CiteTEXT
...of the total seats, women can be given reservation but then it should not be out of proportion. The reservation to any category and caste should be rational and not excessive. The Hon'ble...Constitution of India thus cannot be applied as such, however the ratio of the aforesaid judgment can be looked into for judging the issue as to whether there exist excessive reservation in favour of...category. It is contended that without ascertaining even proportionate population of women, amendment has been made to provide reservation to women to the extent of 50% of the total seats. Taking note of...
...reservation but then it should not be out of proportion. The reservation to any category and caste should be rational and not excessive. The hon'ble supreme court, while considering the m...applied as such, however the ratio of the aforesaid judgment can be looked into for judging the issue as to whether there exist excessive reservation in favour of women or not. Article 14 of the...without ascertaining even proportionate population of women, amendment has been made to provide reservation to women to the extent of 50% of the total seats. Taking note of the aforesaid reservation...
...doubt true that over and above one-third of the total seats, women can be given reservation but then it should not be out of proportion. The reservation to any category and caste should be rationa...aforesaid judgment can be looked into for judging the issue as to whether there exist excessive reservation in favour of women or not. Article 14 of the Constitution...even proportionate population of women, amendment has been made to provide reservation to women to the extent of 50% of the total seats. Taking note of the aforesaid reservation to women to the...
...and by providing as under:- follow department-wise roster as has been followed earlier treating different department as separate cadre; not to provide reservation in super-specialty disciplines and not to ...question. It is also mentioned that while reservations would be made according to the groups as provided above, the total reservation in any of the posts/services so grouped should not exceed 50 p...SCs, STs and OBCs in any post or service should also not exceed 50 per cent...
...reservation should not exceed 50% has to be applied. Similarly, a reserved category candidate selected on merit will not be counted in the quota reserved for such class of candidates.
...final decision in the writ petition on hand. The State Government on 21-3-99 has already issued an order directing the Cane Commissioner, U.P. to ensure compliance of the rule of reservation as envisaged...recruitment to the post of Cane Supervisor in Deoria Region was stayed by the respondents upon the supposition that the rule of reservation as envisaged in the U.P. Public Services. (On Posts Reservation...
...rule is that the reservation under Article 16(4) should not exceed 50% of the appointments or posts to be made in a particular year. This Court has also observed that the rule of 50% a ye...available in the year to fill the reserved seats, the reserved quota should not be carried forward to the next year, so as to exceed the 50% limit for reservation (AIR paras 98-9...for the purpose of making the reservation policy a reasonable one the extent thereof should not exceed 50% save in exceptional situation. The statutory rules also contain such a prohibition. Article 16...
...Scheduled Tribes came to 68 per cent leaving only 32 per cent of the seats for the merit pool. The Court held that generally and broadly reservation should not exceed 50 per cent. The actual perce...Tribes should not ordinarily exceed 50 per cent of the available seats. In the present case it is 41 per cent. On the material before us we are unable to hold that the said reservation is excessiv...)The Court struck down the reservation of 68 per cent as constitutionally invalid.110. The principle that reserved quotas should not together ...
...case 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 the same view has been held by indicating that only a limited reservation not exceeding 50% is permissible. It is to be appreciated th...whole and such percentage of reservation would be less than 50%. How much less of 50% is to be reserved would however depend on the facts and circumstances of a given case.8...Solicitor has submitted that such device of appointment by rotating the roster fulfils the felt need of reservation and also eschews the vice of reservation beyond 50% for the members of the reserved...
...down that overall reservation should not be allowed to exceed 50%.22. In the present case, the rule of reservation as contained in U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 if applied then ou...posts, if one of the posts is given to the scheduled caste category, the reservation would exceed 21% and reach 33%. It would, therefore, violate the maximum permissible limit as contained in the...itself. It, thus, cannot exceed the quota. If is not disputed that in the event of any conflict between the percentage of reservation and the roster, the former shall prevail. Thus, in the peculiar facts...
...reservation on the basis of institutional preference should not in any event exceed 50% of the total number of open seats available for admission to the postgraduate course...considered the problem of the assistance to backward communities, has observed that the percentage of reservation shall not exceed a third of the total number of seats, and it has added that the principle.... But, in our opinion, such reservation should in no event exceed the outer limit of 70% of the total number of open seats after taking into account other kinds of reservations validly made. The Medical...
