AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 117 of the Etates Land Act: see Exs. A-5 and A-14.
  • provisions of Section 117 of the Estates Land Act.
  • Article 12 of the Indian Limitation Act
  • Section 3 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882,
  • Madras Estates Land Act) Satyanarayana
  • Section 10 of the Indian Trusts Act
  • Section 93 of the CPC, or Section 14
  • Article 144 of the Limitation Act
  • Article 95 of the Limitation Act.
  • Section 59 of the I.T Act 1882
  • Section 64 of the I.T Act.
  • Indian Trusts Act, S. 63.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 117 of the Etates Land Act: see Exs. A-5 and A-14.
  • provisions of Section 117 of the Estates Land Act.
  • Article 12 of the Indian Limitation Act
  • Section 3 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882,
  • Madras Estates Land Act) Satyanarayana
  • Section 10 of the Indian Trusts Act
  • Section 93 of the CPC, or Section 14
  • Article 144 of the Limitation Act
  • Article 95 of the Limitation Act.
  • Section 59 of the I.T Act 1882
  • Section 64 of the I.T Act.
  • Indian Trusts Act, S. 63.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Ramaswami, J. (Appeal from Sub-ordinate Judge of Mayuram in O.S. No. 77 of 1951)

Factual and Procedural Background

Muhammad Abdul Kadir Malumiar (the settlor) executed a wakf (private trust) on 19-11-1918 comprising land (Ac.12.80 cents near Nagore), part of a house (door No. 3 in Nagore Town), and cooking vessels. The wakf provided for two annual charitable feedings (a Mouluth and a Mohurram feeding), required reserving one year's funds in poor crop years, and directed that three-quarters of net income from the lands be spent on the trust with one-quarter distributed among the settlor's santhathi (descendants). Trustees initially included the settlor's eldest son (first defendant) and his sons-in-law (second defendant), with subsequent trusteeship capable of passing to other male santhathi subject to conditions; the deed prohibited alienation and gifting.

During the settlor's life the wakf obligations were performed. After his death the plaintiff (a son of the settlor, and in line to be a trustee) alleged that defendants 1 and 2 colluded with the sixth defendant to allow arrears to accrue, resulting in a revenue sale in 1939 whereby most of the wakf property was sold at a grossly undervalued price (Rs. 401/-). Defendants 1 and 2 then purported to privately sell remaining wakf properties to the auction-purchaser (Haja Abdul Hameed), who later purportedly made a wakf of his purchased properties. The plaintiff filed suit in 1951 (pauper form), alleging fraudulent alienations, seeking relief on behalf of the wakf and asserting the suit was not barred by Section 10 of the Indian Trusts Act and was instituted within a year of learning of the alienations.

The Sub-ordinate Judge found for the plaintiff on multiple issues, declaring large parts of the schedules to be trust property, setting aside the revenue sale as void for fraud and collusion, and decreeing recovery of possession on behalf of the trust (with specified exclusions and cost directions). Defendants 3 and 4 (the defeated parties) appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Did the whole of B, D and E Schedule properties belong to Muhammad Abdul Kadir Malumiar (the wakf)?
  2. Is the sale in E.P. No. 27 of 1938 (Sub-Collector's Court revenue sale) liable to be set aside for the reasons set out in the plaint?
  3. Was the C Schedule property not liable to be sold by the Revenue Court?
  4. Is the sale of D and E Schedule properties to the third defendant's husband by defendants 1 and 2 valid and binding on the trust?
  5. Has the plaintiff the right to sue?
  6. Is the suit, as framed, unsustainable?
  7. Is the suit in time (limitation)?
  8. Is the suit barred under Section 47 of the CPC?
  9. Is the suit barred under Section 92 of the CPC?
  10. To what relief is the plaintiff entitled?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The wakf created by Muhammad Abdul Kadir Malumiar was valid, included the properties listed in the plaint schedules, and the charitable objects (periodic feedings of the poor) are valid wakf purposes.
  • Defendants 1 and 2 colluded with the sixth defendant to permit arrears to accrue and to cause a fraudulent revenue sale in 1939, by which wakf property was sold at a gross undervaluation (Rs. 401/-) and thereby the sale is null and void.
  • Defendants 1 and 2 further alienated remaining wakf properties by private sale contrary to the wakf deed's prohibition on alienation.
  • The plaintiff is a beneficiary and an heir capable of being appointed trustee and therefore has the right to sue on behalf of the trust; recovery of possession would be on behalf of the trust.
  • The suit is not barred by limitation (reliance on Article 144 and, alternatively, Article 95) and was filed within a year of plaintiff's knowledge of the fraudulent alienations (plaintiff alleged he only learned while suffering from mental illness).
  • The plaintiff sought relief for recovery of possession and declaratory relief that the relevant properties belong to the wakf and are not affected by the sale.

