Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Execution Courts Cannot Enlarge a Final Service-Benefit Order

Date: Aug 12, 2026

Execution Courts Cannot Enlarge a Final Service-Benefit Order Beyond Its Express Terms Case: STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH v. JAMEET SINGH Citation: 2026 INSC 885 Court: Supreme Court of India Date: 11...

Ratification of Unauthorised Acceptance of Resignation Relates Back and Bars Later Withdrawal

Date: Aug 8, 2026

Ratification of Unauthorised Acceptance of Resignation Relates Back and Bars Later Withdrawal 1. Introduction In Delhi Technological University v. B.S. Rawat, 2026 INSC 797, the Supreme Court of...

Compulsory Retirement under FR 56(j): “Washed-Off Theory” Inapplicable to Retention Review

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Compulsory Retirement under FR 56(j): “Washed-Off Theory” Inapplicable to Retention Review Introduction In Sushil Sharma v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 809, the Supreme Court of India considered the...

Indivisible Turnkey Contracts Cannot Be Notionally Vivisected for Pre-2007 Service Tax under “Commissioning or Installation”

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Indivisible Turnkey Contracts Cannot Be Notionally Vivisected for Pre-2007 Service Tax under “Commissioning or Installation” 1. Introduction In COMMR.OF SERVICE TAX,CHENNAI v. M/S DIEBOLD SYSTEMS(P)...

Non-Stigmatic Discharge of a Probationary Teacher Holding an Unrecognised B.Ed. Requires No Futile Enquiry

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Non-Stigmatic Discharge of a Probationary Teacher Holding an Unrecognised B.Ed. Requires No Futile Enquiry; Later NCTE Recognition Has No Retrospective Effect Case: M/S BHARATIYA VIDYA BHAVAN'S...

Civil Courts Retain Jurisdiction in Scheduled Areas for Disputes Exclusively Between Non-Tribals

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Civil Courts Retain Jurisdiction in Scheduled Areas for Disputes Exclusively Between Non-Tribals Introduction In Mukkera Venkata Ratnam v. Vantasala China Venkateswarlu, the Supreme Court of India...

Kitting Imported Modules Is Not Manufacture Without Proof of Conversion into a New Marketable Article

Date: Aug 6, 2026

Kitting Imported Modules Is Not Manufacture Without Proof of Conversion into a New Marketable Article 1. Introduction In Commissioner of Central Excise, Hyderabad-IV v. M/s Xerox India Ltd. & Ors.,...

Proactive Condonation of Delay in Jail Appeals and the Duty to Scrutinize Sole-Eyewitness Convictions

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Proactive Condonation of Delay in Jail Appeals and the Duty to Scrutinize Sole-Eyewitness Convictions 1. Introduction In ARJUN JANI @ TUNTUN v. STATE OF ORISSA, the Supreme Court of India dealt with...

Subvention Scheme Under TMA Pai Interim Order Ends with Final Declaration of Unconstitutionality

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Subvention Scheme Under TMA Pai Interim Order Ends with Final Declaration of Unconstitutionality Introduction In GOVERNMENT OF INDIA v. SRI DEVRAJ URS MEDICAL COLLEGE, the Supreme Court considered...

Technology-Based Enforcement of Mandatory Motor Insurance and Standardised Four-Layer Motor Policy Disclosure

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Technology-Based Enforcement of Mandatory Motor Insurance and Standardised Four-Layer Motor Policy Disclosure 1. Introduction In NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v. SMT. THUNGALA DHANA LAXMI, the...

Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC Is a Court’s Clarificatory Power, Not a Party’s Tool to Fill Gaps in Evidence

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC Is a Court’s Clarificatory Power, Not a Party’s Tool to Fill Gaps in Evidence Introduction In K. Bharathamma v. Bandaru Sakku Bai, the Supreme Court of India examined the...

Admitted Cheque Signature Triggers Mandatory NI Act Presumptions; Revisional Courts Cannot Reappreciate Concurrent Convictions Absent Perversity

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Admitted Cheque Signature Triggers Mandatory NI Act Presumptions; Revisional Courts Cannot Reappreciate Concurrent Convictions Absent Perversity 1. Introduction In KUNTEGOWDA v. THURUBAIAH, 2026 INSC...

Section 498A IPC Extends to Marriage-like Live-in Relationships with Intent to Marry

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Section 498A IPC Extends to Marriage-like Live-in Relationships with Intent to Marry 1. Introduction In LOKESH B.H v. STATE OF KARNATAKA, the Supreme Court of India decided an important question:...

Revenue-Recorded Shamilat Deh Vests in Panchayat Despite Hasab Rasad and Makbuja Malkan Entries Unless Pre-1950 Partition and Individual Cultivation Are Proved

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Revenue-Recorded Shamilat Deh Vests in Panchayat Despite Hasab Rasad and Makbuja Malkan Entries Unless Pre-1950 Partition and Individual Cultivation Are Proved 1. Introduction In SURAJ BHAN v....

Catastrophically Disabled Child Victims Entitled to Compensation Based on 100% Functional Disability and Lifetime Care Needs

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Catastrophically Disabled Child Victims Entitled to Compensation Based on 100% Functional Disability and Lifetime Care Needs 1. Introduction In GAYATREE PATTNAIK FOR SHREEJITA PATTNAIK v. ARUNDHATI...

Registrar’s Power to Frame Cooperative Service Rules Includes Power to Amend or Delete Them; Legislative Laying Requirement Without Consequence Is Directory

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Registrar’s Power to Frame Cooperative Service Rules Includes Power to Amend or Delete Them; Legislative Laying Requirement Without Consequence Is Directory 1. Introduction In S.P. Chandrakar v....

Statutory Land Acquisition Benefits Are Compensation: Ad Valorem Court Fee Applies to Section 54 Appeals

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Statutory Land Acquisition Benefits Are Compensation: Ad Valorem Court Fee Applies to Section 54 Appeals 1. Introduction In TEHRI HYDRO DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD. v. S.P. SINGH, the Supreme Court...

Unproved Renewal of Driving Licence Breaches Policy: Insurer Entitled to Pay-and-Recover

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Unproved Renewal of Driving Licence Breaches Policy: Insurer Entitled to Pay-and-Recover Introduction In RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD v. OM PARKASH, the Supreme Court of India considered...

Perpetual Post-Facto Environmental Clearance by Executive Order Is Invalid; Narrow Time-Bound Amnesty by Statutory Notification May Be Permissible

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Perpetual Post-Facto Environmental Clearance by Executive Order Is Invalid; Narrow Time-Bound Amnesty by Statutory Notification May Be Permissible Introduction In Vanashakti v. Union of India, 2026...

Failed Joint Development Agreements: No Cheating or Criminal Breach of Trust Without Inception Mens Rea or Entrustment

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Failed Joint Development Agreements: No Cheating or Criminal Breach of Trust Without Inception Mens Rea or Entrustment Introduction In G. SAMINATHAN v. THE STATE REPRESENTED BY THE SUB INSPECTOR OF...