Foreign Travel After Rescission of an LOC: Prior Intimation May Replace Prior Permission Where There Is No Arrest, Summons, or Default

Case: RAJNISH GUPTA v. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Citation: 2026 DHC 8294

Court: Delhi High Court

Date: 24 September 2026

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ravinder Dudeja

Introduction

The Delhi High Court considered whether persons against whom charge-sheets had been filed, but who had neither been arrested nor summoned, could be required to obtain judicial permission before every foreign visit. The petitions were brought by Rajnish Gupta and Nisha Gupta under Article 226 of the Constitution and Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.

The proceedings originated from a complaint by Punjab National Bank concerning a cash-credit facility extended to M/s Skyworld Exim. The CBI registered RC No. 2202022E0001 and filed charge-sheets alleging offences under Sections 120-B, 420, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code.

During the investigation, Look Out Circulars (“LOCs”) were issued against the petitioners. Although the Trial Court rescinded those LOCs on 30 April 2024, it directed that the petitioners should not leave India without its prior permission. The central question was whether that continuing restraint remained justified after completion of the investigation, particularly when the petitioners had cooperated and there was no subsisting bail condition restricting travel.

Summary of the Judgment

The High Court modified the Trial Court’s prior-permission requirement. It relied on the following circumstances:

  • The petitioners were not arrested during the investigation.
  • The charge-sheets had already been filed.
  • Cognizance had not yet been taken.
  • No summons had been issued to the petitioners.
  • There was no material showing non-cooperation, default, or misuse of liberty.
  • The Trial Court had itself found that continuation of the LOC was unjustified.
  • No bail order imposed a foreign-travel restriction.

Recognising the right to travel abroad as part of personal liberty under Article 21, the Court held that a restriction intended to secure an accused’s presence must bear a reasonable connection to that purpose. Requiring prior permission for every foreign trip was considered an excessive procedural burden in the circumstances.

The Court substituted prior permission with prior intimation. The petitioners must provide the Trial Court and the CBI with their complete itinerary, duration of travel, places of stay, and contact details at least two weeks before travelling. They must remain available for the proceedings and cannot seek adjournments because of their travel.

All other directions in the Trial Court’s order remained unaffected. Importantly, the High Court expressly stated that its order was based on the peculiar facts of the case and should not be treated as a precedent.

Analysis

1. Precedents Cited

Karti P. Chidambram Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation, BAIL APPLN. 573/2018

The petitioners relied on this decision to contend that the purpose of requiring permission before foreign travel is to secure the accused’s presence. Where that objective can be achieved through a less restrictive measure, prior intimation may be substituted for prior judicial permission.

Although the High Court did not provide a detailed discussion of this authority, the final arrangement closely reflects the proposition advanced from it. The Court preserved the CBI’s ability to monitor the petitioners’ travel while removing the need for repeated applications and judicial approvals.

Seesa Santosh Vs. State of Telangana and Anr., 2026 SCC Online SC 1071

The CBI cited this Supreme Court decision in support of retaining the prior-permission requirement. It argued that the allegations involved serious economic offences and that travel restrictions were a reasonable safeguard against evasion of criminal proceedings.

The High Court did not set out the factual or legal principles of this authority, nor did it expressly distinguish it. Instead, it resolved the matter through an assessment of the petitioners’ individual circumstances. The seriousness of the accusations was not treated as sufficient by itself to justify a continuing blanket restriction when there was no demonstrated risk of absconding, non-cooperation, or misuse of liberty.

Accordingly, the judgment should not be understood as rejecting the principle that foreign-travel restrictions may be imposed in economic-offence cases. It holds only that such restrictions must remain justified by the procedural status and conduct of the persons concerned.

2. Legal Reasoning

Article 21 and the right to travel abroad

The Court began from the principle that the right to travel abroad forms part of personal liberty protected by Article 21. That right is not absolute: restrictions may be imposed under law where necessary to secure an accused’s presence. Nevertheless, the restriction must be reasonable and connected to its stated purpose.

