Conditional Bail for an Unsuccessful ATM-Theft Attempt: Weighing Prolonged Custody and Dissimilar Antecedents
Case: VISHALBHAI @ TOOFAN RAMESHBHAI THAKOR v. STATE OF GUJARAT
Court: Gujarat High Court
Judge: Justice Nikhil S. Kariel
Date: 9 October 2026
Proceeding: R/Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 22874 of 2026 — successive application for regular bail after filing of the charge-sheet.
1. Introduction
The Gujarat High Court granted conditional regular bail to an accused allegedly involved in a group’s unsuccessful attempt to break open an ATM for theft. The applicant had eight criminal antecedents, but the Court noted that none concerned offences of a similar nature. It also considered his custody of nearly one year, completion of the investigation through filing of the charge-sheet, and the absence of substantial progress in the trial.
The central issue was whether continued detention remained justified when these circumstances were considered together. The applicant sought release under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (“BNSS”), while the State opposed bail because of the nature of the offence and his alleged role.
The order’s significance lies in its cumulative, individualised assessment: multiple antecedents did not automatically defeat bail, and the unsuccessful nature of the alleged attempt was considered alongside custody and trial progress. The decision applies established bail principles; it does not create an automatic entitlement to release in every unsuccessful theft case.
2. Background and Competing Submissions
2.1 The prosecution allegations
The application concerned FIR C.R. No. 11188002250692 of 2025, registered at Bayad Police Station, District Aravalli. The offences invoked were Sections 331(4), 305(a), 324(4), 62, 54, 61(2)(a), and 238(c) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (“BNS”).
According to the allegations recorded in the order, a group approached an ATM intending to commit theft and attempted to break it open, but did not succeed. The applicant’s alleged role was participation in that group. The Court did not undertake a detailed examination of the evidence or determine the ingredients of each charged offence.
2.2 The applicant’s position
The applicant argued that his alleged role and the nature of the accusations justified bail. He further submitted that, because the charge-sheet had been filed, keeping him imprisoned indefinitely would serve no useful purpose. He offered to comply with any conditions imposed by the Court.
2.3 The State’s opposition
The Additional Public Prosecutor opposed release, relying on the nature of the offence and the role attributed to the applicant in the charge-sheet. The State urged the Court not to exercise its discretion in his favour.
3. Summary of the Judgment
The Court identified the following considerations as material to its decision:
- The alleged attempt was unsuccessful: the accused allegedly tried to break open the ATM but did not succeed.
- The applicant’s alleged involvement was identified: he was said to have been part of the group undertaking that attempt.
- The antecedents were dissimilar: although eight antecedents were recorded, none was of a similar nature.
- Custody was substantial: the applicant had been in custody since 20 October 2025.
- The case had reached the post-investigation stage: the charge-sheet had been filed, but the trial had not progressed substantially.
Taking these circumstances together, and referring to Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation, reported in [2012] 1 SCC 40, the Court found the case suitable for regular bail. It expressly avoided a detailed discussion of the evidence and described its assessment as prima facie.
3.1 Bond and conditions
The applicant was directed to execute a bond of ₹15,000 with one surety for the same amount, to the satisfaction of the trial court. Release was subject to the following conditions:
- He must not take undue advantage of, or misuse, his liberty.
- He must not act in a manner injurious to the prosecution’s interests.
- He must surrender his passport, if any, to the lower court within one week.
- He must not leave Gujarat without prior permission of the Sessions Court concerned.
- He must provide his present residential address to the investigating officer and the Court when executing the bond, and give prior intimation to the investigating officer before changing residence.
- He must mark his presence at the concerned police station once a month for one year.
The release direction applied only if he was not required in connection with another offence. The Sessions Court could take appropriate action for breach of the conditions, and the concerned court could delete, modify, or relax them in accordance with law.
Crucially, the trial court was directed not to be influenced by the High Court’s preliminary observations when deciding the case on its merits.
4. Analysis
4.1 Statutory setting: discretion under Section 483 BNSS
Section 483 BNSS provides special bail powers to the High Court and the Court of Session. This application sought regular bail: release from custody while the prosecution remained pending. It was not a determination of innocence or a challenge resulting in termination of the prosecution.
The filing of the charge-sheet was relevant, but not treated as sufficient by itself. Completion of investigation changes the context in which detention is assessed, because custody can no longer be justified simply by saying that the investigation remains incomplete. Nevertheless, post-charge-sheet detention may still be warranted by considerations such as attendance at trial, interference with evidence, or other legitimate risks. The order therefore assessed the procedural stage alongside the particular allegations and custody period.
4.2 Precedent cited: Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation
The only judicial precedent expressly cited was Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation, [2012] 1 SCC 40. The High Court stated that it had considered the law laid down in that decision, without reproducing a passage or identifying a particular paragraph.
The established bail principles associated with that decision explain its relevance:
- Bail is directed principally toward securing attendance: detention before conviction should not operate as advance punishment.
- The seriousness of an accusation is important but not conclusive: it must be assessed with the circumstances bearing on whether continued custody is necessary.
- Pre-trial detention requires justification: an accused remains presumed innocent, and the duration of custody and likely progress of proceedings matter.
- Conditions can protect the process: appropriately framed restrictions may address risks without requiring continued imprisonment.
These principles illuminate the present order’s emphasis on nearly one year of custody, the filed charge-sheet, and limited trial progress. Its passport, travel, reporting, and conduct conditions are also consistent with securing participation in the proceedings while protecting the prosecution.