Appellants' (Defendants 3 & 4) Principal Arguments

  • The appeal pressed three main points before the High Court: (1) that the plaintiff was not entitled to maintain the suit; (2) that the revenue sale was properly held and could not be set aside; and (3) that the suit was barred by limitation (Article 12 of the Limitation Act was relied on).
  • They challenged the validity of the plaintiff's claim to sue and the correctness of the lower court's factual findings (as reflected in the issues raised in the trial court).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Baillie (1) 550 Supports that feeding the poor is a valid wakf object. Cited as authority that poor feeding is a valid object of a wakf when describing the wakf's charitable purpose.
Hidaya 240 Islamic law text cited for validity of charitable feeding as wakf object. Used to support that the wakf's provisions for poor feeding were valid under Muslim law.
Fatma Bibi v. Advocate-General of Bombay, ILR 6 Bom 42 Illustration that certain charitable acts are valid wakf objects. Referenced as authority for the validity of the wakf's charitable object.
Assoobai v. Noorbal, 8 Bom LR 245 Authority on wakf objects and validity under Muslim law. Cited to support characterization of the dedication as a valid wakf.
Keetyan v. Ravuthan, ILR 35 Bom 681 Authority on wakf validity. Referred to in support of the wakf's validity.
Ahmed v. Julaiha Bivi, (1946) 2 Mad LJ 335; AIR 1947 Mad 176 Authority on Muslim wakf principles and treatment under law. Used to show similar treatment of wakf dedications and to support conclusions about the wakf's nature.
Vasudeva Rao v. G.K. Rangai, AIR 1952 Mad 650 Madras High Court authority on wakf/related trust principles. Cited among authorities confirming the wakf characterization and legal consequences.
Abdur Rahim v. Narayan Das, ILR 50 Cal 329; AIR 1923 PC 44 Authority on wakf/Trust principles and consequences of unauthorized alienation. Cited to support the proposition that wakf property and trust principles permit recovery from third persons and that an unlawful alienation is void.
Mahommed Ahsanulia v. Amar Chand, ILR 17 Cal 498 Precedent on wakf/ trust matters. Listed as supporting authority for treatment of wakf property.
Abdul Fata v. Rasamaya, ILR 22 Cal 619 Authority on wakf/trust law. Referenced among authorities confirming wakf principles.
Alima Ammal v. Mohammed Hussain Marcair, Appeal No. 198 of 1946 (dated 27-3-1951) Case involving a similar wakf by a Malumier (East Tanjore). Referred to as a directly comparable decision on similar facts and wakf structure.
Debendra Nath v. Sheikh Safatulla, AIR 1927 Cal 130 Mutawalli (manager) alone can institute a suit for recovery of wakf property; mutawalli can maintain suit for possession though property may not vest in him. Cited to explain who is entitled to sue in relation to wakf property and to frame the scope of beneficiary vs. trustee remedies.
Ashraf Ali v. Mahomed Nurnjjamma, 23 Cal WN 115; AIR 1919 Cal 179 Representative suit by worshipers to set aside alienation by mutawalli is maintainable even without certain statutory sanctions. Used to support the proposition that beneficiaries/worshipers may maintain representative suits to set aside alienations by trustees.
Noor Mohammad v. Karima Bibi, 27 Mad LJ 270; AIR 1915 Mad 687 Authority that beneficiaries/worshipers may sue to challenge alienations. Cited to support the maintenance of suits by beneficiaries.
Afiman v. Hammiduddin Husain, 58 PWRN 1919; 51 Ind Cas 799; AIR 1919 Lah 190 Unlawful alienation of wakf property may be reversed and property restored to the trust. Invoked to show that courts can restore trust property when alienation was unauthorized.
Mahomed Ghouse v. Sheik Moideen, 18 MLT 48; AIR 1915 Mad 1044 Authority on recovery of wakf property from third persons under certain circumstances. Used to support the remedy of recovery of wakf property from third parties.
Hamiduddin v. Court of Wards, Nanpara, 18 Ind Cas 319 (Oudh) Authority on restoration/recovery of trust property. Cited in the survey of authorities showing available remedies for unlawful alienation.
Ahmed Kutty v. Ayithraman Kutty, 1937-2 Mad LJ 301; AIR 1937 Mad 819 Summary of principles regulating suits in relation to trust properties — trustee's primary competence to sue; exceptions where beneficiaries may sue. Quoted by the court to articulate the general principles governing who may institute suits for trust/wakf property.
Rengaswami Naidu v. Krishnaswami Aiyar, 44 Mad LJ 116; AIR 1923 Mad 276 Where no trustee exists, court may direct delivery of possession to worshipers on behalf of trust; beneficiaries may sue for declaration/injunction. Applied to explain that beneficiaries may in appropriate circumstances obtain possession or declaratory relief for the trust.
Mahammad Jafar v. Taqi, AIR 1933 Oudh 517 Hanafi rule that wakf property ceases to be human ownership applied even to wakf for descendants. Referenced to underline general principles of wakf property and enforcement rights of interested persons.
Kazi Hassan v. Balakrishna, ILR 24 Bom 170 Any person interested in the objects of a wakf may institute suit to set aside alienation and enforce wakf provisions. Used to support that interested persons have standing to challenge alienations.
Ahmad Shah v. Atfa Khan, AIR 1934 Pesh 57 Transfer by mutawalli without authority is void and constitutes breach of trust; mutawalli may be removed. Cited to support that unauthorized transfers are void and trustees may be removed for breach of trust.
Shama Churn Roy v. Abdul Kabir, 3 Cal WN 158 Authority on consequences of unauthorized transfer by manager/managerial breach. Used with other cases to demonstrate that unauthorized alienations are void.
Mahim Jan Bibi v. Mir Rahim, AIR 1925 Cal 435 Illustration that mutawalli's unauthorized alienation is void and a breach of trust. Relied on to reinforce the principle invalidating unauthorized transfers by a trustee.
Jabeda v. Mohammed Mozaffar Ali, AIR 1926 Cal 322 Authority on invalidity of unauthorized alienations by a mutawalli. Included among authorities supporting voidness of unauthorized transfers.
Badal v. Tinkori, 41 Ind Cas 736; AIR 1918 Cal (804) Case on unauthorized alienation and consequences. Used as supporting precedent in the discussion of unauthorized transfers by trustees.
Abdur Rahim v. Narayan Das (repeated), ILR 50 Cal 329; 44 Mad LJ 624; AIR 1923 PC 44 Authority that unauthorized alienations may be set aside; discussed earlier and reiterated here. Referred to again as corroboration for the invalidity of the mutawalli's alienation.
Abdul Rajak v. Ali Baksh, AIR 1946 Lah 200 Authority on trustee's unauthorized transfer and breach of trust consequences. Cited among other cases to support legal principles on breach and consequences.
Venkateswarlu v. Veeraswami, ILR (1947) Mad 28; AIR 1946 Mad 461 Madras decision supporting application of Article 144 (Limitation) to similar circumstances. Used to justify that Article 144, not Article 12, governs suits of this character where the plaintiff is not bound by the sale.
Satyanarayana v. Ramaineedi Rayalamma, AIR 1943 Mad 501 Case under Madras Estates Land Act relevant to limitation and setting aside sales. Relied on to show that Article 144 is the proper article in such circumstances.
Lakshmadu v. Ramudu, AIR 1939 Mad 867; ILR (1940) Mad 123 Madras authority on limitation and applicability of Article 144 in revenue-sale contexts. Cited as supporting precedent for application of Article 144.
Venkata Narsiah v. Subbamma, ILR 4 Mad 178 Authority regarding limitation and revenue sale matters. Included as support for adoption of Article 144 in the present case.
Rupa Jagshet v. Krishnaji Govind, ILR 9 Bom 169 Case illustrating application of limitation principles (Article 144 context). Referred to among authorities showing Article 144's applicability.
Nazar Ali v. Kedarnath, ILR 19 All 308 Authority on limitation and sales affecting third parties. Cited in the group of authorities supporting Article 144 application.
Bulaki Das v. Kesari, AIR 1928 All 363; ILR 50 All 686 All-India jurisdiction case on limitation principles applicable to sales. Used as authority in the court's limitation analysis.
Mulkh Raj v. Nanak, AIR 1933 Lah 10 Punjab/Lahore decision relevant to limitation issues. Referred to in the list of authorities applying Article 144 in similar circumstances.
Purnachandra Chatterjee v. Dinabandu, ILR 34 Cal 811 Calcutta precedent on limitation applicable to disputes over sales. Included among authorities showing Article 144 is appropriate.
Ghanasayan Chaudhary v. Bas & Co., 60 Ind Cas 529 (Patna) Patna precedent on limitation/sale issues. Listed as part of supporting authorities for the limitation conclusion.
Khairajmal v. Daim, 32 Ind App 23 Privy Council/appeal authority on limitation/sale matters. Used to buttress the court's choice of Article 144.
Ramabai Govind Gadre v. Raghunath Vasudeo Joshi, AIR 1952 Bom 106 Bombay decision on limitation in context of sales. Included in the court's survey to justify Article 144's application.
Maharaj Singh v. Budhu Chamar, AIR 1952 Pat 46 Patna decision invoked on limitation principles. Referenced among multiple authorities supporting Article 144 application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court reviewed the facts, evidence and the law and reached three principal conclusions (matching the main points pressed on appeal): (1) the plaintiff was entitled to maintain the suit; (2) the revenue sale was not properly held and was impeachable on grounds of fraud and collusion; and (3) the suit was within time under Article 144 of the Limitation Act. The detailed reasoning is summarized below.

