...dated 21.12.2009 for expunction of adverse/below bench mark grading recorded in his ACR for the period 2008-2009 was rejected, order dated 03.02.2011 (Annexure- 4) vide which his representation dated 0...-expunction of adverse/below bench mark gradings contained in his ACRs and the consequential non-consideration of his case for promotion to the post of Statistical Investigator Gr.1. ...orders. 3 4. Expunging of adverse remarks/upgradation of below benchmark grading of each year constitutes a...

...dated 21.12.2009 for expunction of adverse/below bench mark grading recorded in his ACR for the period 2008-2009 was rejected, order dated 03.02.2011 (Annexure- 4) vide which his representation dated 0...-expunction of adverse/below bench mark gradings contained in his ACRs and the consequential non-consideration of his case for promotion to the post of Statistical Investigator Gr.1. ...orders. 3 4. Expunging of adverse remarks/upgradation of below benchmark grading of each year constitutes a...

...the Director General of Police has accepted the revision expunging the adverse remarks, vide order dated 28.11.2002 (P-6), there was no power with the DGP either to issue show cause...set aside the order dated 26.8.2009 (P-15) withdrawing all the service benefits which have accrued to the writ petitioner-respondent on account of expunging of adverse remarks. In...28.11.2002 (P-6) expunging the adverse remarks, has resulted in various benefits which could not have been withdrawn nor the writ petitioner-respondent could have been denied the promotion. Therefore, the a...

...also any remarks which have been made that are likely to affect the reputation of the appellant. Since, the appeal is confined only to expunging of adverse remarks, the same is allowed. There shal...of 2009. The contentions raised by the appellant in the intra-court appeal that the adverse remarks were not at all necessary to adjudicate upon the issue involved in the matter, and further when he...cautiously and carefully adhered to. The advertence has to be sans emotion and sans populist perception, and absolutely in accord with the doctrine of audi alteram partem before anything adverse is said...

...the fact that the adverse entry was expunged on a second representation, irrespective of the fact whether second representation was not maintainable, the expunging of adverse remarks cannot be...Court in Ram Niwas (supra), the issue of adverse remarks was required to be considered having regard to justification or otherwise of adverse remarks in question. If adverse ...preferred another appeal/representation to the Director General of Police, which was accepted on 22.3.2004 and adverse entry was set aside. The successor Director General of Police gave show cause...

.... This is for your information please.'' Since the detailed representation of the applicant dated 22.03.2017 (Annexure-A/12) seeking for expunging of adverse remarks in the APAR has been... OA. 350/898/2017 Date of order: 18.01.2021 Present :Hon'bIe Ms. Bidisha Banerjee, Judicial Member HonlDle Dr. Nandita Chatterjee, Administrative Member !■ Sri...Suhas Ranjan Deb, son of Sri S. Deb, Working as Senior Section Engineer, under Divisional Railway Manager/W/Kathihar/ Drawing Section(Temporary), residing at Railway Quarter No. 264/B, Himachal Colony...

...view that present case is required to be re-visited by Director General of Police for consideration of expunging of adverse remarks in Annual Confidential Report referred to above. Accordingly, th...Magistrate. In the present case, prayer is for quashing of adverse remarks dated 16.09.2013 (Annexure P-5) in the Annual Confidential Report for the period from 07.11.2011 to 31.03.201 despite having been...Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submits that this Court, vide order dated 02.09.2019 passed in CWP No.23940 of 2019 titled as 'ASI...

...), Doordarshan on 03.04.2018 for necessary action. CPIO further submitted that the concerned representation is regarding expunging of adverse remarks in Appellant's APAR for relevant period and the competent... Date of Hearing : 02/04/2019 Date of Decision : 02/04/2019....), Prasar Bharti Secretariat, New Delhi present in person. Appellant stated that he is not satisfied with the response of the CPIO dated 16.02.2018 informing him that the desired...

...petition. The appellant filed the writ petition challenging the action of the government expunging the adverse remarks made in the annual confidential report of Respondent 6. The High Court took the...of the remarks was illegal and invalid, the adverse remarks would continue to remain in the confidential report of Respondent 6 and that would improve the chances of promotion of the appe...view that the appellant was not entitled to complain against the expungement of adverse remarks made in the confidential report of another officer. But this view is, in our opinion, erroneous because the...

