...October, 2009 on various grounds.3. Admittedly, the sur-rejoinder and the sur-sur-rejoinder were filed after the closing of the matter. The parties were represented by the advocates.... Therefore, in my view, the decision based upon the sur-rejoinder and sur-sur-rejoinder which were filed after closing of the matter, need to be reconsidered again. The submission that even otherwise, the...averments made in those sur- rejoinder and/or sur-sur-rejoinder could not have changed the basic award, is not acceptable. Because, it amounts no full opportunity, as contemplated under the principle...

...Heard the parties in respect of M.A. No. 44 of 2018 whereby the respondent has sought permission/liberty to file a sur-rejoinder. In para 2 of the application, it has been submitted that...rejoinder, the respondent seek the liberty to file sur-rejoinder on this limited aspect and to bring on record a sur-rejoinder which is already annexed at Annexure R/6 to the M.A. A perusal of the ...respondent on 27.11.2009.In the facts noted above, we are constrained to grant liberty to the file sur-rejoinder annexed as Annexure R/6 to the M.A. The prayer made in the M.A. is...

....Respondents no. 1, 2, 5 and 7 filed sur-rejoinder. Further affidavit of petitioners not filed.Respondents no. 3, 4 and 8 not filed sur-rej oinder.Learned counsel appearing...except to the extent of filing sur-rejoinder permitted by this Tribunal by it order dated 14.03.2017 which opportunity respondents 3, 4 and 8 did not choose to avail.Hence it is treated...sur rejoinder by Respondents 1 to 8. It is stated by the learned counsel for the petitioner that they could not file their further affidavit because respondents 3, 4 and 8 not filed their sur-rej...

...B.P. Colabawalla, J.:— When this matter is called out, Mr. Godbole, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 seeks time to file an affidavit-in-sur-rejoinder. The...first time which Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 would like to deal with in their affidavit-in-sur-rejoinder. 2. Mr. Kapadia, the learned Counsel for the Petitioners brought to my attention the...made. Mr. Kapadia submitted that these details are still not forthcoming and therefore, the Respondents be directed to furnish these details in their affidavit-in-sur-rejoinder. 3...

.../2018The learned counsel for the official respondents in OA No. 165/2018 seeks four weeks time to file sur-rejoinder. We have gone through the reply filed by the respondents. We do...not find any reasons to grant time to the respondents to file sur-rejoinder neither the applicant has given the specific reasons for granting time for filing sur-rejoinder to the respondents...

....Learned counsel for the TRAI prays for permission to file sur-rejoinder in Appeal Nos. 1 & 2 of 2016. The permission is accorded. The appellant, if so, advised may file a response to the sur...allowed. Both the appeals shall not be tagged with each other. However, Petition No. 444 of 2016 shall be treated as tagged with Appeal No. 1 of 2016. The sur-rejoinder should be filed within two weeks, as prayed for....-rejoinder but they should be careful not to bring in any new facts without seeking any fresh permission from the Tribunal otherwise it shall entail some penalty.On hearing the parties...

...statement has also been filed by the applicant at that stage abruptly sur-rejoinder was filed by the respondents and that taking note of said sur-rejoinder it has become necessary to amend the O.A. He...file ‘C’.4. Considered the submission. Sur-rejoinder was filed without proper permission. As noted above, on 06.09.2021 request to file reply of rejoinder was not...adverted to but to point out the necessity of filing of sur-rejoinder simplicitor adjournment was requested. Rejoinder was filed and then giving impressing that it is in file ‘C’, direction was sought to...

...that there is a substantial Reply and his Rejoinder is likely to be equally substantial, the Rejoinder is to be filed and served in the Registry on or before 15th April 2017. I have no doubt that a Sur...-Rejoinder will also then be necessary. Rather than wasting time in an application for adjournment: Affidavit in Sur-Rejoinder to be filed and served on or before 15 June 2017 and this will be followed...by a month's time until 20 July 2017 for an Affidavit in Sur-Sur-Rejoinder.3. At this point all filings will stop. By then the record should have crossed at least 2000 pages. It will...

..., according to him, the filings in the Notice of Motion have reached the stage of a sur-rejoinder ending at page 441. Mr. Jamsandekar's immediate goal is to file a sur-sur-rejoinder. He says that there...is new material introduced by Indigo in sur-rejoinder and he is going to show actual confusion. Given the highly eccentric paging of this record, some confusion already exists, albeit not of the kind...Mr. Jamsandekar has in mind. Goaded by this, Mr. Kirpekar for Indigo says he will then need to respond, adding even more heft to this already portentous litigation, by filing a sur-sur-sur-rejoinder — although...