1. Maintainability — Plaintiff's Right to Sue

The court found no doubt that the plaintiff could maintain the suit. It reasoned from the wakf deed (Ex. A-1) that the plaintiff is a beneficiary (entitled to the surplus one-fourth) and was within the class of persons who could be appointed trustee during the lifetime of the original trustees. The court surveyed authorities (including Debendra Nath and Ahmed Kutty and others) to state the settled principles: while a lawful trustee (mutawalli) is ordinarily the person competent to institute suits for trust property, beneficiaries or worshipers who are interested may sue to preserve trust property or restore it where the trustee has alienated it improperly or refuses to act. The court held the plaintiff was more than a mere worshiper — he was a beneficiary and potential trustee — and therefore clearly entitled to maintain the suit, though any recovery of possession would be on behalf of the trust.

2. Fraud and Collusion — Validity of the Revenue Sale

On the question whether the revenue sale (E.P. No. 27 of 1938 / sale certificate Ex. B-11 dated 5-7-1939) was void, the court accepted the findings of the Sub-ordinate Judge that the sale was the product of collusion and fraud between defendants 1 & 2 and the auction-purchaser (Haja Abdul Hameed). The court's factual and inferential analysis included:

  • Documentary and oral evidence (accepted by the trial court) showed the lands produced substantial paddy yield (about 130 kalams annually) and, after customary dues, provided ample surplus to perform the wakf charities; yet arrears were permitted to accrue.
  • Defendants 1 and 2 did not testify and remained ex parte, and they made no attempt to set aside the sale, despite being in a position to do so — a circumstance consistent with collusion.
  • The sale was conducted without compliance with mandatory formalities of the Madras Estates Land Act (Section 117): no prior Gazette publication was made as required, the appointment of a selling officer was absent, and publication was belated (after sale), supporting the conclusion the sale was held in a "hole-and-corner" fashion.
  • The sale price (Rs. 401/-) was grossly inadequate given contemporaneous statements of value (Rs. 5,000/-) and the known income; the mismatch was treated as significant evidence of collusion.
  • Subsequent private sale (Ex. B-29) by defendants 1 and 2 of remaining wakf property, despite express prohibition in the deed, further corroborated bad faith and breach of trust.
  • Collectively, the circumstances permitted the inference of fraudulent design even though direct proof of the auction-purchaser's collusion was secretive; the court emphasized that fraud may be inferred from cumulative circumstances.

On these grounds the court agreed with the trial court that the revenue sale was null and void from the beginning and liable to be set aside as affecting the wakf's interests.

