Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2 of the Hindu Women's Rights to Separate Residence and Maintenance Act, 1946,
  • Section 10 of the Indian Divorce Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2 of the Hindu Women's Rights to Separate Residence and Maintenance Act, 1946,
  • Section 10 of the Indian Divorce Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the decree and judgment of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge of Pudukotlai in O.S No. 215 of 1949, where the plaintiff Deivanai Achi sought separate maintenance, past and future, from her husband Kasiviswanathan Chettiar, the first defendant, and his brother Annamalai Chettiar, the second defendant. The plaintiff and first defendant were married on 8-7-1935 and initially lived according to Nattukottai Chetty custom in separate quarters within the family house. Between 1937 and 1941, the plaintiff did not live with her husband, who was in Arimalam and later went to Malaya in 1941, returning in 1946. Post-return, the couple lived apart until the suit's institution. The plaintiff claimed faithfulness and willingness to reside with her husband, alleging neglect and failure to maintain her, and that the husband married a second wife in February 1949, prompting her to file the suit. The husband contended that the plaintiff was troublesome, immoral, and had led an immoral life during his absence, supported by evidence including letters and photographs. The trial court found the plaintiff's immorality established beyond reasonable doubt for the period 1941 to 1946 and dismissed the suit with costs, leading to this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff wife, having left her husband's home and allegedly led an immoral life, is entitled to separate maintenance under Hindu Law and the Hindu Women's Rights to Separate Residence and Maintenance Act, 1946.
  2. The standard and nature of proof required to establish adultery or immorality sufficient to disentitle a wife from maintenance claims.
  3. Whether the husband's remarriage without justifiable cause entitles the wife to separate maintenance.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The plaintiff asserted she was faithful and willing to live with her husband.
  • She alleged neglect and failure by her husband to maintain her.
  • The husband's second marriage justified her claim for separate maintenance.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The husband claimed the plaintiff was troublesome and immoral, leaving for her parents' home in 1937 and not returning.
  • He alleged she engaged in illicit intimacy with Veerappa Chettiar during his absence, supported by letters, photographs, and admissions.
  • Further alleged immoral conduct after 1946 with other men, supported by witness testimony.
  • Argued that due to the plaintiff's immoral conduct, she was not entitled to maintenance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jayanti Subbiah v. Alamelu Mangamma, ILR 27 Mad 45 Husband's personal obligation to maintain wife independent of property possession. Affirmed the husband's maintenance obligation arising from Hindu law.
Narbadabai v. Mahadeo, ILR 5 Bom 99 Maintenance obligation under Hindu law. Supported the principle of maintenance irrespective of property.
Appi Bai v. Khimji, AIR 1936 Bom 138 Husband's duty to maintain wife. Reinforced maintenance duty under Hindu law.
Radhabai v. Gopal, AIR 1944 Bom 50 Maintenance obligation of husband to wife. Confirmed the personal obligation of husband to maintain wife.
Venkatapati v. Puttama, AIR 1936 Mad 609 Maintenance under Hindu law. Supported maintenance principles.
