OTS Consideration Must Follow Correct NPA Dating and the Scheme’s Statutory-Auditor Rule
Case: M/S NANAL HYDRO POWER CONSULTANCY PVT LTD v. The Himachal Pradesh State Cooperative Bank
Citation: 2026:HHC:41428
Court: Himachal Pradesh High Court
Judge: Justice Sandeep Sharma
Decision: 25 September 2026
Proceeding: CWP No. 11392 of 2026
1. Introduction
This judgment concerns the relationship between mandatory banking classifications and a borrower’s consideration under a bank’s One Time Settlement (“OTS”) scheme. The unusual feature was that the borrower sought an earlier date of classification as a non-performing asset (“NPA”). That earlier date affected the account’s treatment under the settlement scheme and, according to the Court, its financial consequences.
M/s Nanal Hydro Power Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. challenged the Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative Bank’s classification of its loan account as NPA from 6 November 2021. The company maintained that the applicable Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”) norms required classification in November 2020. Its position was supported by the Bank’s statutory auditor, whose assessment conflicted with the date recorded in the Bank’s Core Banking System (“CBS”).
The Court accepted the borrower’s position and directed consideration under the OTS Scheme, 2024, using November 2020 as the NPA month, subject to the borrower making the necessary application. The decision does not establish an unconditional right to obtain a settlement. Its central contribution is to distinguish judicial correction of an erroneous classification from judicial compulsion to grant an OTS.
2. Background and Material Facts
The petitioner was developing the Hysrund 3.30 MW run-of-the-river Small Hydro Electric Project in District Chamba. A term loan of ₹20.41 crore was sanctioned in November 2016. Further financing and project delays increased its borrowing exposure. The repayment schedule was subsequently fixed at 144 monthly instalments, running from November 2019 to October 2031, with an EMI of approximately ₹36.69 lakh.
Under a tripartite arrangement involving the petitioner, the Bank and HPSEBL, electricity-sale receipts entered an escrow account managed by the Bank. The Bank recovered instalments directly from that account. Seasonal reductions in electricity generation affected the available receipts and, consequently, repayment.
COVID-19 relief and subsequent defaults
The RBI circulars dated 27 March 2020 and 23 May 2020 provided a moratorium covering March to August 2020. The account already had overdue instalments before that period. Although the Bank received payments through the escrow arrangement during the moratorium, the Court accepted that those receipts were adjusted against liabilities relating to the period before September 2020.
The decisive factual finding was that the instalments for September, October and November 2020 remained unpaid. Nevertheless, the Bank entered the account as NPA in its CBS only from 6 November 2021.
The OTS dispute
The Bank’s OTS Scheme, 2024 covered accounts classified as doubtful assets—D1, D2 or D3—or loss assets as on 31 December 2023, without an amount ceiling. Importantly, its classification clause stated that, where the CBS and the statutory auditor’s report or Memorandum of Change (“MOC”) differed on the NPA date or category, the statutory auditor’s report/MOC would prevail.
The statutory auditor examined the loan records, repayment history and system entries and concluded that November 2020, rather than November 2021, was the correct NPA period. The Bank nevertheless obtained a private chartered accountant’s opinion. That opinion depended on how earlier receipts had been appropriated and expressly called for verification of the underlying position. A separate opinion obtained by the borrower supported the November 2020 classification.
The Bank also relied on an extension of the repayment moratorium and a change to half-yearly instalments. It maintained that the account had been correctly classified in November 2021. By May 2026, it additionally stated that the account qualified under revised settlement criteria and that an OTS offer had already been issued. That subsequent eligibility did not resolve the dispute over the historical classification date and its financial implications.
3. Questions Before the Court
- Did the applicable RBI norms require the account to be classified as NPA in November 2020 rather than November 2021?
- Could the Bank rely on an extended moratorium or altered repayment schedule to justify the later classification on the facts established?
- Could it disregard its statutory auditor’s assessment in favour of an inconclusive private opinion, particularly when the OTS scheme expressly preferred the statutory auditor’s report?
- Would directing consideration on the corrected classification basis impermissibly compel the Bank to grant an OTS?
4. Summary of the Judgment
The High Court allowed the petition. Its principal findings were:
- The account should have been classified as NPA in November 2020, having regard to the established repayment defaults and applicable RBI instructions.
- The Bank’s acceptance of a further moratorium request did not, on the material presented, displace the regulatory obligation to classify the account correctly.
- The private chartered accountant’s opinion was inconclusive and did not provide a sufficient basis for rejecting the statutory auditor’s definite assessment.
- The Bank failed to follow its own scheme, which expressly gave priority to the statutory auditor’s report/MOC when it conflicted with the CBS classification.
- The prospect of losing approximately one year’s interest could not justify rejecting a claim otherwise supported by the governing norms and evidence.
The operative direction required the Bank to consider the petitioner’s case under the OTS Scheme, 2024, treating the account as NPA from November 2020, subject to the petitioner submitting an application. The Court did not itself fix a settlement amount or direct acceptance of a particular proposal.
