed to be withdrawn, with liberty to bring a fresh suit in respect of the same subject-matter, then, unless the Court otherwise directs, a decree shall be drawn up, so as to make payment of costs of the suit, a condition precedent to the plaintiff bringing a fresh suit.
8. Settling of draft of decree. (i) Where the Registrar considers it necessary that the draft of any decree or other should be settled in presence of parties, or where parties require it to be settled in their presence, the Registrar shall, by notice in writing, appoint a time for settling the same and parties shall attend the appointment and produce their briefs and such other documents as may be necessary to enable the draft to be settled.
(ii) Where any party is dissatisfied with the decree or order, as settled by the Registrar, the Registrar shall not proceed to complete the decree or order without allowing that party sufficient time to apply, by motion to the Court.
9. Copies of decrees to Collector in case of pauper costs. The Registrar shall cause copies of decrees to be prepared without delay for communication to the Collector, in cases in which pauper costs are recoverable by the Government.
10. Errors how rectified after decree sealed. After a decree or order has been signed, any application to rectify any inaccuracy, other than a clerical or arithmetical error and to make it in accordance with the judgment, shall be made to the Judge who passed the decree or order, or in the event of his absence, to any other Judge, and the Judge may, after notice to parties, when he deems it necessary, amend the same so as to bring it into conformity with the judgment, or rectify such inaccuracy or error. Save as aforesaid, no alternation or variation shall be made without a review of judgment, and re-hearing under the provisions of Section 114 and Order XLVII of the Code.
Chapter XV
SUITS BY OR AGAINST MINORS AND PERSONS OF UNSOUND MIND
1. Admission of next friend to bring a suit. When a suit is brought on behalf of a minor, the next friend shall, in addition to complying with other applicable provisions of these Rules and the Code, make an affidavit, to be presented with the plaint in the suit, that he has no interest directly or indirectly adverse to that of the minor, and that he is otherwise a fit and proper person to act as such next friend. The age of the minor shall also be stated. No formal appointment of the person instituting the suit as next friend need be made.
2. Next friend to file address for service. (a) The next friend shall provide particulars for address as stipulated in Rule 3 of Chapter III of these Rules
(b) If the next friend fails to comply with the above while filing the suit, or within the time granted by the Registrar, the plaint shall not be admitted.
3. List of all likely guardians ad litem to be filed. (a) In suits, where the defendant is a minor, the plaintiff shall file with the plaint, a list of relatives and all other persons, with their correct addresses, who prima facie are most likely to be capable of acting as guardian for the minor defendant in the suit.
29[(b) A notice shall be issued simultaneously to all such persons. Such persons shall be deemed to be unwilling to act as guardian ad litem, if, after service of notice, they fail to appear on date fixed.]
(c) If the persons specified in the list filed under sub-Rule (a) of this Rule 3 are unwilling to act as guardian ad litem, the Registrar may, it there be more defendants than one, and their interests are not adverse to that of the minor, appoint one of such defendants, who may be willing to act as guardian ad litem; or may appoint, forthwith, one of the officers of the Court as such guardian ad litem.
4. Address for service of guardian ad litem. Every guardian ad litem of a defendant, other than an officer of the Court, shall, within seven days of the order of his appointment as such or within such further time as the Registrar may allow, file in Court, particulars as provided in Rule 3 of Chapter III of these Rules. Failure on his part to do so may be deemed sufficient ground for removing him under Order XXXII Rule 11 of the Code.
5. Application of Rules, 1 to 4 to persons of unsound mind and to appeals and applications. The provisions contained in this Chapter, so far as they may be applicable, apply mutatis mutandis to persons adjudged to be of unsound mind and to persons who, though not so adjudged, are found by Court on enquiry to be incapable of protecting their interests, when suing or being sued by reason of unsoundness of mind or mental infirmity. These provisions shall apply to appeals and applications connected therewith.
Chapter XVI
SUMMARY SUITS
1. Summary Suits. Order XXXVII of the Code, as in force from time to time, shall apply to suits filed under this Chapter, even where the suit is registered as a Commercial Suit.
Chapter XVII
COMMERCIAL SUITS
30[1. Commercial Suits. In exercise of powers conferred under Section 18 of the Commercial Courts Act, the Court has issued Practice Directions in addition to these Rules to supplement the provisions of Chapter II of the Commercial Courts Act or the Code, in so far as such provisions apply to hearing of commercial disputes of a specified value. The Practice Directions under Section 18 of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 are annexed hereto as Annexure E.]
Chapter XVIII
DATES AND CAUSE LISTS
1. Cause lists. The cause list shall be prepared under the directions of the Registrar General and signed by him. The cause list of the Court would comprise of the categories of cases as follows:
a. Supplementary matters (fresh matters and fresh applications)
b. Short matters including Case Management hearings
c. Short cause matters
d. Final matters
The Court shall have the discretion to direct listing of any matter in any category.
2. Hearing of matters. Supplementary matters shall be taken up from 10.30 am onwards followed by short matters including case management hearings. Short cause matters shall be taken up thereafter. All matters in which arguments are required to be heard, shall be part of the short cause matters. The Court shall fix actual dates in all these matters except that the Registrar can fix the cases before the Court in Short Matters. Where the actual dates of hearing are yet to be fixed in the cases, the Registrar shall fix the said matters as Short Matters before the Court for fixing the actual dates of hearing. 31[Cases which are coming up for hearing after evidence shall be listed in the category of Finals].
3. Short cause matter shall include.
(i) Ex-parte suits;
(ii) Undefended suits;
(iii) Suits to which Chapter XVI, applies including summary suits, cases where preliminary issues are to be decided, summary proceedings in commercial matters;
(iv) Mortgage suits, rent suits on bonds or acknowledgement;
(v) Objection to Commissioner's report;
(vi) Such other suits or matters as may, by special order of the Court, be directed to be tried as short causes.
4. Time slots. The Court may, by order, fix the time allotted for hearing short cause and other matters in accordance with its cause list and as considered appropriate by the Court. The Court may in its discretion, considering the nature of the case, pass such orders as it deems fit and appropriate for speedy and expeditious disposal of the case; cutting short the litigation and taking such steps in this behalf.
5. Final Matters. The Court may, from time to time, issue any direction reserving specific days or time for hearing Final matters. The Court/Registrar may order listing of matter in Final as it considers fit and appropriate.
6. Record to be maintained. For facility of fixation of causes in the Court, bound registers or e-record will be maintained by the Court Masters incorporating the above said classification and the actual dates fixed.
7. Format. A format, as given below, so far applicable, will be filed by the plaintiff in new matters, and in pending matters the format will be filed by both the parties. Thereafter, the format will be filled in and completed by the Court Masters as and when new applications are filed and disposed of.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI SUIT/PETITION/O.M.P./AA NO OF .
Plaintiff(s)/Petitioner(s)
v.
Defendant(s)/Respondent(s)
Nature of the matter:
Status invoked:
ADVOCATES
| |
|
| Plaintiff(s)/Petitioner(s) |
Defendant(s)/Respondent(s) |
INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATIONS (IAs)
| S. No. |
No. & Yr. |
Filed by Plaintiff/ Defendant |
Provisions of Law |
Nature of Relief Sought |
Remarks |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Chapter XIX
AFFIDAVITS
1. Proof of facts by affidavits. The Court may, at any time for sufficient reasons, order that any particular fact or facts be proved by affidavit, or that the affidavit of any witness be read at the hearing, on such conditions as the Court thinks reasonable:
Provided that where it appears to the Court that either party bona fide desires that production of a witness for cross-examination and that such witness can be produced, an order shall not be made authorizing the evidence of such witness to be given by affidavit.
2. Evidence by affidavit. The Court may upon any application of either party showing sufficient cause, order attendance, for cross-examination of the deponent, and such attendance shall be in Court, unless the deponent is exempted from personal appearance in Court or the Court otherwise directs. Affidavits by way of evidence shall not merely reproduce pleadings and documents already filed.
3. Title. Every affidavit shall be instituted in the cause, appeal or matter in which it is sworn.
4. Form. Every affidavit shall be drawn up in the first person, and shall be divided into paragraphs to be numbered consecutively, and shall state the description, occupation if any, and the true place of abode of the deponent.
5. Contents of affidavit. Affidavits shall be confined to such facts as the deponent is able, of his own knowledge to prove, except on interlocutory applications, on which statements of his belief may be admitted, provided that the grounds thereof are stated.
6. Interpretation of affidavits. An affidavit requiring interpretation to the deponent, unless interpreted by any of the persons mentioned in Rule 7, shall be interpreted by an interpreter, nominated or approved by the Court, if made within the jurisdiction of the Court, and if made elsewhere, shall be interpreted by a competent person who shall certify that he has correctly interpreted the affidavit to the deponent.
7. Before whom affidavits are to be sworn. (a) Affidavits for the purposes of any cause appeal or matter may be sworn before a Notary or any authority mentioned in Section 139 of the Code or before the Court/Registrar, or before the Commissioner generally or specially authorized in that behalf by Court. The authority attesting any such affidavit shall, wherever the person is known to him, append a certificate to that effect on the affidavit, and where the person affirming the affidavit is not known to the authority concerned, the certificate shall state the name of the person by whom the person affirming the affidavit has been identified.
(b) Wherever an affidavit is affirmed by an illiterate person, or a person not conversant with English language, the authority concerned shall, before attesting the same, translate and interpret the contents of the affidavit to the person affirming the same, and certify the said fact separately under his signature.
(c) Affidavits signed outside India, shall be signed and apostilled in accordance with the provisions of the Hague Convention Abolishing the Requirement of Legalization for Foreign Public Documents, 1961
8. Pardahnashin women. Where the deponent is a Pardahnashin woman, unless she is known to the person attesting the affidavit, she shall be identified by a person to whom she is known, and that person shall also prove the identification by a separate affidavit.
9. Marking, dating and initiating on exhibits. Every exhibit annexed to an affidavit shall be marked, initialed and dated by the authority before which it is sworn.
Chapter XX
RECEIVERS
1. Application for appointment of Receiver to be by petition supported by affidavits. (i) Every application for the appointment of a receiver shall be made in writing and shall be supported by an affidavit.
(ii) No Judicial Officer shall be appointed as a Receiver in any proceedings in Court.
(iii) A copy of the order of appointment shall be sent to the Receiver.
2. Database of Receiver(s). The name(s) of persons appointed as Receivers together with details of cases in which they have been appointed; their dates of appointment(s); schedule of fee ordered to be paid and received by the Receiver(s) shall be maintained in the database.
3. Receiver other than official Receiver to give security. (a) Where an order is made directing a Receiver to be appointed, the person appointed, if not the Official Receiver, shall, unless otherwise ordered, first give security to the satisfaction of the Registrar for the due performance of his duties as receiver. Unless the Court otherwise orders, the Registrar shall take the personal bond of the receiver with such number of sureties as he may consider necessary. The amount of the bond shall be double the annual rental of the immovable property, or the value of the movable property which is likely to come into the hands of the receiver. Such annual rental or value shall be estimated after notice to the parties and the receiver and in case of disagreement the matter shall be placed before a Judge in Chambers for orders.
(b) The sureties shall leave with the Registrar, an address within the jurisdiction of the Court for service of any notice on them.
