Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Professional Autonomy and Child Welfare Are Not “Cruelty” or “Desertion”: Expunging Patriarchal Findings and Deeming Divorce to Rest on Irretrievable Breakdown

Date: May 16, 2026

Professional Autonomy and Child Welfare Are Not “Cruelty” or “Desertion”: Expunging Patriarchal Findings and Deeming Divorce to Rest on Irretrievable Breakdown 1) Introduction Case: ANN SAURABH DUTT...

Billing/Record-Supply Grievances Against Hospitals Are Not Per Se “Criminal Offences”: Section 482 CrPC Quashing Where IPC Ingredients and 2017 Act “Offence” Are Not Pleaded

Date: May 15, 2026

Billing/Record-Supply Grievances Against Hospitals Are Not Per Se “Criminal Offences”: Section 482 CrPC Quashing Where IPC Ingredients and 2017 Act “Offence” Are Not Pleaded Case: NARAYANA HEALTH v....

Regulation 10 “May” Is Directory: No Employee Right to Insist on Common Disciplinary Proceedings

Date: May 15, 2026

Regulation 10 “May” Is Directory: No Employee Right to Insist on Common Disciplinary Proceedings 1. Introduction In CANARA BANK v. PREM LATHA UPPAL (DEAD) (2026 INSC 478, decided on 12-05-2026), the...

Revenue-Sharing in AOP Agreements Creates an Overriding Title: Upfront Gross-Receipt Share Taxable in Member’s Hands; Reassessment Valid on Post-Assessment Tangible Material

Date: May 15, 2026

Revenue-Sharing in AOP Agreements Creates an Overriding Title: Upfront Gross-Receipt Share Taxable in Member’s Hands; Reassessment Valid on Post-Assessment Tangible Material Case: SANAND PROPERTIES...

Finality of the Digitally Signed Supreme Court Order and Strict Maintainability Limits for Post‑Disposal Miscellaneous Applications

Date: May 15, 2026

Finality of the Digitally Signed Supreme Court Order and Strict Maintainability Limits for Post‑Disposal Miscellaneous Applications Case: FAKIR MAMAD SULEMAN SAMEJA v. ADANI PROTS AND SPECIAL...

State Duty to Frame a Time-Bound Mother-Tongue Education Policy and Introduce Rajasthani as a School Subject (Non–Eighth Schedule Status No Defence)

Date: May 15, 2026

State Duty to Frame a Time-Bound Mother-Tongue Education Policy and Introduce Rajasthani as a School Subject (Non–Eighth Schedule Status No Defence) 1. Introduction In PADAM MEHTA v. THE STATE OF...

“Public View” as a Sine Qua Non for SC/ST Act Charges: FIR/Charge-sheet Liable to Be Quashed Where the Foundational Ingredient Is Absent

Date: May 12, 2026

“Public View” as a Sine Qua Non for SC/ST Act Charges: FIR/Charge-sheet Liable to Be Quashed Where the Foundational Ingredient Is Absent 1. Introduction In GUNJAN @ GIRIJA KUMARI v. STATE (NCT OF...

Recounting Must Be Ordered as an Interim Direction in Panchayat Election Petitions; a “Petition Allowed + Recount” Order Renders the Authority Functus Officio

Date: May 12, 2026

Recounting Must Be an Interim Direction in Panchayat Election Petitions; a “Petition Allowed + Recount” Order Renders the Prescribed Authority Functus Officio Case: Urmila Devi v. The State of Uttar...

Conviction Can Rest on Reliable Oral Dying Declaration Corroborated by a Sterling Witness Despite Hostile Witnesses

Date: May 12, 2026

Conviction Can Rest on Reliable Oral Dying Declaration Corroborated by a Sterling Witness Despite Hostile Witnesses 1. Introduction Case: Mitesh @ T.V. Vaghela v. The State of Gujarat (2026 INSC...

Article 142 “Forgiveness-with-Vigil” in Criminal Contempt: Indefinite Suspension of Conviction with Periodic High Court Review

Date: May 12, 2026

Article 142 “Forgiveness-with-Vigil” in Criminal Contempt: Indefinite Suspension of Conviction with Periodic High Court Review Case: Yatin Narendra Oza v. Suo Motu, High Court of Gujarat, 2026 INSC...

