CiteTEXT
...M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. v. Som Datt Builders Ltd...said to have been incorporated into the purchase order.5. We have heard the counsel for the appellant and the respondent. The judgment of this Court in M.R. Engineers case...contract was incorporated by reference in the sub-contract between him and the respondent.6. This Court in M.R. Engineers case...
...).9. This being the case, the present is a clear case where, under Section 7(5) of the Act read with M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd...accordance with Section 7(5) of the Arbitration Act read with this Court's judgment in M.R.... Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. v. Som Datt Builders Ltd. (2009) 7 SCC 696 would make it clear that ther...
...reported at (2009) 7 SCC 696 (M.R. Engineers and.../S. Thermocables Ltd.), and, in all fairness, submits that it could be argued by the opposite party that the said latter judgment had diluted the proposition laid down in M.R. Engineers & Contractors...(P) Ltd. (supra). In the judgment of Inox Wind Limited (supra), it was held, inter alia, that in view of the development of law after the judgment in M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd...
...the Act has been the subject matter of consideration before the Supreme Court on various occasions. In
M.R. Engineers & Contractors...Court in M.R. Engineers (supra) are set out below:
"17. We will give a few instances of incorporation and mere reference to explain the...professional institutions on one hand and the standard terms of one party on the other. Accordingly, the ratio of the judgment in M.R. Engineers (supra) was modified to the limited...
...reference to more than one document.36. In M.R Engineers and...the reference is such as to make the arbitration clause in such document, a part of the contract. In M.R Engineers and Contractors (P) Ltd...must have the intention to incorporate the arbitration clause. In M.R Engineers and...
...between the reference to another document and incorporation of another document in a contract by reference, which has been explained by this Court in M.R. Engineers and....14. In M.R. Engineers and Contractors (P) Ltd. case (2009) 7 SCC 696, this Court considered the true intent and...the following manner: (M.R. Engineers case (2009) 7 SCC 696)“14. The wording of...
...incorporation in the L.O.I. would not make the lis between the parties amenable to the arbitration proceedings. Relying on the judgment of this Court in the case of M.R. Engineers and Contractors...considered by this Court in the case of M.R. Engineers and Contractors Private Limited (supra). After considering the relevant passages from Russell on Arbitration and...incorporate the arbitration clause contained in the document into the contract.
14. The law laid down in the case of M.R. Engineers and...
....6, M.R. Engineers and Contractors Pvt.Ltd. vs. Som Datt Builders Ltd.7
and Duro Felguera S.A. vs...to settle the disputes arising under the referring agreement.
9 There is a binding authority of the Supreme Court in the case of M.R. Engineers and Contractors...."
10 The binding authority of M.R. Engineers' case neither cited before nor considered by the learned Single Judge in Sahyadri Earthmovers (supra...
..., the clause was “inapt” in the language of our judgment in M.R. Engineers & Contractors...clause would be wholly “inapt” as held in M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. (2009) 7 SCC 696 as it was to decide only questions...107 would govern the facts of this case being very similar thereto. He also strongly relied upon para 24(v) of the M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd...
...if it is contained in any correspondence exchange between the parties.
13. The Supreme Court in the case of M.R. Engineers and Contractors...reiterated the position of law in M.R. Engineers and Contractors Private Limited (supra) and observed that the Court was in agreement with the judgment in M.R. Engineers and...standard form would be enough for incorporation of the arbitration clause. In M.R. Engineers [M.R. Engineers & Contractors...
.... Engineers case [M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. v. Som Datt Builders Ltd...regarding incorporation after the judgment in M.R. Engineers [M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. v. Som Datt Builders Ltd...modifying the law laid down in FAO (OS)(COMM)195/2017 Page 13 of 15 M.R. Engineers (supra), also observed that a general reference to a standard form of contract of one party along with those of...
...2018 (2) SCC 519, as reproduced under:
"17. This Court in M.R. Engineers case [M.R. Engineers &am.... Engineers [M.R. Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. v. Som Datt Builders Ltd...incorporation of an arbitration clause. The Court, while modifying the law laid down in
12
M.R. Engineers (supra...
...judgment of the Supreme Court which was rendered in the case of M.R Engineers and Contractors Private Limited v. Som Datt Builders Limited reported in...delivering the judgment in M.R Engineers and Contractors Private Limited's case, the Supreme Court has quoted the following passage from Russell on Arbitration:“Reference to another...
.... The learned counsel put reliance on the decision of this Court in M.R Engineers and...
...placed on M.R. Engineers and Contractors Private Limited v. Som Datt Builders Limited reported in...relied on by the respondents is not applicable to the facts of the instant case and is accordingly distinguishable. In M.R. Engineers (supra), the provision for arbitration contained in the contract...entered subsequently for extension of validity of time. Moreover, M.R. Engineers (supra) emphasises on the point of mutual intention between the parties and interprets the contracts entered into between...
...arbitration clause therein, ‘constitutes’ the entire agreement between the parties.13. What distinguishes the present case from the one in M.R Engineers and Contractors Pvt. Ltd. (supra) is...to main contract unless otherwise mentioned in this order letter.”14. The Supreme Court in M.R Engineers drew a distinction between the contracts which merely made a reference to...the paragraph of the Agreement by which the General Conditions are sought to be incorporated are qualified by the words “concerning its subject matter”. Reference has been made on the decisions in M.R...
...order is unsustainable as the learned arbitrator has erred in law by misinterpreting the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.R. Engineers & Contractors Pvt. Ltd. (supra...submit disputes to arbitration.
29. In M.R. Engineers & Contractors Pvt. Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the arbitration clause...arbitration clause of the Loan Agreement, the respondents cannot be bound by arbitration proceedings. The respondents rely heavily on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.R. Engineers & Contractors...
...Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.R. Engineers and
- 4...this contention is examined in the light of the reference in the Addendum as extracted above, and the following enunciation by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.R. Engineers and...
...respective agreements and not by terms of an agreement not executed by them.
17. He relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in M.R. Engineers and Contractors Pvt. Ltd. vs...such as to make that arbitration clause part of the contract."
25. In M.R. Engineers and Contractors (supra), the Supreme Court explained the scope of Section 7(5) of the Act in the...Agreement be decided by arbitration. ARB. A. (COMM.) 25/2016 Page 12 of 17
28. As explained by the Supreme Court in M.R. Engineers and Contractors (supra) an agreement to refer disputes...
...incorporation in the L.O.I. would not make the lis between the parties amenable to the arbitration proceedings. Relying on the judgment of this Court in the case of M.R. Engineers and Contractors...considered by this Court in the case of M.R. Engineers and Contractors Private Limited (supra). After considering the relevant passages from Russell on Arbitration and...incorporate the arbitration clause contained in the document into the contract.
14. The law laid down in the case of M.R. Engineers and...