Bare Denial Cannot Establish a Fake Motor Insurance Policy: Evidentiary Burden and “Pay and Recover”
Case: SBI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD v. RADHABEN GOVABHAI DESAI (RABARI) (DELETED)
Court: Gujarat High Court
Judge: Justice J. C. Doshi
Decision: 23 October 2026
Proceedings: First Appeal No. 5650 of 2019 with Civil Application No. 1 of 2026
1. Introduction
This judgment addresses the evidence an insurer must produce when seeking to avoid liability on the ground that a motor insurance policy is forged or fabricated. The Gujarat High Court held that an insurer’s denial, even when supported by another policy bearing the same number, does not conclusively establish forgery without an adequate evidentiary foundation.
SBI General Insurance Company Ltd. challenged an award arising from the death of Babubhai Govabhai Desai in a collision between a motorcycle and a car. The insurer maintained that it had never insured the offending car and that the policy relied upon by the claimants was fabricated. The High Court dismissed the appeal because the insurer failed to substantiate that defence through sufficiently reliable evidence.
The decision is significant for its distinction between alleging that no insurance contract existed and proving that allegation. It also illustrates how inadequate records, an insufficiently informed witness, delayed pleadings, and ineffective investigation can undermine an otherwise potentially substantial defence.
2. Factual and Procedural Background
The accident and compensation claim
On 9 March 2015, Babubhai was travelling as a pillion rider on a motorcycle when it collided with a car allegedly driven rashly, at high speed, and on the wrong side of the road. Following treatment at hospitals in Patan and Mehsana, he died on 14 March 2015.
His heirs filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking ₹65 lakh in compensation. They stated that he was approximately 49 years old, worked as a government schoolteacher, and also earned income from agriculture and animal husbandry.
On 31 August 2019, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Patan, awarded ₹37,00,420 with interest at 9% per annum from the filing of the claim petition until realization. The opponents were held jointly and severally liable. The Tribunal also protected SBI General Insurance Company’s recovery rights against the car owner or his legal heirs, addressing the possibility that the policy might subsequently be established as fabricated.
The insurer’s defence
The claimants relied upon a motor insurance policy at Exhibit 66, bearing policy number 0000000004854523. SBI General Insurance Company contended that this number actually related to a long-term home insurance policy issued to another person. It produced that policy at Exhibit 80 and examined its officer, Mohitsinh Hasuji Rana, at Exhibit 78.
The insurer argued that it had received no premium for the car and therefore had no contractual obligation to indemnify its owner. It consequently challenged both direct liability and the direction to “pay and recover.”
The separate appeal
Iffco Tokio General Insurance Company Limited, the motorcycle’s insurer, separately challenged the award in First Appeal No. 663 of 2020. That appeal was de-tagged because it concerned an “Act only policy” issue pending consideration before the Supreme Court. The High Court expressly left all issues in that appeal undecided.
3. Questions Before the Court
- What evidence must an insurer produce to establish that a policy relied upon in motor accident proceedings is forged or fabricated?
- Did the officer’s testimony and the competing policy at Exhibit 80 establish that the policy at Exhibit 66 was fake?
- How should the insurer’s delayed defence, incomplete records, and limited action on the alleged fraud affect the assessment of its case?
- Was the Tribunal justified in retaining the insurer’s obligation to pay compensation while protecting its recovery rights?
Although the insurer had also pleaded that the car driver lacked a valid and effective driving licence, the High Court’s substantive reasoning concerned the alleged fake policy. It did not separately determine a licence-based defence.
4. Summary of the Judgment
The High Court dismissed the appeal. It held that SBI General Insurance Company had failed to prove that the policy relied upon by the claimants was forged or fabricated.
The principal findings were:
- A mere denial of issuance is not automatically proof of forgery.
- The insurer must provide cogent, legally admissible evidence supporting its allegation.
- The witness examined did not adequately establish his knowledge of the relevant issuing office’s records or explain the investigation allegedly conducted.
