New York Case Commentaries

“Furtherance” Under CPL 722.23(2)(c)(ii) Requires More Than Mere Display When the Charged Offense Is Weapon Possession

Date: Jul 29, 2026

“Furtherance” Under CPL 722.23(2)(c)(ii) Requires More Than Mere Display When the Charged Offense Is Weapon Possession 1. Introduction People v. Neyshaliz M. V. (2026 NY Slip Op 04581 [4th Dept July...

People v. Wright: Tarasoff-Style “Public Peril” Disclosures Do Not Authorize Later Trial Testimony; Physician–Patient Privilege Reattaches Once Exigency Ends

Date: Jul 29, 2026

People v. Wright: Tarasoff-Style “Public Peril” Disclosures Do Not Authorize Later Trial Testimony; Physician–Patient Privilege Reattaches Once Exigency Ends Court: Appellate Division, Fourth...

People v. Bentley: Orders of Protection Must State a CPL 530.13-Compliant Expiration Date and May Not Exceed Eight Years Beyond the Maximum Prison Term Expiration

Date: Jul 29, 2026

People v. Bentley: Orders of Protection Must State a CPL 530.13-Compliant Expiration Date and May Not Exceed Eight Years Beyond the Maximum Prison Term Expiration 1. Introduction In People v Bentley...

CPLR 213-c Extends the Limitations Period Without Creating Penal Law Civil Claims; “Physically Helpless” May Include Conscious Incapacity to Communicate Nonconsent

Date: Jul 29, 2026

CPLR 213-c Extends the Limitations Period Without Creating Penal Law Civil Claims; “Physically Helpless” May Include Conscious Incapacity to Communicate Nonconsent 1. Introduction In Gianna T. D. v...

Edwards v. Singer — Sequelae of Known Injuries Do Not Establish Mutual Mistake to Void a Broad Personal-Injury Release on a CPLR 3211(a)(5) Motion

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Edwards v. Singer — Sequelae of Known Injuries Do Not Establish Mutual Mistake to Void a Broad Personal-Injury Release on a CPLR 3211(a)(5) Motion 1. Introduction In Edwards v Singer (2026 NY Slip Op...

Summary Judgment on a Personal Guaranty Requires Proof of the Specific “Guaranteed Obligations” in a Revenue Purchase Agreement

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Summary Judgment on a Personal Guaranty Requires Proof of the Specific “Guaranteed Obligations” in a Revenue Purchase Agreement Case: EBF Holdings, LLC v Defiant Arms, L.L.C. (2026 NY Slip Op 04563,...

“Along” Is Not “Within”: Highway Law § 349-e Does Not Plainly Alienate Humboldt Parkway Parkland, and Green Amendment Claims May Proceed Based on Ongoing Expressway Operations

Date: Jul 29, 2026

“Along” Is Not “Within”: Highway Law § 349-e Does Not Plainly Alienate Humboldt Parkway Parkland, and Green Amendment Claims May Proceed Based on Ongoing Expressway Operations I. Introduction East...

People v. Cooper — Minimal Inquiry Requires a Fair Opportunity to Be Heard Before Denying Substitute Counsel

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Minimal Inquiry Requires a Fair Opportunity to Be Heard Before Denying Substitute Counsel Introduction In People v Cooper (2026 NY Slip Op 04561 [1st Dept July 23, 2026]), the Appellate Division,...

Post-Roberts J-51 Deregulations: Totality-of-Circumstances Fraud Can Be Resolved on Summary Judgment; Pre-Roberts Requires Trial Where Intent Is Disputed

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Post-Roberts J-51 Deregulations: Totality-of-Circumstances Fraud Can Be Resolved on Summary Judgment; Pre-Roberts Requires Trial Where Intent Is Disputed Case: Najera-Ordonez v. 260 Partners L.P.,...

Matter of Lemoine: Reciprocal Disbarment and “Venal Intent” for Misuse of Escrowed Client/Third-Party Funds

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Matter of Lemoine: Reciprocal Disbarment and “Venal Intent” for Misuse of Escrowed Client/Third-Party Funds Court: Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, New York, First Department (Per Curiam)...

