1. Introduction
The Madhya Pradesh High Court considered whether an FIR for forgery could be registered on the direction of a civil court, or whether the alleged offence could be pursued only through a complaint by that court under Sections 215(1)(b) and 379 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (“BNSS”).
Petitioners Himmat Singh and Narendra Singh were brothers of respondent Nos. 2 and 3, who had instituted a civil suit concerning title to agricultural land. Narendra Singh relied upon a purported will of their father, attested by petitioner Nos. 3 and 4. The civil court concluded that the will had been fabricated after the institution of the suit and directed registration of an FIR. Crime No. 242/2026 was consequently registered for offences under Sections 61(2), 336(3), 338 and 340(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (“BNS”).
Invoking Section 528 BNSS, the petitioners sought quashing of the FIR. They contended that the special procedure governing offences relating to documents produced in court excluded an ordinary police FIR and that a civil finding, based on the preponderance of probabilities, could not by itself sustain criminal prosecution.
4. Analysis
4.1 The distinction between pre-production forgery and forgery in judicial custody
The central distinction is between a document forged before it enters court proceedings and an offence committed while the document is in custodia legis—that is, in the legal custody of the court.
Sections 215(1)(b) and 379 BNSS protect the administration of justice by prescribing a special procedure for specified offences affecting court proceedings. Where that bar applies, cognizance ordinarily must rest upon a written complaint by the concerned court or a superior court. It is not a general immunity for every forged document that is later produced in litigation.
The High Court treated the alleged fabrication as an act committed outside the court and therefore held that an ordinary police investigation was permissible. The mere later use of the document in a civil suit did not convert an earlier act of forgery into an offence committed while the document was in judicial custody.
4.2 Precedents cited
The petitioners relied upon this authority, which the Court subsequently referred to as Sachida Nand Singh and another Vs. State of Bihar and Another reported in 1998 SCC (Cri) 660. The quoted passages explain that the procedure corresponding to Section 379 BNSS applies to offences affecting the administration of justice and involving documents produced or given in evidence before the court.
The precedent emphasizes that the relevant offence must have been committed while the document was in custodia legis. A forgery committed outside court before the document was produced does not become an offence against the administration of justice merely because the document later reaches the court record.
This authority formed the principal basis of the decision. Applying it, the High Court held that no preliminary inquiry or court complaint under Section 379 BNSS was indispensable and that there was no impediment to police registration of the case.
This Constitution Bench authority belongs to the same doctrinal line. It adopts a restricted interpretation of the statutory bar: where a document is forged before being produced in court, prosecution is not confined to a complaint by that court. The special procedure is principally attracted when the offence is committed in relation to a document after it has entered judicial custody.
Although the judgment did not separately analyse this precedent, its conclusion is consistent with that distinction and rejects the petitioners’ argument that every alleged forgery involving an exhibited document must proceed exclusively through Section 379 BNSS.
This case was cited by the petitioners in support of the procedural restrictions governing prosecution for offences connected with court documents. The High Court, however, did not reproduce or independently apply its ratio. The judgment instead resolved the controversy through the controlling distinction stated in Sachida Nand Singh.
This authority was also invoked to support the proposition that offences affecting judicial proceedings are subject to the statutory complaint mechanism. It was not separately discussed by the High Court. The implicit reason for not applying the asserted bar was the factual classification of the alleged forgery as an extra-court act rather than an offence committed while the document was under the court’s custody.
This Constitution Bench decision was relied upon affirmatively by the High Court to determine the scope of Section 151 CPC. It recognizes the court’s inherent jurisdiction to pass orders ex debito justitiae—as a matter of obligation to do justice—while also making clear that inherent power cannot nullify or contradict an express provision of the CPC.
The High Court applied this principle to hold that, because no provision expressly or impliedly prohibits a civil court from forwarding a serious allegation of forgery to the police, Section 151 CPC may support such a direction in an appropriate case.
4.3 Inherent powers of the civil court
The Court acknowledged that the CPC does not expressly authorize a civil court to order a party or witness to lodge a police complaint. It nevertheless found that Section 151 CPC fills this procedural space. Fraud and forgery directly threaten the integrity of adjudication, and a court must possess sufficient power to ensure that apparent wrongdoing is investigated.
The rule is not unlimited. Section 151 cannot be used where the legislation expressly requires a different procedure. Thus, if the alleged offence were committed while the document was in judicial custody and the statutory court-complaint bar squarely applied, inherent power could not be used to circumvent it.
4.4 Civil and criminal standards of proof
The petitioners correctly distinguished between the civil standard of preponderance of probabilities and the criminal standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt. The Court’s decision does not make the civil finding conclusive proof of criminal guilt. It merely permits registration and investigation of the alleged offences.
The prosecution must still independently establish every ingredient of conspiracy, forgery and use of a forged document beyond reasonable doubt. The accused retain all procedural protections available during investigation and trial.
4.5 Civil dispute versus criminal wrongdoing
A family dispute over succession may generate both civil and criminal consequences. The existence of civil remedies does not immunize conduct that independently satisfies the ingredients of a criminal offence. According to the Court, treating all alleged forgeries in civil litigation as purely civil disputes would allow wrongdoers to escape investigation merely because an appeal or property dispute remained pending.
4.6 Important factual qualification
The judgment records two different dates for the will—19 February 2019 and 19 December 2019. More importantly, the decisive question under the cited doctrine is not merely whether the act occurred physically “outside the court,” but whether the alleged fabrication occurred before or after the document entered judicial custody. The order treats the case as one of pre-custody forgery, but does not extensively examine that chronology.