- Producing a different policy with the same number did not resolve the dispute, particularly given unexplained features of the insurer’s own document.
- The insurer failed to produce material policy and premium records or adequately informed witnesses.
- Its delayed and poorly followed-up response to the alleged fraud weakened its case.
- The Tribunal’s “pay and recover” arrangement sufficiently protected the insurer’s interests in the circumstances.
The earlier interim relief was vacated, and the connected civil application was disposed of. The Court expressly preserved the independent determination of First Appeal No. 663 of 2020.
5. Analysis of the Court’s Legal Reasoning
A. Alleged fabrication requires proof, not assertion
The central principle appears in paragraphs 18 and 19: an insurer seeking to avoid liability because a policy is fabricated must establish that defence through legally admissible and sufficiently reliable evidence, assessed against the entire record.
The Court distinguished this situation from cases involving a genuine policy later cancelled because a premium cheque was dishonoured, or disputes about whether an existing policy covers a particular vehicle or accident. Those situations involve different factual and legal foundations. Here, the insurer denied that the relevant insurance contract had ever existed.
That denial could not succeed merely because an officer repeated the company’s position on oath. The witness needed an adequate evidentiary basis for explaining why the policy was not attributable to the insurer.
B. The Court’s illustrative evidentiary framework
The judgment identifies several potentially relevant forms of proof:
- Evidence from an authorized officer of the policy-issuing branch explaining the denial and its basis.
- Policy issuance registers or admissible electronic records showing the relationship between policy numbers, vehicle particulars, and dates.
- Premium ledgers, receipts, and payment records.
- Cover-note or policy-number series records capable of showing duplication, misuse, or non-issuance.
- Investigation reports supported by the underlying material.
- Police complaints, FIRs, and investigation material, where available.
Importantly, the Court expressly described these as illustrative modes of proof, not a statutory checklist. The judgment does not require every insurer to produce every listed document in every case. It requires evidence adequate to establish the particular defence.
Similarly, the decision does not make an FIR either indispensable or conclusive. Registration of an FIR would not itself prove fabrication; conversely, the absence of an FIR was considered alongside the other deficiencies rather than treated as the sole basis for liability.
C. Why the witness’s evidence was insufficient
The relevant office was situated at Andheri East, Mumbai, but the witness worked at the Ahmedabad branch. He asserted that “we” had investigated and checked the records without satisfactorily identifying who had undertaken those steps or explaining their foundation.
Cross-examination also established that he had worked for the insurer for only nine months and could not identify whose digital signature appeared on the disputed policy issued in 2015. No adequate explanation was offered for failing to examine the relevant signatories or other material witnesses.
The significance is not that an officer from another branch is automatically incompetent to testify. Rather, this witness failed to demonstrate sufficient knowledge of the historical records and issuing process to substantiate the denial.
D. The competing documents did not conclusively establish fabrication
The insurer’s central documentary argument was that the number on the alleged motor policy corresponded to a home insurance policy. The Court found this insufficient on the evidence presented.
Several circumstances required explanation:
- The owner’s name, registration number, engine number, and chassis number on Exhibit 66 matched the vehicle registration document.
- Exhibit 66 was computer-generated and bore a digital signature, consistent with the insurer’s stated policy-generation practice after 2012.
- Exhibit 66 contained a premium receipt number, while Exhibit 80 did not.
- The Court observed that Exhibit 80 bore a manual signature despite the company’s practice of digitally signing policies.
These features did not independently prove that Exhibit 66 was genuine. They did, however, undermine the contention that Exhibit 80 conclusively established its falsity. The insurer needed supporting records to resolve the discrepancies.
E. Delayed pleadings and inadequate challenge to the claimants’ evidence
The procedural sequence was particularly important. The claimant testified on 11 April 2018, before the insurer had filed its written statement. The insurer cross-examined the claimant without asking a single question about the alleged fake policy. It did not cross-examine the second claimant witness.
The insurer’s officer filed his affidavit on 15 May 2019, while the written statement was filed only on 19 June 2019, near the conclusion of the proceedings.
