All High Courts Case Commentaries

Higher-Post Pay Requires Formal Charge/Appointment: “Equal Pay for Equal Work” Cannot Grant an Individual the Pay of an Unheld Post

Date: Jul 2, 2026

Higher-Post Pay Requires Formal Charge/Appointment: “Equal Pay for Equal Work” Cannot Grant an Individual the Pay of an Unheld Post Case: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC CO-OPERATION & CHILD DEVELOPMENT...

Prospective Operation of University Tenure Statutes: No Retrospective Conversion of a Substantive Director Appointment

Date: Jul 2, 2026

Prospective Operation of University Tenure Statutes: No Retrospective Conversion of a Substantive Director Appointment Case: Dr. Ravindra Kumar Sohane v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court...

Injured Informant’s Testimony Can Sustain Section 323/34 IPC Conviction Despite Hostile Witness and Prior Enmity; Section 307 Requires Proof of Intention/Knowledge

Date: Jul 2, 2026

Injured Informant’s Testimony Can Sustain Section 323/34 IPC Conviction Despite Hostile Witness and Prior Enmity; Section 307 Requires Proof of Intention/Knowledge 1. Introduction The Patna High...

Minority Aided Schools: DoE Cannot Withhold Grant-in-Aid Over Marking-Scheme Disputes Absent Qualification Defects

Date: Jul 2, 2026

Minority Aided Schools: DoE Cannot Withhold Grant-in-Aid Over Marking-Scheme Disputes Absent Qualification Defects 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court in St Anthonys BOYS SECONDARY SCHOOL v....

MACP Parity Across Administrative Bifurcation and the Bar on Supplementing Reasons by Affidavit

Date: Jul 2, 2026

MACP Parity Across Administrative Bifurcation and the Bar on Supplementing Reasons by Affidavit 1. Introduction The Jharkhand High Court (Deepak Roshan, J.) in SHAILESH KUMAR SINGH v. THE STATE OF...

Equivalence of Civil Posts in Survey of India Does Not Confer Automatic Substantive Army Rank; Army Promotion Norms (Including Medical Standards) Prevail

Date: Jul 2, 2026

Equivalence of Civil Posts in Survey of India Does Not Confer Automatic Substantive Army Rank; Army Promotion Norms (Including Medical Standards) Prevail Case: UNION OF INDIA & ORS. v. COL AMARDEEP...

MACPS Upgradation Limited to Next Higher Grade Pay: Policy Deference and Article 14 Limits

Date: Jul 2, 2026

MACPS Upgradation Limited to Next Higher Grade Pay: Policy Deference and Article 14 Limits 1. Introduction In RAM NARESH TIWARI AND ORS v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS (Delhi High Court, decided on...

Interim Relief Cannot Be Granted to Effectively Suspend Operational Service Rules Pending AFT Adjudication

Date: Jul 1, 2026

Interim Relief Cannot Be Granted to Effectively Suspend Operational Service Rules Pending AFT Adjudication 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court, in MAJOR JAYATI CHANDRA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS....

High Threshold for Writ Interference in Sports Selections: MER Criteria Must Be Applied as Written; Post-Selection Bias Objections Can Be Waived

Date: Jun 30, 2026

High Threshold for Writ Interference in Sports Selections: MER Criteria Must Be Applied as Written; Post-Selection Bias Objections Can Be Waived 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court, in SUDIPTI...

Demand as Sine Qua Non in PC Act Traps: Recovery and Uncertified/Unverified Voice Recordings Cannot Sustain Conviction

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Demand as Sine Qua Non in PC Act Traps: Recovery and Uncertified/Unverified Voice Recordings Cannot Sustain Conviction 1. Introduction Case: Anil Markende v. State Of Chhattisgarh (2026 CGHC 25610),...

Suppression in Attestation Form: Probationer’s Termination Sustained Where Candidate Admits Criminal-Case Involvement Under an Alias

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Suppression in Attestation Form: Probationer’s Termination Sustained Where Candidate Admits Criminal-Case Involvement Under an Alias Case: UNION OF INDIA AND ORS v. GUJJUDI VARAPRASAD (Calcutta High...

Employees’ Statutory Gratuity Claims Are Not “Consumer” Disputes: Consumer Fora Lack Jurisdiction under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Employees’ Statutory Gratuity Claims Are Not “Consumer” Disputes: Consumer Fora Lack Jurisdiction under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 1. Introduction In THE TIRUR SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE BANK...

Prima Facie Life-Threat Standard for Court-Mandated Police Protection Despite Adverse Threat Assessments (Madras HC, 29.06.2026)

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Prima Facie Life-Threat Standard for Court-Mandated Police Protection Despite Adverse Threat Assessments Case: C.VE.SHANMUGAM B.A.B.L., v. THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU Court: Madras High Court Coram:...

PILs Challenging Tariff-Based Competitive Bidding and Power-Project Policy Decisions Require Specific, Credible Material and Demonstrable Public-Spirited Standing

Date: Jun 30, 2026

PILs Challenging Tariff-Based Competitive Bidding and Power-Project Policy Decisions Require Specific, Credible Material and Demonstrable Public-Spirited Standing 1. Introduction Case: Anmol Kumar v....

Preventive Detention under the J&K Public Safety Act Requires Independent Application of Mind and Fact-Based Grounds (No “Borrowed Satisfaction” from a Police Dossier)

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Preventive Detention under the J&K Public Safety Act Requires Independent Application of Mind and Fact-Based Grounds (No “Borrowed Satisfaction” from a Police Dossier) 1. Introduction In FAYAZ AHMAD...

Public Interest Primacy in Challenges to Government Infrastructure Projects: Demarcation as the Immediate Remedy

Date: Jun 29, 2026

Public Interest Primacy in Challenges to Government Infrastructure Projects: Demarcation as the Immediate Remedy 1. Introduction In M/S Shri Rk Cold Storage And General Mils And 3 Others v. State Of...

Conviction Cannot Stand on Contradictory “Last Seen” Testimony and Uncorroborated Recovery; Trial Courts Must Not Shift Burden to the Defence

Date: Jun 27, 2026

Conviction Cannot Stand on Contradictory “Last Seen” Testimony and Uncorroborated Recovery; Trial Courts Must Not Shift Burden to the Defence 1. Introduction In BABU DAS v. STATE (Orissa High Court,...

Statutory Oath in Local Self-Government: “In the name of God” Means Exactly That—No Substitution or Expansion

Date: Jun 27, 2026

Statutory Oath in Local Self-Government: “In the name of God” Means Exactly That—No Substitution or Expansion 1. Introduction The Kerala High Court (P.V. Kunhikrishnan, J.) decided two connected writ...

Interim Child-Custody Orders: Overnight Custody Cannot Be Granted When the Court’s Own Findings Negate Readiness and No Compelling Change Is Shown

Date: Jun 26, 2026

Interim Child-Custody Orders: Overnight Custody Cannot Be Granted When the Court’s Own Findings Negate Readiness and No Compelling Change Is Shown 1. Introduction In DISHA GUPTA v. GAURAV BATRA (2026...

Transfer of Investigation under Section 528 BNSS for Biased/Defective Probe: Victim’s Article 21 Right to Fair Investigation

Date: Jun 26, 2026

Transfer of Investigation under Section 528 BNSS for Biased/Defective Probe: Victim’s Article 21 Right to Fair Investigation 1. Introduction Case: Jayaram Venkatesan v. The State of Tamilnadu Court:...