1. Introduction
In Martin v. State, the Delaware Supreme Court addressed when evidence of a perceived deadly threat entitles a criminal defendant to a self-defense instruction. The court held that even accepting the defendant’s account as true, an instruction was unwarranted because his own testimony established opportunities to retreat safely rather than use deadly force.
The court also rejected an unpreserved argument that due process required a separate instruction explaining the defendant’s theory of the case. Counsel had requested a self-defense instruction, not that alternative instruction, and the defendant had been permitted to present his account and supporting expert testimony.
The order principally applies existing Delaware statutes and precedents rather than announcing a new retreat obligation. Its significance lies in distinguishing a potentially believable account of danger from evidence that legally supports every requirement of self-defense.
Background and proceedings
Edward Martin shot and killed Arrick Richards during an argument at Coastal Taproom in Sussex County. The confrontation began around a pool table and escalated despite other patrons’ efforts to intervene. Surveillance footage captured Martin drawing a handgun and, with several people between the men, reaching over his wife and shooting Richards in the chest.
Martin testified that he believed Richards had a gun and was about to use it. After reviewing the surveillance recording, however, Martin acknowledged that Richards had been unarmed. He subsequently identified another patron, Mackenson Jean-Francois, known as “Mac,” as possessing a gun. Martin testified that Mac showed him the weapon but did not threaten him with it.
The defense presented three experts: a retired police officer addressing civilian use of force and two forensic psychologists who testified that Martin reasonably believed himself endangered and acted under extreme emotional distress.
The State charged Martin with first-degree murder, four counts of first-degree reckless endangering, five counts of possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony, and carrying a concealed deadly weapon. After a ten-day trial, the jury convicted him of second-degree murder as a lesser-included offense and of all remaining charges. The Superior Court imposed 55 years of Level V incarceration.
Issues on appeal
- Whether Martin’s testimony and expert evidence required a jury instruction on self-defense.
- Whether refusing that instruction, without giving a separate theory-of-defense instruction, violated the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause.
3. Analysis
A. Statutory framework
Under 11 Del. C. § 464(c), deadly force is justifiable if the defendant reasonably believes it necessary to protect against death or serious physical injury. That authorization is subject to statutory restrictions.
As relevant here, § 464(e) excludes justification when:
- The defendant provoked the use of force in the same encounter with the purpose of causing death or serious physical injury; or
- The defendant knows that the necessity of using deadly force can be avoided with complete safety by retreating.
The retreat restriction was decisive. Although the order also mentioned provocation, it did not make a separate, developed finding that Martin satisfied the statutory purposeful-provocation exclusion. The holding should therefore not be reduced to a rule that anyone who participates in, or escalates, an argument necessarily forfeits self-defense.
Nor does the decision establish an unconditional requirement to retreat whenever an exit exists. The relevant statutory condition is knowledge that retreat can avoid the necessity for deadly force with complete safety. The court found that condition satisfied through Martin’s admissions and the circumstances shown in the record.
B. Precedents cited and their influence
Yocum v. State and Lunnon v. State: independent review of instructional entitlement
The court cited Yocum v. State, 777 A.2d 782, 784 (Del. 2001), which in turn cited Lunnon v. State, 710 A.2d 197, 199 (Del. 1998), for de novo review of the denial of a requested jury instruction.
These authorities supplied the appellate standard rather than the substantive self-defense rule. The Supreme Court independently assessed whether Martin’s evidence legally warranted the requested instruction. It did not merely defer to the trial judge’s conclusion.
Gutierrez v. State: credibility and legal sufficiency are distinct inquiries
Gutierrez v. State, 842 A.2d 650, 652–53 (Del. 2004), was the central substantive precedent. It requires a court considering a defense instruction to determine both whether the evidence describes a situation “within the realm of possibility” and whether that situation would legally satisfy the defense.
If both requirements are satisfied, the jury—not the judge—must decide which account is more believable or better supported by the evidence. In Gutierrez v. State, the defendant was entitled to a self-defense instruction because he presented credible evidence that a corrections officer threatened unlawful force against him.
Martin relied on that decision to argue that the Superior Court had improperly weighed his testimony and expert evidence. The Supreme Court avoided the disputed credibility inquiry. Even assuming Martin’s account was true, his acknowledged ability to retreat safely defeated legal entitlement to the instruction. Thus, Gutierrez v. State both protected the jury’s factfinding role and supplied the framework for withholding an instruction unsupported as a matter of law.
Ford v. State and Probst v. State: preservation of appellate claims
The court cited Ford v. State, 341 A.3d 454, 465 (Del. 2025), quoting its explanation that failure to object ordinarily forfeits appellate review unless the error is plain. Ford v. State relied on Probst v. State, 547 A.2d 114, 119 (Del. 1988). The court also invoked Supreme Court Rule 8.
These authorities mattered because Martin’s trial request for self-defense did not preserve the distinct argument that the Constitution and § 302(b) required an alternative theory-of-defense instruction. Consequently, that claim received only plain-error review.