Rattamma v. Seshachalam, AIR 1927 Mad 502 Husband's maintenance obligation. Reinforced maintenance duty.
Indira Bai v. Makarand, AIR 1931 Nag 197 Maintenance principles. Supported maintenance duty under Hindu law.
Lachmi Singh v. Brij Mohan Lal, AIR 1934 Lah 444 Maintenance obligation. Reinforced maintenance principles.
Savitri Bai v. Laxmi Bai, ILR 2 Bom 573 Maintenance duty of husband. Confirmed personal obligation to maintain.
Unnamali v. Wilson, AIR 1927 Mad 1187 Maintenance under Hindu law. Reaffirmed husband's obligation.
Shinnappayya v. Rajamma, AIR 1922 Mad 399 Maintenance principles. Supported husband's duty to maintain.
Arumuga Mudali v. Viraraghava Mudali, ILR 24 Mad 255 Home as husband's house; maintenance obligation while wife willing to reside. Confirmed husband's duty to maintain wife willing to reside with him.
Kondal Rayal Reddiar v. Ranganayaki Ammal, AIR 1924 Mad 49 Maintenance obligation linked to wife's residence willingness. Supported principle that wife quitting without cause forfeits maintenance.
Naganna v. Rajya Lakshmi Devi, AIR 1928 PC 187 No maintenance if wife leaves without cause or due to ordinary quarrels. Applied to deny maintenance where wife left without just cause.
Sidlingapa v. Sidava, ILR 2 Bom 634 Maintenance principles. Supported maintenance obligations.
Surampalli Bangaramma v. Surampalli Brambuze, ILR 31 Mad 338 Maintenance under Hindu law. Reinforced husband's duty.
Matangini v. Jagendra, ILR 19 Cal 84 Separate maintenance for cruelty, abandonment, or justifiable separation. Supported maintenance on grounds of husband's conduct or justifiable reasons.
Babu Ram v. Musammat Kokla, AIR 1924 All 391 Maintenance entitlement on justifiable grounds. Applied to uphold wife's right to maintenance in justified separation.
Sitajabai v. Ramachandra, 12 Bom LR 373 Maintenance on justifiable grounds. Supported wife's entitlement to maintenance.
Lajwanti v. Batchiram, AIR 1934 Lah 110 Maintenance principles. Reinforced entitlement on justified grounds.
Manilcya Bai v. Venkateswara, AIR 1951 Trav-C. 147 Maintenance entitlement. Supported wife's right to maintenance.
Seethayamma v. Venkataramana, AIR 1940 Mad 906 Maintenance for wife living apart for justifiable reasons. Applied to uphold maintenance claim.
Subba Rao, 45 Mys HCR 485 Maintenance principles. Supported maintenance entitlement.
Sajjanbai v. Prabhulal, AIR 1952 Madh B 140 Maintenance entitlement. Reinforced wife's right to maintenance.
Savitri v. Narayana, 1 Mad HC 372 Disqualification from maintenance due to unchastity. Applied to deny maintenance to immoral wife.
Debi Saran v. Daulata Shukhain, AIR 1917 All 86 Maintenance disqualification for immoral conduct. Supported denial of maintenance.
N. Subhayya v. Bhavani, AIR 1914 Mad 665 Maintenance disqualification for immoral wife. Applied to deny maintenance.
Jeevammal v. Ranganatha Mudaliar, AIR 1939 Mad 788 Wife's immoral conduct bars maintenance claim. Confirmed that husband need not prove wife's immorality at suit time if established earlier.
Kuppammal v. Thangamuthu, AIR 1944 Mad 426 Maintenance disqualification for immoral conduct. Supported denial of maintenance.
Manohari v. Ramchandra, AIR 1953 Raj 113 Maintenance principles. Reinforced maintenance denial for immoral wife.
Parami v. Mahadevi, ILR 34 Bom 278 Effect of repentance and expiation on maintenance rights of unchaste wife. Discussed but noted as not good law currently.
Valu v. Ganga, ILR 7 Bom 84 Denial of starving maintenance to unchaste wife. Applied to disallow starving maintenance.
Rama Raja Thevar v. Papammal, ILR 48 Mad 805 Unchastity disqualifies from maintenance, including concubines. Applied to deny maintenance to immoral women.
