...member. At that stage, another co-ordinate bench cannot be invited to examine and pronounce on this question. It is for that bench and that bench alone to decide that question. Judicial propriety and discipline as...address to the President for the removal of a Judge. Petitioners seek the issue of an appropriate writ or direction to the government to act in aid and furtherance of the Speaker's decision and to provide...requisite and necessary facilities to the Inquiry Committee to enable it discharge its statutory functions. There are also certain prayers — said to be incidental to the main relief — to the effect...

...otherwise, without explaining why it could not follow the said precedent even while extensively quoting the same. Judicial propriety and discipline are not served by such conduct on the part of the...by another coordinate Bench of the same court. The rule of precedent is binding for the reason that there is a desire to secure uniformity and certainty in law. Thus, in judicial administration...judicial power by a judicial forum is for the forum to disclose its reasons by itself and giving of reasons has always been insisted upon as one of the fundamentals of sound administration of the...

...entertained by a Division Bench of this Court, judicial propriety and discipline require that the same order cannot be re-opened subsequently questioning the order passed in the review petition, which was dismissed, affirming the main order. Accordingly, the writ appeal is dismissed. No costs....on the file of this Court.JUDGMENTSatish K. Agnihotri, J.:— Questioning the legality and validity of the original order dated 22.8.2013 passed in W.P No. 36680 of 2006...

...distinguish the reasons therein to arrive at a different conclusion. Failure to do so infracts judicial propriety and discipline. Consistency in judicial outcomes is the hallmark of a responsible judiciary...the clear stream of justice. Impugned order suffers from the vice of judicial caprice and arbitrariness and is liable to be set aside also on this score. 18. For the....…Appellant(s) Versus State of Karnataka and Anr. …. Respondent(s) J U D G M E N T Joymalya Bagchi, J...

...necessary for us to consider the remaining questions Nos. 4 and 5. In fact, this reference involves the much larger question of judicial propriety and discipline. The Tribunal is...Chandra Patnaik [2002] 254 ITR 99 in the following terms (headnote) : "Judicial discipline and propriety demands that a Bench of two judges of...upon the Assistant Collectors and the Appellate Collectors who function under the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. The principles of judicial discipline require that the orders of the higher appellate...

...was followed only because, as expressly stated, judicial propriety and discipline so required. The view expressed by the Tribunal in the second order was contrary to that expressed in the first order...S.P Bharucha, J.— These are appeals against orders of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal dismissing appeals filed by the present appellants, Steel...manufacture of fertiliser; and(ii) The procedure set out in Chapter X of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 is followed.”It was the...

...instant case. Shri Choudhary submitted that the judicial discipline and propriety demands that the Tribunal should have followed its earlier view instead of following the later view. Shri R.L. Jain...would be against judicial propriety and discipline. Thus, the order of the Tribunal suffers from legal infirmity which cannot be allowed to sustain. In view of the aforesaid, it would be in the fitness...not maintaining judicial discipline by following the orders of the higher authorities, held that since in Agrawal Warehousing and Leasing Ltd.'s case, the Tribunal had taken a decision on the legal...

...circumstances recorded above, would be against judicial propriety and discipline, and therefore this application needs to be rejected. Reference in this regard can also be made to the observations of...the opponents from operating the Bank Accounts of the Bhartiya Seva Samaj Trust, until the arrears of Pay and Allowance is paid to the present applicant. The opponents are indicated to be the...Trustees of the said Trust. These directions are sought, in furtherance of the judgment and order of this Court dated 26.07.2012 recorded on Letters Patent Appeal No. 1367 of 2008, by which the said Appeal...

Can't display summary as content is Scanned, Please open the judgment to see full content.

...unsuccessful judicial review before this Court in W.P.No.21358 of 2013. The judicial propriety and discipline require that the same issue cannot be reconsidered by co-ordinate Division Bench. Whether the...(Order of the Court was made by SATISH K.AGNIHOTRI, J.) Questioning the validity and legality of the order dated 08.02.2013 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Tiruppur in...petitioner, he being the son and shareholder in the property in question, is competent to agitate the same issue again before this Court as the order passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate was not in...

...29.7.2004, 10.9.2004 and 5.10.2004 respectively, which is against judicial propriety and discipline.(Harbanslal) J.”9. The Judicial Magistrate sent his reply dated 03.02.2005...grant bail to the accused non-petitioner No. 2 vide impugned order dated 10.01.2005 The said order is against judicial propriety and discipline.11. In addition to the above submission of.... It appears that the Judicial Magistrate has acted contrary to the basic principles of judicial propriety and discipline. It was not open for him to grant bail to accused in this case after rejection...

