...caste/tribe of the petitioner or his ancestors as "Koshti". 6. Though the Committee may be right in recording that in Vidarbha region the community by name Halba-Halbi Koshti exists...finding is not perverse. The Committee has found that in Vidarbha region sub-caste Halbi of Caste Koshti is also recorded as Halbi and therefore, entries are not decisive. It is contended that the.... In the present facts, there is no material indicating that the caste recorded as Halbi is sub-caste Halbi of Koshti caste. In other words, there is no material to doubt the correctness of the claim...

.... Halba, Halbi”9. In the State of Maharashtra, the ambit of Entry 19 became a bone of contention particularly with persons belonging to the Halba-Koshti community...1985 SCC OnLine Bom 214, (1986) 1 Bom CR 403. The Division Bench held that Halba-Koshti constituted a sub-division of the tribe “Halba-Halbi” under Entry 19 of the....”The judgment of the Bombay High Court holding that Halba-Koshti formed a part of the designated Scheduled Tribe, Halba-Halbi was reversed. The declaration of law by this Court...

...to whether “Koshti” is a sub-caste of “Halba” or “Halbi” came up for consideration before a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Milind Sharad Katware v. State of Maharashtra...about other committees or that even without that a conclusion is reached that Halba-Koshti does not form part and parcel of Tribe ‘Halba/Halbi’. It is thus clear that the enquiries undertaken by...about a tribe in cases of near relatives.(5) Circulars dated 31-7-1981 and 23-9-1983 are valid.(6) ‘Halba-Koshti’ is a sub-division of the main tribe ‘Halba/Halbi’ as...

...wherein his caste is shown as Halba/Halbi. She further submitted that in the document of 1957, their caste is shown as Halbi (Koshti), and the document of 1962 pertains to his mother, showing her...petitioner, to substantiate his claim, has produced eight documents pertaining to himself, his father and his mother from 01.05.1957 to 6.8.2012, wherein their caste is shown as Halba/Halbi (Koshti). The...Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Act, 2000 ("the Act", for short) burden castes on the petitioner to prove that he belongs to Halba/Halbi caste. But, he failed to discharge such a burden. He failed to explain the adverse oldest entries of the years 1930, 1957 and 1961 pertaining to his cousin, grandfather, and father. It is pertinent to note that these three documents are the oldest, and their caste is shown as Koshti/Halbi...

...-1953, their caste was recorded as “Koshti (which is scored off) Halba” (Koshti), the Vigilance Officer submitted a report unfavourable to the appellant. The Vigilance Cell found that the appellant was a member of “Halbi” sub...old M.P region, in old records the sub-caste Halbi of the caste Koshti is recorded as Halbi which is popularly known as Halba Koshti and, therefore, this cannot be treated as such...-caste of the “Koshti” caste but does not belong to “Halbi” Scheduled Tribe.6. A copy of the report of the Vigilance Cell was supplied to the...

...which was, as per the case of respondent Bank, mis-leading. 2. After extensive hearing on the matter, it is noticed that the entire controversy of Halba Koshti / Halbi Koshti was...were subject matter of challenge before the different Courts for the declaration of Halba Koshti / Halbi Koshti - Scheduled Tribe / Scheduled Caste. 3. It deserves to be noted that in.../ Claims. Para 5(B) clearly stipulates that the fresh certificate of belonging to Halba Koshti / Halbi Koshti / Koshti Caste submitted by the concerned employee under Para (A) above will be verified...

... Annexure-P/7 dated 02.09.2021 in light of various judgments passed by this High Court. The circular provided that individuals who do not belong to the 'Halba/Halbi Koshti' Scheduled Tribe category...

...for assessing the claim of the petitioner, therefore, the reference to certain surname is irrelevant, who are not shown as the Halbi caste. The committee has emphasized that the Halba Koshti/Halbi Koshti...help the petitioner. There is not a single document which would show single entry as Halba Koshti/Halbi Koshti as regards the petitioner or his relatives. 6. The...are sub-caste of the Koshti, therefore such caste cannot be referred to as the 'Halbi'. There is no dispute about this proposition of law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court. On the contrary, it...

..."Appointment of candidates belonging to the Halba Koshti/Halbi Koshti/Koshti caste against vacancies reserved for the 3 O.A. No. 2174/2011 Scheduled Tribes b ...

