AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act.
  • S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • S. 19-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • S. 69-A(2) of the Transfer of Property Act
  • Madras Agriculturists Relief Act.
  • S. 69-A, Transfer of Property Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act.
  • S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • S. 19-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act
  • S. 69-A(2) of the Transfer of Property Act
  • Madras Agriculturists Relief Act.
  • S. 69-A, Transfer of Property Act,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment (Delivered by Chief Justice)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant executed a deed of simple mortgage on 20 April 1936 in favour of the respondent for Rs. 99,999, covering city houses and lands in Krishna District. On 3 November 1936 the appellant executed a second mortgage in favour of his mother, V. Sundaramma, for Rs. 1,60,000.

V. Sundaramma, as pusine mortgagee, filed an application (Original Side No. 827 of 1949) seeking to scale down the debt claimed by the respondent. Krishnaswami Nayudu, J. held that she was an agriculturist entitled to benefits under the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act and directed an enquiry by the Official Referee. The respondent appealed that order (O.S.A No. 119 of 1950).

Separately, the respondent filed O.P No. 139 of 1949 under S. 69-A of the Transfer of Property Act seeking, inter alia, to restrain the appellant from collecting rents of certain mortgaged properties. An ex parte order (22 April 1949) initially restrained collection of rents; later the Court appointed an Advocate of the Court as receiver to collect the rents and deposit them in Court.

The appellant filed Application No. 2682 of 1950 purportedly under S. 19-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act (relying on newly added S. 13-A) to scale down his debt; Rajagopalan, J. dismissed it on the ground that the appellant was not an "agriculturist" within S. 3(2). The appellant's appeal (O.S.A No. 24 of 1951) was dismissed. Rajagopalan, J. observed that other remedies might be available to the appellant (for example, suing for a declaration or resisting a suit).

Thereafter the appellant filed Application No. 3461 of 1952 in O.P No. 139 of 1949 seeking several reliefs, including discharge of the receiver, on the ground that a proper calculation under S. 13-A had wiped out the mortgage debt. Panchapakesa Aiyar, J. on 12 December 1952 held the application was not the proper form to agitate the appellant's liability and dismissed it; he indicated the appellant could sue for redemption or resist a suit by the creditor.

The appellant appealed from that order. On 28 April 1953 the respondent represented a compromise had been made on 27 April 1953; the appellant denied this. The respondent then filed C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953 to record and enforce the alleged compromise, relying on a letter (Ex. R.2) signed by both parties. The Court directed the Master to inquire as to whether a concluded compromise existed. The Master found there was no concluded compromise; the Court agreed and dismissed C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant, who asserted that the mortgage debt had been wiped out under S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act, could seek discharge of the receiver in the present application (filed in O.P No. 139 of 1949) rather than only in a suit for redemption or in a suit brought by the mortgagee.
  2. Whether S. 69-A(2) of the Transfer of Property Act permits the Court to remove a receiver on application by the mortgagor where the mortgagor alleges there is no debt outstanding (i.e., whether the provision covers pleas that no principal or interest is due).
  3. Whether there was a concluded compromise between the parties dated 27 April 1953 (relevant to C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953).
  4. Whether, on a proper construction of S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of that provision (the Court noted this issue but did not decide it).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant averred (in the affidavit in support of Application No. 3461 of 1952) that on a proper calculation under S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act the mortgage debt in favour of the respondent had been wiped out and therefore the receiver should be discharged.
  • The appellant denied that a concluded compromise had been reached on 27 April 1953 and opposed the respondent's application (C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953) to record that alleged compromise.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent previously contended before Rajagopalan, J. that the appellant was not entitled to rely on S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act (this point was not decided by that Judge).
  • In the proceedings about the alleged compromise, the respondent submitted that a compromise had been reached on 27 April 1953 and relied on a letter dated 27 April 1953 (Ex. R.2) signed by the appellant and also signed in token of acceptance by the respondent; the respondent sought that the Court record and pass a decree in terms of that compromise.
  • At the hearing of the appeal, Mr. Viswanatha Aiyar (learned Counsel for the respondent) argued that on a proper construction of S. 13-A the appellant would not be entitled to its benefit.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the interlocutory application C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953 to record a compromise. Because the parties disputed the factual question whether a concluded compromise existed, the Court directed an inquiry by the Master. The Master found that there was no completed and lawful compromise binding on the appellant; the Court agreed with the Master's finding and dismissed the application to record the compromise.

Turning to the main appeal against Panchapakesa Aiyar, J.'s order dismissing the appellant's application (No. 3461 of 1952) for discharge of the receiver, the Court rejected the learned Judge's view that the appellant could obtain the benefit of S. 13-A only in a suit for redemption or in a suit by the respondent on the mortgage. The Court analysed S. 69-A(2) of the Transfer of Property Act, which provides that a receiver may be removed by writing signed by or on behalf of the mortgagee and mortgagor or by the Court on application made by either party and on due cause shown.