4. Surety may point out omission or neglect of duty cast on receiver. If the security mentioned in Rule 3, be furnished by the receiver by his executing a bond with a surety or sureties (including in the latter term, a guarantee Company or society), the surety or sureties shall be entitled, by an application to bring to the notice of the Court any act, omission or neglect of any duty cast on the receiver by law or any other circumstance, which would entitle the surety or sureties to be discharged from the obligation created by such bond and the Court may thereupon make such order and on such terms as it may think fit.
5. Receiver to submit report. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, the Receiver shall, within one week of the appointment, submit to the Court a detailed report regarding the property with an inventory of the property, account books, etc. taken charge of documents by him.
6. Directions for investment of monies in the hands of the Receiver. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, the Registrar shall, in consultation with the parties, give appropriate directions for the investment of all monies received by a Receiver. Ordinarily such monies shall be deposited in a Scheduled Bank or invested in Government securities.
7. Notice to surety of application effecting surety's risk. The surety or sureties mentioned in Rule 4, shall be entitled to notice of any application to the Court, on the part of the receiver, or any other party interested relating to any property in the management or under the control of the receiver which may affect the risk undertaken by the surety or sureties under the security bond furnished by the receiver and the Court upon hearing the said surety or sureties may make such order as to his or their cost of appearance in such application as it may think fit.
8. Powers of Receiver. In the absence of any order in that behalf every receiver of immovable property shall have all the powers specified in Order XL, rule (d) of the Code, except that he shall not without the leave of the Court
(a) grant lease, or
(b) bring suits, except suits for rent, or
(c) institute an appeal in any Court (except from a decree in a rent suit) where the value of the appeal is over Rs. 1,00,000/-; or
(d) expend on the repairs of any property in any period of two years more than one-fourth of the annual rental of the property to be repaired, such rental being calculated at the amount at which the property to be repaired could be let out within fair state of repairs.
9. Receivers' remuneration. The scale of remuneration of the Receiver shall, unless otherwise ordered by the Court in a particular case, be as under
| (1) |
on |
| (a) |
rents recovered, |
| (b) |
outstanding recovered except as provided in item (2) below, and |
| (c) |
value realized on the sale of movable and immovable properties calculated on any one estate: |
| |
(i) |
On First Rs. 10,000/- |
5 p.c. |
| |
(ii) |
Above Rs. 10,000/- up to Rs. 20,000/- |
3 p.c. |
| |
(iii) |
Above Rs. 20,000/- up to Rs. 50,000/- |
2 p.c. |
| |
(iv) |
Above Rs. 50,000/- up to Rs. 1,00,000/- |
1 p.c. |
| |
(v) |
Above Rs. 1,00,000/- |
p.c. |
| (2) |
On outstanding recovered from a Bank or from a public servant without filing a suit |
| (i) |
Up to Rs. 1,00,000/- |
1 p.c. |
| (ii) |
On any further sum exceeding Rs. 1,00,000/ |
- p.c. |
| (3) |
For taking charge of movable property which is not sold on debentures, debenture-stock or other securities which are not sold |
| on the estimated value |
1 p c. |
| (4) |
For taking custody of moneys |
1 p.c. |
| (5) |
For taking custody of Government securities of stocks, shares, the |
| |
estimated value |
1 p.c. |
| (6) |
For any work, not provided for above, such remuneration as the Court on the application of the receiver shall think reasonable. Whenever the properties are in charge of an official Receiver the above fees shall be credited to Government revenue |
Whenever the properties are in charge of an official Receiver the above fees shall be credited to Government revenue.
10. Establishment and costs therefore to be detailed in the appointment order. The establishment, clerical or otherwise, required by a Receiver, if any, and the cost thereof, chargeable to the state or property of which he is appointed Receiver shall, as far as possible, be detailed in the order of appointments or in subsequent order.
11. No charge for additional establishment allowed. Unless otherwise ordered, no charge for establishment shall be allowed to the receiver.
12. Receiver to file half-yearly accounts. (i) Every Receiver shall, unless otherwise ordered file his half-yearly account in Court, the first of such accounts to be filed within one month after the expiration of six months from the date of his appointment, and every subsequent account within one month after the expiration of each succeeding period of six months, or in a case where the purpose for which the Receiver was appointed has been carried out or completed before the expiry of six months from the date of appointment, within one month from the date of such carrying out or completion.
(ii) Every such account shall show the balance in hand, and if so what portion thereof is required for the purpose of the estate and how much may be paid into Court or invested, and shall be verified by an affidavit.
13. Examining and vouching of accounts by Registrar. Every such account, before being submitted to the Court, shall be examined and verified by the Registrar, who may for this purpose require the attendance of the Receiver or his explanation or his evidence upon oath or affirmation or the production of any document by him and receive within such time as he may appoint and decide objections to the account and shall embody the result of his examination in a report.
14. Appointment of date for passing accounts Notice thereof. After the Registrar shall have submitted his report to the Court under Rule 13, he shall obtain a date from the Court for passing such accounts, or which date notice shall be given to the person interested including the sureties and to the receiver.
15. Objection to report to be filed. Objection, if any to the report shall be filed in Court, one week before the day fixed for the passing of the accounts or within such further time as may be allowed by the Court. They shall specify, in a concise form, the nature of the objection and shall be signed and verified.
16. Passing of accounts by Court. Where no objections are filed, the Court shall, if otherwise satisfied, pass such accounts. Where objections have been filed, the Court shall, subject to Rule 18, after hearing the objections, make such order as it may think proper.
17. Procedure of hearing of objections. The Court may, from time to time, adjourn the hearing of any objections or may refer them to an officer of the Court or to any other person, with such directions as the Court may deem fit.
18. Auditing of difficult and complicated accounts. In any case where the accounts are difficult and complicated, Court may order such accounts to be audited at the expense of the estate by a Chartered Accountant.
19. Order as to payment of balance. The Court, on the passing of the Accounts, may make such order as to the payment of the balance, or any part thereof, either into Court or in such other manner as may seem proper.
20. Consequence of Receiver's negligence to file accounts or pay the balance etc. Where any Receiver neglects to file his accounts, or to pass the same or to pay the balance or any part thereof as ordered the matter shall be reported by the Registrar to Court, and the Court may, from time to time, when the accounts of such Receiver are produced to be examined and passed, not only disallow, the remuneration therein claimed by such Receiver but also charge him with interest not exceeding nine per cent per annum upon the balance, if any, so neglected to be paid by him during the time such balance shall appear to remain in the hands of such Receiver.
21. Consequence or default by Receiver. Where any Receiver fails to file any account or affidavit or to make any payment or commits any other default, the Receiver or persons interested or any of them, may be required by notice to attend before the Court to show cause why such account or affidavit has not been filed or such payment made or any other proper proceeding taken and thereupon the Court may give such directions as may be proper, including the discharge of the Receiver and appointment of another and also the payment of costs by the defaulter.
22. Rule 8 applicable to manager or guardian. Subject to the order of the Court, Rule 8 shall apply to a guardian of the person or estate of a minor and the manager of the estate of a lunatic appointed by the Court.
23. Interim Receiver. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, the provisions of this Chapter shall apply mutatis mutandis to orders for appointment of interim receivers.
Chapter XXI
SECURITY PROCEDURE
1. Security Summons. (a) Subject to any directions given by the Court, where security is ordered to be given to the satisfaction of the Registrar the party ordered to give security shall take out summons within 14 days of the date of the order and shall serve the same upon the opposite party.
(b) The summons shall state the name and address of each surety to be tendered and a full and sufficient description of the property to be given as security.
2. Affidavit to Justification. (a) Simultaneously, every person offering himself as a surety shall make and file an affidavit of justification touching the value of his property and the debts and liabilities to which it is subject and also a draft of the bond proposed to be given. Copies of such affidavits and the draft bond will be served alongwith the summons on the opposite party.
(b) Affidavits of justification shall be deemed insufficient unless they state that each person justifying is worth the amount required, over and above what will pay his just debts and over and above every other sum for which he is then surety.
3. Time for inquiry. Unless time be extended by the Court, the Registrar shall allow or disallow the surety within 60 days of the date of the order requiring security.
4. Production of title deeds etc. and examination. (1) Every person offering himself as surety, shall produce before the Registrar all his title deeds, vouchers and other relevant and necessary documents on the day fixed for his examination. Such person may be examined by the Registrar on oath or solemn affirmation touching the value of his property, and the debts and liabilities to which it is subject. After being examined and allowed, he shall sign the requisite bond and shall deposit his title deeds, vouchers and such other documents as the registrar may require:
Provided that in any case the Registrar may, on good cause shown, dispense with the deposit of some or all of the said documents and may return the same to the surety with an endorsement thereon as follows:
To Whomsoever it May Concern
Take notice that the property to which this document relates stands charged for the payment of a sum of Rs by a bond executed on ..day of (month), (year) ..by ..in suit No ..of ..titled ..v ..pending in the High Court of Delhi
(2) The endorsement referred to in the proviso to sub-Rule (1) shall be cancelled by the Registrar when the surety is or stands discharged.
5. Property in respect of which surety may justify. The title deeds may relate to immovable property situated beyond the local limits of the ordinary jurisdiction of the Court, but shall in all cases be in the name of the proposed surety. A surety may justify also in respect of movable property of which he can produce evidence satisfactory to the Registrar, such as, deposit receipts, Government Promissory Notes, or other evidence of title.
6. More than two sureties irregular. A tender of notice of more than two sureties shall not be accepted except by order of the Court.
7. Who may be present at the examination. Except with the specific permission of the Registrar, no person other than the party giving security, the sureties and their respective Advocates, the party or parties, if any, on whom notice has been served and his or their Advocate or Advocates, shall be present at the examination of any surety by the Registrar.
8. Who are not competent sureties. Unless the Court otherwise orders, an Advocate practicing within the limits of the jurisdiction of the Court, a clerk of such Advocate or an officer of the Court, shall not be accepted as a surety.
9. Security for costs. If a party is required to give security for costs, unless the Court otherwise orders, the penal sum in the bond shall not be less than twenty five thousand rupees.
10. Custody of securities and security bonds. All papers and records relating to the taking of security, including securities and security bonds, shall be kept by the Registrar in safe custody in his safe in the strong room after making an appropriate entry in a register to be maintained by him for the purpose.
Chapter XXII
COURT DEPOSITS AND PAYMENTS
1. Payment of money. (a) The Registrar and subject to his directions, any other officer of the Court shall receive all monies paid into the Court and shall pay out all monies duly ordered to be paid out of Court. All money received in Court shall be kept in fixed deposit for a reasonable period, subject to the orders which may be passed by the Court.
(b) Money may be paid or deposited in Court by postal money order. In that case, the person making the payment shall send to the Registrar a statement containing full particulars regarding the intended payment or deposit.
2. Notice of payment or deposit to decree-holder or Collector. (a) A person paying money into or depositing property in the Court in part or full satisfaction of a decree or order shall give notice through the Court of such payment or deposit to the decree-holder.
(b) Where the decree directs payment of Court-fees to Government under Order, 33, Rule 10 of the Code, no order shall be made on the application for payment of such money or delivery of such property without giving notice thereof to the Collector at the expense of the applicant.
