Operational LILO Assets Attract Transmission Tariff Despite Delayed Network Expansion: Generator Liability for an Unbuilt Dedicated Line
- Case
- POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LIMITED v. TANGEDCO
- Citation
- 2026 INSC 1237
- Court and date
- Supreme Court of India, 18 November 2026
- Bench
- J. B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran JJ.; judgment delivered by K. Vinod Chandran J.
1. Introduction
This judgment addresses an important question in electricity regulation: can a transmission licensee recover charges for commissioned transmission assets actually carrying electricity when another part of the wider transmission network remains incomplete? The Supreme Court answered affirmatively on the facts, restoring the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission’s tariff order and placing the allocated liability on the generating company whose dedicated transmission line remained unbuilt.
Power Grid Corporation of India Limited, acting as the Central Transmission Utility for the arrangements in dispute, claimed transmission charges for two Line-In Line-Out arrangements, or LILOs, connecting the Tuticorin JV–Madurai transmission line with the Tuticorin Pooling Station. The generating company, Moxie Power Generation Limited, formerly Coastal Energen Private Limited, and the distribution licensee, Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited (TANGEDCO), disputed liability.
Their central argument was that the LILOs could not serve their intended purpose until the further transmission connection towards Salem and Madhugiri became operational. The Court rejected that premise: electricity was already being transmitted through the LILOs using the existing Tuticorin JV–Madurai route. The incomplete additional route did not render the operating assets commercially useless.
The decision also clarifies the distinction between an asset entering actual regular service and an asset that is ready but prevented from entering service. That distinction determined whether the special commercial-operation procedure under Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations applied.
2. Background: Two Different LILO Arrangements
Understanding the dispute requires separating two physically and legally distinct arrangements.
-
The generator’s temporary LILO: This connected Coastal Energen’s generating station to one circuit of the Tuticorin JV–Madurai line. It enabled evacuation of electricity before the generator completed its dedicated transmission line directly to the Tuticorin Pooling Station.
-
PGCIL’s permanent LILOs: These intercepted both circuits of the Tuticorin JV–Madurai line at the Tuticorin Pooling Station, routing electricity into the station and then back onto the transmission line. These were the assets for which the disputed tariff was claimed.
The permanent LILOs formed part of the agreed transmission scheme. The generator’s temporary connection was not a substitute for its contractual obligation to construct a dedicated line to the pooling station.
Key chronology
| Date |
Event and significance |
| 27 August 2009 |
The 29th Standing Committee Meeting considered the regional evacuation scheme and a temporary connection for Coastal Energen. |
| 24 February 2010 |
The Bulk Power Transmission Agreement was executed, identifying the generator’s dedicated-line obligations and PGCIL’s transmission works. |
| 5 May 2010 |
The 30th Standing Committee Meeting approved LILO arrangements at Tuticorin Pooling Station following constraints on available bays at Tuticorin JV. |
| 8 September 2011 |
The amended agreement expressly separated the Tuticorin pooling station and LILOs into Part A, with the further transmission works towards Salem and Madhugiri in Part B. |
| 23 December 2014 |
The Court treated this as the commencement of generation relevant to its analysis. Electricity was initially evacuated through the temporary connection. |
| 4 and 8 January 2015 |
The respective commercial operation dates accepted for PGCIL’s two LILO assets. |
| 29 July 2016 |
CERC approved the relevant commercial operation dates and determined tariff liability. |
| 27 October 2016 |
The generator commissioned its dedicated transmission line, ending the disputed period of generator-specific recovery. |
| 13 November and 1 December 2016 |
The judgment records commissioning of the Tuticorin–Salem connection on the former date and operationalisation of the generator’s long-term access on the latter. |
The disputed non-Point of Connection claim before APTEL was ₹15,43,26,909. The Supreme Court restored CERC’s order rather than undertaking a fresh calculation of that amount.
3. Issues and Rival Positions
PGCIL’s position
PGCIL argued that the LILOs were permanent, approved components of the transmission scheme and had actually carried the generator’s electricity. Their commercial operation dates were supported by successful trial-operation certification from the Regional Load Despatch Centre and safety certification from the Central Electricity Authority.
It further contended that the generator’s failure to construct its dedicated line justified the allocated bilateral charges until that line became operational. Payment of short-term or medium-term open-access charges did not, according to PGCIL, discharge the distinct charges attributable to these newly tariffed assets.