Denemark v New Chapter Capital, Inc.: When “Litigation Funding” Becomes a Usurious Loan

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Denemark v New Chapter Capital, Inc.: Litigation Funding Is a Usurious Loan When Repayment Is Effectively Guaranteed (Security Interest, Escrow Controls, and “Trigger” Guaranties) 1. Introduction In...

Home Improvement Contracts: Noncompliance with GBL § 771 Not Per Se Unenforceable; Written Change-Order Clauses May Be Waived by Conduct; Owner Credits Must Offset Extra Costs

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Home Improvement Contracts: Noncompliance with GBL § 771 Not Per Se Unenforceable; Written Change-Order Clauses May Be Waived by Conduct; Owner Credits Must Offset Extra Costs 1. Introduction P.E....

Tax Regulation Challenges Are Unripe Before a Notice of Deficiency: Ripeness, Administrative Review, and Retroactivity Due Process in New York Franchise Tax Apportionment

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Tax Regulation Challenges Are Unripe Before a Notice of Deficiency: Ripeness, Administrative Review, and Retroactivity Due Process in New York Franchise Tax Apportionment 1. Introduction Matter of...

People v. Dacosta: A Vacated Plea Extinguishes Its Appeal Waiver; Police-Controlled Buys Can Supply Probable Cause Without a Darden Hearing

Date: Jul 25, 2026

People v. Dacosta: A Vacated Plea Extinguishes Its Appeal Waiver; Police-Controlled Buys Can Supply Probable Cause Without a Darden Hearing 1. Introduction In People v Dacosta (2026 NY Slip Op 04532...

Strategic Use of Uncharged Molineux Evidence and a Narrow Molineux Instruction Can Defeat Ineffective-Assistance Claims (People v Chauhan)

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Strategic Use of Uncharged Molineux Evidence and a Narrow Molineux Instruction Can Defeat Ineffective-Assistance Claims (People v Chauhan) 1. Introduction In People v Chauhan (2026 NY Slip Op 04531...

Contract Clauses that Eliminate All Judicial and Nonjudicial Review Are Void as Against Public Policy (Hochhauser v Urban Off. Architecture, PLLC)

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Contract Clauses that Eliminate All Judicial and Nonjudicial Review Are Void as Against Public Policy 1. Introduction Hochhauser v Urban Off. Architecture, PLLC (2026 NY Slip Op 04491 [2d Dept 2026])...

Municipal Bid Specifications May Require DOL-Approved Apprenticeships With Graduation-Rate Thresholds for High-Value Public Works Without Preemption

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Municipal Bid Specifications May Require DOL-Approved Apprenticeships With Graduation-Rate Thresholds for High-Value Public Works Without Preemption 1. Introduction In Matter of Peckham Rd. Corp. v....

Lusk v. McNamee: Contemporaneous Deed–Contract–Note Read as One; Extrinsic Emails Resolve Ambiguity and Prior Holdover Notice Can Satisfy Ejectment Notice-to-Quit

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Lusk v. McNamee: Contemporaneous Deed–Contract–Note Read as One; Extrinsic Emails Resolve Ambiguity and Prior Holdover Notice Can Satisfy Ejectment Notice-to-Quit Case: Lusk v McNamee, 2026 NY Slip...

Violation Petitions Must Allege Post–Order Conduct; Consent Orders of Protection Are Not Modifiable Under Family Ct Act § 844 Absent a Dispositional Hearing

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Violation Petitions Must Allege Post–Order Conduct; Consent Orders of Protection Are Not Modifiable Under Family Ct Act § 844 Absent a Dispositional Hearing Case: Matter of King v. King, 2026 NY Slip...

RPAPL 1304 Strict-Compliance Requires the Statutory Notice Language in Effect When the Foreclosure Is Commenced

Date: Jul 25, 2026

RPAPL 1304 Strict-Compliance Requires the Statutory Notice Language in Effect When the Foreclosure Is Commenced 1. Introduction Case: Bank of Am., N.A. v Thomas, 2026 NY Slip Op 04485 (App Div, 2d...