3. Delivery of securities jewelry or other valuables into Court. When jewelry or other valuables are brought into Court, three copies of a descriptive list thereof shall be presented and shall be checked and signed by the Registrar in the presence of the depositor. The jewelry or other valuables shall be placed in a box furnished with a lock and key to be provided by the Depositor. A copy of the list shall be kept in the box and the box shall then be locked and sealed with the Seal of the Court. One copy of the list shall be given to the depositor and the third copy of the said list and the key of the box shall be retained by the Registrar. The box shall thereafter be kept in safe custody by the Registrar or in such other custody as the Court may direct.
4. Application for payment of money etc. Every application for payment of money or delivery of property deposited in Court, shall be instituted in the suit or matter and shall also show the number of the execution application, if any, pending, showing the right and interest of the party applying and the amount claimed.
5. Applications to be checked. Applications to make or receive payments shall be duly checked by reference to the record of the suit or matter before submission for orders to the Registrar.
6. Payment by money order, bank draft, etc. On the application of the decree-holder or other person entitled to any money deposited in Court and not expended for the purpose for which it was deposited, if there is no objection to the payment of money on the ground of attachment or otherwise, the Registrar may order that the amount, after making all necessary and lawful deductions, be sent to the applicant at his risk.
(i) By money order, or
(ii) By bank draft by registered post acknowledgement due; or
(iii) In any other manner specified by the applicant, which the Registrar approves:
Provided that before payment is ordered to be made under clause (ii) or (iii), the applicant shall submit a duly stamped receipt for the amount due in the form given below:
FORM OF RECEIPT
Received the sum of Rs (Rupees only) from the High Court of Delhi bearing the amount deposited in the said Court in (particulars of case) connection with (diet money/decree/costs etc.).
Dated (Stamp)
(Signature of the payee)
7. Written authority of client requisite for payment for Advocate. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, no payment in excess of Rs. 1,000/- shall be made to an Advocate on behalf of his client unless specifically directed by court and without special authorization in that behalf by the client in favour of the Advocate.
8. Account books to be kept. The following account books shall be kept in hard copy or electronic form:
(a) Book of receipts for money paid into Court.
(b) Process-fee receipt book.
(c) Register of deposit receipts, viz., register of sums received in Court in connection with suits or judicial proceedings and deposited with Government (to be kept in duplicate).
(d) Register of deposit payments, viz., register, of payments from sums received into Court in connection with suits or judicial proceedings and deposited with Government (to be kept in duplicate).
(e) Files of applications for refund of lapsed deposits and of statements of lapsed Civil Courts deposits.
(f) Register of attached property.
(g) Register of money received on account of subsistence money of civil prisoners, expenses of witnesses and miscellaneous petty items required for immediate disbursement.
(h) Register of payments on account of subsistence money of civil prisoners, expenses of witnesses and miscellaneous petty items required for immediate disbursement.
(i) Cash Book.
(j) Ledger.
(k) Bank of Treasury pass book.
(l) Bank of Treasury cheque/voucher book.
(m) Register of receipts and of withdrawal of property left in the custody of the Registrar.
(n) Such other registers as may be directed by the Chief Justice to be kept.
9. Signing of cheques and checking of accounts. The Registrar or such other officer, as may be specifically authorized by the Chief Justice in that behalf, is authorized to sign cheques. He shall, at least once a month, call for the registers and accounts and satisfy himself that the entries have been carefully and properly made. When such inspection is made, he should note the fact in his own hand on the register or account inspected.
10. Notice to other party. At the time of depositing any amount/security/property, the party making the deposit shall intimate to the other party all particular details of the deposit including the amount so being deposited.
Chapter XXIII
COSTS & TAXATION OF COSTS
1. Power of Court/Registrar General/Registrar to impose cost. (i) If the Court considers any party abusing the process of Court or in any manner considered dilatory, vexatious, mala fide and abuse of process by them, the Court shall require the delinquent party to make deposit/payment upfront, in the manner directed by Court of such costs as the Court deems appropriate, before proceeding further in the matter. For the purpose of this Chapter, the expression Court shall mean and include the Court, the Registrar General and the Registrar, as the case may be.
(ii) In addition to exercise of powers under Rule 1(i) above, the Court may impose suitable costs upon any party at any stage of the proceedings, including at the stage of filing any interlocutory application; framing of issues; determining order and conduct of recording evidence etc., if it considers imposition of such costs just, necessary and proper, according to the proceedings in the matter.
(iii) While determining costs, the Court may also take into consideration factors, such as, inconvenience caused to parties/witnesses/other persons connected with the proceedings; previous conduct of parties; the stage at which the offending conduct is committed by the delinquent party; the probability and likelihood of success of vexatious efforts of the delinquent party; the relevancy of number and nature of witnesses; questions (including depositions by way of examination-in-chief) put to the witnesses and such other conduct as the Court considers inappropriate.
(iv) Failure of the said party in making payment/deposit of costs may result in all consequences provided in the Code for defaults and adverse orders being passed against the said party, as the Court deems appropriate and proper, besides enabling the other party to file execution proceedings against the delinquent party for recovery of said costs.
2. Imposition of actual costs. In addition to imposition of costs, as provided in Rule 1 of this Chapter, the Court shall award costs guided by and upto actual costs as borne by the parties, even if the same has not been quantified by parties, at the time of decreeing or dismissing the suit. In this behalf the Court will take into consideration all relevant factors including (but not restricted) the actual fees paid to the Advocates/Senior Advocates; actual expenses for publication, citation etc.; actual costs incurred in prosecution and conduct of suit including but not limited to costs and expenses incurred for attending proceedings, procuring attendance of witnesses, experts etc.; execution of commissions; 32[whether any reasonable offer to settle is made by a party and unreasonably refused by the other party, denial of documents due to frivolous reasons at the stage of admission/denial] and all other legitimate expenses incurred by the party, which the Court orders to be paid to any party.
In addition to imposition of costs as above, the Court may also pass a decree for costs as provided in Sections 35-A and 35-B of the Code or under any applicable law.
3. Taxing Officer. The Registrar or such other officer, as the Chief Justice may appoint for the purpose, shall be the Taxing Officer of the Court.
4. Time for filing Bill of costs. (a) Parties shall file their respective Bill of costs at the following stages:
(i) at the stage of framing of issues;
(ii) at the stage of the defendant being proceeded ex-parte or where the defendant has stopped appearing;
(iii) at the stage of conclusion of evidence of the parties; and
(iv) at the stage of delivery of judgment or final order.
(v) additionally, each party may be required to file composite Bill of costs not later than fifteen days from the date on which the judgment is delivered or order is passed, or within such time as the Taxing Officer may allow.
(b) Notwithstanding Rule 4(a) of this Chapter, the Court may award costs at all or any stage of the case, as the facts and circumstances may warrant.
5. Contents of the Bill of costs. The Bill of costs shall, inter-alia, set out:
(a) court fee
(b) process fee spent;
(c) expenses of witnesses, including the actual reasonable expenses incurred on travel, boarding and lodging, if any, and other incidental expenses;
(d) Advocate's fee including the fee of a Senior Advocate, if any;
(e) expenses of typing, photocopying and expenses incurred for sending summons by Registered post, speed post, courier, fax, electronic mail service and by such other modes as may have been directed by Court.
(f) such other amounts as may be allowable under these Rules or as may be ordered by the Court as costs taking into account:
(i) judicial time consumed in litigation;
(ii) delay in service of summons or efforts made in serving summons on the defendant, as the case may be;
(iii) delay caused by any of the parties by raising frivolous issues or unnecessary objections during the proceedings or during recording of evidence;
(iv) failure of a party to effect discovery of documents or its refusal to answer interrogatories; (v) incorrect denial of facts/documents, thus, protracting trial;
(vi) monetary and other stakes involved in the proceedings;
(vii) costs incurred on execution of commission; and
(viii) any other cost which Court may deem fit and proper.
6. Evidence for Bill of Cost. Documentary evidence, if any, in support of payments made shall accompany Bill of costs. If any party raises any objections to the Bill of costs/documents so filed, costs shall then be determined by Court.
7. When an Advocate appears for different parties in the same matter. Where an Advocate appears for different parties in the same suit or matter, only one set of fees shall be allowed.
8. Review of taxation only on notice to opposite side. No application for review of taxation, (unless taxation was ex parte), shall be made, except on notice to the opposite side.
9. No review of taxation of costs, if Bill of costs not filed. Subject to any orders passed by Court, if Bill of costs is not filed within time allowed, under Rule 4 of this Chapter, the Taxing Officer shall compute costs in accordance with these Rules. No application for review of taxation shall be allowed, unless made before the decree is signed.
10. Costs after taxation. The Court may allow, after preparation and signing of decree, only such costs as it deems fit and appropriate incurred by a party for effecting transmission of the decree to another court. In addition, the Court executing the decree/the executing court may also award costs of execution as it considers fit and appropriate, in accordance with these Rules/rules applicable to the executing court.
11. Meaning of proportionate costs. Where proportionate costs or costs in proportion are allowed, such costs shall bear the same proportion to the total costs, as the successful part of the claim bears to the total claim.
12. Costs against multiple plaintiffs/defendants. Court to order proportion in which payable, time period for payment and mode of recovery.
13. Application to Court for review of taxation. Any party, who may be dissatisfied with the decision of the Taxing Officer as to any item or part of any item, may, not later than fifteen days from the date of the decision, or within such further time as the Court may allow, apply to the Court for an order to review taxation as to the said item or part of any item, and the Court may thereupon, after notice to the other side, if necessary, make such order as seems to it just. Subject to the above, taxation by the Taxing Officer shall be final and conclusive as to all matters.
14. Hearing of application under Rule 13. An application under Rule 13 of this Chapter, shall be heard and determined by Court upon the evidence and material provided to the Taxing Officer and no further evidence or material shall be received by Court, unless otherwise ordered.
Chapter XXIV
PROCEEDINGS IN EXECUTION
1. Interpretation. In this Chapter the word decree includes order.
Application for Transmission
2. Transmission of decree for execution. (a) An application for transmission of a decree to another Court for execution shall be in the form prescribed and shall specify the Court to which the transmission of the decree is sought and whether the decree has already been satisfied in part and if so, to what extent. The same shall be supported by an affidavit. It shall also be accompanied by a certified copy of the decree or an application for the same.
(b) The Registrar shall transmit by registered post, at the cost of the applicant, the certified copy of the decree together with the other documents mentioned in Order XXI Rule 6 of the Code, to the Court to which the transmission is sought in accordance with the provisions of rules, 4 and 5 of Order XXI of the Code.
Application for Execution
3. Application under Order XXI Rule 15 of the Code to be supported by affidavit. An application under Order XXI Rule 15 of the Code shall be in the prescribed form and supported by an affidavit. The Rules of payment of one time process fee as applicable to a plaintiff/defendant shall apply mutatis mutandis to execution proceedings.
4. Checking and admission of execution petition. Applications for execution shall ordinarily be checked in accordance with these Rules.
5. Procedure in execution application under Order XXI Rule 15 of the Code. When an application is made by one or more of several joint decree-holders, unless a written authority signed by the other decree-holders for the applicant to execute the decree and to receive the money or property recovered is filed in Court, the Court or the Registrar, may give notice of the order, if any, passed for the execution of the decree to all the decree-holders who have not jointed in the application and may also give notice of any application for payment or delivery to the applicant of any money or property recovered in execution.
