CiteTEXT
...limited it to the question as to whether the principle in Cooper Engineering Ltd. v. P.P Mundha (1975) 2 SCC...enunciated by this Court in Cooper Engineering Ltd. case (1975) 2 SCC 661, (1976) 1 SCR 361.7. Before...Tarkunde this proposition is no more res integra and is concluded by the decision of this Court in Cooper Engineering Ltd. case (1975) 2...
...procedure as envisaged by Cooper Engineering Ltd. v. P.P. Mundhe 1975-II L.L.J. 379 : (1975) 48 F.J.R. 152. When as a result of a domestic enquiry...procedure as laid down in Cooper Engineering Ltd. v. P.P. Mundhe, (supra) before proceeding further. There will be an order accordingly. No costs.
...
...calling him to adduce further evidence to sustain the charges, if the employer chooses to do so, by relying on the decision of this Court in the case of Cooper Engineering Ltd...on the question as to the stage as to when leave to adduce further evidence is to be sought for, the decision of this Court in Cooper Engineering Ltd...
...disposed of.13. This Court in Cooper Engineering Limited v. Shri P.P Mundhe . (1975) 2 SCC 661...
...the case of Cooper Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe, AIR
Page 1 of 3
1975 SC 1900 and the judgment dated...apposite to incorporate the observations made in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra):-
"22.We are, therefore, clearly of opinion that when a case of...considering the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra), has observed thus:-
9. From the above decisions and in particular from the decision of...
....
3. At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Cooper Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe....
4. At this stage, it would be apposite to incorporate the observations made in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra):-
Page 1 of 3...Coordinate Bench of this Court on a similar issue, after considering the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra), has observed thus...
.... At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Cooper Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe....
4. At this stage, it would be apposite to incorporate the observations made in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra):-
Page 1 of 3...Coordinate Bench of this Court on a similar issue, after considering the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra), has observed thus:-
9. From...
.... At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Cooper Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe....
4. At this stage, it would be apposite to incorporate the observations made in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra):-
"22.We are, therefore, clearl....
5. The Coordinate Bench of this Court on a similar issue, after considering the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra), has observed thus...
...decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Cooper Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe, AIR 1975 SC 1900 and the judgment dated 04.08.2004...the observations made in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra):-
"22.We are, therefore, clearly of opinion that when a case of...this Court on a similar issue, after considering the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra), has observed thus:-
9. From the above...
...1987 (55) Fac LR 634 : (1987 Lab IC 1854) and the Cooper Engineering Ltd. v. P.P Mundhe reported in 1975 (31) Fac LR 188...on the judgment in the case of Cooper Engineering Ltd., ((1975) 2 SCC 661...anxiety that there is no undue delay in industrial adjudication.”6. In view of the aforesaid it appears that question involved in the case of Cooper Engineering Ltd...
...Cooper Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe, AIR 1975 SC 1900 and the judgment dated 04.08.2004 passed in Special Civil Application No.8754...considering the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering (supra), has observed thus:-
9. From the above decisions and in particular from the decision...of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Cooper Engineering (supra), one thing is clear that whenever the Labour Court or the Industrial Tribunal decides the validity of the departmental...
...Apex Court in Cooper Engineering Ltd. Vs. B.P.Mundhe, (1975-LIC, P. 1441) has rightly dismissed the Revision filed by the Petitioner as not maintainable. In the circumstance, no fault...Industrial Court in Revision has held that in view of the case of Cooper Engineering Ltd.
3
(supra), the Revision...
...that case by the employer on the decision of this Court in Cooper Engineering Ltd. v.P.P Mundhe (1975) 2 SCC 661, (1976...to raise the issue.”Relying on this statement of law in Cooper Engineering Ltd. case...
...under section 33 of the Act.”5. The Apex Court in the Cooper Engineering Limited v. P.P Mundhe, (1975) 2 SCC..., after considering its earlier judgments explained the Cooper Engineering case by observing that decision in Cooper Engineering case does not propose the departure from the ratio of the earlier decisions...Shankar Chakravarty the Apex Court clarified that in Cooper Engineering merely stage was indicated and, therefore, Cooper Engineering case was not an authority for the proposition that in every case...
...referred case to this Bench. This latter decision, relying on the decision in Cooper Engineering Limited v. Shri P.P Mundhe...domestic enquiry as preliminary issue while the decision in Star Paper Mills Ltd. (supra) relied on the decision in The Cooper Engineering Ltd. (supra) holds the labour court should first decide as a...observations, while the decision in The Cooper Engineering Ltd. (supra) is specific on the question of domestic enquiry, hence the same should be relied. Further, contention is, learned single Judge while...
...)32. The question as to what is the appropriate stage came to be considered in Cooper Engineering Limited v. Shri..., (1972) 3 SCR 29 came to be considered again by this Court in the case of Cooper...Engineering Limited v. Shri P.P Mundhe . (1975) 2 SCC 661...
..., 243/2000 and 245/2000. 2. In the light of the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Cooper Engineering Ltd. Vs. P.P.Mundhe reported in...
...decision rendered by the Apex Court in the case of Cooper
Engineering Limited vs. P.P.Mundhe, reported in AIR
(1975) SC 1900.
In...
...preliminary issue. This
is the view taken by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Cooper Engineering Ltd. (supra). Ordinarily, the courts do
not entertain petition against the decision on...not open to any employer. I say that such a situation has
been appreciated by Hon'ble Apex Court in the decision of Cooper
Engineering Ltd. Vs. P.P. Mundhe reported in...in case of
Cooper Engineering Ltd. (Supra) has been followed by this High Court
on number of occasions. I say that, following the decision referred
above and also taking note of all decisions of...
....10. In Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City I v. Cooper Engineering Ltd...