...can this matter be reduced to a mathematical formula so as to be adhered to in all cases. Decided cases of this Court have no doubt laid down that the percentage of reservation should not ...1964 SC 179, (1965) 2 LLJ 560 that the reservation should not exceed 50% does not refer to Dr Ambedkar's aforesaid observations and is, therefore, not based on it, and is based o...the percentage of reservation should not exceed 50%. As I read the authorities, this is, however, a rule of caution and does not exhaust all categories. Suppose for instance a State has a large nu...
...217, (1992) 22 ATC 385, JT (1992) 6 SC 273 that the total reservation of vacancies of all categories should not exceed 50% of the total vacancies. The University then stated:...ATC 385, JT (1992) 6 SC 273 and exceed 50% reservation which is maximum? Our reply is in the negative. Let us consider the issue.25. In Indra Sawhney (I...selected. She challenged a notification of the State Government on the ground that the reservation was 65% which exceeded 50% and was thus violative of the constitutional guarantee under Articles 14, 16...
..."to fulfil this condition it is not necessary that an annual rent - should be reserved. What is necessary is that if an annual rent is reserved, it should not exceed Rs. 50/ -."10. This commentary,...rent and the rent should not exceed Rs. 50/ - and then alone the document will come within the exemption to Section 17(1)(d) of the Indian Registration Act. In the present case t...should exceed one year, and (2) it should reserve a yearly rent exceeding Rs. 50/ -.6. The rent deed in the present case, no doubt, is for a period of more than a year. The questions...
...: A.I.R 1993 SC 477, such reservation should not exceed 50%.2. In response - to. the petition one Shri M.R Patel, Dis...(1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : AIR 1993, SC, 477), and the prevailing Government policy, such reservation shall not exceed 50% of t...reservation to the extent of 74% of the vacancies of Vidya Sahayak, in the affidavit filed before the High Court, where such policy was challenged, clarified that such reservation would not exceed 50%. The...
...-12-2004.39. A significant aspect which needs to be discussed is that the aggregate reservation should not exceed 50% of all the available vacancies, in accordance...(3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 the same view has been held by indicating that only a limited reservation not exceeding 50% is permissible. It is to be appreciated that Article 15(4) is an ...reserved category candidates, the aggregate reservation could possibly exceed 50% of all of the available posts.40. In...
...that reservation under Art. 16(4) of the Constitution should not be unreasonable, namely that reservation should not exceed 50% of the total number of posts and that backwardness...in law and we are not interfering with the appointments made on the basis of the said reservation.21. Mr. Mehere has canvassed a view that this Court can suggest that reservation should not ...(4) of the Constitution, was noted. Then, it was observed that generally speaking, reservation ought to be less than 50%. On the facts before the Supreme Court, reservation was as high as 64% and it...
...action. The Constitution of India does not permit 100% reservation in respect of any particular class or category to the total exclusion of others. Reservation set out under Article 16 should not ...should also be exercised in a fair manner and within reasonable limits—and what is more reasonable than to say that reservation under clause (4) shall not exceed 50% of the appointments or posts...R. Chitralekha v. State Of Mysore AIR 1964 SC 1823, it was laid down that reservation should not exceed 50%; however, a little relaxation is p...
...217 , 1992 SCC (L&S) Supp 1, concluded that the aggregate reservation should not exceed 50%. Therefore, even when an MRC opts for a seat reserved for reserved category candida...significant aspect which needs to be discussed is that the aggregate reservation should not exceed 50% of all the available vacancies, in accordance with the decision of this Court in ...the aggregate reservation should not exceed 50%.24. It follows from the cases cited above that the 50% reservation rule should not be breached under any circum...
...above directions clearly shows that as per direction (iv), the Government, while making reservations both for women and other categories, shall ensure that reservations should not exceed 50% of the fair price shops...both for women and other categories shall ensure that the reservation should not exceed 50% of the fair price shops. According to the learned Government Pleader, the women reservation as ...other reservations shall not exceed 50%. But as it is very clear from the judgment, when 30% reservation was directed to be provided for women candidates, which is to be applied horizontally i.e.,...
...Supreme Court clearly observed that in any cadre, reservation should not exceed beyond 50 per cent. It has also been provided where 50% reserved category candidates have already been recruited, th...Section 3(1) makes it clear that in any year of recruitment, reservation shall not exceed either 50% of the total vacancies in that year of recruitment or even 50% of the cadre strength of the service to...further that reservation of vacancies for all categories of persons shall not exceed in any year of recruitment fifty per cent of the total vacancies of that year as also fifty per cent of the cadre...