Dayavati v. Kesarbai, AIR 1934 Bom 66 Maintenance disqualification for immoral conduct. Supported denial of maintenance.
Nagubai v. Monghibai, AIR 1926 PC 73 Unchastity bars maintenance. Reinforced maintenance denial.
Sathyabhama v. Kesavacharya, AIR 1916 Mad 464 Exception for mothers: unchastity does not bar maintenance. Noted as exception to general rule.
England v. England, (1952) 2 All ER 784 Adultery proof by circumstantial evidence and strict standards. Applied principles of strict proof and circumstantial evidence.
Ginesi v. Ginesi, (1948) 1 All ER 373 Adultery as quasi-criminal offence requiring strict proof. Applied strict standard of proof for adultery.
Fairman v. Fairman, (1949) 1 All ER 938 Corroboration required for accomplice evidence in adultery cases. Applied requirement of corroboration for accomplice testimony.
Haji Saboo Siddick v. Ayeshhabai, ILR 27 Bom 485 Burden of proving unchastity lies on the party alleging it. Applied burden of proof principles.
Lakhmichand v. Anandi, AIR 1935 PC 180 Burden and standard of proof for unchastity. Reinforced strict proof requirement.
Kista v. Amrithammal, AIR 1938 Mad 833 Right to rebut evidence in unchastity allegations. Ensured opportunity for rebuttal.
Barker v. Barker, AIR 1955 Madh-B 103 Standard of proof under Indian Divorce Act Section 10. Applied strict proof standards.
White v. White, AIR 1954 Pat 560 Proof standards for matrimonial offences. Reinforced strict proof requirement.
Dwarka Bai v. Nainan Mathews, AIR 1953 Mad 792 Proof of matrimonial offences. Supported strict proof standards.
Ramachandra v. Saraswati, AIR 1953 Punj 68 Proof requirements under matrimonial law. Applied strict proof principles.
Mrs. Thomas v. Mr. Thomas, AIR 1952 Punj 39 Proof standards in matrimonial offences. Reinforced strict proof standards.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the facts against established Hindu law principles and statutory provisions, particularly the Hindu Women's Rights to Separate Residence and Maintenance Act, 1946. It acknowledged the husband's personal obligation to maintain his wife but emphasized that this duty is forfeited if the wife leaves the matrimonial home without justifiable cause or pursues an immoral course of life. The Court reviewed the evidence presented, including letters, photographs, and witness testimonies, which established beyond reasonable doubt the plaintiff's immoral conduct during the period 1941 to 1946. It applied the strict standard of proof required for matrimonial offences, noting that adultery is generally proved by circumstantial evidence corroborated by other evidence. The Court rejected the plaintiff's contention that the husband must prove her immorality at the time of filing the suit, relying on precedents that a wife who leaves home for unchastity and persists in such conduct cannot claim maintenance. The Court found the plaintiff's evidence vague for other periods but sufficient for 1941-1946, leading to dismissal of her maintenance claim.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED THE APPEAL WITH COSTS, affirming the trial court's decision that the plaintiff wife, having left her husband's home for purposes of unchastity and persisted in immoral conduct, is not entitled to separate maintenance. The direct effect is that the plaintiff cannot claim maintenance or restitution of conjugal rights. No new precedent was established; the decision reinforces established principles that immorality and unjustified separation disentitle a wife from maintenance under Hindu law and the 1946 Act.