The precedent did not make release inevitable. Rather, it supplied the governing approach within which the High Court exercised fact-sensitive discretion. The order contains no extended comparison with the facts of Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation, and no further precedents were discussed.
4.3 The unsuccessful attempt: relevant to bail, not a finding of innocence
The Court mentioned the failure to break open the ATM both when recording the allegations and when explaining why indulgence was appropriate. This repetition indicates that the unsuccessful outcome materially influenced the discretionary assessment.
That reasoning has limits. An unsuccessful attempt may still attract criminal liability, and the Court did not hold otherwise. Nor did it conclude that the applicant lacked the alleged intention, that no damage occurred, or that the prosecution could not prove its case. The narrower point was that the actual alleged conduct and its outcome were relevant when deciding whether further pre-trial detention was necessary.
The order should therefore not be read as equating an unsuccessful offence with a trivial offence. It distinguishes the bail assessment from the eventual determination of liability.
4.4 Eight antecedents: significance beyond the numerical count
A notable feature is the Court’s treatment of the applicant’s eight antecedents. It expressly acknowledged them but also recorded that none was similar in nature to the present allegations. Their existence was therefore not ignored; their character formed part of the assessment.
This supports a contextual approach rather than a purely numerical one. A criminal history may be relevant to risk, but the present order shows that the number of previous matters need not automatically determine the result.
At the same time, the judgment does not disclose the offences, procedural status, or outcomes of those antecedents. They cannot be described as eight convictions. Nor does the order establish that dissimilar antecedents are irrelevant or must always receive little weight.
4.5 Custody and trial progress: a cumulative justification
The applicant had spent nearly one year in custody, while the trial had not progressed substantially despite the filing of the charge-sheet. These circumstances gave practical force to the concern that detention should not become punishment before adjudication.
The Court did not prescribe a fixed custody period after which bail becomes mandatory. It also did not attribute responsibility for the pace of the trial to either side. Its reasoning was cumulative: time already spent in custody mattered in conjunction with the alleged unsuccessful attempt, the nature of the antecedents, and the stage of proceedings.
4.6 The limits of the successive-bail ruling
The proceeding was identified as a successive regular-bail application. However, the supplied order does not state why an earlier application failed, whether it was withdrawn, or which developments occurred afterward.
Consequently, this decision cannot support a detailed proposition about the requirements for entertaining successive applications. Its express reasoning concerns the circumstances existing at the time of this application, not the legal effect of any earlier bail order.
4.7 Conditional liberty and preservation of the trial
The conditions reflect a balance between liberty and procedural safeguards. Restrictions on travel, surrender of a passport, address disclosure, and monthly attendance maintain supervision and accessibility. The prohibitions on misuse of liberty and conduct harmful to the prosecution protect the integrity of the proceedings.
Importantly, monthly attendance was limited to one year, and the conditions remained capable of lawful modification. Release was also expressly subject to the applicant not being required in another case. This bail order therefore did not override an independent basis for custody elsewhere.
The direction insulating the trial court from the High Court’s observations preserves the distinction between a provisional liberty decision and a final adjudication of guilt.
5. Potential Impact and Precedential Reach
The order may assist future bail arguments where several comparable circumstances coexist: a completed investigation, substantial custody, limited trial progress, an unsuccessful alleged attempt, and antecedents that do not concern similar conduct.
Its broader contribution is methodological. Courts should examine how the relevant circumstances interact, rather than allowing a single factor—whether seriousness, antecedents, or filing of a charge-sheet—to replace the overall assessment. For applicants, concrete information about custody and procedural progress may therefore be particularly important. For the prosecution, specific reasons why detention remains necessary may carry greater weight than a general reference to the accusation’s seriousness.
The decision remains a fact-specific bail order. It does not establish that unsuccessful ATM-theft attempts necessarily warrant release, that dissimilar antecedents must be disregarded, or that filing a charge-sheet ends the lawful basis for detention. Its value lies principally in illustrating the application of established principles to the particular combination of facts before the Court.
6. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Regular bail
- Release from custody while a criminal case continues, subject to conditions. It does not amount to acquittal.
- Successive bail application
- A later request for bail after an earlier application. This order does not provide the earlier application’s history.
- Charge-sheet
- The police report submitted after investigation, setting out the prosecution case and supporting material. Filing it does not prove guilt.
- Criminal antecedents
- An accused person’s previous involvement in criminal matters. The expression does not, without further information, mean previous convictions.
- Prima facie assessment
- A preliminary evaluation for deciding an interim question, rather than a final conclusion reached after trial.
- Bond and surety
- The bond records the accused’s undertaking to comply with release obligations; the surety provides an additional guarantee. The ₹15,000 amount is not a fine or a finding of liability.
- Rule made absolute
- The Court finally granted the relief in the application to the extent specified in its order.
7. Conclusion
The Gujarat High Court granted bail because the circumstances, viewed together, favoured conditional release: the alleged ATM-breaking attempt had failed, the applicant’s eight antecedents were dissimilar, custody had approached one year, the charge-sheet was filed, and the trial had not progressed substantially.
Read with Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation, the order reinforces that pre-trial detention requires an individualised justification and must not become anticipatory punishment. Its significance is not an automatic rule favouring bail for unsuccessful offences, but a practical demonstration of reasoned discretion, supported by safeguards and without prejudging the trial.