The generator’s and TANGEDCO’s position
The respondents maintained that the LILOs had no relevant beneficial use before completion of the onward transmission system. They argued that electricity could continue to move along the existing Tuticorin JV–Madurai line and that the generator’s delayed dedicated line was immaterial because PGCIL’s further network was itself incomplete.
They also challenged the commercial-operation procedure, relying on Regulation 4(3)(ii), and contended that existing open-access payments precluded an additional claim.
The Court’s three questions
- Were the two LILOs includable in transmission tariff under the statutory and contractual scheme?
- Was APTEL correct in requiring reconsideration of their commercial operation dates under Regulation 4(3)(ii)?
- Did the generator’s delay in completing its dedicated line justify liability during the disputed period?
The Court answered the first and third questions affirmatively and the second negatively.
4. Summary of the Judgment
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals, set aside APTEL’s original and review orders, and restored CERC’s order.
-
Actual use was established: Once PGCIL’s LILOs intercepted the relevant circuits, electricity travelled through the Tuticorin Pooling Station before returning to the Tuticorin JV–Madurai line.
-
The incomplete additional route was not decisive: The existing Madurai route provided an operating evacuation path, notwithstanding delay in the connection towards Salem and Madhugiri.
-
The accepted commercial operation dates remained valid: Successful trial operation, certification and regular service supported 4 January 2015 and 8 January 2015 for the respective assets.
-
The exceptional procedure did not apply: Regulation 4(3)(ii) concerns assets prevented from entering regular service. These assets were already in service.
-
The generator remained liable under CERC’s allocation: Its dedicated line was not operational until 27 October 2016.
Importantly, paragraph 34 describes CERC’s allocation as placing 50% of the relevant LILO charges in the PoC mechanism and the remaining 50% on the generator lacking its dedicated line. The judgment should therefore not be read as imposing every cost of the entire transmission scheme exclusively on the generator.
5. Analysis of the Legal Reasoning
A. Actual network configuration displaced the “no use” argument
The Court’s reasoning began with the physical configuration of the network, not merely the ultimate ambitions of the regional transmission project. The LILOs interrupted the original circuits and routed power through the pooling station. On the Court’s reading of the diagram, electricity could not continue directly to Madurai along an uninterrupted original route after those interventions became operational.
The generator’s appeal pleadings provided additional support. It had acknowledged using the Tuticorin Pooling Station and the relevant transmission assets, including for medium-term access supplying TANGEDCO, while arguing that their charges should be shared through the PoC mechanism.
This admission mattered because it distinguished two arguments: the assets were unused, and their charges should be shared differently. The Court rejected the former and held that the latter could not overcome the consequences of the uncompleted dedicated line.
The respondents’ abstract reliance on electricity following a path of least resistance could not displace the actual circuit arrangement. The judgment’s conclusion is therefore best understood as a finding about the established topology and use of this network, not a universal proposition about electricity flows.
B. Completion of the wider scheme was not a prerequisite to tariff for every operating element
APTEL had treated the missing onward transmission connection as preventing the LILOs from serving their purpose. The Supreme Court instead identified two available transmission arrangements: the proposed route towards Salem and Madhugiri, and the functioning route through the Tuticorin JV–Madurai line.
The latter was sufficient to evacuate the electricity in question. Accordingly, completion of the former was not a condition precedent to recognising the LILOs’ actual commercial service.
This is the judgment’s central contribution to phased infrastructure disputes: an operating element does not necessarily lose its tariff entitlement merely because the wider project remains incomplete. The element must, however, satisfy the applicable commissioning requirements and be shown to perform an actual service.
C. Ordinary commercial operation versus readiness without service
Regulation 3(53) defines “Regular Service” by reference to use following successful trial operation and certification by the relevant Regional Load Despatch Centre. The Court read the ordinary transmission provision in Regulation 4(3) consistently with that definition.
By contrast, Regulation 4(3)(ii) addresses a transmission system or element prevented from entering regular service for qualifying reasons outside the transmission licensee’s responsibility, including delayed commissioning of connected generation or transmission infrastructure.
These provisions address different situations:
- Actual operation: The element has completed trial operation and entered regular service.
- Prevented operation: The element is ready but cannot enter regular service because a connected facility is unavailable.
The LILOs fell into the first category. Their successful trial operation and regular service were established; no missing connection prevented them from transmitting the electricity actually generated. APTEL therefore erred in requiring the exceptional approval route.