6. Procedure when cause not shown. When execution is for arrest of a judgment debtor and the judgment-debtor does not appear on the day of hearing fixed under the notice issued or on such other day to which the hearing thereof is postponed, the notice and the affidavit of service thereof shall be filed and the Registrar, shall thereafter, place the matter before the Court for orders.
7. Registrar not to issue execution simultaneously against person and property. Execution shall not be issued against the property of a judgment-debtor at once with the issue of execution against his person. But a decree-holder desiring to proceed against both simultaneously, shall apply to the Court and in case of such application being refused, shall not be allowed to include the costs thereof, in his costs as against the judgment-debtor without the special order of the Court. Where a warrant for the arrest has not been executed, a warrant for attachment may, at the request of the decree-holder, be issued.
8. Application for appointment of Receiver in execution of decree. An application for the execution of a decree by the appointment of a Receiver under Section 51 and Order XI, Rule 1 of the Code to realize or otherwise deal with property under attachment shall be made to the Court, and such receiver shall, unless otherwise ordered, be subject to the rules of the Court, applicable to persons appointed as receivers of property in a suit.
MODE OF EXECUTION
Execution of Documents
9. Copies of draft to be filed. The decree-holder shall file two copies of the draft referred to in Order XXI Rule 34(1) of the Code and two copies of the notice in the prescribed form 33[* * *] for service thereof. One of the copies of the draft shall be served on the person directed to execute the document in the manner prescribed for service of summons on the defendant to a suit.
10. Execution of document under Order XXI, Rule 34(5) of the Code. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, a document shall be executed or a negotiable instrument endorsed under Order XXI, Rule 35(5) of the Code by the Registrar.
ARREST
11. Deposit with warrant of arrest. With every application for warrant of arrest, before or after judgment, a sum of Rs. 10,000/- shall be deposited with the Registrar for the intermediate subsistence of the judgment-debtor, pursuant to Order XXI, Rule 39(1) to (4) of the Code.
ATTACHMENT AND SALE
12. Application of encumbrancer to be made a party to the suit or to join in the sale. An encumbrancer, not a party to the suit, may at any time before the sale, apply to the Court to be made a party, or for leave to join in the sale; such order shall be made thereon in protection of his right and as to costs as the Court shall deem fit.
13. Receipt of attached property to be given. A bailiff attaching movable property shall, furnish to the judgment-debtor or other person, from whose possession the movable property is attached, a receipt in the form of a list of the said property signed by the said bailiff and take an acknowledgment to that fact on the warrant of attachment.
14. Deposit of cost for removal or maintenance of property. Before making any order for the attachment of live-stock or other movable property, or at any time after any such order has been passed, the Court or the Registrar, may require the person at whose instance the order of attachment is sought or has been made to deposit in Court, such sum of money as the Court or the Registrar may consider necessary:
(a) for the removal of the property to the Court premises or other appointed place and its maintenance, guarding and custody till arrival thereat;
(b) for the maintenance, guarding and custody of the property at the Court premises or other appointed place till it is sold or otherwise disposed of; and
(c) for the maintenance, guarding and custody of the property at the place at which it was attached or elsewhere.
In case of failure to deposit such sum within the time prescribed by the Court or Registrar, the Court or Registrar may, either, refuse to issue or may cancel the order of attachment, as the case may be.
15. Account to be rendered on demand. An account of the expenses actually incurred shall, on demand being made on or before the date of the sale, be furnished to the attaching creditor and to the person whose property was attached. After hearing objections to the account, if any, made within three days of its receipt by a party, the amount that the Registrar finds, to be properly due shall be deducted at first charge from the proceeds of the sale of the property and paid to the attaching creditor along with any balance of the deposit made by him.
16. Restoration of attached property on payment of costs incurred. (a) If in consequence of the cancellation of the order of attachment or for any other reason, the person whose property has been attached, becomes entitled to receive back the live-stock or other movable property attached, he shall be given a notice by the Registrar that he should take delivery of it within the time specified by the Registrar on payment by him of the charges, if any, found by the Court or the Registrar to have been properly incurred and which have not been defrayed or for the defrayal of which, no money has been deposited by the attaching-creditor.
(b) If he commits default in taking delivery of the property, by failure to pay the requisite charges or otherwise the Court may order that the property be sold by public auction and that after defraying the charges referred to in sub-Rule (a), if any, and the expenses of the sale, the balance of the sale-proceeds be credited to his account.
SALE OF ATTACHED PROPERTY
17. Notice regarding sale of guns and other arms, etc., attached. Whenever guns or other arms in respect of which licences have to be taken by purchasers under any law in force for the time being or any other articles in respect of which licences have to be taken under any law in force, are sold by public auction in execution of decrees, the Registrar shall give due notice to the District Magistrate concerned, or other appropriate officer, of the names and addresses of the purchasers and of the time and place of the intended delivery to the purchaser of such arms or other articles. No such arm or other article shall be delivered to the purchaser unless he holds a licence for the same.
18. Immediate sale of movable property. In the case of property to be sold under the proviso to Rule 43 of Order XXI of the Code, if such property, in the custody of the Registrar, he may authorize an officer of the Court to sell the same by public auction and may give such directions as to the date and time and place of sale and the manner of publishing the same as the circumstances of the particular case admit.
19. Contents of sale proclamation. In addition to the particulars specified in Order XXI sub-rule (2) of Rule 66 of the Code, the sale proclamation shall contain a notice that only the right, title and interest of the judgment-debtor is to be sold. The title, deeds or an abstract of the judgment-debtors title, if available, will be open for inspection at the office of the Registrar.
The proclamation shall, whenever such information is available, also state in whose possession and occupation the property is and the tenancy or terms on which any person is in occupation or possession.
20. Appearance of judgment-debtor. (a) If the judgment-debtor appears before the Registrar pursuant to the notice issued, under Order XXI Rule 66(2) of the Code, the Registrar shall examine him on any matter affecting his title to the attached property. The decree-holder may also examine him on any matter relating thereto. If the judgment-debtor fails to attend, the Registrar shall proceed ex parte.
(b) The Registrar may also exercise powers under Order XXI, Rule 66(4) of the Code. If any documents are produced relating to the attached property by any person, the same shall be left with the Registrar, and shall be subject to his directions both as to their custody pending the sale and their ultimate disposal, such directions being subject to appeal to the Court.
21. Publication of proclamation. Whenever the sale of land or of a house or houses exceeding Rs. 10,000/- in value or movable property exceeding Rs. 10,000/- in value is ordered, the Registrar shall, with the permission of the Court, advertise such sale in a local newspaper or newspapers.
22. Copy of sale proclamation to be sent to Collector in case of sale of land. When any land or share of land is ordered to be sold in execution of a decree, the Court shall send a copy of the proclamation of sale issued under Order XXI Rule 67 of the Code to the Collector concerned.
23. Arrest on sale on holidays. No arrest shall be effected and no sale shall be held in execution on Sundays or during holidays or vacation of the Court, except by leave of the Court or the Registrar.
24. Leave to bid and reserved price. (a) An application for leave to bid by the decree-holder at the sale shall be supported by an affidavit giving reasons why the applicant should be permitted to bid.
(b) In cases in which the Registrar considers that the applicant should not be allowed to bid for less than a sum to be fixed, it shall be competent for the Registrar to give leave to bid at the sale only on condition that the applicant's bid shall not be less than the amount so fixed, which amount shall as far as practicable, be determined with reference to the market value of the property or of the lot or lots into which the property is divided for sale.
25. Sale. On the day and at the time and place appointed for the sale, the proclamation of sale shall be read out before the property is put up for sale.
26. Postponement of sale or want of sufficient bidding. If there be no bid or the highest bid be below the reserved price (if any), or be deemed insufficient by the Registrar or other officer conducting the sale, he shall postpone the sale and record the reason for such postponement in the bidding paper.
27. Postponement of sale otherwise than under Rule 26. The Registrar or other officer conducting the sale may for sufficient cause postpone the sale. The costs of a postponement rendered necessary by the absence of the Registrar or other officer conducting the sale shall be costs in the cause. The costs of a postponement, made at the request of the party or by reason of his conduct, shall be borne by him.
28. Bidding paper. The name of each bidder at the sale of property shall be noted on a paper to be called the bidding paper each bid shall be signed by the bidder and the amount of the bid shall be entered opposite his name. If there be no bid, the words no bid shall be written in the bidding paper opposite the property or, as the case may be the number of the lot. If the highest bid be deemed insufficient, the word not sold shall be written opposite the property or the number of the lot. If the property be sold, the highest bid shall be inserted opposite the property or the number of the lot, wherein the full name and address of the bidder be taken and his signature obtained and purchaser shall write his full name opposite such entry and shall add his address and occupation. All notices thereafter served at the address so given shall be deemed to have been duly served on the purchaser.
29. Agent to produce Authority. A person purchasing for another as his duly authorized agent shall produce his authority in writing at the time of bidding, and sign the bidding paper as such, giving the full name, address occupation both of himself and his principal. All notices thereafter served at either of the addresses given shall be deemed to have been duly served.
30. Declaration of purchase. If the highest bid be equal to or higher than the reserved price, if any, the Registrar or other officer conducting the sale shall make an entry in the bidding paper to the following effect.
I (name) declare to have been the highest bidder for the purchase of the property above set forth (or of lot No.) for the sum of Rs .
31. Report of sale. Upon the completion of the sale the Registrar or other officer conducting the sale shall file in Court his report of the sale.
32. Time for confirming sale. A sale of immovable property shall not be confirmed until after the expiration of 30 days from the date thereof.
Chapter XXV
REVIEW
1. Review. Where the Judge or the Judges, or any of the Judges, who passed the decree or made the order a review of which is applied for, continues or continue attached to the Court at the time when the application for a review is presented, and is not or are not precluded by absence or other cause for a period of six months after the application from considering the decree or order to which the application refers, such Judge or Judges or any of them shall hear the application, and no other Judge or Judges of the Court shall hear the same.
Provided that if the said Judge or Judges, or any one of the Judges, who passed the decree or made the order, is or are precluded by absence or other cause for a period of six months after the application from considering the decree or order to which the application refers, it shall be heard by a Bench consisting of as many Judges as the Bench whose decree or order a review is applied for. Where the Judge(s), who passed the decree or made the order, is/are available, such judge(s) shall be members of the Bench aforesaid.
Chapter XXVI
ELECTION PETITIONS
1. Extant Rules made by the Court regarding election petitions under the Representation of Peoples Act, 1951 shall stand incorporated by inclusion in these Rules.
2. The Registry shall not return election petitions to the party filing the same under any circumstances once it has been presented. The defects/objections if any pointed out by the Registry shall be placed before the Judge for orders:
3. The following endorsements shall be made on the election petition at the time of presentation:
Presented by Shri
Petitioner/s in person Accompanied by/identified by Sh., Advocate on (DATE) at AM/PM (TIME)
Chapter XXVII
E-FILING
1. E-Filing. Practice Direction(s) for Electronic Filing (E-Filing) in the High Court of Delhi shall stand incorporated by inclusion in these Rules and are annexed hereto as Annexure C.