...Application Nos.11 and 12 of 2025 have been filed by the plaintiff in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.190 of 2024 seeking leave of this Court to file reply to the sur-rejoinder filed by the respondent in O.A.Nos.744... said applications, provided the applicant serves reply to the sur-rejoinder along with supporting documents before 4 pm on 04.01.2025, failing...which, this Court will not consider the reply to the sur-rejoinder as well as supporting documents. 3. In the aforementioned terms, Application Nos.11 and 12 of 2025...

...for the Respondent No. 15 submits that in the Rejoinder filed by the Applicant new facts and grounds have emerged and, therefore, it is necessary for him to file a Sur-Rejoinder. Liberty is granted to...him to file Sur-Rejoinder within two weeks from today.During the course of the arguments it has been brought to our notice that some similar matter is also pending before the High Court...the said Respondent No. 2 be filed within two weeks from today with advance copy to the Learned Counsel appearing for the Applicant who may file Rejoinder thereto, if any, within one weeks thereafter...

...rejoinder, just nowand therefore, he desires to give response inasmuch as the rejoinder affidavit is elaborate and requires sur-rejoinder.Considering the fact that the matters are pending...) weeks hereafter. Applicant — Mayur Raskar or Shalini Raskar may file sur-rejoinder, if any, to the affidavit filed today compositely within period of two (2) weeks. The parties may exchange the documents...Item No. 6 April 16, 2014 Order No. 10The Counsel for Respondent No. 1, has submitted an affidavit in rejoinder to the Application of the Applicant, filed on 26 February...

...directed to file rejoinder within two weeks, supplying simultaneously copy thereof to the respondents. The respondents may file sur-rejoinder if, they think so.4. List the matter for.../contemnors, supplying simultaneously copy thereof to the respondents/contemnors. The respondents/contemnors, if so desire, may file sur-rejoinder within two weeks.7. List this matter for final hearing on 21-06-2018..... She submits that since, the leading counsel of the petitioner is not present before this Bench today, she needs some time to file rejoinder.3. Heard both the parties. The petitioner is...

...Respondent Nos. 2 to 6 are seeking permission to file Sur-Rejoinder. Time is granted with the permission not to raise any other issue but to confine the Sur-Rejoinder to the contents in the pleadings...10.03.2017. A Rejoinder by R. 7, if any, to be filed on or before 20.03.2017.5. In respect of main Petition a Rejoinder has been filed by the Petitioner on 02.02.2017, in that regard, the...

Can't display summary as content is Scanned, Please open the judgment to see full content.

...11 shall be permitted to place on record their further pleadings in the form of sur-rejoinder but only to the extent of new facts, if any, pleaded in the rejoinder filed by the...plaintiff. In other words, sur- rejoinder shall remain confined to any such fact, if at all, newly pleaded by the plaintiff in the rejoinder." and further stated that in view of...petitioner has submitted that in the above Order, the Hon'ble Apex Court was pleased to permit the defendants therein to place on record their further pleadings in the form of sur-rejoinder. Therefore, the...

...Hariharan for the Respondent. This is an application filed to take on record the sur-rejoinder. The sur-rejoinder is taken on record. Accordingly, this application is allowed and disposed of. Sd/- Sd/- MEMBER (T) MEMBER (J) ...

.... MA No. 429/2020 has been filed by the respondents to take on record sur-rejoinder. MA is allowed and sur-rejoinder is taken on record. The respondents' counsel submits...

....The learned counsel for the respondents has also pressed CA No. 255/2015 with a prayer for taking the record of the sur-rejoinder on account of some of the fresh pleas taken in the rejoinder. It is...submitted that the said Misc. Application with the sur-rejoinder was filed in the Company Law Board in the year 2015. The prayer for taking on record the sur-rejoinder is not opposed subject to the right.../Pb/2016. In view of the above, the prayer is allowed. Sur-rejoinder be taken on record. CA No. 255/2015 thus stands disposed of. The learned counsel for the petitioner seeks sufficient time that may be...

...the Sur-Rejoinder in accordance with law, incorporated in Rule 23 of the NCLT Rules, 2016. Therefore, this Bench cannot legally take cognizance of the aforesaid sur joinder unless the defects in the...aforesaid sur rejoinder are removed by the parties concern, in the meantime.In that connection, I have heard Mr. Bharali, learned counsel for the non-applicants/respondents who admitted...that some defects did creep up in preferring/submitting the aforesaid sur rejoinder before this Bench and, therefore, he urged this Bench to allow him to rectify the defects, so pointed out by the...