    Deivanai Achi v. Kasi Viswanathan Chettiar

    JUDGMENT

    1. This appeal is preferred against the decree and judgment of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge of Pudukotlai in O.S No. 215 of 1949. The plaintiff Deivanai Achi who sues for separate maintenance, past and future, against her husband Kasiviswanathan Chettiar impleaded as the first defendant and his brother Annamalai Chettiar, impleaded as the second defendant in the suit, was married to the first defendant on 8-7-1935; see the marriage invitation Ex. A-16. There is no dispute that this couple lived in accordance with the Nattukottai Chetty custom in separate quarters in the family house of the defendants between 1935 and 1937, Between 1937 and 1941 when the first defendant was in Arimalam the plaintiff wife does not seem to have lived with her husband. Then in 1941 when the first defendant left for Malaya and returned to India in 1946 and the plaintiff lived only in Arimalam.

    2. Then after the first defendant's return from foreign parts in 19-16 till the date of the institution of the suit the husband and wife have been living apart. It is the case for the wife that she has been throughout faithful to her husband and was always willing to reside with him but that without justifiable cause her husband failed and neglected to maintain her and in February 1949 he married a second wife and that therefore she has filed this suit for the above reliefs.

    3. On the other hand, the case for the first defendant husband is that even in the first period when the plaintiff was living with him she proved troublesome and a termagant wife, that she left for her parents' house in 1937 and did not return back to him, that she had become immoral and her carryings on constituted an open scandal, that in accordance with the practice in those parts scandalmongers pasted wall-posters proclaiming the conduct of the wife and the shame of the husband, that he left for foreign parts on that ground, that during his absence his wife was leading an immoral life by living in terms of illicit intimacy with D.W 1 Veerappa Chettiar of Puduvayal openly, that this brazen illicit intimacy is shown by the letters Exs. B-1 to B-9 and the photo Ex. B-10 and the admissions in plaintiff's cross-examination showing her close movements with D.W 1 like giving her watch to him for repairs and not getting it back, the commotion created by her sudden unaccompanied visit to Puduvayal, Veerappa Chettiar's place, etc.

    4. Then in regard to what happened after the return of the husband in 1946, we have the evidence of the first defendant examined as D.W 2, that she had started intimacy with one Thyagarajan, her family native physician's son, one Chinniah Asari, a goldsmith who keeps his smithy in the shed next to her house with one Balakrishnan Servai of Vennavalkudi and one Appuraman Chettiar between 1948, and 1947. D.W 2 is corroborated by D.W 3 who says that he has seen the plaintiff moving in a manner inconsistent with the decent manners of a wife with Appuraman Chettiar. The learned Sub-ordinate Judge who saw P.W 1 in the box states:

    “I may state that from the manner and method of her answers in the witness box and from her gestures and gesticulations while answering questions she appears to be a person fit further stage or the screen and not for family life as per the opinion of D.W 3 which he is stated to have communicated to D.W 2, also.”

    5. On this evidence the learned Sub-ordinate Judge came to the conclusion that the evidence regarding the immorality of this plaintiff for the first period between 1937 and 1941 is vague, that the evidence for the period between 1941 and 1946 has established beyond reasonable doubt the immorality of the plaintiff with Veerappa Chettiar D.W 1 and to which D.W 1 speaks and which is corroborated by other evidence as it should be and that the evidence regarding the third period after 1946 is vague and that in view of his finding that the plaintiff had been leading a life of immorality during the years 1341 to 1946 after her husband left for foreign parts; the plaintiff was not entitled to the reliefs asked for by her. He therefore dismissed the suit with costs. Hence this appeal by the defeated plaintiff.

    6. The maintenance of a wife by her husband is of course a matter of personal obligation which attached from the moment of marriage. It is a liability created by the Hindu Law in respect of the jural relationship of husband and wife and is not an obligation arising out of a contract. This obligation to maintain exists independently of the possession of property, ancestral or separate. Jayanti Subbiah…(Plaintiff), v. Alamelu Mangamma…(Defendant), .*, ILR 27 Mad 45 (A); Narbadabai v. Mahadeo, ILR 5 Bom 99 (B); Appi Bai v. Khimji, ILR 60 Bom 455 : (AIR 1936 Bom 138) (C); Radhabai v. Gopal, AIR 1944 Bom 50 at page 52 (D); Venkatapati v. Puttama, (1936) 71 Mad LJ 499 : (AIR 1936 Mad 609) (E); Rattamma v. Seshachalam, AIR 1927 Mad 502 (F); Indira Bai v. Makarand, AIR 1931 Nag 197 (G); Lachmi Singh… v. Brij Mohan Lal…Opposite Party., AIR 1934 Lah 444 (1) (H); Savitri Bai v. Laxmi Bai, ILR 2 Bom 573 (FB) (I); Lakshmi 1925 MJ 57 (Sic.); Unnamali v. Wilson, AIR 1927 Mad 1187 (J); Shinnappayya v. Rajamma, 43 Mad LJ 174 : (AIR 1922 Mad 399) (K).