Chapter XXVIII
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION, ARBITRATION AND MEDIATION
1. Extant rule(s), notification(s), scheme(s) and Practice Directions in relation to proceedings under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as amended from time to time, shall stand incorporated by inclusion in these Rules.
2. Extant rule(s), notification(s), scheme(s) and Practice Directions in relation to mediation, as contemplated under Section 89 of the Code, including Practice Directions for Mediation dated 12.03.2009 published vide Notification No. 7/Rules/DHC shall stand incorporated by inclusion in these Rules, as Annexure D.
Chapter XXIX
TESTAMENTARY AND INTESTATE JURISDICTION
1. Application for grant of probate or letters of administration. No application for grant of probate or letters of administration will be received by the Registry, except where the Administrator General is the applicant, unless:
(i) it is accompanied by an affidavit of valuation as required by Section 19-1 of the Court Fees Act, 1870, prepared strictly in the form set forth in the Third Schedule thereof; and
(ii) is also accompanied by an affidavit of proof or certificate of death.
2. Verification. An application for probate shall be verified by at least one of the witnesses to the will, when procurable, in the form set forth in Section 281 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, and the affidavit of such witness shall also be filed. If no affidavit by any of the attesting witnesses is procurable, evidence on affidavit must be produced of that fact and of the handwritings and/or any circumstances which may raise a presumption in favour of due execution of the will.
3. Memo of parties. In all applications for probate; for letters of administration with the will annexed; or for administration of the estate, the petitioner shall state the name(s) and all available particulars, as provided in Rule 3 of Chapter III of these rules, of members of the family or other relatives upon whom the estate would have devolved in case of an intestacy.
4. Application by creditor. In all applications by a creditor for letters of administration, it shall be stated particularly how the debt arose and whether the applicant has any, and if so what, security for the debt.
5. Notice. (i) The Registrar shall give notice of all application(s) for probate or letters of administration to the Chief Controlling Revenue authority in accordance with Section 19-H of the Court-fees Act, 1870, and it will be the duty of the petitioner or his Advocate to ask for issuance of the same.
(ii) In all applications for probate or letters or administration, notice of the application shall be given to all heirs and next of kin of the deceased mentioned in the application.
(iii) Before setting down an application for probate or letters of administration for final hearing in Court, the Registrar will certify that notice of the application has been served on the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority.
6. Non-contested applications. Non-contested applications for probate or letters of administration may be disposed off, either on affidavits or evidence, as the Court may deem fit.
7. Valuation of property. A copy of affidavit of valuation of property of the deceased, accompanying the application for probate or letters of administration, shall be annexed to the grant of probate or letters of administration.
8. Forms. The forms prescribed in Nos. 173 to 180, both inclusive, in Volume 6 Part A of the Rules and Orders of the Punjab High Court (1960 edition) , with such variations or modifications as the circumstances may require, shall be used for the purposes therein mentioned.
9. Grant of probate or letters of administration. Grant of probate or letters of administration shall issue in the name of the Court and be signed by the 34[Registrar/Joint Registrar/Deputy Registrar].
10. Administration bond. (i) An administration bond, unless dispensed with by Court, shall be executed in favour of the Registrar General. Provided if value is less than Rs. 1,000/-, one surety only may be given.
(ii) The Court may direct such bond be given with or without surety/sureties approved by the Registrar for the amount of the value of the property for which the grant is made.
(iii) Administration bonds shall be attested by the Registrar or such other officer(s) of Court, as may be nominated in this behalf.
Chapter XXX
CAVEAT
1. Caveat. In any suit or proceeding to which Section 148-A of the Code applies, the person instituting the same shall state in the plaint, petition or application, whether or not he has received notice of any caveat lodged in the Court in respect thereof, and, if so particulars of the same.
2. Format. Filing of a caveat shall be in on a format provided below as under:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION CAVEAT NO OF
In the matter of a suit/appeal proceeding instituted (give the particulars), or expected to be instituted, by
Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Against
Respondent(s)
To
The Registrar,
Delhi High Court,
New Delhi
Let no order (here state in detail the precise nature of the order apprehended) be made in the above matter without notice to the undersigned.
Dated this the _____ day of _____.
Sd/-
Name and address of the Caveator and his Advocate, if any Filed on .
Chapter XXXI
REPEAL AND SAVINGS
1. The Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1967 and Practice Directions, applicable to the Original Side of the Court, except to the extent incorporated in these Rules, and not inconsistent herewith, are hereby repealed.
2. The repeal of the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1967 and Practice Directions, applicable to the Original Side of the Court shall, however, not affect:
(a) the previous operation of the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1967 and Practice Directions, applicable to the Original Side of the Court, so repealed or anything duly done or suffered thereunder; or
(b) any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or incurred under the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1967 and Practice Directions, applicable to the Original Side of the Court, so repealed; or
(c) any liability incurred in respect of any contravention under the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1967 and Practice Directions, applicable to the Original Side of the Court, so repealed; or
(d) any proceeding or remedy in respect of any such right, privilege, obligation, or liability, as aforesaid, and any such proceeding or remedy may be instituted, continued or enforced, and any such obligation may be imposed or made as if the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1967 and Practice Directions, applicable to the Original Side of the Court, had not been repealed.
Provided however, in respect of Commercial disputes, the Commercial Courts Act read with these Rules shall apply, as provided in the Commercial Courts Act.
ANNEXURE A
Practice directions for issuance of summons/notices through speed post/registered post with Proof of Delivery (POD) in the High Court of Delhi
ANNEXURE B
Guidelines for the conduct of court proceedings between Court and remote sites - video conferencing guidelines issued by the High Court of Delhi
ANNEXURE C
Practice directions for Electronic Filing (E-Filing) in the High Court of Delhi
ANNEXURE D
Practice directions For Mediation dated 12-3-2009 published vide Notification No. 7/RULES/DHC
ANNEXURE E
Practice directions under Section 18 of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015
ANNEXURE A
PRACTICE DIRECTIONS FOR ISSUANCE OF SUMMONS/NOTICES THROUGH SPEED POST/REGISTERED POST WITH PROOF OF DELIVERY (POD) IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
1. These practice directions will apply in all cases where the Hon'ble Court has ordered issuance of summons/notices through Speed Post or Registered Post. These Practice Directions will come into force immediately.
2. In all cases where summons/notices have been ordered by Hon'ble Court to be served through Speed Post or Registered Post the following procedure will be followed:
a) The Advocate/Party-in-Person will file Process Fee at the Filing Counter, Delhi High Court, clearly mentioning therein his contact number and address along with copies of the petition/application to be sent with the summons/notices and adequate numbers of the envelopes specially designed, containing proof of delivery (PoD) bearing the address of the respondent/addressee. These envelopes are available at the Extension Counter set up by the Department of Posts in the Receipt and Despatch Branch, Main Building, A Block, Delhi High Court.
b) The Process Fee Form along with envelope(s) and the copies of petition/application so filed will be sent by the Filing Counter to the concerned Branch for preparation of summons/notices.
c) The concerned branch will prepare the summons/notices within a period of three working days of receiving the process fee form from the filing counter. The branch will immediately thereafter send the copies of summons/notices, envelope(s) and copy of the petition/application to the Receipt & Despatch Branch, which will seal the process in the envelope(s).
d) The Advocate/Party-in-Person will collect sealed envelope(s) from the Receipt and Despatch Branch and submit them directly at the extension counter set up by the Department of Posts.
e) The Advocates will pay the following charges directly at the Counter set up by the Department of Posts.
i) Speed Post charges for the article as determined by the Department of Posts.
ii) Speed Post charges for the PoD as determined by the Department of Posts.
iii) Handling charges @ Rs. 5/- per acknowledgment (PoD) at the time of booking of the article.
iv) Scanning charges for the PoD @ Rs. 10/- at the time of booking of the article.
3. The Speed Post charges paid once will not be refunded even if the article is not delivered or is received back unserved.
4. The concerned Advocate/Party-in-Person will file an affidavit of service along with the receipt of summons/notices sent in the specially designed envelope(s) through Speed Post and the tracking report as available on the net.
5. The Department of Posts will send the scanned copy of the PoD electronically to the e-mail ID of the nominated officer of the Delhi High Court immediately on receipt of the same in the concerned Post Office.
6. The undelivered/refused articles or the duly signed PoD (or its scanned copy) received in the Receipt & Despatch Branch will be sent to the concerned Branches for further necessary action.
7. If the advocate/party concerned desires to have a scanned copy of the POD then he may furnish his e-mail ID at the time of filing of Process Fee form and should send a request to the Assistant Registrar (Appellate) (Email arappellate.dhc@nic.in) through email in this regard, who shall forward the scanned copy of the POD received electronically from the Department of Posts.
ANNEXURE B
VIDEO CONFERENCING GUIDELINES ISSUED BY THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Guidelines for the Conduct of Court Proceedings between Courts and Remote Sites
Introduction
Video conference facilities enabling audio and visual communication between persons at different locations have now been installed in:
Delhi High Court
All the District Courts in Delhi, i.e. Tis Hazari, Patiala House, Karkardooma, Rohini, Dwarka and Saket Courts
Prisons in Delhi i.e. Tihar and Rohini Prison Complex
Video-conferencing facilities provide Courts in Delhi with the capacity to receive evidence and submissions from Witnesses or persons involved in Court proceedings in circumstances where it would be expensive, inconvenient or otherwise not desirable for a person to attend a Court in person. An over-riding factor is that the use of video-conferencing in any particular case must be consistent with furthering the interests of justice and should cause minimal disadvantage to the parties. However, it is for the Court to decide whether evidence should be recorded by video-conferencing.
Even with the advancement of technology, there is a delay of milliseconds between video picture seen and sounds being heard. Allowances appropriate to this time gap need to be made to avoid one participant talking over another.
Microphones set up at the bench, the bar table and at the witness box are highly sensitive. Persons during a video conferencing should assume from the time the video conference is activated until the same is disconnected that microphones are live and as such all remarks are audible to the Court.
1. General
1.1 In these guidelines, reference to the court point means the Courtroom or other place where the Court is sitting or the place where Commissioner appointed by the Court to record the evidence by video conference is sitting and the remote. point is the place where the person to be examined via video conference is located, for example, a prison.
1.2 Person to be examined includes a person whose deposition or statement is required to be recorded or in whose presence certain proceedings are to be recorded.
1.3 Wherever possible, proceedings by way of video conference shall be conducted as judicial proceedings and the same courtesies and protocols will be observed. AII relevant statutory provisions applicable to judicial proceedings including the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 shall apply to the recording of evidence by video conference.
1.4 Video conferencing, facilities can be used in all matters including remands, bail applications and in civil and criminal trials where a witness is located intrastate, interstate, or overseas. However, these guidelines will not apply to-proceedings under Section 164 of Cr. P.C.
1.5 The guidelines applicable to a Court will mutatis mutandis apply to a Local Commissioner appointed by the Court to record the evidence.
2. Appearance by video conference
A Court may either suo moio or on application of a party or a witness, direct by a reasoned order that any person shall appear before it or give evidence or make submissions to the Court through video conference.
