Accidental Display of the National Flag with “Saffron Down” Is Not an Offence Without Intent to Insult

Case: MOHAMMED KASIM H. K, v. UNION TERRITORY OF LAKSHADWEEP

Citation: 2026 KER 74369

Court: High Court of Kerala

Coram: Justice A. Badharudeen

Date: 26 September 2026

1. Introduction

The Kerala High Court considered whether a photograph showing the Indian National Flag with the saffron band facing downward constituted an offence under Section 2 of the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971. The photograph had been shared through WhatsApp groups and was noticed by the police.

Mohammed Kasim H.K., the sole accused in C.C. No.18 of 2023, contended that the photograph had been taken while participating in the “Har Ghar Tiranga” programme and that the inverted positioning of the flag was an inadvertent mistake. He invoked the High Court’s inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking quashing of the prosecution.

The case raised two principal questions:

  1. Whether circulation in a private WhatsApp group amounts to conduct in a place “within public view”; and
  2. Whether an accidental display of the National Flag with “saffron down,” without an intention to insult it, attracts Section 2 of the 1971 Act.

2. Factual Background

On 14 August 2022, the Inspector of Police, Kavaratti Police Station, registered an FIR suo motu after receiving, through a WhatsApp group titled “M.G.College,” a photograph of the petitioner holding the Indian National Flag with the saffron band facing downward.

The police recorded statements from several witnesses who stated that they had seen the photograph and felt that the flag had been insulted. A final report was consequently filed alleging an offence under Section 2 of the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971.

The petitioner maintained that the photograph was taken at his residence with his wife as part of the “Har Ghar Tiranga” campaign. It was initially forwarded to a private WhatsApp group consisting of BJP members from Lakshadweep. According to him, the orientation of the flag was neither deliberate nor intended to show disrespect.

3. Summary of the Judgment

The High Court allowed the petition and quashed Crime No.26 of 2022 and all proceedings in C.C. No.18 of 2023.

The Court reached two important conclusions:

  • A private WhatsApp group containing several members may qualify as a place “within public view” for the purposes of Section 2 of the 1971 Act.
  • Displaying the Indian National Flag with “saffron down” becomes punishable under clause (l) of Explanation 4 only when the display is intentional and accompanied by the requisite intention to insult or show disrespect.

Although the first requirement concerning public view was satisfied, the prosecution materials did not allege or demonstrate that the petitioner had intentionally displayed the flag in that manner. His participation in the “Har Ghar Tiranga” programme supported the conclusion that the inverted display was accidental. Continuation of the prosecution would therefore have amounted to an abuse of process.

4. Statutory Framework

Section 2 of the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971 penalises anyone who, in a public place or any other place within public view, burns, mutilates, defaces, defiles, disfigures, destroys, tramples upon, shows disrespect to, or brings into contempt the Indian National Flag or the Constitution of India.

The relevant statutory explanations were:

  • Explanation 2: The expression “Indian National Flag” includes photographs, pictures, paintings, drawings and other visible representations of the flag.
  • Explanation 3: A “public place” means a place intended for use by, or accessible to, the public and includes public conveyances.
  • Explanation 4, clause (l): Intentionally displaying the Indian National Flag with “saffron down” constitutes disrespect.

5. Analysis

5.1 Private WhatsApp Groups and “Public View”

The Court distinguished a “public place” from “any other place within public view.” A public place is one accessible to or intended for use by the public. A place within public view may, however, be private if members of the public can see or access what occurs there.

Applying this distinction to digital communication, the Court held that a private WhatsApp group with numerous members cannot automatically be treated as outside public view. The private designation of the group is not conclusive; the number of participants and the accessibility of the material to several persons may bring the communication within the statutory expression.

This part of the ruling is significant because it applies a statutory concept framed in spatial terms to online communication. Digital circulation among multiple persons may satisfy the publicity element even though the online group is not open to everyone.

5.2 Intention as an Essential Ingredient

The decisive issue was mens rea. Clause (l) expressly uses the word “intentionally.” Thus, proof that the flag appeared with saffron facing downward is not, by itself, sufficient. The prosecution must also disclose material showing that the accused deliberately displayed it in that orientation as an act of disrespect.