3. Limitation

The appellants argued that Article 12 of the Limitation Act applied and barred the suit. The court disagreed: it explained that Article 12 applies to suits to set aside sales that are binding on the plaintiff unless set aside. Here, the court concluded the plaintiff was not bound by the revenue sale either because he was not a party to the decree/proceeding or because the sale itself was null and void for want of jurisdiction and compliance with mandatory provisions. The court therefore held Article 144 to be the proper article (as supported by a string of Madras and other decisions cited), and found the suit to be within time under Article 144. The court considered, but did not finally decide, the possible application of Article 95 (because it found Article 144 sufficient).

4. Remedies, Decree Modification and Accounting

While confirming the trial court's conclusions on the principal issues, the High Court considered practical and equitable adjustments to the decree. It directed that, before the plaintiff obtains the decree on behalf of the trust:

  • The plaintiff should be made liable to reimburse the legal representatives of Haja Abdul Hameed an amount of Rs. 401/- (the purchase money) as part of the adjustments;
  • The plaintiff should account for interest and mesne profits up to the date of suit;
  • The legal representatives of Haja Abdul Hameed may establish in execution the value of improvements they allege to have effected; such value may be set off against mesne profits subsequent to the date of suit, with any balance remaining liable to the plaintiff on behalf of the trust;
  • The decree should correct an agreed error in acreage described in Ex. B-2 (from Ac. 2-19 cents to Ac. 2-67 cents); and
  • Credit should be given for amounts spent by the 3rd defendant under the wakf for services prescribed by Ex. A-1 when assessing mesne profits prior to the lower court's decree.

The court directed immediate delivery of possession to the plaintiff on behalf of the trust and stated that questions of accounting need not await delivery of possession.

Holding and Implications

The court's final decision may be summarized as follows:

Core Ruling: The appeal is dismissed and the decree and judgment of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge are confirmed with modifications as detailed by the High Court (including reimbursement of Rs. 401 to the legal representatives of the auction purchaser, accounting for interest and mesne profits, allowance for improvements to be proved and set off, correction of acreage, and the decree for recovery of possession on behalf of the trust).

Implications and Direct Effects

  • The plaintiff (a beneficiary and potential trustee) may recover possession of the wakf properties on behalf of the trust.
  • The revenue sale of 1939 was declared null and void due to fraud and collusion; the trust's interest is treated as unaffected by that sale for purposes of this suit.
  • The plaintiff must reimburse the auction-purchaser's legal representatives the purchase consideration of Rs. 401/-, account for mesne profits and interest up to the date of suit, and permit the legal representatives to prove improvements for set-off in execution.
  • Costs and court-fees directions as recorded by the trial court and modified by the High Court shall be borne out of the estate as directed.
  • The decree's property-description is corrected in acreage as agreed by the parties (Ac. 2-67 cents instead of Ac. 2-19 cents for Ex. B-2).

The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle; it applies established principles of wakf/trust law, rules on parties' standing, fraud inference, and limitation (Article 144) to the facts of the case.

    Thangachi Nachial And Another v. Ahmed Hussain Malumiar And Others

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Ramaswami, J.:— This is an appeal preferred against the decree and judgment of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge of Mayuram in O.S No. 77 of 1951.

    2. The facts are:— Muhammad Abdul Kadir Malumiar created a private trust on 19-11-1918 i.e subsequent to the Mussalman Wakf Validations Act of 1913. The Wakf comprised of Ac. 12.80 cents of land near Nagore, portion of a house bearing door No. 3 in Nagore Town, and cooking vessels etc., mentioned in Wakf Deed. The trust was created for the purpose of meeting the expenses of a Mouluth to be performed in the month of Rabiulavul when 40 marakkals of rice should be cooked and distributed to relatives, friends and the poor and another Mouluth to be performed in the Mohurram month of each year in the Hussainia Moulathkhana belonging to the settlor when 25 marakkals of rice have to be cooked and distributed to poor muslims. This poor feeding is a valid object of a Wakf: Baillie (1) 550; Hidaya 240; Fatma Bibi v. Advocate-General of Bombay, ILR 6 Bom 42 (A); Assoobai v. Noorbal, 8 Bom LR 245 (B); Keetyan v. Ravuthan, ILR 35 Bom 681 (sic). The vessels were for use on those occasions and it is provided that at the time of the Mouluths the entire house referred to above was to be vacated by the persons occupying the portion. The expenses have to he met from out of the income of the lands after paying the melwaram due to the Nagore Durgah.

    3. The wakf deed also provided that ¾ the of the net income from the lands was to be spent for the trust, but, in order to provide for the due performance of the trust, in years when there may be a failure of crops, a reserve-fund was to be kept sufficient to enable the trust being performed, for one year; and, subject to the said provision being made for the regular performance of the charity every year, one-fourth of the income was to be “distributed among the founder's Santhathi, male and female.

    4. The first defendant, the eldest son of the dedicator, and the second defendant, his sons-in-law, were constituted trustees, but after them, or even during the life-time, any Santhathi of the settlor, who was a male, who was a proper person, and who was capable of performing the charity, could be the trustee. And, any trustee, who misconducted himself, could be removed from office, at the instance of a Santhathi of the settlor. There are other terms prohibiting alienation and gifting of the Wakf property and for building up of reserves.

    5. Thus this was a permanent dedication by a Muslim, of properties partially for the maintenance and support of his family children and descendants and for purposes recognized by Mussalman law — religious, pious or charitable. Ahmed v. Julaiha Bivi, (1946) 2 Mad LJ 335 : (AIR 1947 Mad 176) (176) (Patanjali Sastri and Bell JJ.); Vasudeva Rao v. G.K Rangai, A.S No. 92 of 1946: (AIR 1952 Mad) (650) High Court to which Govinda Menon, J. was a party); Abdur Rahim v. Narayan Das, ILR 50 Cal 329 at p. 334 : (AIR 1923 PC 44 (2) at pp. 45, 46) (E); Mahommed Ahsanulia v. Amar Chand, ILR 17 Cal 498 at p. 509 (PC) (F); Abdul Fata v. Rasamaya, ILR 22 Cal 619 (PC) (G); Alima Ammal v. Mohammed Hussain Marcair, Appeal No. 198 of 1946 (Govinda Menon and Chandra Reddi, JJ.) dated 27-3-1951 (H) where a similar wakf by a Malumier from East Tanjore came up for consideration.