The Court did not dispense with commercial-operation requirements. It upheld their satisfaction through the evidence already examined by CERC, including the RLDC certificates, CEA safety certification and the voltage-control arrangement at the pooling station.
D. The generator’s dedicated-line obligation remained independently enforceable
Section 10 of the Electricity Act places responsibility on generating companies for their associated facilities, including dedicated transmission lines. The BPTA translated that statutory framework into a specific obligation: Coastal Energen had to connect its generating switchyard directly to Tuticorin Pooling Station.
The temporary LILO enabled generation and supply to continue, but did not extinguish that obligation. Nor did the delay in the additional Salem route excuse it, because the operating Madurai route already enabled evacuation.
Liability was consequently tied to the period during which PGCIL’s LILOs were commercially operating while the generator’s dedicated line remained unavailable. The respective starting dates were 4 and 8 January 2015; the terminating event was commissioning of the dedicated line on 27 October 2016.
Although the concluding answer uses 4 January as shorthand for the disputed period, the judgment repeatedly recognises the separate commercial operation dates of the two assets.
E. Planning approvals and the BPTA established the assets’ permanent character
The Standing Committee records and contractual annexures showed that PGCIL’s LILOs were not an improvised temporary connection comparable to the generator’s arrangement. They formed part of the approved permanent transmission scheme.
The amended BPTA was particularly significant: it placed the Tuticorin pooling station and the LILOs in Part A, while placing the further transmission works in Part B. This supported the Court’s refusal to treat every element as commercially inseparable.
The Court also treated the agreed planning decisions as having legal sanctity under Section 29(4), emphasising stakeholder participation and the absence of objection by the generating company. Nevertheless, planning approval was not the sole foundation of recovery: contractual responsibility, certified commissioning and actual use were also essential.
F. “Beneficial use” was not an additional whole-network test
The Supreme Court rejected APTEL’s conclusion that beneficial use was absent. It did not establish that use is always irrelevant to tariff entitlement; indeed, it expressly found beneficial use proved.
The narrower and sounder reading is that the phrase cannot introduce an additional requirement that the entire contemplated network, or its full intended capacity, must be available before an actually operating element attracts tariff.
The Court also rejected APTEL’s reliance on paragraph 72 of CERC’s order. Read in context, that paragraph recorded TANGEDCO’s contention rather than CERC’s finding. The following paragraphs examined liability and imposed it on the generator. This illustrates the importance of distinguishing a tribunal’s recital of submissions from its operative reasoning.
G. Open-access payments did not automatically discharge the asset-specific liability
PGCIL argued that short-term and medium-term open-access charges were calculated using the applicable charging arrangements and did not include the disputed LILO costs before their tariff determination. It also explained that previously tariffed fixed-asset costs could already form part of open-access charging.
Accordingly, the issue was not simply whether the generator had paid something for transmission. It was whether those payments already covered the particular asset costs being recovered.
Restoration of CERC’s order rejected the respondents’ contention that open-access payments automatically defeated this claim. The judgment should not, however, be expanded into a general authorisation for duplicate recovery or a rule that open-access charges never contain capital-cost components.
H. Tariff entitlement did not erase scrutiny of PGCIL’s own delay
CERC had not condoned the commissioning overrun on the material before it, though it permitted PGCIL to produce supporting evidence at truing-up. That treatment affected the calculation of relevant tariff components.
The Supreme Court’s restoration of the order therefore preserved an important distinction: entitlement to recover approved charges for operating assets does not establish entitlement to pass through every cost associated with delayed construction.
6. Precedents Cited and Their Influence
A. Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited and Ors. — (2025) 8 SCC 705
This was the principal precedent, relied upon by all parties. It concerned a mismatch between completion of PGCIL’s assets and delayed commissioning of the connected downstream system by another entity.
The earlier case upheld CERC’s authority to impose appropriate monetary consequences on the party responsible for the mismatch. Its discussion covered transmission charges following an approved commercial operation date and compensation-related construction costs.
Its influence here was twofold. First, it supported allocating the financial consequences of a delayed connected facility to the responsible party. Secondly, it confirmed that CERC’s regulatory and adjudicatory powers are not necessarily paralysed by the absence of a specific regulation addressing every contingency.
The factual distinction remains important. The earlier case involved assets whose service was obstructed by delayed downstream infrastructure and approval under Regulation 4(3)(ii). The present LILOs were already in regular service. The precedent supported the allocation principle, but did not require use of the same commercial-operation procedure in materially different circumstances.