The Court treated this sequence as demonstrating a casual and inadequately developed defence. It did not hold that every late written statement automatically invalidates earlier evidence or cross-examination. Its criticism was directed to the insurer’s overall conduct and failure to put the central allegation effectively in issue.
F. Failure to respond diligently to suspected fraud
The insurer received notice of the claim in July 2015, but sent its complaint communication only in November 2017. The witness could not explain the delay or establish whether an FIR had been registered or what action followed.
The insurer had not notified the vehicle owner about the alleged fabrication or informed the Regional Transport Office. Nor had it adequately pursued possible involvement by an agent or employee.
These omissions were relevant because a serious allegation of policy fabrication should ordinarily produce a timely, traceable response. The Court regarded the lack of follow-up as part of the broader evidentiary weakness.
G. The limits of the “pay and recover” holding
The High Court upheld the Tribunal’s arrangement requiring payment while preserving recovery against the vehicle owner or his legal heirs. It considered that arrangement protective of both the third-party claimants and the insurer.
This holding must be read within its factual setting: the alleged fabrication had not been proved. The judgment does not establish that an insurer must invariably pay and recover even where a policy is conclusively shown to be forged and no insurance relationship existed.
Further, the Tribunal’s reasoning linked recovery to fabrication being established in future. The judgment should not be read as finally determining that the owner had committed fraud or that fabrication had already been proved.
6. Precedents Cited and Their Influence
Cited as 2026 INSC 339, this Supreme Court decision supplied the principal authority concerning an insurer’s duty to act diligently after discovering an allegedly forged policy.
The High Court reproduced the observation that once an insurer knows and is satisfied that a policy is forged or fabricated, it must inform the appropriate authorities, including the police. This supported scrutiny of SBI General Insurance Company’s delayed complaint and failure to establish any effective follow-up.
The precedent’s role was to reinforce the duty of prompt reporting. It was not treated as making a police complaint conclusive evidence of forgery.
Oriental Insurance Company Limited v/s. Jayeshbhai Bhagubhai Patel
The claimants relied on this Gujarat High Court decision in First Appeal No. 4114 of 2009 with First Appeal No. 4115 of 2009. The Court quoted it at length and regarded its facts as materially similar.
The quoted passage emphasized that third-party claimants should not lose compensation because of an inadequately proved dispute between the insurer and vehicle owner. It also relied on the insurer’s failure to initiate proceedings, communicate with the owner, or otherwise act on its allegation.
This coordinate-bench authority reinforced both the evidentiary conclusion and the protection of third-party claimants. Its rejection of a hypertechnical approach operated alongside—not in place of—the requirement to assess the evidence.
This Sikkim High Court decision, reported in 2015 ACJ 2575, appeared in the Tribunal’s reasoning reproduced by the High Court.
The quoted account concerned an allegedly fake policy issued by an insurer’s official, where the owner had accepted it as genuine and was not alleged to have colluded with the employee. The insurer was held responsible for its employee’s conduct, with the passage also referring to the limits of defences under Section 149(2).
Its relevance was protection of an innocent third party and responsibility for employee conduct. However, the present High Court judgment principally rested on failure to prove fabrication. It did not independently find that an SBI employee had issued Exhibit 66 or adopt an unrestricted rule excluding every forgery defence under Section 149(2).
Davinder Pal Singh v/s. Lakhwinder Singh and others
The insurer cited this Punjab and Haryana High Court decision dated 5 March 2009 to support the proposition that an insurer should not be liable where a policy is proved to be forged and fabricated.
The High Court did not undertake a detailed examination of that decision. Its relevance was limited by the factual premise: in the present case, fabrication had not been established. The judgment therefore does not necessarily reject the principle advanced by the insurer; it rejects the claim that its evidentiary foundation existed here.
Anitaben and other v/s. Abdulhakim Allarkhan Shaikh
The insurer also cited this Gujarat High Court decision, reported in (1996) 1 ACC 497. The supplied judgment records the citation but does not explain its facts or reasoning. It cannot therefore be characterized as expressly overruled, distinguished, or substantively adopted.
HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited v/s. Smt. Nisha Milind Kamble and Ors.
The claimants cited this Bombay High Court decision in First Appeal No. 1221 of 2023. Its reasoning is not reproduced or separately analysed. It formed part of the claimants’ submissions, but the supplied text does not support attributing a specific adopted proposition to it.
V. Ravi v. New India Insurance Company
Reported as 1997 (2) T.A.C. 693, this decision appears within the passage quoted from the coordinate-bench judgment. It was referred to in support of the approach protecting third-party claimants where the fake-policy defence was not convincingly established. Its facts and reasoning were not independently examined here.
United India Insurance Company vs. Ms. Meena Mitra and another
This Calcutta decision, reported as 2003 (2) T.A.C. 407 (Calcutta), likewise appears within the quoted coordinate-bench reasoning. Its influence was indirect, supporting the rejection of an inadequately proved policy defence. No broader conclusion about its precise holding can safely be drawn from this judgment alone.
7. Impact and Limits of the Decision
For insurers
The judgment encourages early, records-based investigation of suspected fake policies. Insurers should preserve issuance and premium records, identify witnesses capable of explaining them, raise the defence promptly, and document reports to authorities and subsequent action.
An internal investigation’s conclusion cannot substitute for proof of the records and facts underlying that conclusion.
For claimants and tribunals
Claimants receive protection against unsupported allegations that would otherwise obstruct compensation. Tribunals are given a practical framework for testing such allegations without treating either a printed policy or an insurer’s denial as automatically decisive.
For future litigation
The decision is particularly relevant where an insurer relies on a duplicate policy number, an officer without adequate historical knowledge, or a complaint unsupported by further investigation. Its force is evidentiary rather than absolute: a future case supported by reliable records and competent testimony may produce a different result.
The judgment does not decide the consequences of conclusively proved forgery, resolve the separate “Act only policy” dispute, or undertake a fresh determination of inter-vehicle negligence or compensation quantum. The Court described the deceased pillion rider’s position as involving composite negligence, but did not use this appeal to resolve the separate insurer’s outstanding issues.
8. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Evidentiary burden
- The responsibility to support a disputed assertion with adequate evidence. Here, the insurer had to substantiate its allegation that the policy was fabricated.
- Cogent and legally admissible evidence
- Evidence that the law permits the court to consider and that convincingly supports the relevant conclusion.
- Competent witness
- A witness able to explain the relevant facts or records reliably. Job title alone does not establish sufficient knowledge.
- Third-party claimant
- A person seeking compensation for injury or death caused by a vehicle, rather than enforcing the insurance contract as its purchaser.
- Joint and several liability
- Liability allowing the claimant to seek the recoverable compensation from the persons held responsible, without first collecting a fixed share from each.
- Pay and recover
- An arrangement requiring an insurer to pay the claimant while preserving a right to recover from the person ultimately responsible, subject to the terms of the order.
- Vicarious liability
- Legal responsibility for another person’s conduct, such as an employer’s responsibility for certain acts of an employee.
- Composite negligence
- A situation in which the negligence of more than one person combines to injure someone who is not responsible for that negligence.
- “Act only policy”
- Insurance providing the statutory minimum cover, rather than necessarily including broader contractual protection. Its application in the separate appeal remained undecided.
9. Conclusion
The judgment establishes a practical evidentiary rule: an insurer cannot avoid liability merely by asserting that a motor insurance policy is fake; it must establish that defence through reliable, legally admissible evidence.
SBI General Insurance Company’s competing policy, insufficiently informed witness, missing supporting records, and inadequate follow-up did not meet that requirement. The High Court therefore maintained the compensation arrangement and the insurer’s protected recovery rights.
The broader significance lies in balancing effective scrutiny of insurance fraud with timely protection of accident victims. Alleged fraud must be investigated seriously—but it must also be proved.