Departmental Fraud in Police Recruitment: “Some Evidence” Suffices; High Courts Cannot Reappreciate Facts, and Article 142 May Quash a Parallel Fraudulent Appointment

Date: May 9, 2026

Departmental Fraud in Police Recruitment: “Some Evidence” Suffices; High Courts Cannot Reappreciate Facts, and Article 142 May Quash a Parallel Fraudulent Appointment Case: THE STATE OF JHARKHAND v....

MANJULA v. D.A. SRINIVAS (2026 INSC 465) — Commentary

Date: May 9, 2026

Direct Confiscation Consequence After Final Judicial Declaration of a Benami Transaction & Retroactive Reach of the 2016 Benami Machinery Provisions Case: MANJULA AND OTHERS v. D.A. SRINIVAS...

Indian Railways’ Captive Traction Network Is Not “Distribution”: Open-Access Procurement Attracts Cross-Subsidy & Additional Surcharge

Date: May 9, 2026

Indian Railways’ Captive Traction Network Is Not “Distribution”: Open-Access Procurement Attracts Cross-Subsidy & Additional Surcharge 1. Introduction This Supreme Court decision in INDIAN RAILWAYS...

State as Model Employer: Final, Unchallenged Service Tribunal Orders Must Be Implemented Despite Delay—Suppression Sanctioned by Denial of Interest

Date: May 9, 2026

State as Model Employer: Final, Unchallenged Service Tribunal Orders Must Be Implemented Despite Delay—Suppression Sanctioned by Denial of Interest Court: Supreme Court of India Date: 08 May 2026...

No Automatic Rescission of a Specific Performance Decree for Delay in Deposit; Equity-Based Section 28 Discretion and Procedure

Date: May 8, 2026

No Automatic Rescission of a Specific Performance Decree for Delay in Deposit; Equity-Based Section 28 Discretion and “Same Suit” Procedure 1) Introduction Case: ANAND NARAYAN SHUKLA v. JAGAT DHARI...

IBC Section 7 Cannot Be Invoked as Recovery Tool Where Bank’s Disbursement Is Intertwined with Builder Obligations Under a Quadripartite Property Transaction

Date: May 8, 2026

IBC Section 7 Cannot Be Invoked as Recovery Tool Where Bank’s Disbursement Is Intertwined with Builder Obligations Under a Quadripartite Property Transaction Case: DHANLAXMI BANK LTD. v. MOHAMMED...

Depreciation Recovery in Electricity Tariff is Limited to the Commission-Approved Supply Period (Not the Asset’s Technical Useful Life)

Date: May 8, 2026

Depreciation Recovery in Electricity Tariff is Limited to the Commission-Approved Supply Period (Not the Asset’s Technical Useful Life) Case: DELHI ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION v. TATA POWER...

Mere Non-Communication Without Cogent Proof Is Not Cruelty Under Section 498A IPC

Date: May 8, 2026

Mere Non-Communication Without Cogent Proof Is Not Cruelty Under Section 498A IPC Introduction In Jayesh Kanna v. The Assistant Commissioner Law and Order (West), the Supreme Court of India...

Section 36(1)(iii): Interest Deduction Allowed Where Borrowed Funds Are Routed Through a Group Entity on Grounds of Commercial Expediency

Date: May 8, 2026

Section 36(1)(iii): Interest Deduction Allowed Where Borrowed Funds Are Routed Through a Group Entity on Grounds of Commercial Expediency Case: L.K. TRUST v. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (2026 INSC...

Geo-Tagging Conditions in Public Tenders Cannot Be Used to Arbitrarily Disqualify Genuine Bidders

Date: May 8, 2026

Geo-Tagging Conditions in Public Tenders Cannot Be Used to Arbitrarily Disqualify Genuine Bidders 1. Introduction In VIDYASAGAR VIJAYKUMAR KAMBOJ v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, 2026 INSC 697, the...