The FIR and final report alleged that the petitioner had insulted the flag, but they did not allege that he intentionally positioned it with saffron down. The prosecution argued that intention could be inferred from the circumstances. The Court rejected that contention because the surrounding circumstances instead suggested an inadvertent mistake.

The photograph was taken during the “Har Ghar Tiranga” programme, whose purpose was to honour the National Flag. That context was inconsistent with an intention to insult it. The fact that witnesses felt insulted established their reaction to the photograph, but not the petitioner’s state of mind.

5.3 Exercise of Power Under Section 482 Cr.P.C.

Section 482 preserves the High Court’s inherent power to prevent abuse of the judicial process and secure the ends of justice. At the quashing stage, the Court does not ordinarily conduct a trial or determine disputed evidence. It may nevertheless intervene where the prosecution materials, accepted at face value, fail to establish an essential ingredient of the alleged offence.

Because intentional disrespect was absent from the allegations and supporting materials, no prima facie offence was disclosed. The prosecution was therefore quashed without requiring the petitioner to undergo a criminal trial.

6. Precedents Cited

Mammen Varghese v. State of Kerala [2024 KHC OnLine 705]

In that case, the saffron portion of the National Flag had been outlined with a black line alongside a picture of the Father of the Nation. The Kerala High Court quashed the proceedings after finding that the act did not amount to an absolute insult to national honour.

The precedent supported a contextual rather than mechanically literal application of Section 2. An unconventional depiction or treatment of the flag does not automatically constitute criminal disrespect unless the statutory elements are satisfied.

V.K.Narayanan v. The State of Maharashtra (Crl.Application No.7 of 2026)

The Bombay High Court dealt with a ceremony in which the National Flag was hoisted with saffron facing downward. The accused was merely a participant, and the prosecution records did not show that he had hoisted or dishonoured the flag. The proceedings were therefore quashed.

This authority reinforced the principle that criminal liability cannot arise merely from presence, association or participation. The prosecution must connect the accused personally and intentionally with the prohibited act.

Binoy Balakrishnan v. State of Kerala [2026 KHC 1507 : 2026 (1) KLT 291]

This decision supported the proposition that a private WhatsApp group containing several members may constitute a place within public view. The Court followed that reasoning while rejecting the petitioner’s argument that a private group necessarily falls outside Section 2.

7. Complex Concepts Simplified

Mens rea
The legally required guilty state of mind. Here, the prosecution had to show that the petitioner deliberately displayed the flag with saffron down as an act of disrespect.
Prima facie case
A case supported by enough initial material to justify a trial. If an essential ingredient is missing even on the prosecution’s own version, no prima facie case exists.
Public place and place within public view
A public place is generally accessible to the public. A place within public view may be private but visible or accessible to several persons. The Court extended the latter concept to multi-member WhatsApp groups.
Quashing under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
The High Court may terminate criminal proceedings where the allegations do not constitute an offence or where continuing the prosecution would misuse the judicial process.
Suo motu FIR
An FIR registered by the police on their own initiative after receiving information about a suspected offence, rather than on a formal complaint from an individual.

8. Impact of the Judgment

  • Mens rea must be established: Accidental, mistaken or negligent inversion of the National Flag will not attract clause (l) unless intentional disrespect is shown.
  • Public reaction is not proof of intention: Witnesses feeling offended cannot substitute for evidence of the accused’s deliberate purpose.
  • Digital groups may satisfy the publicity requirement: A private WhatsApp group is not automatically beyond the reach of statutes requiring an act to occur within public view.
  • Context remains important: The occasion, purpose of display and conduct of the accused must be examined before inferring criminal disrespect.
  • Protection against over-criminalisation: The judgment prevents patriotic symbols legislation from being used to prosecute innocent mistakes while preserving liability for deliberate insult.

9. Conclusion

The judgment establishes that an inverted display of the Indian National Flag is not a strict-liability offence. Under clause (l) of Explanation 4 to Section 2 of the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971, the prosecution must demonstrate intentional disrespect. An accidental display made during a patriotic campaign does not satisfy that requirement.

At the same time, the Court clarified that circulation within a private, multi-member WhatsApp group may amount to conduct within public view. The ruling therefore balances respect for national symbols with the fundamental criminal-law principle that punishment should not follow where the required guilty intention is absent.