...to 8.23. Para 3 prescribes minimum service as Executive Engineer so as to enable such officer to be considered eligible for the promotional post of Superintending Engineer...Engineer from the post of Executive Engineer is merit i.e selection and placement of an Executive Engineer in Category I prior to other officers placed in Category II. A direction was issued by the Court...to the Corporation to offer to the writ petitioner first available vacancy of Superintending Engineer and to promote him to the said post.2. To appreciate the points raised...

...Kuldip Singh, J.— Special leave granted.2. S.M Sharma is employed as Sub-Divisional Officer in the service of the Haryana State Agricultural...Marketing Board (the Board). The Chief Administrator of the Board by the order dated June 13, 1991 entrusted Sharma with the current duty charge of the post of Executive Engineer. Later on by the order dated...Rules gives the power of appointment to the post of Executive Engineer to the Board. It is not disputed that the Board by its resolution dated November 18, 1986 delegated its powers to appoint Class...

...Engineer from any sector other than the sector of Tamil Nadu or a retired Engineer of the State Government might be appointed as arbitrator.6. The contract between the parties...Respondent 2 — the Superintending Engineer (Highways) World Bank Project Circle, Madras, and the said Company on 28-4-1979.3. According to the conditions of the contract...before the arbitrator, namely, Superintending Engineer (Highways and Rural Works), Rural Roads Circle, Tiruchirapalli, being the second respondent herein.5. During the...

...Mishra for quashing certain orders and notifications issued by the Government of Orissa in regard to Krishna Moorthy's appointment as an Assistant Engineer and his subsequent promotions to higher posts...his first appointment as an Assistant Engineer. The Government of Orissa thereafter consulted the Public Service Commission and after obtaining its concurrence, it passed an order dated March 14, 1962...regularizing Krishna Murthy's service by absorbing him in the regular cadre as an Assistant Engineer retrospectively from January 19, 1959. That order is Annexure II to the writ petitions. On...

...S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.2. The first respondent herein was appointed on deputation as Chief Engineer of the Public Works Department, Government...) dated 14-2-2005 as illegal and unconstitutional and thus render justice.”3. R. Sundar Raju (appellant in the connected appeal), Superintending Engineer, having...three years' experience, who was holding the current charge of the duties of the post of Chief Engineer at that time, in the meanwhile had filed an application questioning the deputation of the first...

...of the ABA, possession of the flats was to be handed over to the buyers on 31-1-2014. However, the developer received an occupation certificate only on 10-2-2016 and it was thereafter from May 2016...not lay down that there is an absence of jurisdiction in the adjudicatory fora constituted under the CP Act, 1986 to award remedial compensation to a flat buyer for the delay of the developer in handing...submission, which was urged before the Court by Mr Prashant Bhushan, learned counsel. By a communication dated 16-2-2016, the developer informed a flat buyer that in terms of the ABA, the allottee is required...

...the terms of the ABA, possession of the flats was to be handed over to the buyers on 31 January 2014. However, the developer received an occupation certificate only on 10 February 2016 and it was...thereafter from May 2016 that the developer started issuing letters offering possession. Based on this, the NCDRC awarded compensation in the form of interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum. The...constituted under the CP Act 1986 to award remedial compensation to a flat buyer for the delay of the developer in handing over possession on the agreed date.39. In the...

...someone in the office, probably the inwards clerk. The Chief Engineer received the copy of the award from the Tribunal on 19-3-2001.3. On 10-7-2001, the Chief Engineer presented...represented the Union of India and the notices, during proceedings of the arbitration, were served on the Chief Engineer. Even the arbitral award clearly mentions that the Union of India is...before it, unless they are all brought to his notice by the officer dealing with that arbitration and who is in charge of those proceedings. Therefore, in our opinion, service of the arbitral award on...

...arbitrator. The contractor submitted a claim of Rs 1,28,000 while the respondents also submitted a counterclaim. By an award dated 20-3-1972, the arbitrator awarded an amount of Rs 31,932 to the contractor and...a sum of Rs 21,504 to the respondents. The award was filed in the court. The contractor filed an application in the court for modification or correction of the award in respect of three items of his...claim (1, 8 and 9) and Item 1 of the respondent's counterclaim. The Department also filed its objections to the award and prayed that a sum of Rs 8080.29 should be awarded in favour of the Department...

...Order1. Leave granted.2. The respondent is an Executive Engineer working in the Department of Water Resources of the...appellant-Government. He worked as Assistant Engineer from 3-6-1989 to 25-7-1992 at Bhopal and after a short spell of six months again he was transferred to Bhopal in the promoted post of Executive...Engineer and he continued at Bhopal from 19-10-1992 to 9-7-1993. The Department initiated orders of transfer at the instance of the Chief Engineer. The respondent came to be transferred from Bhopal to...

