Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Criminal Conspiracy Cannot Be Proved by Weak Motive, Post-Occurrence Calls, or Inadmissible Disclosure Alone

Date: May 21, 2026

Criminal Conspiracy Cannot Be Proved by Weak Motive, Post-Occurrence Calls, or Inadmissible Disclosure Alone 1. Introduction In Pulkit @ Monu v. The State of Madhya Pradesh, the Supreme Court of...

Illegal Sentences Below Statutory Minimum May Be Corrected Despite Bar on Enhancement in an Accused’s Appeal

Date: May 21, 2026

Illegal Sentences Below Statutory Minimum May Be Corrected Despite Bar on Enhancement in an Accused’s Appeal Introduction In KARAN CHETTRI v. STATE OF SIKKIM, 2026 INSC 659, the Supreme Court of...

Strict-Liability Penalty for Non-Demonstration of Declared Capability: “Gaming” Distinct from Grid-Code Misdeclaration

Date: May 20, 2026

Strict-Liability Penalty for Non-Demonstration of Declared Capability: “Gaming” Distinct from Grid-Code Misdeclaration Case: PUNJAB STATE POWER CORPORATION LIMITED v. TALWANDI SABO POWER LIMITED...

Limits of Bail Jurisdiction under Section 483 BNSS: High Courts Cannot Issue Systemic Administrative Directions While Deciding Bail

Date: May 20, 2026

Limits of Bail Jurisdiction under Section 483 BNSS: High Courts Cannot Issue Systemic Administrative Directions While Deciding Bail Case: Rambalak v. State of U.P. (2026 INSC 511) Court: Supreme...

Crime-Scene Re-enactment Is Not Per Se Self-Incrimination: Article 20(3) Limits, Electronic-Evidence Proof, and Appellate Restraint in Reversing Trial Findings

Date: May 20, 2026

Crime-Scene Re-enactment Is Not Per Se Self-Incrimination: Article 20(3) Limits, Electronic-Evidence Proof, and Appellate Restraint in Reversing Trial Findings Case: THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU v....

Post-Repeal Invalidity of Old-Act Posting Changes: Section 31 Savings Do Not Revive Section 13(4) Powers or Old Panels

Date: May 20, 2026

Post-Repeal Invalidity of Old-Act Posting Changes: Section 31 Savings Do Not Revive Section 13(4) Powers or Old Panels 1) Introduction Case: MANOJ KUMAR RAWAT v. STATE OF UP & ORS. (Supreme Court of...

Institutional Premises Excluded from “Re-Release” under ABC Rules, 2023: Article 21-Driven Stray Dog Removal, SOP Validity, and Feeder/Carer Tort Liability

Date: May 20, 2026

Institutional Premises Excluded from “Re-Release” under ABC Rules, 2023: Article 21-Driven Stray Dog Removal, SOP Validity, and Feeder/Carer Tort Liability Court: Supreme Court of India Date:...

Overqualification and Suppression of Educational Credentials Can Void Public Employment Where Maximum Qualification Is Prescribed

Date: May 20, 2026

Overqualification and Suppression of Educational Credentials Can Void Public Employment Where Maximum Qualification Is Prescribed 1. Introduction In GENERAL MANAGER (HR) v. K POOVARASAN, 2026 INSC...

Partition Decree with Built-in Sale/Mesne-Profits Directions is Partly Final and Executable Without a Fresh Final-Decree Application

Date: May 19, 2026

Partition Decree with Built-in Sale/Mesne-Profits Directions is Partly Final and Executable Without a Fresh Final-Decree Application 1. Introduction In JENNIFER MESSIAS v. LEONARD G LOBO (Supreme...

Article 21 “Melts Down” Section 43-D(5) UAPA in Prolonged Incarceration: K.A. Najeeb as Binding Stare Decisis and the Impermissibility of Smaller-Bench Dilution

Date: May 19, 2026

Article 21 “Melts Down” Section 43-D(5) UAPA in Prolonged Incarceration: K.A. Najeeb as Binding Stare Decisis and the Impermissibility of Smaller-Bench Dilution 1. Introduction In SYED IFTIKHAR...