...1987 Mh.L.J. 572. It was observed by the Division Bench of this Court in the said judgment that Halba/Halbi Koshti is sub-division of tribe as per Entry 19 of the...Court that Halba Koshti Caste is not a sub-tribe within the meaning of Entry 19 (Halba-Halbi) of the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950 relating to State of Maharashtra. Though the judgment in...revealed that several documents of the years ranging from 1937 to 1956 and showing the entries 'Koshti' and 'Halba-Koshti'' in the caste column were concealed by the petitioners and were not produced...

...1987 Mh.L.J. 572. It was observed by the Division Bench of this Court in the said judgment that Halba/Halbi Koshti is sub-division of tribe as per Entry 19 of the...Court that Halba Koshti Caste is not a sub-tribe within the meaning of Entry 19 (Halba-Halbi) of the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950 relating to State of Maharashtra. Though the judgment in...revealed that several documents of the years ranging from 1937 to 1956 and showing the entries 'Koshti' and 'Halba-Koshti'' in the caste column were concealed by the petitioners and were not produced...

.../Mannawar 6 Halba/Halbi Koshti/Halba Kosthi The monographs of Prof. Mutatkar and Dr. Tribhuwan have...

..., Department of General Administration, all appointments made prior to 28.11.2000 of the candidates belonging to Halba Koshti/Halbi Koshti/Koshti caste will be protected.They state, in...belonging to ‘Halba’ community. The respondents dismissed the petitioner's services by invoking Rule 10 of MPCS (CCA) Rules, 1966 by order dated 4.11.2009 The said order was...will hold the field and appointment made prior to 28.11.2000 of all candidates belonging to ‘Halba’ ‘Kosthi’ caste shall be protected. The Review Petition filed by the State was dismissed on the...

.... Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner belongs to 'Koshti' caste and was issued a caste certificate of 'Halba' caste on 25.7.1978, as 'Halba' Koshti/Halbi Koshti/Koshti were...under the category of Scheduled Tribe belongs to 'Halba' Koshti/Halbi Koshti/Koshti castes were protected by the State Government in the light of judgment rendered by the Apex Court in the case of...contended by learned counsel for the petitioner, at the relevant point of time, Halba Koshti/Halbi Koshti/Koshti were treated as 'Halba' caste. The High Level Caste Scrutiny Committee in its order dated...

...caste entry as 'Koshti' or 'Halba-Koshti' or 'Halbi-Koshti' or " 'Halba'/'Halbi' as a sub-caste of 'Koshti' " either in the name of the petitioner or any of...-1985 and 13-6-1995, and (vii) The information collected by the Committee by contacting several old people belonging to 'Halba/Halbi, Scheduled Tribe', make it very clear that apart from 'Halba/Halbi, Scheduled Tribe', there are also sub-caste 'Halba', sub-caste 'Halbi', and sub-caste 'Halba-Koshti of...entitled to benefits of recognized Scheduled Tribe. (B) The caste 'Koshti' or 'Halba-Koshti' is included in the list of Special Backward Classes in the State of Maharashtra, and there is similarity in the nomenclature between the two groups, viz. (i) 'Halba'/'Halbi', and...

... aunt is mentioned as 'Koshti (Halbi) and Halba Koshti respectively on 20.07.1955 and 11.07.1961, that is after 1950. The Committee holds that...'Koshti'. The documents having probative value negatived the claim of the petitioner for Halba - Scheduled Tribe category. We find that the order is based upon the evidence available on record and we do...Court had directed the declaration of the results of the exam of the petitioner. 2] The caste claim of the petitioner for Halba - Scheduled Tribe category was referred to...

...October, 2011, wherein it has been categorically mentioned that any person belonging to Halba Koshti or Halbi Koshti or Koshti who have been given appointment prior to 28.11.2000, his services need not be...terminated. Ld. counsel for the applicant also drew attention of this Tribunal to DoPT Office Memorandum dated 10.08.2010, wherein also there is a categorical direction that persons belonging to Halba...Koshti/ Koshti caste, who got appointment in the Scheduled Tribe category on the basis of Caste Certificates issued to them by the competent authority in State of Maharastra and whose appointment done...

...); 4. Gond Gowari Gowari 5. Mannerwarlu Munnurwar/Mannerwar/Mannawar 6. Halba/Halbi Koshti/Halba...(Entry No. 18)(5) Mannervarlu (Entry No. 27)(6) Halba, Halbi (Entry No. 19)18. Over a period of time, it is revealed that the persons belonging to no...KoshtiThe monographs of Prof. Mutatkar and Dr. Tribhuwan have emphasized that there has been a rapid rise in the growth rate of the Scheduled Tribes between...