    7. As soon as the wife has matured, her home is necessarily her husband's house. (Arumuga Mudali…(Plaintiff) v. Viraraghava Mudali…(Defendant) .*, ILR 24 Mad 255 (L); Kondal Rayal Reddiar v. Ranganayaki Ammal, ILR 46 Mad 791 : (AIR 1924 Mad 49) (M). He is bound to maintain her in it while she is willing to reside with him. If she quits him of her own accord either without cause or on account of ordinary quarrels as are incidental to married life in general, she can set up no claim to separate maintenance. Naganna v. Rajya Lakshmi Devi, 55 Mad LJ 242 : AIR 1928 PC 187 (N); Sidlingapa v. Sidava, ILR 2 Bom 634 (O); Surampalli Bangaramma v. Surampalli Brambuze, ILR 31 Mad 338 (P).

    8. But if on account of cruelty or abandonment or where the husband for reasons of his own chooses to put his wife away from him or the wife lives away from her husband for justifiable reasons, she can be awarded separate maintenance. Matangini v. Jagendra, ILR 19 Cal 84 (Q); Babu Ram…(Plaintiff); v. Musammat Kokla…(Defendant).*, ILR 46 All 210 : (AIR 1924 All 391) (R); Sitabai v. Ramachandra, 12 Bom LR 373 (S); Lajwanti v. Batchiram, AIR 1934 Lah 110 (Sic); Manilcya Bai v. Venkateswara, AIR 1951 Trav-C. 147 (T); Seethayamma v. Venkataramana, (1940) 2 Mad LJ 276 : (AIR 1940 Mad 906) (U); Subba Rao, 45 Mys HCR 485 (V); Sajjanbai v. Prabhulal, AIR 1952 Madh B 140 (W).

    9. In short it may be said that the grounds which would be available to a wife for restitution of conjugal rights would also entitle her to live apart from her husband and claim separate maintenance.

    10. Under Section 2 of the Hindu Women's Rights to Separate Residence and Maintenance Act, 1946, which came into operation on 23-4-1946, a Hindu married woman is entitled to separate residence and maintenance from her husband on one or more of the grounds specified therein.

    11. Before the said Act the circumstance of a man taking another wife even without any justifying cause did not by itself entitle the wife to leave her husband's home so long as the husband was willing to keep her there. Under this Act the wife has become entitled to separate maintenance if the husband had married again.

    12. The law has always been that a wife who leaves her home for the purpose of unchastity and persists in following a vicious course of life cannot claim to be maintained or to be taken back. Savitri v. Narayana, 1 Mad HC 372 (X); Debi Saran v. Daulata Shukhain, ILR 39 All 234 : (AIR 1917 All 86) (Y); N. Subhayya…Plaintiff v. Bhavani…Defendant ., 24 Ind Cas 390 : (AIR 1914 Mad 665) (Z); Kandaswamy v. Murugammal, ILR 19 Mad 6 (Z1). A wife who has sued for maintenance on the ground that she was a chaste woman and that she had to leave her husband owing to his conduct is not entitled when the husband proves her vicious course of life to claim maintenance on the ground that the husband should also prove that she was leading an immoral life when she filed the suit. Jeevammal v. Ranganatha Mudaliar, ((1939) 2 Mad LJ 294 : (AIR 1939 Mad 788) (Z2); Kuppammal v. Thangamuthu, (1944) 1 Mad LJ 327 : (AIR 1944 Mad 426) (Z3); Manohari v. Ramchandra, 1952 RLW 300 : (AIR 1953 Raj 113) (Z4).