3. Preparatory arrangements for video conference
3.1 There shall be Co-ordinators. both at the court point as well as at the remote point.
3.2 In the High Court, Registrar (Computers) shall be. the co-ordinator at the court point.
3.3 In the District Courts, official-in-charge of the Video Conferencing Facility (holding the post of Senior Judicial Assistant/Senior Personal Assistant or above) nominated by the District Judge shall be the co-ordinator at the court point.
3.4. The Co-ordinator at the remote point may be any of the following:
(i) Where the person to be examined is overseas, the Court may specify the coordinator out of the following:
(a) the official of Consulate/Embassy of India,
(b) duly certified Notary Public/Oath Commissioner,
(ii) Where the person to be examined is in another State/U.T, a judicial Magistrate or any oilier responsible official as may be deputed by the District Judge concerned or Sub-Divisional Magistrate or any other responsible official as may be deputed by the District Collector concerned,
(iii) Where the person to. be examined is in custody, the concerned Jail Superintendent or any other responsible official deputed by him,
(iv) Where the person to be examined is in a hospital, public or private, whether run by the Central Government, the State Government, local bodies or any other person, the Medical Superintendent or In-charge of the said hospital or any other responsible official deputed by him,
(vi) Where the person to be examined is in Nirmal Chhaya, the Superintendent/Officer In-Charge of the Nirmal Chhaya or any other responsible official deputed by him,
(vii) Wherever a co-ordinator is to be appointed at the remote point under Clause 3.4 sub-Clause (ii); (iii), (iv), (v) & (vi), the Court concerned will make formal request through the District Judge concerned to concerned official.
(viii) In case of any other person, as may be ordered by the Court.
3.5 The co-ordinators at both the points shall ensure that the minimum requirements as mentioned in the Guideline No. 4 are in position at the court point and the remote point and shall conduct a test between both the points well in advance, to resolve any technical problem so that the proceedings are conducted without interruption,
3.6 It shall be ensured by the co-ordinator at the remote point that;
(i) the person to be examined or heard is available and ready at the room earmarked for the video conference at least 30 minutes before the scheduled time.
(ii) no other recording device is permitted except the one installed in the video conferencing room.
(iii) entry into the video conference room is regulated.
3.7 It shall be ensured by the co-ordinator at the court point that the co-ordinator at the remote point has certified copies or soft copies of all or any part of the court record in a sealed cover directed by the Court sufficiently in advance of the, scheduled video conference.
3.8 The Court shall order the co-ordinator at the remote point or at the court point wherever it is more convenient, to provide:
(i) a translator in case the person to be examined is not conversant with Court language;
(ii) an expert in sign language in case the person to be examined is speech and/or hearing impaired;
(iii) for reading of documents in case the person to be examined is visually challenged;
(iv) an interpreter or special educator, as the case may be, in case the person to be examined is temporarily or permanently mentally or physically disabled.
4. Minimum requisites for video conference
(i) A desktop or laptop with internet connectivity and printer
(ii) Device ensuring uninterrupted power supply
(iii) Video Camera
(iv) Microphones and speakers
(v) Display unit
(vi) Document visualizer
(vii) Comfortable sitting arrangements ensuring privacy
(viii) Adequate lighting
(ix) Insulations as far as possible/proper acoustics
(x) Digital signatures from licensed certifying authorities for the co-ordinators at the court point and at the remote point
5. Cost of video conferencing
5.1 In criminal cases, the expenses of the video conference facility including expenses of preparing soft copies/certified copies of the Court record for sending to the co-ordinator at the remote point and fee payable to translator/interpreter/special educator, as the case may be, and to the co-ordinator at the remote point shall be borne by such party as the Court directs talcing into account the Delhi Criminal Courts (Payment of Expenses to Complainant and Witnesses) Rules, 2015.
5.2 In civil cases, as a general rule, the party making the request for recording evidence by video conference shall bear the expenses.
5.3 In other cases, the court may make an order as to expenses as it considers appropriate talcing into account rules/instructions regarding payment of expenses to complainant and witnesses as may be prevalent from time to time. .
6. Procedures generally
6.1 The identity of the person to be examined shall be confirmed by the court with the assistance of the co-ordinator at remote point at the time of recording of the evidence.
6.2 In civil cases, party requesting for recording statement of the person to be examined by video conferencing shall confirm to the Court location of the person, his willingness to be examined by video conferencing, place and facility of such video conferencing.
6.3 In criminal cases, where the person to be examined is a prosecution witness or court witness, the prosecution and where person to be examined is a defence witness, the defence counsel will confirm to the Court his location, willingness to be examined by video conferencing, place and facility of such video conferencing.
6.4 In case person to be examined is an accused, prosecution will confirm his location at remote point.
6.5 Video conference shall ordinarily take place during the court hours. However, the Court may pass suitable directions with regard to timings of the video conferencing as the circumstances may dictate.
6.6 The, record of proceedings including transcription of statement shall be prepared at the court point under supervision of the Court and accordingly authenticated. The soft copy of the transcript digitally signed by the co-ordinator at the court point shall be sent by e-mail through NIC or any other Indian service provider to the remote point where printout of the same will be taken and signed by the deponent. A scanned copy of the statement digitally signed by co-ordinator at the remote point would be sent by e-mail through NIC or any other Indian service provider to the court point. The hard copy would also be sent subsequently, preferably within three days of the recording, by the co-ordinator at the remote point to the court point by courier/mail.
6.7 The Court may, at the request of a person to be examined, or on its own motion, talcing into account the best interests of the person to be examined, direct appropriate measures to protect his privacy keeping in mind his age, gender and physical condition.
6.8 Where a party or a lawyer requests that in the course of video-conferencing some privileged communication may have to take place, Court will pass appropriate directions in that regard.
6.9 The audio-visual shall be recorded at the court point. An encrypted master copy with hash value shall be retained in the Court as part of the record. Another copy shall also be stored at any other safe location for backup in the event of any emergency. Transcript of the evidence recorded by the Court shall be given to the parties as per applicable rules. A party may be allowed to view the master copy of the audio video recording retained in the Court on application which shall be decided by the Court consistent with furthering the interests of justice.
6.10 The co-ordinator at the remote point shall be paid such amount as honorarium as may be decided by the Court in consultation with the parties.
6.11 In case any party or his/her authorized person is desirous of being physically present at the remote point at the time of recording of the evidence, it shall be open for such party to make arrangements at party's own costs including for appearance/representation at the remote point subject to orders to the contrary by the Court.
7. Putting documents to a person at remote point
If in the course of examination of a person at a remote point by video conference, it is necessary to put a document to him, the Court may permit the document to be put in the following manner:
(a) if the document is at the court point, by transmitting a copy of it to the remote point electronically including through a document visualizer and the copy so transmitted being then put to the person;
(b) if the document is at the remote point, by putting it to the person and transmitting a copy of it to the court point electronically including through a document visualizer. The hard copy would also be sent subsequently to the court point by courier/mail.
8. Persons unconnected with the case
8.1 Third parties may be allowed to be present during video conferencing subject to orders to the contrary, if any, by the Court.
8.2 Where, for any reason, a person unconnected with the case is present at the remote point, then that person shall be identified by the co-ordinator at the remote point at the start of the proceedings and the purpose for his being present explained to the Court.
9. Conduct of proceedings
9.1 Establishment and disconnection of links between the court point and the remote point would be regulated by orders of the Court.
9.2 The Court shall satisfy itself that the person to be examined at the remote point can be seen and heard clearly and similarly that the person to be examined at the remote point can clearly see and hear the Court.
10. Cameras
10.1 The Court shall at all times have the ability to control the camera view at the remote point so that there is an unobstructed view of all the persons present in the room.
10.2 The Court shall have a clear image of each deponent to the extent possible so that the demeanour of such person may be observed.
11. Residuary Clause
Such matters with respect to which no express provision has been made in these guidelines shall be decided by the Court consistent with furthering the interests of justice.
ANNEXURE C
PRACTICE DIRECTIONS FOR ELECTRONIC FILING (E-FILING) IN
THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
1. These practice directions will apply to Electronic Filing (e-filling) of cases in the High Court of Delhi and will be effective from the dates and for the categories of cases as may be notified by the Chief Justice of the High Court of Delhi from time to time.
2. Except as provided elsewhere in these practice directions, all petitions, applications, appeals and all pleadings/documents in fresh, pending and disposed of cases will be filed electronically in the manner hereafter provided.
3. PROCEDURE FOR E-FILI NG
3.1 The original text material, documents, notice of motion, memorandum of parties, main petition or appeal, as the case may be, and interlocutory applications etc. will be prepared electronically using MS Word or Open Office software. The formatting style of the text will be as under:
| Paper size |
: |
A-4 |
| Margins |
: |
|
| Top |
: |
1.5 |
| Bottom |
: |
1.5 |
| Left |
: |
1.75 |
| ication |
: |
Full |
| Font |
: |
Times New Roman |
| Font size |
: |
14 |
| Line spacing |
: |
1.5 |
3.2 The documents should be converted into Portable document Format (PDF) using any PDF converter or in-built PDF conversion plug-in provided in the software. Procedure to convert word document to PDF is set out in Appendix I to these Practice Directions.
3.3 Where the document is not a text document and has to be enclosed with the petition, appeal or application or other pleadings, the document should be scanned using an image resolution of 300 dpi (dot per inch) and saved as a PDF document.
3.4 The maximum permissible size of the file that can be uploaded at the time of e-filing is 300 MB.
3.5 The text documents prepared in MS Word/Open Office as well as scanned documents should be merged as a single PDF file and book-marked. The procedure for this purpose is set out in Appendix II to these Practice Directions.
3.6 The merged documents should be uploaded at the time of e-filing by using the facility provided at the e-filing centre in the High Court Lawyers Chambers Block-I. The screen shots of the manner of accessing the e-filing portal and filling up the relevant columns for the purpose of e-filing are set out in Appendix III to these Practice Directions.
4. DIGITAL SIGNATURE
All electronic documents filed using the e-filing system will have to be digitally signed by the advocate for the parties or where it is being filed in person, by the party concerned. The list of recognized Digital Signature Providers and the procedure involved in appending single or multiple digital signatures are set in Appendix IV to the Practice Directions.
5. PAYMENT OF COURT FEE
Court fee can be paid buy purchase of electronic court fee either from the online facility provided by the stock Holding corporation of India Limited (http://www.shcilestamp.com/) or the counters provided for the purpose in the Delhi High Court or from any other authorized court fee vendor in Delhi. The payment code whether automatically generated on payment of court fee online through the payment gateway of Stock Holding Corporation of India Limited on the receipt when court fee is purchased from the counter, has to be filed in the appropriate box at the time of e-filing.
6. RETENTION OF ORIGINALS
6.1 The originals of the documents that are scanned and digitally signed either by counsel or parties in person at the time of e-filing should be preserved for production upon being direction by the court at any time.
In any event, signed Vakalatnama, signed and notarized/attested affidavit shall be filed in original in the Registry. Any other document whose authenticity is likely to be questioned should be preserved at least for a period of two years till after the final disposal of the case; (Final disposal shall include disposal of appeals if any) and the following documents be preserved permanently:
(a) A negotiable instrument (other than a cheque) as defined in Section 13 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (26 of 1881).