Ushery v. State and Wainwright v. State: the plain-error threshold
Ushery v. State, 346 A.3d 621, 625 (Del. 2025), quoting Wainwright v. State, 504 A.2d 1096, 1100 (Del. 1986), supplied the governing standard: the claimed error must be so clearly prejudicial to substantial rights that it jeopardizes the fairness and integrity of the trial process.
This demanding threshold framed the constitutional analysis. Martin had to establish more than that another instruction might have been useful. The court found no due process violation, particularly because he presented his defense evidence and received the lesser-included-offense instructions he requested.
Perkins v. State: no general duty to instruct without a request
The court cited Perkins v. State, 920 A.2d 391, 400 (Del. 2007), for the proposition that the Superior Court had no affirmative duty to give the instruction at issue sua sponte—on its own initiative.
That principle supported rejecting the contention that the trial judge should have independently supplied an alternative instruction after properly refusing self-defense.
State v. Brower: party autonomy in selecting instructions
State v. Brower, 971 A.2d 102, 108, 110 (Del. 2009), reaffirmed Delaware’s party-autonomy rule in the context of unrequested lesser-included-offense instructions. Requiring judges to give such instructions independently would undermine the parties’ responsibility for shaping the case.
The court used this authority to reinforce its request-based approach to jury instructions. Although State v. Brower concerned lesser-included offenses, its broader relevance was that trial judges ordinarily need not reconstruct counsel’s instructional strategy.
Dordell v. State: potentially available affirmative defenses need not all be charged
Finally, Dordell v. State, 115 A.3d 1214, 2015 WL 2345579, at *2 (Del. May 15, 2015) (TABLE), stated that neither statute nor common law requires a trial court to instruct sua sponte on every potentially available affirmative defense.
This authority complemented Perkins v. State and State v. Brower. Together, they supported the conclusion that Martin’s unsuccessful request for one instruction did not obligate the court to formulate a different, unrequested instruction.
C. Why the self-defense evidence was legally insufficient
The key analytical step was to separate two questions:
- Could a juror believe Martin thought he faced a deadly threat?
- Even if so, would the circumstances he described authorize deadly force under Delaware law?
The court resolved the appeal on the second question. Martin admitted that he could have left earlier in the encounter, that clear paths to exits remained available, and that he could have withdrawn after producing his gun. He nevertheless leaned closer to Richards.
Importantly, the decision did not rest solely on a missed opportunity to leave before any threat developed. The court specifically relied on the continued opportunity to withdraw after Martin drew the weapon. That evidence connected the retreat analysis to the period immediately preceding the shooting.
The defense experts’ testimony did not eliminate this independent statutory obstacle. Evidence supporting fear or perceived danger cannot, by itself, establish justification where the defendant’s account also establishes a disqualifying opportunity for known, completely safe retreat.
D. What the court did not decide about credibility and expert testimony
The Superior Court had emphasized the absence of a reasonable perception of imminent harm and observed that Martin’s use-of-force expert could not affirmatively endorse shooting Richards. The Supreme Court, however, did not resolve whether Martin’s evidence was credible or whether his perceived threat was reasonable.
Accordingly, the order should not be read as requiring a use-of-force expert to approve a shooting before a defendant may obtain a self-defense instruction. Nor does it hold that shooting an actually unarmed person automatically defeats self-defense. The decisive point was the retreat restriction, even assuming Martin’s account of his perception.
E. Justification and evidence negating an offense are different
Martin’s constitutional argument invoked 11 Del. C. § 302(b). That provision permits a defendant to offer evidence tending to negate an element of an offense and, when a reasonable juror might believe it, provides for an instruction directing the jury to consider whether the evidence raises reasonable doubt.
This argument differed from self-defense. Justification concerns whether otherwise criminal force was legally permissible. Evidence negating an offense concerns whether the State proved a required element at all. Evidence of fear or emotional distress may remain relevant to the latter question even when a justification defense is unavailable.
The court did not treat the rejection of self-defense as making Martin’s evidence irrelevant. He testified, presented three experts, and obtained instructions on lesser offenses. The court instead rejected the proposition that, on this record and without a request, the trial judge was constitutionally required to formulate an additional theory-of-defense instruction.
The court viewed the second-degree murder verdict, rather than a first-degree murder conviction, as indicating that Martin’s theory had at least some effect on deliberations. That observation supported its fairness analysis, although it does not reveal precisely how the jury evaluated individual witnesses or pieces of evidence.
F. Potential impact
- Instructional disputes: Courts may assume the defense account is true and still deny an instruction when that account fails an independent statutory requirement.
- Retreat evidence: A defendant’s admissions about accessible exits, opportunities to withdraw, and movement toward an alleged threat can be decisive. Physical access to an exit alone, however, is not a substitute for the statutory inquiry into known, completely safe retreat.
- Expert evidence: Opinions about fear, danger, or emotional distress do not resolve every legal condition governing deadly force.
- Defense requests: Counsel should separately identify and request instructions on justification, evidence negating offense elements, and applicable lesser-included offenses, rather than assume one request preserves all related theories.
- Constitutional claims: The decision limits an unpreserved demand for an additional instruction in these circumstances; it does not categorically eliminate due process challenges to the omission of properly requested, legally supported defense instructions.