    13. Semble, if she repents, returns to purity and performs expiatory rites does she become entitled to all the conjugal and social life unless her adultery is with a man of lower Caste in which case after expiation she can claim no more than bare or starving maintenance and residence. This was the observation of Chandavarkar, J., in Parami v. Mahadevi, ILR 34 Bom 278 (Z5), but it does not seem now to be good law, because as pointed out in Gupte's Hindu Law, Second Edition, page 1060:

    “It is well established that a wife who has been unchaste (whether she is living with the husband or apart from him) loses her right to maintenance; but it is not yet decided whether where she wholly renounces her immoral conduct she should be allowed starving maintenance.”

    14. (This request to starving maintenance was disallowed by the Bombay High Court in Valu v. Ganga, ILR 7 Bom 84 (Z6). See the guarded language of Mulla's Hindu Law 11th Edn. edited by Shri B.K Mukherjea late Chief Justice, Supreme Court in S. 556 “it would seem”).

    15. In fact our court has gone to the extent that a wife who is unchaste or who leaves her husband's home for improper purposes forfeits her right to maintenance even though it is secured by a decree. ILR 19 Mad 6 (Z1). This is in accordance also with what our ancient writers have held. Manu Ch. IX—80 to 82 says that a wife who is immoral may be superseded or deserted. Yagnayavalkya and Vignaneswara authorise desertion where a wife is guilty of unchastity.

    16. The disqualification of unchastity for maintenance even applies to other categories of women also like concubines (Avarudhas three); Rama Raja Thevar v. Papammal, ILR 48 Mad 805 : (AIR 1925 Mad 1230) (Z7); Dayavati v. Kesarbai, AIR 1934 Bom 66 (Z8); Nagubai v. Monghibai, AIR 1926 PC 73 : ILR 50 Bom 604 (Z9); Sathyabhama v. Kesavacharya, ILR 39 Mad 658 at p. 660 : (AIR 1916 Mad 464 at p. 465) (Z10), only in the case of a mother due to close and tender relations that exist between her and her son is placed on a different footing and unchastity does not deprive her of her right to maintenance, J. Bhattacharya in his Hindu Law deduces the proposition from the texts of Baudhayana, (II-2-3-42) Apastamba (I-X-28-9) and Gautama (XXI-15); ILR 7 Bom 84 (Z6); ILR 39 Mad 658 : AIR 1916 Mad 464 : 29 Mad LJ 87 (Z10), where there are observations that the case of a mother is an exception to the general rule that unchastity disqualifies a woman for maintenance.

    17. Adultery may be proved in various ways. Direct proof is very rare and even if produced, the Court will look upon it with disfavour, as it is highly improbable that any person could be a witness to such acts, as they are generally performed with the utmost secrecy. In fact direct evidence would normally be required to be corroborated by circumstantial evidence. Adultery is as a general rule, proved by presumptive proof based on: (a) Circumstantial evidence; (b) evidence as to non-access and the birth of children; (c) contracting venereal disease, (d) by evidence of visits to houses of ill-re-pute, (e) decrees and admissions made in previous proceedings, and (f) confessions and admissions of the parties; see the Law and Practice of Divorce by Manchanda, page 47.

    18. Proof of a matrimonial offence is as strict as that required in criminal proceedings. It is not, however, necessary to adduce direct evidence in order to prove adultery. There would be no protection for the wronged spouse if the rule were otherwise, as such evidence rarely exists. The fact that adultery has taken place is inferred in almost every case from all the surrounding circumstances., such as undue familiarities, confessions and admissions, suspicious circumstances, improper behaviour, compromising letters, association coupled with opportunity, inclination and opportunity etc., England v. England, (1952) 2 All ER 784 : (1953) P. 16 (Z11); Ginesi v. Ginesi, (1948) 1 All ER 373 : (1948) P. 179 (Z12); Gower v. Gower, (1950) 1 All ER 804 : (1950) WN 156 (Z13).