...known as the Indian Police Force.”12. This Court held that the Court in its inherent jurisdiction can expunge the adverse remarks suo motu or even on application of a party. However,...)18. Thus, in view of the above, the arguments advanced on behalf of the applicants are not justified. The applicants cannot be permitted to make out a new case to justify expunging ...J.M Panchal, J.— The respondent Narmada Bachao Andolan (hereinafter called as “NBA”) has filed the aforesaid applications for expunging certain adverse remarks made in paras...

...submissions in his defence. Considering the fact that he was not given an opportunity to explain his position, his performance during a particular year has been discredited as the adverse remarks were not expunged by the competent a...remarks made in his ACRs from the year 1987 to 2005. 3. The CPIO has furnished partial information, while the adverse remarks/entries made in his ACRs were denied u/s 8(1)(e) of the...Act, on the ground that the information was available in fiduciary capacity. The appellate authority has observed that the adverse remarks in the ACR of the appellant for the year 1991 were verbally...

...him and on his exoneration, approached the Inspector General of Police through a representation for expunging of adverse remarks recorded against him. The said representation of the petitioner has...charges. The adverse remarks in the Annual Confidential Report for the period 01.04.2010 to 24.12.2010 stand expunged on 09.07.2013 by the Inspector General of Police. Petitioner, after the decision of the...submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner and on going through the records of the case, I am of the considered view that the representation of the petitioner against the adverse remarks...

Can't display summary as content is Scanned, Please open the judgment to see full content.

...This is an application filed by the applicant, by virtue of which, he has prayed for expunging of adverse remarks for the year 1993 on the ground that he has not worked under the...Initiating Officer for more than 90 days. It is also prayed by the applicant that once the adverse remarks against the applicant are set aside on account of the aforesaid reason, he may be given all...of the applicant is that adverse remarks have been recorded against him by an officer who was not competent to initiate his ACR.4. The respondents have contested the claim of the...

...This is an application filed by the applicant, by virtue of which, he has prayed for expunging of adverse remarks for the year 1993 on the ground that he has not worked under the...Initiating Officer for more than 90 days. It is also prayed by the applicant that once the adverse remarks against the applicant are set aside on account of the aforesaid reason, he may be given all...applicant is that adverse remarks have been recorded against him by an officer who was not competent to initiate his ACR.4. The respondents have contested the claim of the applicant...

...refuses the prayer of the applicant for expunging of the entire adverse remarks and order expunging of adverse remarks communicated to the applicant by Memorandum No. 4....the interest of justice and equity.”2. The respondents have issued a memorandum dated 12-11-2003 (Annexure A11) communicating adverse remarks recorded in the CR of the applicant for the...adverse remarks on 5-12-2003. No orders were passed in the said matter till 28-9-2005 on which date another communication dated 28-9-2005 communicating one more adverse remarks in the ACR of the...

...respondent No.7, the same have been rendered infructuous by afflux of time. However, as regards grant of writ of mandamus, whereby expunging of adverse remarks/entry in the Service Book ...seeking expunging of the adverse remarks against the applicant in his Service Book, which read as "that the official is habitual of remaining 4...mandamus commanding the respondents to expunge the adverse remarks/entry in the Service Book of the petitioner by respondent No. 4. III/ A writ in the nature of...

...of the matter the order passed by the respondents is reproduced as under:- "Subject:- Request for expunging of adverse remarks in incomplete APARs-My... and invalid for any official purposes, d) Declare adverse /vague remarks by Reporting Officers as unjustified and uncalled for and not...acceptable as same were never submitted even during service period of Reviewing Officer and accordingly forfeited his right to record any remarks in APARS in the light of...

...officer.7. Since during the arguments learned counsel for the applicant did not press for any other reliefs, mentioned in the Original Application except for expunging of adverse remarks in...had forfeited their rights to write their comments on these ACRs. Thus, the adverse comments of reporting officer and reviewing officer in these ACRs deserve to be expunged as the concerned authorities..., he shall forfeit his right to enter any remarks in the ACR of the officer to be reported upon and he shall submit all ACRs held by him for reporting to the Reviewing Officer on the next working day...

...relatingto expunging of adverse remarks from her ACR was provided. However, she desired the copy of her entire file pertaining to this matter and prayed that action be initiated against the erring official...record was provided to the Appellant. However, the complete file pertaining to expunging of her ACRs is not traceable as stated by the HoS of the school. Shri Mehek Singh added that he assumed the duties...-judicial stamp paper explaining the factual position regarding the availability of her file pertaining to expunging of her ACRs to the Appellant. A compliance report pertaining to the aforementioned...