The Court reasoned that the language of S. 69-A(2) is broad enough to cover a case where the mortgagor alleges there is no debt outstanding and therefore no justification for continuance of a receiver. The Court further noted the duties of a Receiver under Sub-section (8) clauses (iv) and (v) of S. 69-A — namely, to apply sums received in payment of interest falling due under the mortgage and, if directed by the mortgagee, in or towards discharge of principal — and posed the rhetorical question whether a mortgagor should be precluded from placing before the Court pleas that no principal or interest is due or that the mortgage is barred. The Court answered that the mortgagor is not precluded.

On that basis the Court held that the appellant's plea founded on S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act should be enquired into and disposed of in the ongoing application for discharge of the receiver. The Court expressly declined to decide the substantive question whether, on proper construction, S. 13-A would in fact entitle the appellant to relief — observing that that point had not been considered by Panchapakesa Aiyar, J. and that it was not necessary or desirable for the appellate Court to decide it at that stage.

Consequently, the appellate Court set aside the order of Panchapakesa Aiyar, J., so that the application challenging the need for the receiver (including the appellant's plea under S. 13-A) could be taken up and disposed of according to law in the light of the Court's directions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed. The Court set aside the order of Panchapakesa Aiyar, J., which had dismissed the appellant's application. The Court also held that there was no concluded compromise binding on the appellant and dismissed C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953.

DIRECT EFFECT ON THE PARTIES:

  • The appellant's application (No. 3461 of 1952) challenging the continuance of the receiver and asserting that the mortgage debt had been wiped out under S. 13-A is to be taken up on file and disposed of in accordance with law in the light of this judgment.
  • The application to record and enforce an alleged compromise (C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953) was dismissed because the Master and the Court found no concluded compromise.
  • Costs were awarded in the cause. The appellant is to receive a refund of the court-fee paid on the memorandum of appeal.

Implications: The Court held that S. 69-A(2) of the Transfer of Property Act can, in its language and effect, cover applications by a mortgagor seeking removal of a receiver on the ground that no debt is outstanding. However, the Court did not decide the substantive question whether the appellant in fact qualified for relief under S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act — that issue remains open for determination in the application itself. The opinion does not purport to decide the substantive entitlement under S. 13-A and directs further adjudication on that point in the proper proceedings.

Prepared strictly from the text of the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in the opinion itself.

    V. Venkatanarayana Rao v. Champalal Savansukha And Another.

    JUDGMENT

    (Delivered by Chief Justice.)

    The appellant executed on 20th April 1936 in favour of the respondent a deed of simple mortgage for a sum of Rs. 99,999. The properties secured under the mortgage included houses in the city and lands in the District of Krishna. He executed a second mortgage in favour of his mother, V. Sundaramma for Rs. 1,60,000 on 3rd November 1936. She, as pusine mortgagee filed an application on the Original Side of this Court (No. 827 of 1949) to scale down the debt due to the respondent. On that application, Krishnaswami Nayudu, J. made an order directing the matter to be enquired into by the Official Referee, after holding that V. Sundaramma was an agriculturist entitled to the benefits of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act. The respondent filed an appeal against the said order, O.S.A No. 119 of 1950. Meanwhile, the respondent filed a petition, O.P No. 139 of 1949, on the Original Side, under S. 69-A, Transfer of Property Act, inter alia to restrain the appellant from collecting the rents of some of the properties which were included in the mortgage, which in fact were the only properties left after other properties mortgaged had been sold. There was an ex parte order on the application on 22nd April 1949 restraining the appellant from collecting the rents of the suit properties. Subsequently, the Court varied the order by appointing an Advocate of this Court as a receiver for collecting the rents and depositing the same into Court towards the credit of the said petition (O.P No. 139 of 1949). The appellant then filed an application No. 2682 of 1950, purporting to be under S. 19-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act for scaling down his debt on the basis that he was entitled to the benefit of the newly added S. 13-A of the said Act. That application was dismissed by Rajagopalan, J. on the ground that a substantive application by the appellant under S. 19-A of the Act was not maintainable as he was not an agriculturist within the definition in S. 3(2) of the Act. The appellant carried the matter in appeal (O.S.A No. 24 of 1951), but the appeal was dismissed. The respondent contended before Rajagopalan, J. that the appellant was in any event not entitled to rely on S. 13-A of the Act, but this contention was not dealt with in the view taken by the learned Judge. This point was not dealt with in appeal either, Rajagopalan, J. in the course of his judgment made it clear that his decision did not imply that the appellant had no other remedy. He said:

    “It may be open to the debtor to sue the creditor for a declaration that only a certain amount is due, as calculated with reference to S. 13-A. It may equally be possible for the debtor to resist a claim in a Court of law by the creditor as plaintiff to the contract rate of interest and say that only statutory rate of interest referred to in S. 13-A should be allowed. I am not exhausting the list of remedies open to a creditor or debtor.”