    6. This Abdul Kadir Malumiar so long as he was alive was carrying out the terms of the wakf deed. Subsequently after his death, according to the plaintiff, what happened was as follows. The first and the second defendants colluding with the sixth defendant purposely allowed arrears of rent to the Nagore Durgah to accrue when the nanja lands were fetching 130 kalams of paddy as the tenants' share, and a fraudulent revenue sale was held in 1939 and the bulk of the properties even then worth about Rs. 5,000/- and now worth Rs. 15,000/- was sold for Rs. 401/-. This included a bungalow in item 1 and the tank which could not be sold for arrears under the Madras Estates Land Act.

    7. After the said revenue sale of the bulk of the properties, defendants 1 and 2 purported to convey by a private sale the remaining properties covered by the D and E Schedules to the plaint to the self-same auction purchaser viz., Haja Abdul Hameed Sahib. This Haja Abdul Hameed Sahib died four years ago and the third defendant is widow and legal representative. This Haja Abdul Hameed Sahib in his turn purported to make a wakf of the properties which he had purchased, prescribing similar celebrations and made the fourth defendant his trustee. The fifth defendant is the daughter of the first defendant who has purported to gift to her a portion of the house No. 3 as stridhanam on the occasion of her marriage in September 1946, entirely overlooking the terms of the wakf deed prohibiting any alienation or gift.

    8. In these circumstances the plaintiff, who is the son of the founder of the trust and is in the line of trustee appointed by the founder and interested in seeing that the properties are not lost to the trust and who is also a beneficiary of the surplus one-fourth which has to be distributed by the trustee amongst the heirs of the original founder, has filed this suit in 1951 in the pauper form alleging that on account of his suffering from mental illness he came to know of these alienations about one year prior to the filing of this suit, properties mentioned in B, C, D, E and F Schedules to the trust created by the plaintiff's father as per wakfnama dated 19-11-1918. The suit is stated to be not barred under Section 10 of the Indian Trusts Act and that even otherwise it had been instituted within a year of the plaintiffs knowledge of the fraudulent alienations.

    9. The contest raised by the contesting defendants is reflected in the following issues:

    1. Did the whole of B, D and E Schedule properties belong to Muhammad Abdul Kadir Malumiar?

    2. Is the sale in E.P No. 27 of 1938 on the file of the Sub-Collector's Court liable to be set aside for any of the reasons set out in the plaint?

    3. Was the C Schedule property not liable to be sold by the Revenue Court?

    4. Is the sale of D and E Schedule properties to the third defendant's husband by defendants 1 and 2 valid and binding on the trust?

    5. Has the plaintiff right to sue?

    6. Is the suit, as framed, unsustainable?

    7. Is the suit in time?

    8. Is the suit barred under Section 47 of the CPC.?

    9. Is the suit barred under Section 92 of the CPC.?

    10. To what relief is the plaintiff entitled?

    10. The learned Sub-ordinate Judge found under issue 1 that B, D and E Schedules belonged to the trust excluding Ac. 2-19 cents covered by Ex. B-2; under issue 2 that, as the revenue sale was due to the collusion and fraud between defendants 1 and 2 and Haja Abdul Hameed Sahib, the purchaser, and that as the revenue sale held has been shown to be null and void, the sale in E.P No. 27 of 1938 on the file of the Sub-Collector's Court was liable to be set aside for the reasons set out in the plaint; under issue 3 that the C Schedule property could not be sold by the revenue Court; under issue 4 that the private sale under Ex. B-29 was clearly invalid; under issue 5 that plaintiff was entitled to maintain the suit, though recovery of possession can be ordered only in favour of and on behalf of the trust and which position was accepted by the plaintiff; under issue 6 that the suit as framed is maintainable; under issue 7 that the suit is not barred as it is governed by Article 144 of the Limitation Act when the revenue sale in favour of Haja Abdul Hameed Sahib has been found to be invalid from the very beginning; under issue 8 that the suit is not barred under Section 47 of the CPC; under issue 9 that the suit is not barred under Section 92 of the CPC and under issue 10 that the plaintiff would be entitled to the following reliefs:

    “In the result, the suit is decreed in favour of the plaintiff, for recovery of possession, on behalf of the trust created under Ex. A-1 of the plaint B, C, D, E & F Schedule properties, excluding however, the properties (2 acres 19 cents) delivered under, covered by and specified in Ex. B-2, as against all the defendants. The plaintiff will have proportionate costs of suit from defendants 1 and 2 and the estate in the hands of defendants 3 and i. Defendants 1, 2 and 4 will pay the court fee payable on the plaint, proportionate to the success of the plaintiff, to the Government; and, the plaintiff, will pay the balance of court-fee due to the Government……….”

    11. The defeated defendants 3 and 4 have preferred this appeal.

    12. On a review of the entire circumstances of the case, we have come to the same conclusion as she learned Sub-ordinate Judge on all the three joints which were pressed before us viz., that the plaintiff is not entitled to maintain the suit; secondly, that the revenue sale was held properly and cannot be set aside; and thirdly, that the suit is barred by limitation. Here are our reasons.

    13. Point 1:— That the plaintiff can maintain the suit as it stands framed can admit of no doubt Whatsoever. Under the terms of Ex. A-1 the plaintiff is entitled to share in the surplus one-fourth remaining after the performance of the charities. Bo he is certainly a beneficiary within the meaning of Section 3 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882, i.e, one of the persons for whose benefit the confidence is accepted by the trustee from the author of the trust. Secondly, under the terms of Ex. A-1 during the lifetime of defendants 1 and 2, if there was a proper male issue of the founder capable of management, he can be a trustee.

