AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 9-A Sub S. (9)(1) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • provisions of S. 9-A(9) of the Agriculturists Relief Act,
  • S. 9-A(9) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • provisions of Madras Act IV of 1938
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 9-A Sub S. (9)(1) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • provisions of S. 9-A(9) of the Agriculturists Relief Act,
  • S. 9-A(9) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • provisions of Madras Act IV of 1938
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary (Delivered by Rajagopala Aiyangar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal is a second appeal concerning the construction of S. 9-A Sub-S. (9)(1) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act. The plaintiff in the original suit (now the appellant in this second appeal) was the mortgagee in a usufructuary mortgage executed on 17 August 1945 for Rs. 2,000. The mortgagee entered into possession. On 5 August 1947 the mortgaged property was leased back to the mortgagor (now the respondents) for one year, fasli 1357, with rent fixed at delivery of 30 kalams of samba paddy; the lease was renewed informally for fasli 1358. The lessee did not deliver the stipulated rent for either year.

The mortgagee filed a suit to recover Rs. 1,303-11-10 (the value of the paddy agreed as rent for faslis 1357 and 1358) with interest at 6% per annum from the due dates. The defendants (mortgagor-lessees) pleaded (1) entitlement to scaling down under the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act (S. 9-A Sub-S. 6 corresponding to present Sub-S. 9) and (2) that rent for fasli 1357 had been paid. The trial Court rejected both defences, finding no rent payment and holding the defendants not entitled to relief under S. 9-A because the usufructuary mortgage was executed after the enactment of Madras Act IV of 1938. The trial Court decreed Rs. 922-4-3 (interest before suit disallowed) with interest at 5½% from plaint and costs.

The defendants appealed to the Subordinate Court, raising only the scaling-down issue. The Subordinate Judge applied S. 9-A(9) and reduced the claim by calculating interest at 5½% of Rs. 2,000 (Rs. 110 per year) and passed a decree for Rs. 220. The mortgagee (plaintiff) filed the present second appeal from that subordinate court judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. How is S. 9-A Sub-S. (9)(1) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act to be properly construed — in particular, whether its scaling-down mechanism is an independent provision applicable in suits for recovery of rent or is confined to suits for redemption?
  2. Whether a usufructuary mortgage executed on 17 August 1945 is governed by the provisions of Madras Act IV of 1938 (i.e., whether the relief under S. 9-A applies to that mortgage)?
  3. Given subsequent events (a separate redemption suit decreeing redemption of the mortgage), whether the rent claim for faslis 1357–1358 must now be scaled down under S. 9-A(9) and interest allowed at 5½% under S. 9 read with S. 13 of the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (mortgagee / plaintiff)

  • Reliance on the decision of Subba Rao J. in T.V. Srinivasaraghava Aiyangar v. M. Narasimha Mudaliar: where it was held that S. 9-A Sub-S. (9) could not be availed of by a mortgagor in a suit that is merely for recovery of rent and not for redemption.
  • Contended that because the present suit was for recovery of rent and not for redemption, the scaling-down provisions of S. 9-A(9) were inapplicable to the mortgagor-lessee.

Respondents' Arguments (mortgagor-lessees / defendants)

  • Sought to rely on Bench decisions such as Sankara Aiyar v. Yagappan Servai and observations in V. Venkatanarayana Rao v. Champalal Savansukha to urge reconsideration of Subba Rao J.'s ruling and to support a broader application of the scaling-down provision.
  • Pleading before the trial Court included (a) entitlement to scaling down under the Madras enactment and (b) that rent for fasli 1357 had been paid (the trial Court rejected both pleas).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T.V. Srinivasaraghava Aiyangar v. M. Narasimha Mudaliar Whether the scaling down in S. 9-A Sub-S. (9) is available in suits for recovery of rent or confined to suits for redemption; Subba Rao J. held it applies only in suits involving redemption. The Court accepted the correctness of Subba Rao J.'s reasoning, treated Sub-S. (9) as analogous to earlier sub-sections that operate to determine amounts payable for redemption, and relied on it in concluding that Sub-S. (9) is not an independent provision applicable to ordinary rent recovery suits.
Sankara Aiyar v. Yagappan Servai Principle that a Court may go behind the debt sued on to ascertain its origin and, if the debt represents interest, a defendant may be entitled to scaling down on that basis. The Court held this authority to be irrelevant to the main question decided by Subba Rao J.; it observed the decision would only assist if S. 9-A(9)(a)(i) were an independent provision (which the Court held it was not).
V. Venkatanarayana Rao v. Champalal Savansukha Referenced by respondents; observations were relied upon to seek reconsideration of Subba Rao J.'s ruling. The Court stated that this decision did not bear on the point arising in the present appeal and conceded it had no bearing on the principal issue.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the language of S. 9-A and the scheme of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act. It concluded that Sub-S. (9) is analogous to Sub-Ss. 8 to 6 and is designed for determining the amounts payable to a mortgagee to enable redemption. Consequently, the machinery of the scaling-down provisions operates in the context of redemption proceedings and cannot be read as an independent provision that can be invoked in any suit for recovery of rent.