Executive Instructions Give No Enforceable Right Once Article 309 Rules Supersede: “Things Done” Saving Clause Does Not Preserve an Unheld DPC

Date: May 19, 2026

Executive Instructions Give No Enforceable Right Once Article 309 Rules Supersede: “Things Done” Saving Clause Does Not Preserve an Unheld DPC 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India, in STATE OF...

Res Judicata Bars Repeat Order VII Rule 11 Attempts; Section 6(5) HSA Is a Saving Clause—Section 8 Rights of Daughters Survive

Date: May 16, 2026

Res Judicata Bars Repeat Order VII Rule 11 Attempts; Section 6(5) HSA Is a Saving Clause—Section 8 Rights of Daughters Survive Case: B.S. LALITHA v. BHUVANESH (2026 INSC 499) Court: Supreme Court of...

Mediclaim Reimbursement Not Deductible from MACT Medical Expenses: Contractual Benefit Independent of MV Act Compensation

Date: May 16, 2026

Mediclaim Reimbursement Not Deductible from MACT Medical Expenses: Contractual Benefit Independent of MV Act Compensation Case: THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v. DOLLY SATISH GANDHI & ANR....

Pleadings vs Proof in Rent-Eviction: Substance over Form, Co-owner as “Landlord”, and Limited Appellate Revival of Pleading Objections

Date: May 16, 2026

Pleadings vs Proof in Rent-Eviction: Substance over Form, Co-owner as “Landlord”, and Limited Appellate Revival of Pleading Objections Case: MARIETTA D SILVA v. RUDOLF CLOTHAN LACERDA & ORS. (2026...

Reasoned Concurrence Requirement in CBI-Investigated Remission: Non-Speaking MHA Rejection Quashed; Court May Grant Premature Release Without Remand

Date: May 16, 2026

Reasoned Concurrence Requirement in CBI-Investigated Remission: Non-Speaking MHA Rejection Quashed; Court May Grant Premature Release Without Remand 1. Introduction In ROHIT CHATURVEDI v. STATE OF...

Co-mingled Pipeline Gas is an Inter-State Sale: Explanation 3 to Section 3 CST Act is Clarificatory (Retrospective) and States Cannot Levy VAT

Date: May 16, 2026

Co-mingled Pipeline Gas is an Inter-State Sale: Explanation 3 to Section 3 CST Act is Clarificatory (Retrospective) and States Cannot Levy VAT 1. Introduction This Supreme Court decision (15 May...

Stamp-Duty Guideline Value as the Statutory Baseline in NH Act Acquisitions: Single, Dissimilar Sale Exemplar as “Patent Illegality”

Date: May 16, 2026

Stamp-Duty Guideline Value as the Statutory Baseline in NH Act Acquisitions: Single, Dissimilar Sale Exemplar as “Patent Illegality” 1. Introduction This Supreme Court decision in Project Director...

Regulatory Securities as a Compensation Fund for Court-Ordered Student Relocation

Date: May 16, 2026

Regulatory Securities as a Compensation Fund for Court-Ordered Student Relocation: Equitable Fee Apportionment When a Medical College Defaults Case: SOUMYA RANJAN PANDA v. SUBHALAXMI DASH Citation:...

Hostile Witness Testimony Can Be Used to Acquit: Symmetric Use of Hostile Evidence and Collapse of Uncorroborated Medical Proof

Date: May 16, 2026

Hostile Witness Testimony Can Be Used to Acquit: Symmetric Use of Hostile Evidence and Collapse of Uncorroborated Medical Proof 1. Introduction In TALARI NARESH v. THE STATE OF TELANGANA (2026 INSC...

“Loan” Nomenclature Irrelevant: Money Advanced on Promise of Return With Interest Is a “Deposit” Under the MPID Act; MPID Remedy Independent of IPC Findings

Date: May 16, 2026

“Loan” Nomenclature Irrelevant: Money Advanced on Promise of Return With Interest Is a “Deposit” Under the MPID Act; MPID Remedy Independent of IPC Findings 1. Introduction In ALKA AGRAWAL v. STATE...