B. PTC India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, Thr. Secretary — (2010) 4 SCC 603
This decision supplied the foundational distinction between CERC’s powers under Sections 79 and 178 of the Electricity Act.
- Section 178: Delegated legislative power to make generally applicable regulations.
- Section 79: Regulatory and adjudicatory powers exercised in particular matters within CERC’s statutory jurisdiction.
The absence of a regulation does not necessarily prevent CERC from acting under Section 79. Where regulations exist, however, its orders must conform to them. Case-specific orders also cannot assume the general overriding effect associated with valid delegated legislation.
Applied here, this reasoning supported CERC’s authority to determine responsibility for the delayed dedicated line without treating a supposed regulatory gap as immunity from liability. It did not authorise departure from the Tariff Regulations or the parties’ agreed obligations.
The judgment also reiterates the distinction between challenging delegated legislation through judicial review and appealing an individual regulatory order before APTEL under Section 111. Its isolated reference to “Section 179(1)” in recounting the principle is an apparent textual slip; the surrounding analysis concerns Section 79(1).
This authority reinforces Section 79(1) as the repository of CERC’s regulatory powers. Those powers operate subject to applicable regulations or guidelines, but their exercise is not necessarily excluded where a regulatory lacuna exists.
Its role was confirmatory: CERC could address the consequences of a generator’s delayed infrastructure within its statutory jurisdiction. Read alongside PTC India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, Thr. Secretary, it supports regulated gap-filling, not unrestricted equitable power.
D. Other regulatory references
The judgment mentions CERC Petition No.233 of 2009, an unnamed connected matter and several Standing Committee decisions. These formed part of the project’s approval history and regulatory context. The supplied judgment does not identify enough detail to treat the unnamed connected matter as a separately analysable judicial precedent.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- LILO
- A transmission arrangement that diverts an existing line into a substation and then returns it to the onward line. Here, PGCIL’s LILOs routed power through Tuticorin Pooling Station.
- Dedicated Transmission Line
- A point-to-point connection associated with a generating station. The generator was responsible for constructing the direct connection required in this case.
- Pooling station
- An electrical hub that collects generation from connected sources for onward transmission. The Court used the 2023 Grid Code definition to explain its function; it did not expressly apply that later code retrospectively to create the disputed liability.
- Commercial Operation Date
- The legally recognised starting point of commercial operation under the applicable regulations. It is not simply the date on which construction appears complete.
- PoC and non-PoC charges
- PoC refers to allocation through the applicable Point of Connection sharing mechanism. Non-PoC recovery here meant charging the responsible generator directly for its allocated share during the relevant period.
- STOA, MTOA and LTOA
- Short-term, medium-term and long-term open-access arrangements governing access to transmission capacity. Their existence does not by itself determine whether a particular asset’s approved costs have already been recovered.
- Truing-up
- A later regulatory reconciliation of approved assumptions with supported actual expenditure and operational information.
8. Likely Impact and Limits
-
Phased commissioning disputes: Courts and regulators must examine whether the particular element is operating, rather than assume that an incomplete wider scheme renders every component unusable.
-
Generator accountability: A temporary evacuation arrangement does not ordinarily displace a specific obligation to build a dedicated line.
-
Evidence of use: Network diagrams, trial certificates, operational records and admissions may be decisive in disputes framed as absence of beneficial use.
-
Correct commercial-operation route: The distinction between actual regular service and prevented service must be maintained when applying Regulation 4(3)(ii).
-
Regulatory authority with limits: CERC may address infrastructure mismatches within its statutory powers, but must respect existing regulations and contractual arrangements.
-
Consumer protection remains relevant: The judgment permits recovery under the approved allocation; it does not dispense with prudence review, justify duplicate recovery or automatically approve construction-delay costs.
The precedent is therefore strongest where an approved transmission element has entered certified regular service, an alternative functioning evacuation route exists, and the party resisting payment has failed to complete its own required infrastructure. It does not decide that mere physical readiness always creates an unrestricted right to tariff.
9. Conclusion
The Supreme Court restored a fact-sensitive allocation of transmission costs: PGCIL’s LILOs were permanent, certified and actually used, while the generator’s dedicated line remained incomplete. Delay in a separate onward route did not negate that service.
The judgment’s enduring principle is that actual operation of an approved transmission element must be distinguished from completion of the entire network. Its companion principle is equally important: a party cannot escape the allocated consequences of its own infrastructure delay merely because the wider transmission project also experienced delay.