    19. But the evidence must go beyond establishing suspicion and opportunity to commit adultery and must be such as to satisfy the court that from the nature of things adultery must have been committed; where the evidence is entirely circumstantial the Court will not draw the inference of guilt unless the facts relied on are not reasonably capable of any other explanation. The evidence of an accomplice like D.W 1 here must be corroborated; Fairman v. Fairman, (1949) 1 All ER 938 : (1949) P. 341 (Z14); Galler v. Galler, (1954) 1 All ER 536 : (1954) P. 252 (Z15); See Tolstoy's Divorce Law and Practice, Second Edition, page 24; Latey on Divorce 14th Edn. S. 149 page 77; Phillips Divorce Practice, Fourth Edn. P. 16.

    20. Rayden on Divorce, Fifth Edition, page 90, note (a) has the following to say:

    “(1948) 1 All ER 373, C.A (Z12), applying dictum of Lord Merriman P., in Churchman v. Churchman, (1945) P. 44 at p. 51 : (1945) 2 All ER 190, at P. 195, C.A (Z16); “The same strict proof is required in a case of matrimonial offence as is required in connection with criminal offences properly so called.”

    21. In Ginesi v. Ginesi (Z12) (Supra) Tucker L.J, cited with approval the words of Hodson, J., in the Court below Ginesi v. Ginesi, (1947) 2 All ER 438 : (1947) WN 248 (Z17), in which he described adultery as a ‘quasi-criminal offence’; but note that the, dictum of Lord Merriman, P., is not limited to cases of adultery, although he was in fact dealing with a case of connivance at adultery. See also Blunt v. Park Lane Hotel Ltd., (1942) 2 KB 253 : (1942) 2 All ER 187 (Z18). The C.A in Ginesi v. Ginesi, (supra) expressly limited their decision to cases of adultery, and left for future consideration whether the same standard applies to other matrimonial offences.” (See also Bater v. Bater, (1950) 2 All ER 458 : (1951) P. 35 (Z19); Preston Jones v. Preston Jones, (1951) 1 All ER 124 : (1951) AC 391 (Z20).

    22. The case law in India is also the same namely that, imputation of unchastity to any person being a serious charge it must be specifically set up and clearly established, general averments are insufficient and a court should not base its findings on mere suspicious, loose talk tittle-tattle or gossip. The burden, of proving unchastity is on the person setting up. Haji Saboo Siddick v. Ayeshhabai, ILR 27 Bom 485 (Z21); Lakhmichand v. Anandi, AIR 1935 PC 180 : ILR 57 All 672 : 69 Mad LJ 380 (Z22); Soundrarajaswami In Re. 2 Weir 647 (Z23); Jodhan Sahu… v. Mt. Kulwanti Kuer…Opposite Party., 49 Crl LJ 323 : (AIR 1948 Pat 285) (Z24). The wife must always be given an opportunity of adducing rebutting evidence. Kista v. Amrithammal, 39 Cr. LJ 951 : (AIR 1938 Mad 833) (Z25). See following decisions regarding standard of proof under Section 10 of the Indian Divorce Act of 1869; Barker v. Barker, AIR 1955 Madh-B 103 (FB) (Z26); White v. White, AIR 1954 Pat 560 (Z27); Dwarka Bai v. Nainan Mathews, AIR 1953 Mad 792 (Z28); Ramachandra v. Saraswati, AIR 1953 Punj 68 (SB) (Z29); Mrs. Thomas v. Mr. Thomas, AIR 1952 Punj 39 (FB) (Z30).

    23. Bearing these principles in mind if we examine the facts of this case, we find that it has been established beyond reasonable doubt that this plaintiff has left her husband's home for purposes of unchastity and persisted in following a vicious course of life and it is idle on her part to contend that the husband should also prove that she was leading an immoral life when she filed the suit and therefore she cannot claim to be maintained or to be taken back by her husband. The appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

    H.G.P

    24. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Deivanai Achi v. Kasi Viswanathan Chettiar
    (Nov 20, 1956)