(b) A power-of-attorney as defined in Section 1-A of the Power-of-Attorney Act, 1882 (7 of 1882).
(c) A trust as defined in Section 3 of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 (2 of 1882)
(d) A will as defined in clause (h) of Section 2 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (39 of 1925) including any other testamentary disposition by whatever name called.
(e) Any contract for the sale or conveyance of immovable property or any interest in such property.
6.2 The responsibility for producing the originals and proving their genuineness shall be of the party that has electronically filed the scanned copies thereof.
7. ACCESS TO ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS
Access to documents and pleadings filed electronically in a case will be provided only to advocates for the parties in that case or the concerned parties themselves. The advocate or the party may obtain documents from the Filing Counter by mailing an application along with a blank CD-R/DVD-R to be provided by the party.
8. EXEMPTION FROM ELECTRONIC FILING
Exemption from e-filling of the whole or part of the pleadings and/or documents may be permitted by the Court upon an application for that purpose being made to the Court in the following circumstances:
(i) e-filing is, for the reasons to be explained in the application, not feasible; or.
(ii) there are concerns about confidentiality and protection of privacy; or
(iii) the document cannot be scanned or filed electronically because of its size, shape or condition; or
(iv) the e-filing system is either inaccessible or not available for some reason; or
(v) any other sufficient cause.
9. SERVICE OF ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS
In addition to the prescribed mode of service, notices, documents, pleadings that are filed electronically may also be served through e-mail by the High Court of Delhi. The e-mail ID of the High Court of Delhi (delhihighcourt@nic.in) will be published on its website so as to enable the recipients to verify the source of the e-mail at the e-mail addresses, if available, of the advocates or parties.
10. COMPUTATION OF TIME
10.1 Electronic filing through the e-filing centre is permissible up to 4 p.m. on the date of filing. All other rules relating to holidays etc. for the purpose of computation of limitation, as specified in the Rules of the High Court of Delhi will apply to online electronic filing as well. The period during which e-filing system is in-operational for any reason will be excluded from the computation of such time. This, however, will not extend limitation for such filing for which the facility of Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 or any other statutory extension of period of limitation is not available.
10.2 For electronic filing done through the e-filing centre in the Delhi High Court premises, the rules relating to time for the purpose of limitation will be no different from those applicable for the normal filing.
10.3 As and when the facility of electronic online filing commences, such electronic online filing would be permissible up to midnight on the date of filing.
11. CAVEATES, SUPPLEMENTARY AFFIDAVITS ETC.
Caveats can be registered, and all written statements, counter affidavits or reply affidavits, affidavits by way of rejoinder, documents, applications in pending matters or in disposed of matters, supplementary pleadings, documents etc in pending cases can be filed electronically using the e-filing system. The procedure for this purpose is set out in Appendix V to these Practice Directions.
12. HARD COPIED OF PLEADINGS AND DOCUMENTS FILED ELECTRONICALLY
Lawyers as well as parties can print hard copies of all pleadings and documents filed electronically for their use in the Court or elsewhere. Likewise the Registry will wherever required, prepare hard copies for use of the courts.
13. STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL OF ELECTRONICALLY FILED DOCUMENTS AND PLEADINGS
The pleadings and documents electronically filed will be stored on an exclusive server maintained under the control and directions of the High Court of Delhi. Each case will be separately labeled and encrypted for this purpose to facilitate easy identification and retrieval. The security of such document and pleadings will be ensured and access to them would be restricted in the manned indicated hereinbefore and as may be notified from time to time. Back-up copies of all electronically filed pleadings and documents will be preserved in the manner decided by the Court on its administrative side.
Appendix I
In case of any difficulty, please contact:
Mr. Sarsij Kumar, email@: sarsij.kumar@nic.in
Mr. Zameem Ahmad Khan, email@: zameem.dhc@nic.in
HOW TO CONVERT WORD FILE TO PDF
Word 2007
Open the file you wish to save.
Click the File button in the top left-hand corner Go to
Save As & PDF or
.png)
In case of unavailability of above option, open the URL
http://www.microsoft.com/downloads for the downloading of Microsoft's free PDF and XPS converter.
Note: It will work only for the Windows (Operating System);
Word 2010/13
Click File, Share. From the Share menu, Click Create PDF Document then on the right-side Click Create a PDF.
.png)
Other Versions of Word
Open the file you wish to save. Go
to File > Print .
Click the dropdown list of installed printers and select PDF . Newer versions of Microsoft Word have this option; if it does not appear on your version, try one of the methods below. Click OK . This will convert your document and open it in Adobe Reader (if you have already installed it otherwise need to be install it at first).
PDF Conversion Website
Go to a free PDF conversion website.
Examples include
http://printinpdf.com
http://www.freepdfconvert.com,
http://www.pdfonline.com/convert-pdf
http://docupub.com/pdfconvert
Do not use a site that asks you to pay, install unnecessary software, or anything else you're uncomfortable with. There are many free, easy-to-use PDF conversion sites available online.
Click Browse to locate the desired Word file(s).
Provide your email address if necessary. Some sites will email the file directly to your inbox. If you don't want to provide your email address, note that Print in PDF does not require your email address .
Click Convert and wait for it to process.
Check your file. Check the website for your converted file; otherwise, look for the file in your inbox.
Click on your PDF file(s) to open and/or download them. Save if necessary.
Using Open Office
1. Download OpenOffice. This is a free, open-source word processor that is fully compatible with Word.
2. Double click on the downloaded file to install OpenOffice on your computer. Open the Word document you want to convert in Open Office.
3. From the main menu, select File & Export as PDF . There is also an export to PDF button right on the main taskbar.
4. Choose a file name for your PDF. Make sure that everything else is how you want it.
5. Click Okay or Save to convert. This will convert your document and open it in Adobe Reader (if you have already installed it otherwise need to be install it at first).
.png)
Appendix II
Merging file and Bookmarking
There are many free software programs available online that can be downloaded from internet for creating bookmarks in PDF document, merging and splitting PDF files. These include Foxit Reader, PDFsam, Jpdf etc.
Example 1: Foxit Reader(Using for Bookmark)
Download the software from website
http://www.foxitsoftware.com/Secure_Pdf_Reader. The software program may be downloaded by clicking on Free Download link available on website.
.png)
Once the software is downloaded, get it installed by clicking on downloaded program. Start the Foxit Reader program. We can navigate through the pdf document. The bookmark items will automatically be kept in sysnc with page being displayed.
.png)
Example 2: Pdfsam PDF MERGE AND SPLIT
PDF Split and Merge is a very simple, easy to use, free, open source utility to split and merge pdf files. It has a simple graphical interface to let the user choose pdf files, split or merge them. a simple, open source and free software for pdf manipulation.
MERGE into PDF Here is the Merge/Extract main window:
.png)
Click the Add button to choose the pdf files you want to merge together.
.png)
Select pdf files you want to merge; if you want to select more the one file press the
.png)
Once your files have been selected you'll see the selection table containing files details:
Use the buttons Move Up , Move Down to change the files order or select one or more documents and drag&drop. Press Remove to remove unwanted files from the list. Press Clear to clear the selection table. Click on the columns header to have the table ordered on that column values.
Double click the Page Selection cell if you want to merge only a subset of the document. Click the Run button.
SPLIT into PDF
Here is the split main window:
.png)
Select the split option you need:
Burst splits the pdf file into single pages, one pdf file-one page.
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
Appendix IV
Please go to the websitehttp://cca.gov.into get the list of Licensed CAs
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
ANNEXURE D
HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
No. 7/Rules/DHC Dated: 12.3.2009
PRACTICE DIRECTIONS FOR MEDIATION
Hon'ble the Chief Justice, in supersession of the earlier practice directions bearing No. 3/Rules/DHC dated 16.2.2009, has been pleased to issue the following practice directions:
1) Plaintiffs/defendants and appellants/respondents along with the plaints, appeals or the written statement/replies/rejoinder would annex duly filed up proforma as placed at Annexure A indicating their willingness to opt for any of the Alternate Dispute Resolution methods i.e. Mediation, Conciliation, Arbitration, Lok Adalat or Judicial Settlement.
2) The Registry, while issuing summons or notices of plaints or appeals, shall annex the copy of the options so exercised by the plaintiffs/petitioners/appellants to the summons/notice issued to the defendant/respondent.
3) When the case is listed before the Court, the Court may consider the option so exercised by the parties while taking a decision to refer the matter for settlement by mediation or any other alternative dispute resolution method.
4) The Courts may refer a case for mediation at any stage of the proceedings.
5) On the date when issues are framed, the Court shall consider the feasibility and advisability of referring the case for ADR. If such a case is referred for mediation, then the Court shall fix a date for recording of evidence as per the calendar making it clear that if mediation fails, the evidence shall be recorded on the date fixed and on a day to day basis.
6) When a case is referred for mediation, not more than 90 days adjournment for hearing may be given with the direction that the Mediator shall submit his report before the Court prior to the date fixed so as to avoid any delay in trial.
7) The Mediator shall maintain strict confidentiality of mediation proceedings and the confidentiality factor should be explained to the parties at the outset.
8) The report of the Mediator to the Court should only state whether or not the settlement between the parties has been arrived at. In the event of parties arriving at a settlement, the Mediator shall satisfy himself that settlement covers all the issues between the parties and thereafter shall reduce the terms of settlement into writing. He shall explain the same to the parties and obtain their signatures on the settlement before referring it to the Court.
9) The Mediator shall not state in his report as to what transpired during the mediation and what was the stand taken by respective parties and cause for failure of mediation.
10) The case which is referred for mediation, if returned without any settlement, will be placed before the same Hon'ble Judge, who in the first instance, referred it for mediation irrespective of whether the Hon'ble Judge is sitting on the same board or not.
By order of the Court, Sd/-
(Ajit Bharihoke)
Registrar General
ANNEXURE A
FORM A
IN THE COURT OF____________________DELHI
In the matter of a suit/appeal/proceeding instituted (give the particulars)
Plaintiff(s)/Appellant(s)
Against
Defendant(s)/Respondent(s)
I,_______________, S/o_____________ plaintiff/defendant/respondent,
appellant/respondent, give my consent to settle this case by mediation/conciliation/arbitration/lok adalat/judicial settlement.
Signature
PLACE:
DATE:
ANNEXURE E
PRACTICE DIRECTIONS UNDER SECTION 18 OF THE COMMERCIAL COURTS, COMMERCIAL DIVISION AND COMMERCIAL APPELLATE DIVISION OF HIGH COURTS ACT, 2015
1. These Practice Directions are issued by the Court in exercise of powers conferred under Section 18 of the Commercial Courts Act to supplement the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 2018, the provisions of Chapter II of the Commercial Courts Act or the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, in so far as such provisions apply to the hearing of commercial disputes of a specified value. said Act, as applicable, shall apply to all suits/original proceedings in relation to commercial disputes , as defined under Section 2(c) of the Commercial Courts Act.
2. Where parties seek to rely upon any documentary evidence, they must include the same alongwith the plaint and identify the relevant content of such documentary evidence on which they rely. Where the documentary evidence is in electronic form, parties shall furnish requisite affidavit under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, in support of the said electronic record. They shall also state in such affidavit that to the best of the deponent's knowledge and belief, such computer system operated properly at the material time, the deponent was provided with relevant data, and the printout in question represents correctly, or it is appropriately derived from, relevant data.