...Engineer and a promotee by operation of Rule 2(7) stands excluded until he is appointed substantively to a cadre post.12. When an officer is appointed substantively to a cadre...list prepared as aforesaid. On promotion, as per Rule 11(1), officer shall be on probation for a period of one year, but if the officer had been officiating as an Executive Engineer the period of...contention that Rule 12 adumbrates that not only a member of the service, but even an officer officiating as an Executive Engineer before becoming a member of the service is entitled to a year of allotment...

...Engineer prior to their confirmation as Assistant Engineers. Respondents 4 to 66 were initially recruited as Assistant Executive Engineers in Class I and were promoted to the grade of Executive...Engineer between the period March 11, 1957 and February 23, 1966.2. The appellants in Civil Appeals Nos. 1745 of 1974 and 1746 and 1747 of 1974, who were recruited directly to...of Assistant Executive Engineer (Class I) and certain Assistant Engineers (Class II) are eligible for promotion to the grade of Executive Engineer (Class I). The vacancies in the grade of Executive...

...under: the Election Commission notified the election schedule for the Thirteenth Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly on 3-3-2006. Pursuant to the said notification, the Returning Officer, Cheranmahadevi...appellant and the respondent were accepted by the Returning Officer.3. During the scrutiny of the nomination papers on 21-4-2006, the appellant raised an objection that since...Government were terminated before filing of the nomination papers and, therefore, his nomination papers were not liable to be rejected. The Returning Officer passed an order dated 26-6-2006 overruling the...

...the claims made by the contractor (Respondent 1), award dated 25-6-2000 published on 14-11-2000 was a nullity.4. The second issue is regarding the merits of the claims made...claimant (contractor) raised disputes, said to have arisen out of the works entrusted under the contract. By letter dated 23-3-1998 the contractor called upon the Chief Engineer to act as an arbitrator...Engineer/Superintending Engineer and the contractor regarding the following matters namely:(i) the meaning of the specifications, designs, drawings and...

...and the employer shall give effect forthwith to every such decision of the engineer unless and until the same shall be revised, as hereinafter provided, in an amicable settlement or an arbitral award...justified in holding that no reasons have been assigned by the Arbitral Tribunal in support of their award in respect of Claims 1 and 4-B. He referred to the definitions of “employer” and “engineer”; Clause...being disposed of by this common judgment.2. The State of Kerala represented by the Chief Engineer, National Highway, Public Works Department awarded a contract to M/s Som Datt...

...judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Karnataka but by that time he had retired from service as Chief Engineer. Though he was unsuccessful, while declining to interfere with the order of the...Order1. One D. Dasegowda, the then Superintending Engineer, a government employee on deputation to Bangalore Municipal Corporation (for short, ‘the...Corporation’) as Chief Engineer, was appellant in Civil Appeal No. 797 of 1993. As a last resort to salvage him, the Government had revalidated the Rules but was unsalvaged. He had challenged the...

...status of the delegate. An Officer subordinate to another will not become his equal in rank by reason of his coming to possess some of the powers of that another. The Divisional Engineer, in other...Electrical Engineer. That the order of appointment was made by the C.E.E is undisputed and indeed there can be no controversy over it. The list of officers declared to be heads of departments shows...that Chief Electrical Engineers are heads of their departments. By an order dated August 31, 1976, the appellant was removed from service by Respondent 1, the Divisional Assistant Engineer, Central...

...jetting. The Department, however, refused the claim which led to the arbitration under clause 34 of the tender notification. The arbitrator was the Chief Engineer. It appears the award was based on...the award of the arbitrator who had earlier refused the claim of the appellant.2. The appellant (briefly “the contractor”) was a successful tenderer for construction of...instructions to the contractor to adopt the process of jetting for driving piles for the tank at Thoppumpady which is alone in dispute in this case. On October 7, 1965, the Chief Engineer after scrutinising...

...that the award does not violate Clauses (2) and (3) of the agreement making certain decisions of the Superintending Engineer/Engineer-in-charge final, nor Clause (10)(cc) of the agreement relating to...34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and affirmed the award passed by the arbitrator dated 5-9-2001, with clerical corrections made on 22-9-2001).2. On 26-3-1993...aggregating to Rs. 2,79,54,225.5. By award dated 5-9-2001 (as amended on 22-9-2001) the arbitrator awarded a sum of Rs. 1,04,58,298 with interest and costs in favour of the...

...payment of lift equivalent and leads for machine route are referred to the arbitration of Shri A.V Viswanatha Sastri, retired High Court Judge, Madras, and his award shall be final and binding on the...A.N Grover, J.— This is an appeal by certificate from a judgment of the Orissa High Court relating to an award given by Shri A.V Viswanatha Sastri, an ex-Judge of the Madras...the right duke of the Hirakud Dam.2. The Chief Engineer, Hirakud Dam, invited tenders on behalf of the Union of India for execution of work specifying certain details as to...