The Court accepted the correctness of Subba Rao J.'s decision (as subsequently considered in C.R.P. Nos. 1109 and 1110 of 1953) that the words in Sub-S. (9) treating rent payable to a mortgagee as interest on mortgage cannot be divorced from the overall scheme and invoked separately outside redemption suits.

The Court considered the respondents' reliance on the Sankara Aiyar decision but held it irrelevant to the issue of whether S. 9-A(9) is an independent provision; Sankara Aiyar would only assist if S. 9-A(9)(a)(i) stood independently, which the Court rejected.

Importantly, the Court proceeded to consider events that occurred after the lower appellate judgment: the respondents had instituted and obtained a decree in a separate redemption suit (O.S. No. 364 of 1951; A.S. No. 71 of 1952 on appeal). That redemption litigation established that Rs. 1,500 had been paid by a purchaser of part of the mortgaged property, the principal was statutorily deemed written down to Rs. 1,600 by reason of subsistence of the mortgage from 1945 to 1951, and the remaining Rs. 100 was paid by the mortgagor to effect redemption. All claims between the parties were resolved in those proceedings except the rent claim for faslis 1357–1358, which was excluded pending this second appeal.

Given that redemption had now been effected (and the redemption decree had become final), the Court held that the rent claim must be scaled down under S. 9-A(9) with interest at 5½% under S. 9 read with S. 13. To avoid multiplicity of proceedings (because executing a full unreduced decree and later scaling it down at time of redemption would create further litigation), the Court elected to treat the rent claim "as if it arose in a suit for redemption" and to pass a decree limited to the amount the mortgagee would be entitled to in a redemption action.

Applying that approach, the Court determined that the sum due for rent would be Rs. 100 per year (the opinion states this figure and notes it is the same sum decreed by the Subordinate Judge), and therefore affirmed the Subordinate Judge's decree though on different grounds from those relied upon below.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The second appeal is DISMISSED and the judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge are AFFIRMED.

Implications and consequences:

  • The Court reaffirmed that S. 9-A Sub-S. (9) is not an independent provision to be invoked in every suit for recovery of rent; its scaling-down machinery is meant to operate in the context of redemption proceedings.
  • Because the mortgage was subsequently redeemed in separate proceedings and that decree became final, the rent claim for faslis 1357–1358 must now be scaled down under S. 9-A(9) with interest at 5½% under S. 9 read with S. 13; the Court therefore made a decree limited to the amount a mortgagee would be entitled to in a redemption action (stated in the opinion as Rs. 100 per year).
  • No new precedent expanding S. 9-A(9) beyond its redemption context was established; the decision affirms the confined application of the provision and resolves the parties' dispute accordingly.
  • Costs: The Court ordered that there should be no order as to costs in the second appeal (noting the appellant was justified in coming to this Court and that the appellant's rights were curtailed only by proceedings instituted after the second appeal was filed).

This summary is strictly confined to the content and statements made in the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the judgment has been introduced.

    N.A Visalakshi Achi v. Mayalagu (Minor) By His Mother And Guardian. Suppammal And Another.

    (Delivered by Rajagopala Aiyangar, J.)

    This second appeal raises for consideration the proper construction of S. 9-A Sub S. (9)(1) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act and has been placed before a Bench by an order of Krishnaswami Nayudu j.

    The plaintiff is the appellant before us. A usufructuary mortgage was executed in his favour on 17th August 1945 for a sum of Rs. 2,000. Apparently the mortgagee entered into possession of the property immediately thereafter. On 5th August 1947 the mortgaged property was leased back to the mortgagor now represented by the respondents for a period of one year fasli 1357 on terms of his delivering 30 kalams of samba paddy of 54 measures per kalam.

