CiteTEXT
...impugned judgment.24. In M.C Gupta (Dr.) v. Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta...Court that it would normally be prudent and safe for the courts to leave the decision of academic matters to experts. The Court observed as under: [M.C Gupta (Dr.) case...decide the cases of both the appellants, Dr. Basavaiah and Dr. D. Manjunath, because exactly similar issues have been raised in both the appeals. But, for the sake of convenience, the facts of Civil...
...and therefore it would be unwise to substitute experts' decision by Court's decision. In this connection, reliance was placed on M.C Gupta (Dr.) v...look with respect upon the performance of duties by experts in the respective fields as has been said in Dr. M.C Gupta case (1979) 2 SCC.... Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta (1979) 2 SCC 339 in which this Court held as under:‘7...
..., the same has been held to be a part of medicine by this Court in M.C Gupta (Dr.) v. Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta.... Strong reliance, as noticed hereinbefore, has been placed by Mr Viswanathan on Dr. M.C Gupta (1979.... The opinion of experts in this case is just the converse. In an academic field, apart from Dr. M.C Gupta (...
...by the present appellant Dr M.C Gupta; Special Appeal 264 of 1975 was preferred by the State of U.P; and Special Appeal 256 of 1975 was filed by Respondents 1, 2 and 3 in Civil Appeal 357/77 against...that part of the judgment of the learned Single Judge by which appointment of appellant Dr M.C Gupta and Respondent 6, Dr R.N Tandon, was not quashed.2. The appellate Bench...partly allowed the appeals and while confirming firming the order quashing the selection of Dr M.C Gupta and Dr R.N Tandon, also quashed their appointment and remitted the matter to the Commission...
...Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C. Gupta (Dr.) v. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.), reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the sam...(Dr.) v. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein below:—“When selection is made by the Commission aided and...Ujwal v. Maharishi Dayanand Saraswati University [(2005) 13 SCC 744];4) Kanpur University v. Samir Gupta...
...Courts in academic matters, held as under :
"24. In M.C. Gupta (Dr.) v. Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta [(1979...matters to experts. The Court observed as under: [M.C. Gupta (Dr.) case
6/14...with the employer and Courts shall not ordinarily dilute the said criteria. In support of his contentions, reliance was placed on the following decisions :-
i) Dr...
...: - M.C. Gupta (Dr.) v. Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta (1979) 2 SCC 339, J.P. Kulshrestha (...finding in the impugned order that it is below 90 per cent is incorrect. He explains that even if the appointment of Dr. Aruna Tiwari, who has joined as a lower faculty on 16.11.2022, is not considered in...officer from the commission was directed.
10. In pursuance to the directions dated 20.01.2023, today Dr. Raghurama Bhatt, Senior Officer, appears along with Ms. Archana Pathak...
...the Group Head of the Law Department, Dr. M.C Gupta. All the proceedings were always communicated to Defendant 2.After the closing of evidence by the...-1999, the counsel asked Defendant 2 to clear the arrears which were sent to the counsel vide communication of their law officer dated 9-4-2001 through the Head of the Law Department Dr. M.C Gupta....defendants to vacate the premises. Immediately after recording of the statement, a written communication dated 24-5-2001 was sent to Defendant 2 as well as to Dr. M.C Gupta, Head of the Law Department of...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...) JBCJ 641 (HC)], relying on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case M.C Gupta (Dr.) V. Arun Kumar...Gupta (Dr.),
reported in (1979) 2 SCC 339, has also reiterated the same. Relevant
13
para of the judg...(Dr.) V. Arun Kumar Gupta (Dr.) is reproduced herein...
...: - M.C. Gupta (Dr.) v. Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta, J.P. Kulshrestha (Dr.) v. Allahabad University, Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth, Da...Abasaheb Solunke v. Dr. B.S. Mahajan, Neelima Misra v. Harinder Kaur Paintal, Bhushan Uttam Khare v. B. J. Medical College, Chancellor v. Dr. Bijayananda Kar, J&K State Board of Education v. Feyaz...Ahmed Malik, Dental Council of India v. Subharti K.K.B. Charitable Trust, Medical Council of India v. Sarang, Rajbir Singh Dalal (Dr.) v. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, B.C. Mylarappa v. Dr. R...
...sent a representation to the Government requesting that the eligibility of Dr. Tandon and Dr. Gupta may be investigated. A few days later, on September 13, 1974, Dr. A.K Gupta, Dr. Brij Kishore an.... On October 30, 1974, the State Government appointed Dr. R.N Tandon and Dr. M.C Gupta to the two posts of Professor in Medicine. Dr. R.N Tandon was posted in G.S.V.M Medical College, Kanpur, thereby...displacing Dr. S.N Agarwal, who was officiating on the post, and reverting him to the post of Reader in Medicine in the same College. Dr. M.C Gupta was posted to the S.N Medical College, Agra, thereby...
...of Mysore (supra) is being constantly followed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in all subsequent decisions. [See:— M.C. Gupta (Dr.) v. Dr. Arun Kumar Gupta.... Samir Gupta, (1983) 4 SCC 309], the Court recommended a system of:(1) moderation;(2) avoiding ambiguity in the questions...(1979) 2 SCC 339, J.P. Kulshrestha (Dr.) v. Allahabad University (1980) 3 SCC 418...