Procurement Irregularity Alone Cannot Criminalise Suppliers: Rejection of a Closure Report Requires Specific Inculpatory Material

Case: Ms Geeta Infotech Sales And Service Bhopal Proprietor Pankaj Soni v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh Through Economic Offenc Wing

Citation: 2026 MPHC-IND 25211

Court: Madhya Pradesh High Court, Indore Bench

Coram: Justice Subodh Abhyankar and Justice Alok Awasthi

Date: 21 September 2026

1. Introduction

This decision examines the limits of judicial supervision over a police closure report and the distinction between administrative procurement irregularities and criminal liability. The petitioners were contractors and suppliers implicated in the purchase of equipment and other materials worth approximately ₹96.23 lakh for Industrial Training Institutes in the Ujjain Division.

The Economic Offences Wing alleged that the purchases were made through limited tenders rather than open tenders, at rates higher than prevailing market prices, and from selected firms in violation of the Madhya Pradesh Store Purchase Rules and Financial Code. Crime No. 05/2017 was registered under Sections 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and Sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

After investigation, however, the investigating agency repeatedly submitted closure reports for want of sufficient evidence. The Special Judge declined to accept those reports and repeatedly ordered further investigation. The central question before the High Court was whether such rejection could be sustained without identifying specific material showing dishonest intention, conspiracy or conscious participation by the petitioners.

2. Factual and Procedural Background

  • A departmental communication dated 20 March 2015 sought investigation into alleged irregularities committed by S.M. Kumbhare, then Principal and In-charge Deputy Director, Regional Skill Development.
  • The allegation was that materials worth ₹96.23 lakh had been purchased through limited quotations instead of open tenders and that quotations had been obtained from connected firms.
  • The EOW registered Crime No. 05/2017 against departmental officers and several supplier firms, including the petitioners.
  • The first closure report was declined by the Special Judge on 27 October 2021, with directions for further investigation.
  • A subsequent closure report was again rejected on 17 May 2025, followed by another direction for further investigation.
  • In Criminal Revision No. 2719/2025, the High Court remanded the matter for reconsideration in light of Abhinandan Jha and Others v. Dinesh Mishra, AIR 1968 SC 117.
  • On 12 February 2026, the Special Judge once again rejected the closure report and ordered further investigation, substantially repeating the earlier grounds.
  • The petitioners challenged that order in the present criminal revision. A delay of 27 days was condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.

3. Summary of the Judgment

The High Court allowed the revision, set aside the Special Judge’s order dated 12 February 2026 and quashed consequential proceedings arising solely from that order.

The Court held that:

  1. Non-acceptance of a closure report does not itself establish that the allegations are proved or that sufficient material exists to prosecute the accused.
  2. A court may disagree with the police conclusion or direct further investigation, but it cannot compel the investigating agency to form a particular opinion or submit a charge-sheet.
  3. Departmental or procedural irregularities do not automatically create criminal liability for contractors or suppliers.
  4. Section 420 IPC requires fraudulent or dishonest intention from the inception of the transaction.
  5. Section 120-B IPC requires material showing an agreement or meeting of minds to commit an unlawful act.
  6. The impugned order disclosed no fresh material or specific act connecting the petitioners with cheating, conspiracy or corruption.
  7. Repeated directions for further investigation on substantially identical grounds could not justify the petitioners’ continued involvement in criminal proceedings.

4. Analysis

4.1 Precedent Cited

Abhinandan Jha and Others v. Dinesh Mishra, AIR 1968 SC 117

This Supreme Court decision formed the principal precedential basis of the High Court’s reasoning. It establishes that a Magistrate is not bound by the opinion expressed by the police in its final report. On receiving a closure report, the court may:

  • accept the report and close the proceedings;
  • disagree with the police opinion and proceed in accordance with law if the material supports such a course; or
  • direct further investigation where the circumstances warrant it.

At the same time, the court cannot direct the police to submit a charge-sheet or force the investigating officer to reach a particular conclusion. Investigation and the formation of an opinion on its result remain within the statutory domain of the investigating agency.

The High Court applied this principle to hold that judicial supervision cannot become judicial substitution. Although the Special Judge was entitled to reject the closure report, that power had to be exercised on identifiable material and through legally permissible options. Repeatedly sending the matter back for investigation on the same grounds, without fresh incriminating evidence, effectively pressured the agency toward a predetermined result.