    Without any writing therefor the lease was renewed for another year fasli 1358. The lessee however did not pay the rent for either 1357 or 1358 and the present suit was filed for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 1303-11-10 being the value of paddy agreed to be delivered as rent for faslis 1357 and 1358 with interest at 6 per cent per annum from the due dates. The plea of the defendants was two-fold. The first was that as they were agriculturists entitled to the benefits of Act IV of 1936, the debt should be scaled down in accordance with the provisions bf S. 9-A Sub-S. 6 corresponding to the present Sub-S. 9. The second was that the rent for fasli 1357 had been paid up and discharged. The trial Court held against the defendants in respect of both these defences. It found that no portion of the rent for fasli 1357 had been paid up and also that the defendants were not entitled to the relief under S. 9-A by reason of the usufructuary mortgage having been executed after Act IV of 1938 was enacted. It passed a decree however for Rs. 922-4-3 which figure was reached by disallowing interest prior to the suit. The decree allowed the plaintiff interest at 5 1/2 per cent per annum from the date of the plaint and costs. The defendants filed an appea to the Sub Court of Devakottai raising only the question of their claim to a staling down under the Madras enactment and did not further agitate their plea as to discharge. The learned Subordinate Judge rejected the contention of the plaintiff that usufructuary mortgages executed after 22nd March 1938 would not be governed by S. 9-A(9) and applying its provisions reduced the claim to 5½ per cent of the principal amount of Rs. 2000 that is, Rs. 110 per year and passed a decree for Rs. 220. It is from this judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge that the present second appeal has been filed by the mortgagee-lessor.

    The appeal came on before Krishnaswami Nayudu J. and before him learned Counsel for the appellant relied on the decision of Subba Rao J. in T.V. Srinivasaraghava Aiyangar v. M. Narasimha Mudaliar(1) and contended that as the suit was merely for the recovery of rent and not one for redemption, the provisions of S. 9-A Sub-S. (9) could not be availed of by the mortgagor. On the other hand, learned Counsel for the mortgagor respondent urged that by reason of the decision of a Bench in Sankara Iyer v. Yagappa Servai(2), and the observations contained in another Bench decision in V. Venkatanarayana Rao v. Champalal Savansukha(3), the correctness of the ruling of Subba Rao J. should be reconsidered. In view of this argument, Krishnaswami Nayudu J. directed the appeal to be posted before a Bench.

    We are clearly of the opinion that the two Bench decisions referred to above do not affect the correctness of the decision of Subba Rao J. and do not in fact, bear upon the point decided by that learned Judge. The question that was mooted in T.V. Srinivasaraghava Aiyangar v. M. Narasimha Mudaliar was whether the scaling down provided for by S. 9-A Sub-S. (9)(1) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act was available to the mortgagor-lessee in every suit for the recovery of the rent due or whether the relief provided was confined to suits for redemption, wherein the entire relationship between the mortgagor and the mortgagee was being put an end to for ever. The learned Judge after a consideration of the relevant provisions of S. 9-A and the scheme of the enactment came to the conclusion that it was only to a suit which involved redemption of the mortgage that these provisions could be applied. The question of the correctness of this decision of Subba Rao J. came up before one of us in C.R.P Nos. 1109 and 1110 of 1953. The facts of that case were practically identical with those of the present and the position was thus formulated:

    “The argument of Mr. Kesava Aiyangar, learned Counsel for the petitioners is that this [S. 9-A Sub-S. (9)(a)(i)] is an independent provision which treats all rents due from a mortgagor where a usufructuary mortgagee leases back the property to the mortgagor, as interest due on the mortgage money with the result that the provisions of S. 8 or S. 9 read with S. 12 or S. 13 of the Act apply to the scaling down of such rent viewed as interest. On the other hand, in the decision of this Court, abovementioned, Subba Rao J. has held that the scaling down effected by this sub-section is available to a mortgagor-lessee only in cases where he files a suit for redemption, and that this apart, the provision is inapplicable to cases where a mortgagee files a suit for the recovery of the rent stipulated under the lease-back.”

    The language of the different subsections of S. 9-A and scheme underlying the provisions were again analysed and the conclusion was stated in these terms:

    “The above analysis makes it clear that Sub-S. (9) is really analogous to Sub-Ss. 8 to 6 in cases where is a lease back Just as the earlier sub-sections apply only for the determination of the amounts payable to a mortgagee to enable redemption to be effected, Sub-S. 9 also is similarly designed and operates to achieve a similar purpose. The machinery therefore of the scaling down provision can only apply for the determination of the sum payable for redemption and the words of the provision referring to the rent payable to the mortgagee as interest on the principal amount of the mortgage debt cannot be divorced from this scheme and invoked as an independent provision for scaling down rents. This conclusion is reinforced by the use of the expression the ‘entire debt’ at the end of Sub-Cl. (i).”