...judgments of other High Courts in a manner contrary to judicial propriety and discipline? 2. Whether the Appellate Tribunal is right in law in acting on the retracted...[(2008) 300 ITR 157 (Mad)] affirmed by the Supreme Court by order in CIT vs. S.Khader Khan Son [(2013) 352 ITR 480 (SC)] and relying on...confessional statement of the appellant, uncorroborated by tangible material, which has no evidentiary value and is also against the CBDT instructions on the subject? 3...

...have been entertained by the Sessions Judge/Additional Session Judge being a subordinate Court to the High Court to uphold the judicial propriety and to maintain the judicial discipline. Once a matter...attended by the same Presiding Judge if available at station, that should be strictly followed to maintain the judicial propriety and discipline.6. Revert back to the facts in hand as...@ Kutti Mia to be released on bail in the event of arrest in connection with West Agartala P.S Case No. 170/2K under Section 148/149/302 I.P.C read with Section 3/5 of Explosive Substance Act and under...

...propriety and discipline required that the earlier precedent by followed. He has also pointed out that before the Supreme Court in the Special Leave Petition the present appellants had relied on the judgment...Harjit Singh Bedi, J.:— By this judgment we propose to dispose of Letters Patent Appeal Nos. 756, 824 of 1991 and Civil Writ Petition Nos. 8175, 8651, 10777, 10948, 11282, 18454 of 1991..., 2744 and 6840 of 1992. The facts of the case have been taken from LPA No. 756 of 1991.2. The present appeal is directed against the judgment of the learned single Judge allowing the writ...

...imperative in upholding judicial propriety and discipline. The principle of stare decisis, which emphasizes adherence to precedent, guides this imperative. Firstly, judicial propriety necessitates honoring the decisions of Coordinate Benches, to ensure consistency and predictability in the application of legal principles. The judiciary's credibility relies on maintaining a coherent and - 8 - uniform approach to legal interpretation, especially concerning recurring issues like those involving the powers of law enforcement officials. Secondly, judicial discipline mandates... Court of Allahabad..." "Judicial discipline/propriety demand to respect the order passed by the Coordinate Bench and more...not under challenge before it." 9. Therefore, in light of the principles of judicial propriety and discipline, this Court is duty-bound to...

...conduct of the counsel and the Bench in relation to a disposed of matter in a wholly unconnected judicial proceedings. In doing so he transgressed all bounds of judicial propriety and discipline.26...have been put in issue in this appeal, touch not only upon the discipline of the High Court and the powers of the Chief Justice to assign cases and allot Benches but also the larger issue of judicial...Chief Justices regarding the “illegal” drawal by them of daily allowance while sitting at Jaipur.6. While the judicial propriety, validity and justification for making...

...manner. Therefore all those engaged in this endeavour were expected to observe the rules of the game or else it would throw judicial propriety and discipline overboard and breed judicial malfunctioning...judicial order. A Court had an inherent obligation to support its action by reasons, otherwise all its judgments/orders would tantamount to a dictate and a fiat. It was immaterial whether a Judgment...that the order passed by the Division Bench was binding on that Court and ought to have been carried out in that spirit. After all our Judicial system functions in a prescribed methodical order and...

...proceedings. It is also submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the decision of the tribunal is contrary to the judicial propriety and discipline as the Division Bench decision passed...judicial propriety or discipline on the part of the Division Bench in passing the impugned order. Accordingly, following the reasons assigned in the order passed in WP No. 50850/2004, this writ petition is dismissed setting aside the order of the disciplinary authority and appellate authority imposing penalty of reducing the salary by seven stages with cumulative effect....his qualification and that misconduct of the applicant had not been proved and the order of penalty confirmed in appeal and revision was liable to be set aside.2. The respondent herein...

...other alternative but to set aside the Order dated 20.09.2018 of the State Commission and to remand the case back to the State Commission. Judicial propriety and discipline demand that the matter be...Commission's impugned Order dated 20.09.2018, the 'Coram' has been shown to be that of Mr. Ram Singh Chaudhary, Judicial Member and Mrs. Manjula, Member. Even the Order has been signed by both the said Members...before the State Commission. The arguments were heard on 18.09.2018 by only Mr. Ram Singh Chaudhary, Judicial Member, and Mrs. Manjula, Member was not sitting in the arguments. However the Order dated...

...other alternative but to set aside the Order dated 20.09.2018 of the State Commission and to remand the case back to the State Commission. Judicial propriety and discipline demand that the matter be...Commission's impugned Order dated 20.09.2018, the 'Coram' has been shown to be that of Mr. Ram Singh Chaudhary, Judicial Member and Mrs. Manjula, Member. Even the Order has been signed by both the said Members...before the State Commission. The arguments were heard on 18.09.2018 by only Mr. Ram Singh Chaudhary, Judicial Member, and Mrs. Manjula, Member was not sitting in the arguments. However the Order dated...