4.2 Legal Reasoning

A. Rejection of a closure report is not proof of guilt

The Court drew an important distinction between declining to accept the investigating agency’s conclusion and affirmatively finding sufficient grounds for prosecution. A closure report may be rejected because the investigation is incomplete or because the court interprets the available material differently. That rejection does not, by itself, establish the ingredients of an offence.

B. Departmental irregularity and criminal misconduct are different

The case arose primarily from alleged violations of procurement rules, including the use of limited tenders, alleged overpricing and failure to follow prescribed purchase procedures. The Court held that these matters might justify departmental scrutiny against officials responsible for observing those rules. They could not automatically be attributed to suppliers merely because the suppliers participated in the transactions.

Criminal liability is personal. It requires material showing what each accused did, intended or agreed to do. The impugned order did not identify any representation, inducement, agreement, wrongful gain or conscious participation attributable to the petitioners.

C. Ingredients of cheating under Section 420 IPC

Cheating requires fraudulent or dishonest intention at the very beginning of the transaction. A subsequent breach, procedural defect or irregularity is insufficient unless evidence shows that deception was intended from the inception and that it induced delivery of property or caused legally recognised harm.

In the present case, no specific material showed that the petitioners supplied goods pursuant to an initially dishonest design or deceived the purchasing authorities.

D. Ingredients of conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC

Criminal conspiracy requires an agreement or meeting of minds to commit an illegal act, or to accomplish a lawful object by illegal means. Mere business dealings with public officials, participation in a tender process or association with a disputed transaction cannot substitute for evidence of such an agreement.

The Court found no material demonstrating that the petitioners had acted in concert with departmental officers to cause wrongful loss or obtain wrongful gain.

E. Absence of fresh evidence

Closure reports had been submitted on three occasions. The Special Judge’s latest order substantially repeated findings already made in the order dated 17 May 2025. No fresh evidence showing active participation by the petitioners was identified. This repetitive process weighed heavily in favour of intervention by the revisional court.

F. Scope of the relief

The High Court set aside the order dated 12 February 2026 and quashed consequential proceedings arising solely from that order. The judgment is therefore directed against continuation of the process on the existing, insufficient material; it does not create a general immunity for suppliers where concrete evidence of collusion, deception or corrupt participation exists.

5. Impact of the Judgment

  • Protection against criminalisation of contractual disputes: Suppliers cannot be prosecuted merely because the purchasing department failed to comply with procurement rules.
  • Requirement of accused-specific findings: Courts must identify the particular act, intention or agreement attributable to each private participant.
  • Limits on repeated further investigation: Successive directions cannot be made mechanically on substantially identical grounds without fresh or overlooked material.
  • Reasoned treatment of closure reports: A court disagreeing with a closure report must select a legally permissible course and explain the evidentiary basis for doing so.
  • No immunity for collusive suppliers: The decision does not prevent prosecution where evidence establishes inflated billing, false quotations, kickbacks, deception or a concerted arrangement with public officials.

6. Complex Concepts Simplified

Closure report or “Khatma report”
A police report stating that the investigation has not produced sufficient evidence to prosecute the accused.
Further investigation
Additional investigation ordered or undertaken after an earlier investigation, usually to examine missing evidence or unresolved issues.
Dishonest intention from inception
For cheating, the accused must have intended to deceive when the transaction began; later non-compliance alone is ordinarily insufficient.
Meeting of minds
An agreement between two or more persons to pursue an unlawful object or use unlawful means. It is the core of criminal conspiracy.
Departmental lapse
A breach of administrative or procedural rules by officials. It may lead to disciplinary consequences but does not necessarily amount to a criminal offence.
Criminal revision
A supervisory remedy through which a higher court examines whether a lower criminal court acted legally, correctly and within its jurisdiction.

7. Conclusion

The judgment affirms that procurement irregularity, supplier status and business association with public officials cannot replace proof of criminal intent or conspiracy. While a court is not bound by a police closure report, it cannot repeatedly reject that report in an effort to secure a particular investigative conclusion.

The controlling principle is that criminal proceedings against contractors or suppliers must rest on specific, accused-linked material showing deception, dishonest intention, agreement or conscious participation in corruption. In the absence of such material, administrative lapses cannot be transformed into criminal liability.