5. Legal Reasoning
5.1 Regulatory classification cannot be determined merely by a system entry
The Court treated NPA classification as the consequence of applicable prudential norms and the actual repayment record, rather than a matter controlled conclusively by the date entered into the Bank’s software.
The Bank admitted the continuous defaults for September, October and November 2020. Applying the RBI’s overdue-classification framework, the Court held that the Bank was required to recognise the account as NPA in November 2020. A later CBS entry could not postpone the regulatory consequences of the established default.
The broader principle is that a banking database records a classification; it does not independently determine what the correct classification must be. Where the entry conflicts with the governing norms and verified repayment history, it is open to correction.
However, the judgment should not be read as a universal rule that any three missed payments invariably establish the precise NPA date. The applicable overdue period, repayment schedule and appropriation of receipts remain relevant. Here, the Court considered those matters sufficiently established to identify November 2020 as the correct month.
5.2 A repayment accommodation does not automatically alter regulatory treatment
The Bank argued that the petitioner had requested, and received, an extension of the moratorium after the RBI’s general relief ended. It also relied on a subsequent shift from monthly to half-yearly repayment.
The Court rejected these explanations. It noted the absence of RBI permission authorising departure from the classification requirements and held that the Bank could not use its repayment accommodation to avoid those requirements. Even assuming that the Bank could extend repayment relief under its own policy, that did not answer the separate question of correct asset classification.
This reasoning distinguishes:
- The contractual repayment arrangement: when and how the borrower is permitted to pay; and
- The regulatory classification: how the account must be recognised under applicable banking norms.
The conclusion is fact-sensitive. The judgment does not establish that every restructuring or rescheduling is ineffective for classification purposes. Rather, the Bank failed to show a sufficient regulatory basis for its treatment of this account.
5.3 Moratorium relief was not equivalent to repayment
The professional material relied upon by the petitioner distinguished temporary deferment and classification relief from actual extinguishment of arrears. The Court’s findings similarly turned on whether receipts had cleared the relevant liabilities and whether fresh defaults remained after the moratorium.
The existence of deposits during March–August 2020 did not, by itself, demonstrate that the September–November instalments had been paid. Their appropriation mattered. The Court accepted that those receipts related to liabilities preceding September 2020 and therefore did not defeat the petitioner’s case.
5.4 The statutory auditor’s priority arose from the scheme itself
Clause 2 of the OTS scheme supplied an express rule for resolving disagreement between the CBS and the statutory auditor’s report/MOC: the auditor’s date or category would be treated as final.
The statutory auditor had examined the relevant records and identified the November 2021 entry as incorrect. The private accountant consulted by the Bank offered a conditional assessment dependent on verification of payment appropriation. The Court found that this opinion neither conclusively contradicted the statutory auditor nor justified disregarding the scheme’s express rule.
The Bank also argued that earlier auditors had not raised the discrepancy and that the later assessment was not grounded in those earlier audit reports. The Court nevertheless relied on the definite statutory-auditor assessment and the supporting repayment evidence. It also noted that internal Bank notings initially agreed with that assessment before the matter was referred for private opinion.
The holding is therefore narrower than a general rule that a statutory auditor always overrides every other expert. It rests on the specific priority clause in this scheme, reinforced by the comparative quality of the opinions before the Court. The judgment does not comprehensively resolve all questions about the formal status required of an auditor’s communication or when a separate MOC must be issued.
5.5 Financial consequences could not validate an incorrect classification
The Bank submitted that granting relief would cause a loss to the public exchequer. The Court accepted that correcting the date could affect approximately one year’s interest, but held that this could not defeat the petitioner’s rightful claim.
The reasoning places legal compliance before preservation of a financial advantage arising from an incorrect classification. It does not, however, establish that NPA status itself extinguishes contractual interest. The actual financial adjustment must follow the applicable settlement formula and the eventual decision on the application.
6. Precedents Cited and Their Influence
6.1 Bijnor Urban Cooperative Bank Limited v. Meenal Aggarwal and others
Citation: (2023) 2 SCC 805.
The Bank relied on paragraphs 11–14 of this Supreme Court decision to argue that a borrower cannot demand the benefit of an OTS scheme as a matter of right.
The High Court expressly accepted that proposition. It distinguished the precedent because the petitioner’s essential complaint concerned the date from which an already classified NPA should be recognised. The Bank itself accepted that the account could be considered under an available settlement framework. The dispute was therefore not simply a demand that the Court compel a concession regardless of eligibility.
The precedent influenced the limits of the relief. The High Court corrected the classification basis for consideration without declaring that the borrower was entitled to an approved settlement. It did not reject or dilute the Supreme Court’s rule against an unconditional right to OTS.
Citation: (2023) 1 SCC 540.
The Bank cited this decision for the proposition that a High Court, exercising jurisdiction under Article 226, cannot issue a writ compelling a financial institution positively to grant OTS benefits. Such benefits remain subject to the governing eligibility criteria and guidelines.
The High Court again accepted the governing principle but considered it distinguishable. The OTS scheme remained operational, and the immediate controversy concerned the correct historical NPA date. Once that date was judicially determined, the application could be considered within the scheme.