Absence of a demonstrated flight risk

The record contained no allegation that the petitioners had avoided the investigation, breached an undertaking, disobeyed a court direction, or attempted to evade proceedings. On the contrary, the Trial Court had recorded that they had joined the investigation and that the LOCs were no longer justified.

These findings weakened the basis for requiring prior permission for every trip. A restraint cannot continue merely because an investigation once existed or because the allegations are serious; its necessity must be supported by present circumstances.

Procedural stage of the criminal case

The Court attached particular weight to the fact that cognizance had not been taken and summons had not been issued. The petitioners were therefore not shown to be in default of any current obligation to appear. They had also not been arrested or released on bail, so no subsisting bail condition required prior permission to travel.

Use of the least restrictive safeguard

The judgment adopts a proportional approach. Rather than removing every safeguard, the Court replaced prior approval with advance disclosure. The two-week intimation requirement enables the Trial Court and the CBI to know where the petitioners will be, how they may be contacted, and when they will return.

This arrangement balances two competing interests:

  • the petitioners’ personal liberty and freedom from repetitive procedural burdens; and
  • the State’s interest in ensuring their availability during criminal proceedings.

Internal consistency after rescission of the LOC

The Court also identified tension in the Trial Court’s order. Once the LOC was rescinded because the petitioners had cooperated and its continuation was unjustified, a continuing requirement of judicial permission for every trip needed an independent and persuasive basis. No such basis was evident from the record.

3. Operative Rule Applied

On the facts of this case, where an accused was not arrested, cooperated with the investigation, faced no summons or subsisting bail restriction, and was not shown to present a flight risk, the objective of securing attendance could adequately be achieved by prior intimation rather than prior judicial permission.

This is a fact-specific rule, not a declaration that prior-permission conditions are invariably invalid.

4. Potential Impact

The decision reinforces the need for courts to periodically examine whether a travel restriction continues to be necessary. It suggests that the seriousness of an economic offence cannot automatically substitute for evidence of flight risk or non-cooperation.

The judgment may encourage courts to consider graduated safeguards, including:

  • advance disclosure of itineraries;
  • submission of foreign addresses and contact details;
  • undertakings to remain available;
  • directions not to seek adjournments because of travel; and
  • prior permission only where a specific risk justifies it.

Its formal precedential value is, however, deliberately limited. Paragraph 17 expressly states that the order was passed in the peculiar facts of the case and may not be treated as a precedent. Future litigants may find its proportionality-based reasoning persuasive, but cannot rely on it as establishing a universal entitlement to travel on mere intimation.

Complex Concepts Simplified

Look Out Circular

An LOC is an alert used at immigration points to monitor or prevent a person from leaving or entering India. Rescinding an LOC means withdrawing that alert.

Cognizance

Cognizance is the stage at which a criminal court formally applies its mind to the alleged offences and decides whether judicial proceedings should move forward.

Charge-sheet Filed Without Arrest

Filing a charge-sheet without arrest means that the investigating agency completed its investigation and placed its allegations before the court without considering custodial arrest necessary.

Prior Permission and Prior Intimation

Prior permission requires a person to obtain the court’s approval before each trip. Prior intimation merely requires advance disclosure of travel details; the person need not wait for an order granting permission.

Proportionality

Proportionality requires a restriction on liberty to be no more burdensome than necessary to achieve a legitimate objective. Here, advance reporting was found sufficient to secure the petitioners’ availability.

Section 528 of the BNSS

Section 528 preserves the High Court’s inherent powers to make orders necessary to prevent abuse of judicial process or secure the ends of justice.

Conclusion

RAJNISH GUPTA v. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION demonstrates that restrictions on foreign travel must be justified by current and individualised circumstances. The filing of a charge-sheet and the seriousness of allegations do not, by themselves, justify an indefinite requirement of prior judicial permission.

By replacing prior permission with two weeks’ advance intimation, the Court adopted a less restrictive mechanism that protects personal liberty while preserving the administration of criminal justice. The decision’s broader significance lies in its proportionality-based approach, although its express non-precedential qualification confines the ruling to its particular facts.