    We have heard no argument to throw doubt upon the correctness of the reasoning in this judgment or the conclusion reached. Learned Counsel for the respondents relied on a decision in Sankara Aiyar v. Yagappan Servai for the position that the Court should go behind the debt sued on in order to find out its origin and that if that debt really represented interest, the defendant was entitled to a scaling down on that footing. This, however is wholly irrelevant for the consideration of the point involved in the decision of Subba Rao J. There can be no doubt that if S. 9-A Sub-S. (9)(a)(i) stood as an independent provision, the scaling down would be as contended by learned Counsel for the respondents which is all the assistance that the decision in Sankara Aiyar v. Yagappan Servai affords him. As we have pointed out earlier, S. 9-A Sub-S. (9)(a)(i) is not an independent provision but in the context and setting in which it appears is designed for the determination of the amount payable on redemption.

    It was conceded before us that the decision in V. Venkatanarayana Rao v. Champalal Savansukha did not have any bearing upon the point arising for consideration in the present appeal.

    If matters stood as they were when this litigation commenced or even when this appeal was filed, there could be no doubt that the judgment of the learned District Munsif would have to be restored though for quite different reasons. In passing we might mention that the District Munsif was wrong in holding that the suit mortgage of August 1945 was not governed by the provisions of Madras Act IV of 1938 and that the Subordinate Judge was right in the view that he took as regards applicability of this enactment as amended.

    Almost at the close of his arguments seeking to support the interpretation of S. 9-A(9) of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act which was upheld by the Subordinate Judge, learned Counsel for the respondents, brought to our notice that subsequent to the decision of the lower appellate Court his clients had filed a suit for redemption of the suit mortgage which has been decreed. We adjourned the proceedings to enable the respondents to place before us the judgment in the redemption action so that we might consider the decree to be passed on the claim for rent for faslis 1357-1358 in the light of that decree. We have now been furnished with copies of the judgment in the respondents' suit, O.S No. 364 of 1951 on the file of the District Munsif's Court, Devakottai, for the redemption of the suit mortgage and of the judgment of the Subordinate Judge of Devakottai in A.S No. 71 of 1952 on appeal from that decree. These establish that subsequent to the decision of the lower appellate Court in the present case a sum of Rs. 1,500 had been paid to the mortgagee by the purchaser-of one of the items of the mortgaged property. The two Courts dealing with the redemption suit have further held that the principal amount under the usufructuary mortgage should be statutorily deemed to have been written down to Rs. 1,600 by virtue of the subsistence of the mortgage from 1945 to 1951. It is also made out that the balance of Rs. 100 has been paid by the mortgagor and the mortgage has been redeemed and the judgments make it clear that all other claims between the mortgagor and the mortgagee have been decided except the claim for rent for fasli 1357-1358 which was excluded from the scope of the suit as being the subject matter of this second appeal pending in this Court. It is also now admitted that the decree in A.S No. 71 of 1952 on the file of the Sub Court, Devakottai, has become final and that no second appeal has been filed therefrom.

    In view of these facts which transpired subsequent to the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge now under appeal it is clear that the amount of rent due for faslis 1357-1358 has to be scaled down by applying the provisions of S. 9-A(9) of the Agriculturists Relief Act, by allowing interest at 5 1/2 per cent per annum under S. 9 read with S. 13 of the Act.

    In the earlier part of our judgment we have held that the appellant-lessor was entitled to a decree for the full amount of the rent stipulated by the parties under the contract on the ground that the present suit not being one for redemption the scaling down provisions do not apply. If the decree for the full amount were executed and the sum recovered, the amount thus received would be taken into account at the time of redemption, when of course the scaling down provision would be applied and any excess received over any sum properly payable as interest—that is calculated at 5½ per cent per annum would go in reduction of the principal amount due under the mortgage. This is the scheme of S. 9-A(9) of the Act and as in the present case the entire sum due to the mortgagee for redemption has been paid off except in relation to the rent due for faslis 1357-1358, The allowance of any sum in excess of Rs. 110 per year would lead merely to further proceedings becoming necessary to scale down this decree. In order therefore to obviate multiplicity of proceedings we propose to deal with the claim for rent as if it arose in a suit for redemption and pass a decree only for such amount as the mortgagee would be entitled to, in such an action. There can be no dispute-that viewed in this light the sum due would be only Rs. 100 per year which is the same which has been decreed to the appellant by the learned Subordinate Judge.

    The result is that the decree of the learned Subordinate Judge has to be affirmed though on very different grounds. The appeal will therefore stand dismissed and the judgment of the lower appellate Court affirmed.

    In regard to costs, as the appellant was justified in coming up to this Court and as it is only by virtue of the proceedings instituted after the second appeal was filed that the appellant's rights have been cut down, we consider that this is a propar case in which there should be no order as to costs in the second appeal.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    N.A Visalakshi Achi v. Mayalagu (Minor) By His Mother And Guardian. Suppammal And Another.
    (Apr 7, 1955)