    The learned Judge concluded by saying that the disposal of the application before him in noway precluded the appellant from enforcing his rights in other and appropriate proceedings.

    After the disposal of O.S.A No. 24 of 1951, the appellant filed an application No. 3461 of 1952, in O.P No. 139 of 1949 for several reliefs of which it is sufficient to mention one. namely, to discharge the receiver from the office of the receivership. In the affidavit filed by him in support of this application, he alleged that on a proper calculation in accordance with the provisions of S. 13-A the mortgage debt in favour of the respondent had been wiped away and nothing was due from him to the respondent and therefore the receiver should be discharged. We are not concerned with the other allegations and reliefs claimed by the appellant. The application was heard and disposed of by Panchapakesa Aiyar, J. on 12th December 1952. The learned Judge held that the application was not the proper form to agitate the matter of the liability of the appellant. In his opinion, the appellant could either tile a suit for redemption or resist a suit against him for the full unscaled amount and in such proceedings he could plead his right to scale down the debt. It is against this order of Panchapakesa Aiyar. J., that the above appeal has been preferred.

    On 28th April 1953, when the appeal was called, the learned Counsel for the respondent made a representation to us that the matter had been compromised on the previous day, that is, 27th April 1953. This was denied by the appellant. The appeal was therefore adjourned at the instance of the respondent who represented that he would file an application to enforce the compromise. He accordingly filed on 8th July 1953 an application C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953, praying that this Court may record the compromise entered into between the parties and pass a decree in terms thereof. The terms of the compromise, according to the respondent, were contained in a letter dated 27th April 1953 from the appellant to the respondent (Ex. R. 2). The letter was annexed to the affidavit in support of the application. The letter is signed by the appellant, and there is also the signature of the respondent in token of his acceptance. The Appellant opposed the application on the ground that there had been no completed compromise binding on him. As there was a dispute on a question of fact, namely, whether there was a concluded compromise or not, we thought it desirable to direct the Master to hold an inquiry after notice to the parties and to submit a report on a consideration of the evidence adduced before him on the question whether there was a concluded compromise between the parties. In pursuance of our order the Master made an enquiry and has sent up his finding that, there was no completed and lawful compromise so as to bind the appellant. Mr. Viswanatha Aiyar, learned Counsel for the respondent in the appeal and the petitioner in the application attacked the correctness of this finding.

    We hold agreeing with the master that there was no concluded compromise and therefore the application, C.M.P No. 6930 of 1953 must be dismissed.

    This leaves us with the main appeal, which as already mentioned is against the order of Panchapakesa Aiyar, J., dismissing the appellant's application for the discharge of the receiver appointed in O.P No. 139 of 1949, on the ground that the debt due under the mortgage in favour of the respondent had been wiped out on an application of the provisions of S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act. We do not agree with the learned Judge that the appellant can get the benefit of the application of S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act only in a suit filed by him for redemption or in a suit by the respondent on foot of the mortgage. In our opinion, the appellant can get relief, if he is otherwise entitled to it, in the present application itself. S. 69-A(2) of the Transfer of Property Act inter alio provides that a receiver may at any time be removed by writing signed by or on behalf of the mortgagee and the mortgagor or by the Court on application made by either party and on due cause shown. Though there is no direct authority on the point, we are inclined to hold that the language of this provision would cover a case in which it is alleged by the mortgagor that there is no debt outstanding and therefore there should be no receiver. Under Sub-S.(8), Cl. (iv) of S. 69-A the Receiver is bound to apply the money received by him in payment of the interest falling due under the mortgage, and under Cl. (v) in or towards the discharge of the principal money if so directed by the mortgagee. Suppose in a particular case it is alleged by the mortgagor that there is no amount due for principal or interest under the mortgage or again, take a case where the mortgagor alleges that the mortgage has become barred. Can it be said that the mortgagor in such circumstances is precluded from putting forward such pleas and has to submit to the receiver being in possession and collecting the income from the property and making payments which are not due? We think not. In the present case, the mortgagor says that no further amount is due and payable to the mortgagee. Then, should there be the continuance of the receiver? We are of opinion that the appellant's plea based on S. 13-A of the Madras Agriculturists Relief Act should be enquired into and disposed of in the application. Mr. Viswanatha Aiyar contended that on a proper construction of S. 13-A the appellant will not be entitled to the benefit of its provision. This point was not considered by Panchapakesa Aiyar, J., and we do not think necessary or desirable that we should deal with it, as the entire matter is at large.

    The appeal is allowed and the order of Panchapakesa Aiyar, J., dismissing the appellant's application is hereby set aside. The application will be taken up on file and disposed of in accordance with law in the light of this judgment. Costs, costs in the cause. The appellant will have a refund of the court-fee paid on the memo of appeal.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V. Venkatanarayana Rao v. Champalal Savansukha And Another.
    (Dec 4, 1953)