3. The aggregate value of the claim and counter-claim, if any, as set out in the statement of claim and the counter-claim, if any, in an arbitration of a commercial dispute shall be the basis for determining whether such arbitration is subject to the jurisdiction of a Commercial Division, Commercial Appellate Division or Commercial Court, as the case maybe.
4. The Registry shall maintain, regularly, on a monthly basis, a separate statistical data regarding the number of suits, applications, appeals or writ petitions filed before the Commercial Court or Commercial Division, as the case may be.
5. In commercial cases, the index of the case shall also specify whether the originals of the documents filed are in the power, possession, control or custody of the party filing the same as also the mode of execution, issuance or receipt and line of custody of each document [Order XI Rule 1(2) of the Code]. The Registry will ensure that the plaints, petitions, applications and documents are placed in the appropriate part of the files soon after they are presented.
6. Documents shall be filed only with a list of documents. No document shall be filed as annexure to any pleading.
7. Powers conferred upon the Registrar under Chapter II Rule 3 of these Rules, shall be deemed to be conferred upon him in dealing with Commercial Suits also.
8. A list of dates/brief synopsis shall be filed along with the suit/plaint/petition.
9. In the case of commercial disputes, the Court may, inter-alia, pass orders as it may think fit for the speedy disposal of the suit or narrowing the controversy between the parties, including:
(a) calling upon the parties to admit or deny such allegations of fact as are made in the plaint or written statement and are not expressly or by implication admitted or denied by the party against whom they are made as provided in Order X Rule 1 of the Code.
(b) recording the statement of the parties under Order X Rule 2 of the Code with a view to elucidate the matter in controversy or answer the material questions relating to the suit.
(c) calling upon parties to conduct inspection of documents as required under Order XI Rule 3 of the Code as applicable to commercial disputes and direct the inspection to be conducted at any place convenient to the parties within a fixed time schedule not exceeding 30 days from the date of filing of the written statement;
(d) call upon the parties to, after inspection of the documents, file statements of admission/denial as per Order XI Rule 4 of the Code;
(e) passing an order of admission of a document under Order XII Rule 2-A of the Code, in case a party to which a notice has been given under Order XII Rule 2 of the Code, has failed to deny specifically or by necessary implication and also passing an order of compensation where a party unreasonably neglects or refuses to admit a document after the service of notice.
(f) passing an order for paying cost of proving a document or a fact by a party, refusing or neglecting to admit a document.
(g) direct listing of the matter before the Registrar for marking of exhibits on all admitted documents as also public documents of third parties for e.g., documents issued by government authorities, reputed publications, newspaper articles, electronic printouts from websites which are accessible openly;
(h) conduct a Case Management hearing under Order XV-A of the Code and as part of the said case management hearing
i. explore the possibility of settlement between the parties as per Section 89 of the Code.
ii. explore the possibility of deciding the dispute by a summary judgment, without a specific application for the said purpose, on the basis of pleadings dispensing with the trial of the suit on the questions of law or of facts on which the parties are not at issue;
iii. frame only such issues that arise for adjudication and upon insistence by any parties for framing of issues which the Court considers either frivolous or not maintainable, affix costs on a per issue basis to be paid by the losing party after trial;
iv. decide such issues which do not require evidence as preliminary issues;
v. fix a date for filing of list of witnesses by both parties;
vi. examine the list of witnesses and direct only such witnesses to be examined as are essential for adjudication of the issues so framed so as to not permit unnecessary protraction of trial with large number of witnesses;
vii. fix time schedules for filing of affidavits in evidence by all parties including rebuttal evidence, if any;
viii. It shall be endeavour of Court/Registrar to appoint such person as a Commissioner to record evidence, who would be in a position to carry out the commission within the time lines provided by these Rules, and in any case, not a person who is appointed as a Commissioner for recording evidence, and who has not more than ten pending matters as on that date.
ix. The Commissioner shall, to the extent possible, make himself available for recording evidence throughout the working hours of the Court and endeavour to record evidence on a day-to-day basis.
x. The Court/Registrar may require the Commissioner to furnish a report of the progress of commission on such periodicity as it considers appropriate including requiring the Commissioner to file his reports and record of proceedings, on a hearing to hearing basis, and not at the end of the recordal of evidence. The Commissioner shall, in his record of proceedings/order sheet, mention the time at which the proceedings commenced; the time at which the examination-in-chief, cross-examination, and re-examination, if any, respectively, commenced and ended. In such record the Commissioner shall also mention the time at which commission proceedings closed on the said date.
xi. The Commissioner shall record all objections raised during recording of evidence and shall not delay or adjourn the recording of evidence on that ground. All such objections shall be decided at the time of decision of the suit/other original proceeding or at such time as the Court considers appropriate.
xii. If the Commissioner is of the view that a party is unduly, unreasonably or unjustifiably prolonging cross-examination of a witness; the Commissioner shall immediately bring it to the notice of Court/Registrar for appropriate orders.
xiii. The Commissioner shall obtain signatures of witness on every page of the testimony.
xiv. The Commissioner shall endeavour to complete recording of evidence within six months from the date first fixed before him. In case the recording of evidence cannot be completed within six months, the Commissioner shall furnish a report explaining reasons for delay and direct parties to seek appropriate orders from Court/Registrar. The Court/Registrar, in its discretion, upon examining the report of the Commissioner, may grant a further period within which the commission is to be completed or pass such orders as it considers appropriate.
xv. Where Court/Registrar/Commissioner deems appropriate, keeping in view volume/number of documents required to be marked/identified, it may dispense with marking of documents in presence of witnesses, by directing a pre-trial hearing before Court/Registrar/Commissioner, when identification and marking of exhibits/affixation of suitable marks of identification can be carried out in terms of respective affidavit(s) of witnesses filed. While doing so the Court/Registrar/Commissioner would record objections, if any, of any party objecting to marking/identification of documents;
xvi. monitor the trial being carried out by fixing periodic dates before itself every 3 months after the Case Management hearing; xvii. direct consolidation of trials in cases where identical or similar issues arise; xviii. direct filing of synopsis in the suit;
xix. direct pagination of the record and convert them to digital copies to be given to all parties in the case;
xx. fix time limits for final arguments.
10. Summons for settlement of issues in Commercial Cases shall be as per Form below
Summons for Settlement of Issues in a Suit relating to Commercial Dispute (U/s 6 of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Divisions and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 amending Order V, Rule I of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908)
In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi
..Plaintiff
versus
..Defendant
To
(Name, description and place of residence)
Whereas ..has instituted a suit relating to a commercial dispute against you and you are hereby summoned to file a written statement within 30 days of the service of the present summons and in case you fail to file the written statement alongwith an affidavit of admission/denial of documents filed by the plaintiff, within the said period of 30 days, you shall be allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as may be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing and on payment of such costs as the Court deems fit, but which shall not be later than 120 days from the date of service of summons. On expiry of One Hundred and Twenty days from the date of service of summons, you shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the Court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record.
You are required to appear in this Court in person, or by a pleader duly instructed, and able to answer all material questions relating to suit, or who shall be accompanied by some person able to answer all such questions, on the . day of ..at O clock, to answer the claim; and further you are hereby directed to produce on the said day all documents in your power or possession upon which you base your defence or claim for set off or counter-claim, and where you rely on any other document, whether in your power or possession or not, as evidence in support or you defence or claim for set-off, or counter-claim, you shall enter such documents in a list to be annexed to the written statement.
Take notice that, in default of your appearance on the day and time aforementioned, the suit will be heard and determined in your absence.
Given under the hand and the Seal of Court, on this .day of .. 20
Judge/Registrar
35[ANNEXURE F
Chapter VII Rule 17
Procedure to be followed in dealing with confidential documents/information
Upon hearing of an application, the Court may allow constitution of a Confidentiality Club in the following manner
(a) All documents/information considered as confidential ( Confidential Documents/Information ) by the Court shall be permitted to be filed in a sealed cover to kept in the safe custody of Registrar General.
(b) Each party shall nominate not more than three Advocates, who are not and have not been inhouse lawyers of either party, and not more than two external experts, who shall constitute the Confidentiality Club. Members of the Confidentiality Club alone shall be entitled to inspect the Confidential Documents/Information.
(c) Members of the Confidentiality Club shall be allowed to inspect the Confidential Documents/Information before the Registrar General, without making copies thereof. After the inspection, the Confidential Documents/Information shall be resealed and kept in the custody of the Registrar General.
(d) Members of the Confidentiality Club shall not make copies of, or disclose, or publish the contents of, the Confidential Documents/Information to anyone else in any manner or by any means, or in any other legal proceedings and shall be bound by the orders of the Court in this behalf.
(e) During recordal of evidence with respect to the Confidential Documents/Information, only members of the Confidentiality Club shall be allowed to remain present.
(f) During proceedings of the Court, when the Confidential Documents/Information are being looked at or their contents discussed, only members of the Confidentiality Club shall be permitted to be present.
(g) The Court may in its discretion and in an appropriate case, permit copies of the Confidential Documents to be given to the opposite party after redacting confidential information therefrom, if such redaction be possible and not otherwise.
(h) Any evidence by way of affidavit or witness statement containing confidential information derived from the Confidential Documents/Information shall be kept in a sealed cover with the Registrar General and would be accessible only to the members of the Confidentiality Club. However, a party filing such evidence by way of affidavit shall, if so directed by the Court, give to the opposite party, a copy of such affidavit after redacting therefrom the confidential information, if such redaction is possible and not otherwise.
(i) The Confidential Documents/Information shall not be available for inspection after disposal of the matter, except to the Party producing the same.
(j) In cases where the Confidentiality Club is constituted or documents are directed to be kept confidential, the Court may consider extending the time for filing of pleadings. However, the same shall be within the overall limits prescribed by the applicable provisions.
ANNEXURE G
Chapter XI Rule 6
Hot-tubbing is a technique in which expert witnesses give evidence simultaneously in each other s presence and in front of the Judge, who puts the same question to each expert witnesses. It is a co-operative endeavour to identify key issues of a dispute and where possible evolve a common resolution for all of them. However, where resolution of issues is not possible, a structured discussion, allows the experts to give their opinions without the constraints of the adversarial process and in a setting which enables them to respond directly to each other. The Judge is thereby not confined to the opinion of only one expert but has the benefit of multiple experts who are rigorously examined in public.
When parties to a commercial suit wish to rely on the hot tubbing method to record the deposition of expert witnesses, then the Court may adopt the following procedure:
(a) Prior to a hearing taking place, the expert witnesses take parting a meeting, at a mutually convenient place, where they prepare a Joint Statement which shall be filed before Court.
(b) The Joint Statement shall consist of the agreed statement of facts and disputed issues.
(c) Thereafter, suggested questions to be put to the expert witnesses, shall be filed by the parties.
(d) A hearing is then conducted on the disputed issues.
(e) Counsels may put questions to the expert witnesses, as may be permitted by the Court.
(f) At the end of the proceeding, the Court would draw up the issues on which the expert witnesses agree and the issues on which they disagree.
(g) On the issues on which the expert witnesses disagree, the Court shall record their statements.]