Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Nomination by Incumbent Sajjadanashin Through Khilafatnama Prevails Over Rival Claims Based on Power of Attorney or Management

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Nomination by Incumbent Sajjadanashin Through Khilafatnama Prevails Over Rival Claims Based on Power of Attorney or Management Introduction In SYED MOHAMMED GHOUSE PASHA KHADRI v. SYED MOHAMMED ADIL...

Termination and Blacklisting Are Distinct: Blacklisting Requires Specific Notice, Independent Application of Mind and Natural Justice

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Termination and Blacklisting Are Distinct: Blacklisting Requires Specific Notice, Independent Application of Mind and Natural Justice Introduction In M/S A. K. G. CONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD...

Mandatory Oral Enquiry and Proof by Witnesses in Cooperative Society Disciplinary Proceedings Unless Clear Admission

Date: Apr 2, 2026

Mandatory Oral Enquiry and Proof by Witnesses in Cooperative Society Disciplinary Proceedings Unless Clear Admission Introduction In Jai Prakash Saini v. Managing Director, U.P. Cooperative...

Section 37A FEMA “Non-Confirmation” Must Be Appellately Settled Before Section 16 Adjudication Proceeds

Date: Apr 2, 2026

Section 37A FEMA “Non-Confirmation” Must Be Appellately Settled Before Section 16 Adjudication Proceeds Introduction This Supreme Court decision in J. Sri Nisha v. The Special Director, Adjudicating...

Conditional Bail Premised on Investor Settlement: Non-Compliance Cancels Bail and Triggers Forfeiture (Grand Venice Project)

Date: Apr 2, 2026

Conditional Bail Premised on Investor Settlement: Non-Compliance Cancels Bail and Triggers Forfeiture (Grand Venice Project) Case: SATINDER SINGH BHASIN v. GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI (2026 INSC 310)...

Second Section 11 Petition Barred After Abandonment: Order 23 Rule 1 CPC Principles Apply to Arbitration Appointment Proceedings

Date: Apr 2, 2026

Second Section 11 Petition Barred After Abandonment: Order 23 Rule 1 CPC Principles Apply to Arbitration Appointment Proceedings 1. Introduction Case: RAJIV GADDH v. SUBODH PARKASH (Supreme Court of...

Section 197 CrPC Sanction Is Tested at the Date of Cognizance: Later Section 197(3) Notifications Do Not Invalidate Earlier Cognizance

Date: Apr 2, 2026

Section 197 CrPC Sanction Is Tested at the Date of Cognizance: Later Section 197(3) Notifications Do Not Invalidate Earlier Cognizance 1. Introduction Case: Samarendra Nath Kundu v. Sadhana Das, 2026...

Judicial Restraint in QCBS Tenders: Courts Should Not Substitute the Owner’s Choice on Marginal Scoring Differences Absent Mala Fides/Arbitrariness

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Judicial Restraint in QCBS Tenders: Courts Should Not Substitute the Owner’s Choice on Marginal Scoring Differences Absent Mala Fides/Arbitrariness 1. Introduction STEAG ENERGY SERVICES (INDIA) PVT....

Withdrawal of Statutory Tax Exemptions Requires Reasonable Transitional Notice: Section 5A Bombay Electricity Duty Act

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Withdrawal of Statutory Tax Exemptions Requires Reasonable Transitional Notice: Section 5A Bombay Electricity Duty Act 1. Introduction The State of Maharashtra v. Reliance Industries Ltd. (2026 INSC...

Finality of Supreme Court Eviction Orders: Rent Authority Recall/Restoration Without Jurisdiction Is Void and Undermines Judicial Discipline

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Finality of Supreme Court Eviction Orders: Rent Authority Recall/Restoration Without Jurisdiction Is Void and Undermines Judicial Discipline 1. Introduction Rajesh Goyal v. M/S Laxmi Constructions &...