    14. It follows therefore that if defendants 1 and 2 were to be removed from the trusteeship, which is the only possible result of our confirming the decree and judgment of the lower Court, this plaintiff would be entitled to become a trustee.

    15. The law relating to suits for recovery of waqf property has been summarised by K.P Saksena Muslim Law (Third Edition) (1954) as follows:

    “A worshiper can enforce his individual right in connection with a mosque, but he cannot sue for the recovery of an unauthorized alienation of wakf property; the mutawalli alone can have the right to institute a suit for its recovery: Debendra Nath v. Sheikh Safatulla, AIR 1927 Cal 130 (I). A Mutawalli can maintain a suit for recovery of possession of the wakf property against a trespasser although it does not vest in him.

    16. A representative suit by two worshipers to set aside an alienation by the mutawali is, however, maintainable even without the sanction under Section 93 of the CPC, or Section 14 of the Religious Endowments Act: Ashraf Ali v. Mahomed Nurnjjamma, 23 Cal WN 115 : (AIR 1919 Cal 179) (J); Noor Mohammad v. Karima Bibi, 27 Mad LJ 270 : (AIR 1915 Mad 687 (1)) (K). The wakf property may, like other trust properties be recovered from third persons under circumstances referred to in the Indian Trusts Act, S. 63.

    17. In case of an unlawful alienation or a mortgage of the mosque property by its manager, any person interested may seek remedy in a civil Court and restore the property to the trust, and the same is true also in case where wakf property is auctioned in execution of a decree not binding on the trust; Afiman v. Hammiduddin Husain, 58 PWRN 1919 : 51 Ind Cas 799 : (AIR 1919 Lah 190) (L); Mahomed Ghouse v. Sheik Moideen, 18 MLT 48 : (AIR 1915 Mad 1044) (M); Hamiduddin v. Court of Wards, Nanpara, 18 Ind Cas 319 (Oudh) (N).

    18. The principles which regulate the right to institute suits in relation to trust properties are well settled as pointed out by Venkataramana Rao, J. in Ahmed Kutty v. Ayithraman Kutty, 1937-2 Mad LJ 301 : (AIR 1937 Mad 819) (O). When there is a lawful trustee for an institution, he is the person competent to institute a suit in relation to the property of the institution, to take the necessary steps for safe-guarding and preserving it and to eject a trespasser and recover possession thereof for the trust, but the recovery of the property is only for and on behalf of the institution which he represents. But where a trustee has alienated the trust property and therefore would not proceed tox recover possession of the same or has disabled himself otherwise from maintaining a suit in respect thereof or declines to institute a suit, it cannot be said that the institution is without a remedy.

    19. The worshipers, who are the beneficiaries entitled to participate in the benefits of the institution, are entitled to maintain a suit for preserving the trust property or restoring the property to the trust either by instituting a suit for declaration or for an injunction or even for possession; but whether the worshipers are entitled to claim any or all of the reliefs which a trustee is entitled to do in a properly framed suit would depend upon the circumstances of each case.

    20. It is desirable and necessary to make the trustee a party to the suit, and where he is made a party it is open to the Court to would the relief as the circumstances may require. If the suit is one brought for possession by the worshipers, the Court can, after declaring the property to be trust property and setting aside the alienation, direct delivery of possession to the trustee. In cases where there is no trustee, it is open to the Court to direct delivery of possession to the worshipers on behalf of the trust: Rengaswami Naidu v. Krishna swami Aiyar, 44 Mad LJ 116 : (AIR 1923 Mad 276 (2) (P). Again, in certain circumstances it is competent to the worshipers to maintain an action for a declaration that a certain property is trust property and for an injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with their right of worship, which is a personal right, without making the trustee a party to the suit.

    21. This would not offend the principle that a trustee alone is competent to maintain a suit to eject a trespasser; See Kuvarbai v. Mir Alam Khan, ILR 7 Bom 170 (Q). Even a worshiper can recover possession of trust properties on behalf of the trust so that when proper proceedings are instituted for the management of the trust property and a trustee is appointed, he might hand over possession to the trustee. The general principle applicable to Muslim Wakf is the same as that applicable to the property of a Hindu idol. The rule of Hanafi Law that wakf property is taken to have ceased to be held in human ownership is applied to all such property even if the wakf be a waki al-al-aulad or wakf for the benefit of the descendants: Mahammad Jafar v. Taqi, AIR 1933 Oudh 517 (R). So when a waqf property is unlawfully alienated any person interested in the objects of the waqf may institute a suit to set aside the alienation and for the enforcement of the provisions of the waqf: Kazi Hassan v. Balakrishna, ILR 24 Bom 170 (S).

    22. In this case the plaintiff is not a mere worshiper but an actual beneficiary interested in the trust and what is more an heir entitled to be appointed under the terms of the trust deed as a trustee in certain circumstances. Therefore, this plaintiff is clearly entitled to maintain the suit, though any recovery of possession ordered in his favour can only be on behalf of the trust. The beneficiary's right to sue embodied in Section 59 of the I.T Act 1882 is an illustration of the maxim “A trust shall not fail for want of a trustee”: Halsbury's Laws of England Hailsham edition Vol. XXXIII Pages 134-135 and authorities cited therein; Lewin on Trusts 14th Edition p. 723.