Although the petition expressly included a prayer for a direction to consider settlement, the Court characterised the substance of the relief as correction of the classification premise, not compulsory approval of an OTS. That distinction is essential to understanding the decision consistently with the Supreme Court authorities.
6.3 The boundary preserved by both precedents
Read together, the authorities and the present judgment distinguish between:
- Compelling a settlement: directing the Bank to accept a compromise or grant a concession merely because the borrower requests it; and
- Correcting an unlawful premise: requiring consideration under an existing scheme on the basis of the proper classification and the scheme’s own rules.
The High Court placed its order in the second category. Its reasoning depends on maintaining that boundary.
7. Scope of the Relief and Important Qualifications
Consideration, not automatic settlement
The Court did not approve an OTS amount, prescribe a repayment schedule or discharge the debt. It directed consideration using November 2020 as the NPA month. Other applicable requirements of the scheme were not dispensed with.
A formal application remained necessary
Although the record referred to earlier representations and proposed settlement communications, the Court recorded that an application under the scheme had not yet been made. It noted that the petitioner could apply until 30 September 2026 and expressly made its direction conditional on an application.
The doubtful-asset category was not independently fixed
The statutory auditor referred to D2 status, while the borrower’s independent accountant discussed D1 eligibility. The operative order settled the NPA month, not a separate, definitive D1/D2 classification. Those professional descriptions should not be treated as interchangeable judicial findings.
No general cancellation of interest
The Court discussed the possible interest consequences of using the earlier date. Nevertheless, NPA classification and interest waiver are distinct matters. The judgment supplies a corrected basis for the settlement exercise; it does not announce a universal rule cancelling interest from the NPA date.
The operative order was narrower than the full prayer
The petition also sought to quash several communications and notices. The operative paragraph allowed the petition through a specific direction for OTS consideration on the corrected date. It did not separately articulate an unrestricted annulment of every recovery step challenged.
8. Potential Impact
For banks and financial institutions
The decision emphasises that classification records should be reconcilable with repayment histories and audit findings. Where an OTS policy expressly prioritises a statutory auditor’s report, the institution must apply that rule rather than select a more favourable but inconclusive opinion.
The scheme’s description as “non-discretionary and non-discriminatory,” together with the duty on branches to identify eligible accounts, strengthened the expectation of consistent administration. This does not make every settlement mandatory, but it limits arbitrary treatment within the scheme.
For borrowers
A borrower may have a legitimate interest in correcting an NPA date even where the correction moves the date backwards. Historical classification can affect settlement cut-offs, asset ageing and financial calculations. A challenge supported by repayment records and the scheme’s express terms is materially different from a bare request for a concession.
For future litigation
The judgment offers a route for distinguishing prohibited judicial imposition of settlement from permissible review of an erroneous eligibility premise. Its persuasive strength is greatest where defaults are established, the scheme remains open, and its own provisions resolve the classification discrepancy.
Its reach is correspondingly limited where payment appropriation remains disputed, a regulator-authorised restructuring changes the analysis, or the borrower seeks actual approval of settlement rather than correction of an antecedent error. The decision also does not separately resolve broader questions about the writ amenability of every co-operative bank.
9. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Non-performing asset (NPA)
- A loan classified under applicable regulatory norms because repayment has remained overdue for the prescribed period. Classification does not itself cancel the loan.
- IRAC norms
- Income Recognition and Asset Classification norms govern how banks recognise income, classify loan quality and make provisions for potential loss.
- Days Past Due (DPD)
- The period for which a payment remains overdue. Correct calculation depends on due dates, receipts, payment appropriation and applicable regulatory relief.
- Moratorium
- A temporary postponement of repayment. It is not necessarily a waiver of debt, interest or existing arrears.
- One Time Settlement (OTS)
- A compromise mechanism for settling a loan account under specified conditions. Eligibility to apply or receive consideration is not the same as a guaranteed settlement.
- D1, D2 and D3
- Categories within doubtful assets. Their application depends on the relevant classification and ageing rules, which can affect scheme eligibility.
- Core Banking System (CBS)
- The Bank’s electronic account-management system. An incorrect entry does not override the governing legal classification.
- Memorandum of Change (MOC)
- An audit document identifying required changes to accounts or classifications. The scheme expressly recognised statutory auditors’ reports/MOCs when resolving discrepancies.
- Escrow account
- An account through which designated receipts are held and applied for agreed purposes. Here, electricity-sale proceeds were used for loan recovery.
- Writ of mandamus
- A judicial direction requiring performance of a legal duty. Correcting the basis of consideration does not necessarily mean ordering the authority to grant the requested financial benefit.
10. Conclusion
The judgment establishes that an OTS application must be considered on the basis of the correct regulatory classification, not an erroneous CBS date. Where the scheme expressly gives priority to the statutory auditor’s report/MOC, the Bank cannot disregard that rule on the strength of an inconclusive private opinion.
Its significance lies equally in its restraint: the Court corrected the NPA month and required scheme-compliant consideration, while leaving the settlement decision conditional on an application and the applicable framework. The decision therefore protects lawful access to consideration without creating an automatic right to compromise a bank debt.