Unsigned/Defective Charge Does Not Mandate De Novo Trial Absent Prejudice: Substantial Compliance Under Sections 215 & 464 CrPC

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Unsigned/Defective Charge Does Not Mandate De Novo Trial Absent Prejudice: Substantial Compliance Under Sections 215 & 464 CrPC 1. Introduction Case: Sandeep Yadav v. Satish & Others (2026 INSC 301),...

Section 28-A Re-determination Must Follow the Final Appellate Award: Second Application Maintainable on High Court/Supreme Court Enhancement

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Section 28-A Re-determination Must Follow the Final Appellate Award: Second Application Maintainable on High Court/Supreme Court Enhancement 1. Introduction ANDANAYYA AND ORS. v. DEPUTY CHIEF...

Plenary Tariff Jurisdiction of SERCs, but Renewable “Generation Based Incentive” Must Remain Over-and-Above Tariff Unless Purposively Integrated

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Plenary Tariff Jurisdiction of SERCs, but Renewable “Generation Based Incentive” Must Remain Over-and-Above Tariff Unless Purposively Integrated I. Introduction In SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY...

Abandonment of Prior Title-Challenge Suits Bars Dispossession of Third Parties Through Execution Despite No Res Judicata

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Abandonment of Prior Title-Challenge Suits Bars Dispossession of Third Parties Through Execution Despite No Res Judicata Case: SHARADA SANGHI v. ASHA AGARWAL Citation: 2026 INSC 292 Court: Supreme...

NHAI v. Tarsem Singh (2026): Cut-off (28.03.2008) and Delay-Based Denial of Interest for NH Act Solatium Claims; Finality Protected

Date: Mar 26, 2026

NHAI v. Tarsem Singh (2026): Cut-off (28.03.2008) and Delay-Based Denial of Interest for NH Act Solatium Claims; Finality Protected 1. Introduction In NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA v. TARSEM...

Strict Enforcement of Section 228-A IPC Anonymity and the Primacy of Credible Child-Victim Testimony over Peripheral “Improbabilities”

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Strict Enforcement of Section 228-A IPC Anonymity and the Primacy of Credible Child-Victim Testimony over Peripheral “Improbabilities” 1. Introduction Case: THE STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH v. HUKAM...

State Cannot Impose Arbitration on Municipal Octroi Contracts Without a Valid Arbitration Agreement

Date: Mar 25, 2026

State Cannot Impose Arbitration on Municipal Octroi Contracts Without a Valid Arbitration Agreement 1. Introduction Case: M/S. BHARAT UDYOG LTD. (FORMERLY KNOWN AS M/S. JAI HIND CONTRACTORS PVT....

DSC Second-Service Pension: Mandatory Half‑Year Reckoning First, Then One‑Year Condonation; Executive Letters Cannot Override Pension Regulations

Date: Mar 25, 2026

DSC Second-Service Pension: Mandatory Half‑Year Reckoning First, Then One‑Year Condonation; Executive Letters Cannot Override Pension Regulations 1. Introduction Union of India & Ors. v. Balakrishnan...

“Excepted Matters” Cannot Exclude Justice: Finality/No-Arbitration Clauses in Government Contracts Apply Only to Quantification Where Liability is Admitted

Date: Mar 25, 2026

“Excepted Matters” Cannot Exclude Justice: Finality/No-Arbitration Clauses in Government Contracts Apply Only to Quantification Where Liability is Admitted 1. Introduction The Supreme Court in M/s....

ACRs Written Under a “No-PC” Regime Cannot Be Used to Deny Later PC; One-Time Deemed 20-Year Pension & Mandatory Transparency for IAF SSCO PC Boards

Date: Mar 25, 2026

ACRs Written Under a “No-PC” Regime Cannot Be Used to Deny Later PC; One-Time Deemed 20-Year Pension & Mandatory Transparency for IAF SSCO PC Boards Court: Supreme Court of India Date: 24-03-2026...