    23. Turning to the other branch of the argument, it is not necessary that a representative suit should be filed with the permission of the Court under O. 1, R. 8 of the CPC. The plaintiff himself can file a suit and recover possession on behalf of the trust. In Maulvi Muhammad Fahimul Haq v. Jagat Ballay Ghosh, ILR 2 Pat 391 : (AIR 1923 Pat 475) (T), which was a case of Muhammadan wakf, it was held that the beneficiary of a trust, in respect of a Muhammadan wakf, interested in the maintenance of a mosque or other charitable institution, may, without having recourse to O. 1, R. 8 of the CPC, and without suing in a representative capacity, on behalf of the other beneficiaries, sue for recovery of possession of property, wrongfully alienated by the trustee, and for the incidental declaration that the properties are the subject of the trust and that they cannot be alienated.

    24. The beneficiary has the right under Section 59 of the I.T Act subject to the provision of the instrument of trust that the trust property shall be properly protected and held and under S. 63 follow the trust property into the hands of third persons. The savings of the rights of transferees are embodied in Section 64 of the I.T Act. Therefore point 1 has been rightly decided in favour of the plaintiff.

    25. Point 2: This rent sale has undoubtedly been brought about by fraud and collusion between defendants 1 and 2 and the sixth defendant and was a regular hole-and-corner affair without observing the mandatory provisions of Section 117 of the Estates Land Act. These are proved by the following circumstances. The lands in question, nanja and punja with a building and tank, were undoubtedly fetching on an average 130 kalams per year: see Exs. B-31 and B-27 and the evidence of D.W 4. Defendants 1 and 2 have not gone into the box to give their own version regarding the income from the properties.

    26. On these lands the melwaram of 42 kalams was payable to the Nagore Durgah and 10 kalams to the Perumal temple. Therefore, there was not less than a surplus of 60 kalams per year for the performance of the charities which were nothing more than two feedings of the poor on two occasions in a year which would not have required more than 16 kalams of paddy. It is clear therefore that defendants 1 and 2 with ulterior objects of their own were allowing the arrears to accrue in order that the lands might be sold in collusion with another, to ensure secret benefit to themselves. Secondly, that these defendants 1 and 2 were making preparations for this mala fide rent sale is evident from the testimony of P.W 2. (After discussion of evidence his Lordship proceeded:)

    27. In other words, the testimony of P.Ws 2, 4 and 5, which has been accepted by the learned Sub-ordinate Judge, clearly shows the preparation made by defendants 1 and 2 to get these properties sold in revenue sale with a collusive auction-purchaser in order to obtain secret benefit to themselves. Subsequent to this sale we have the significant fact that no endeavour has been made by defendants 1 and 2 to raise and deposit money to set aside the sale, which is consistent only with the sale being a collusive and fraudulent one. This receives corroboration from another significant circumstance that not only did defendants 1 and 2 make no endeavour to get the sale set aside, but they even sold the remaining properties of the trust under Ex. B-29 dated 24-6-1939, which is sometime prior to the date of the sale certificate Ex. B-11 dated 5-7-1939, for Rs. 300/- reciting that as the bulk of the properties had been sold away in auction and the remaining properties were insufficient for proper performance of the charity, the trustees were selling the remaining properties.

    28. It is stated that the learned advocate who appeared for defendants 3 and 4 found this too much on this being pointed out to him and frankly conceded that he could not at all support the sale Ex. B-29 in the face of the express provision in the wakf deed Ex. A-1. It need not be pointed out that if muttawalle transfers property without any authority of the wakf or the Court the alienation is void and he is guilty of committing a breach of trust for which he may be removed; Ahmad Shah v. Atfa Khan, AIR 1934 Pesh 57 (U); Shama Churn Roy v. Abdul Kabir, 3 Cal WN 158 (V); Mahim Jan Bibi v. Mir Rahim, AIR 1925 Cal 435 (W); Jabeda v. Mohammed Mozaffar Ali, AIR 1926 Cal 322 (X); Badal v. Tinkori, 41 Ind Cas 736 : (AIR 1918 Cal) (804); Abdur Rahim v. Narayan Das, ILR 50 Cal 329 : 44 Mad LJ 624 : (AIR 1923 PC 44 (2)) (Z); Abdul Rajak v. Ali Baksh, AIR 1946 Lah 200 (Z1). This receives further corroboration from another circumstance that the first defendant has gifted the P. Schedule properties to his daughter, when there is an express provision in Ex. A-1 against gifting or alienating wakf properties.

    29. These defendants 1 and 2 remained ex parte throughout. There can be no doubt in these circumstances that defendants 1 and 2 had got hold of the sixth defendant in order to dispose of these trust properties and this collusion is finally shown from the fact that documents Exs. B-5 and B-10, which should be in the custody of the second defendant came from the custody of the contesting defendants 3 and 4. It has been argued that this Haja Abdul Hamid is a stranger and therefore no fraud could be inferred.

    30. But it should not be overlooked that in the very nature of things, as has been repeatedly pointed out, fraud is secret in its origin and inception and the means adopted for its success and fraudulent motive or design cannot be proved to the very hilt and that it should be inferred from the circumstances placed before Court. Each circumstance by itself may not mean much, but taking all of them together, they may reveal a fraudulent or dishonest plan. In addition to the circumstances pointed out above which show collusion between defendants 1 and 2 and Haja Abdul Hamid, we have the further fact that the circumstances and the manner in which the revenue sale was held show that the auction-purchaser must also have been a party thereto.

    31. There was no publication in the Gazette as required by the mandatory provisions of Section 117 of the Etates Land Act: see Exs. A-5 and A-14. The defendants have filed only a publication after the sale as per Ex. B-25. Secondly, there was no appointment of a selling officer: see Exs. A-12-B to A-12-H. Thirdly, for a paltry arrears of Rs. 100 and odd, the entire B Schedule properties were brought to sale: see the suit register extract, Ex. A-4. It is extremely unlikely that this Haja Abdul Hamid would have been a genuine auction-purchaser when the sale took place under such circumstances and what is more in a hole-and-corner fashion inside the house of the village munsif.

    32. The properties are found from their extent and income to be worth at least Rs. 2000/- then and now must be worth much more. According to the P.Ws the properties were worth Rs. 5,000/- in May 1939 and it is significant to note that in Ex. A-1 of the year 1914 the properties are stated to be worth Rs. 5,000/-. It is a well known fact that in wakf documents, to escape stamp duty, there will be only under-valuation and not over-valuation. We have already alluded to the net Income of the properties and their extent. The fact that they have been knocked off for a sum of Rs. 401/- is eloquent testimony of the fraudulent and collusive character of the sale.

    33. Therefore, the learned Sub-ordinate Judge came to the correct conclusion that this sale, null and void from the very beginning, was brought about by fraud and collusion between defendants 1 and 2 on the one hand and Haji Abdul Hamid on the other hand.

    34. Point 3: It is contended by the learned advocate for the appellants that Article 12 of the Indian Limitation Act would apply to this case and that this suit has been filed long after the sale was confirmed and the sale certificate was issued. In advancing this argument it is overlooked that Article 12 applies to suits to set aside sales referred to therein. A sale can be set aside by a person only if it is said that it is binding on him unless and until it is set aside. This Article will not therefore apply to cases where the plaintiff would not be bound by the sale even if it were not set aside.

    35. Now a person may not be bound by (i) either because he is not a party to the decree or proceeding in which the sale is held, or (ii) because the sale itself is null and void and without jurisdiction. In the first case the sale cannot in fact be set aside by a third party because as between the parties to the decree or other proceeding the sale will be valid and binding. In the latter case there is nothing to be set aside. The plaintiff in such a case can get a declaration that the interests of the trust are not affected by the sale. In fact it has been held that even if the plaintiff sues to set aside such a sale it will be regarded as being in effect a suit for such a declaration.

    36. Such a suit for a declaration is not governed by Article 12. Further, in such a case the plaintiff can ignore the sale. The only restriction is that the purchaser should not have prescribed title by adverse possession and limitation for over the statutory period of 12 years after getting possession of the property. Therefore, the proper Article to be applied in this case is Article 144 of the Limitation Act and this is evident from the following Madras decisions: Venkateswarlu v. Veeraswami, ILR (1947) Mad 28 : 226 Ind Cas 411 : (AIR 1946 Mad 461) (Z2). (Case under Madras Estates Land Act) Satyanarayana v. Ramaineedi Rayalamma, AIR 1943 Mad 501 : 213 Ind Cas 255 (Z3); Lakshmadu v. Ramudu, AIR 1939 Mad 867 : ILR (1940) Mad 123 : 187 Ind Cas 816 (Z4); Venkata Narsiah v. Subbamma, ILR 4 Mad 178 at p. 179 (Z5). See also Rupa Jagshet v. Krishnaji Govind, ILR 9 Bom 169 at p. 172 (Z6); Nazar Ali v. Kedarnath, ILR 19 All 308 (Z7); Bulaki Das v. Kesari, AIR 1928 All 363 : ILR 50 All 686 (Z8); Mulkh Raj v. Nanak, AIR 1933 Lah 10 (Z9); Purnachandra Chatterjee v. Dinabandu, ILR 34 Cal 811 (FB) (Z10); Ghanasayan Chaudhary v. Bas & Co., 60 Ind Cas 529 (Patna) (Z11); Khairajmal v. Daim, 32 Ind App 23 (Z12); Ramabai Govind Gadre…(Original Plaintiff), v. Raghunath Vasudeo Joshi…(Original Defendant), .*, AIR 1952 Bom 106 (Z13); Maharaj Singh v. Budhu Chamar, AIR 1952 Pat 46 (Z14).

    37. The plaintiff also relied upon Article 95 of the Limitation Act. But having found that Article 144 applies and the suit is within time, it is unnecessary for us to canvass the merits of this claim because though there is some evidence that P.W 1 on account of his mental illness was going from Durgah to Durgha and was not in a position to accurately comprehend the collusive and fraudulent sale which took place in 1939 there also is some evidence that P.W 1 was always or frequently in Nagore and could not have escaped having knowledge of this revenue sale. It is unnecessary therefore for us to consider whether Article 95 of the Limitation Act would apply to this case.

    38. The decree and judgment of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge, however, require modification on two points viz., that we consider in the circumstances of this case, the decree should not be given to the plaintiff on behalf of the trust without making him firstly liable to reimburse the legal representatives of Haja Abdul Hamid in a sum of Rs. 401/- and secondly equating the interest and mesne profits upto the date of suit and thirdly permitting the legal representatives of that Haja Abdul Hamid to establish in execution the value of improvements said to have been effected by them and set it off against the mesne profits subsequent to the date of suit and liable for the balance if any as this will shorten the litigation and avoid multiplicity of suits and save the trust funds and do complete justice between the parties.

    39. The plaintiff on behalf of the trust will take immediate possession of the properties and the question of accounting need not await the delivery of possession. To this course the plaintiff and defendants can have no objection and have no objection. In regard to the extent of the property mentioned as comprised in Ex. B-2 both sides agree that the decree mentions Ac. 2-19 cents whereas it ought to be Ac. 2-67 cents. In assessing the quantum of mesne profits prior to the decree of the lower Court the amount spent under the wakf created by the 3rd defendant on services prescribed under Ex. A-1 will, as proved, be given credit to. Subject to these modifications the decree and judgment of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge are confirmed and this appeal is dismissed, and the costs of both parties (plaintiff and defendants 3 and 4) including court-fee both as awarded in the lower Court and here will come out of the estate.

    K.S.B

    40. Decree modified.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thangachi Nachial And Another v. Ahmed Hussain Malumiar And Others
    (Apr 5, 1956)