...not in issue. What is stated is that there existed a vacancy in the institution where father of respondent no.5 was employed, and therefore her placement in a different institution in question is ....5 was a Class-IV employee in another institution and it is upon his sudden death that respondent no.5 has been offered compassionate appointment. The qualification of respondent no.5 for the post is...liable to be entertained in service matter. Petitioner claims himself to be a prospective candidate and has questioned the appointment of respondent no.5. It is not in issue that father of respondent no...

...credit. Petitioner No. 2 immediately applied for compassionate appointment. Initially the Authority declined to accede to such request, however, ultimately he was considered for compassionate appointment. Pertinent...reserve 5% vacancies for compassionate appointments. The petitioner No. 2 could not be considered for the year 2000-2001 in absence of any vacancy. In 2002 he was considered, however, he could not...applied for compassionate appointment. The Authority should have considered him contemporaneously. They initially rejected the claim in 2000 and again considered him for the year 2002 and rejected such...

...respondents opposed the plea by submitting that in terms of clause 3 of the scheme for compassionate appointment, the Head of the Department is competent to make compassionate ...), there is no scope for appointment on compassionate ground in the absence of vacancies, but the respondents need to consider the case of the applicant on availability of the vacancies. ...to assess the candidature of the applicant for compassionate appointment as per the procedure laid down in para 13 of the scheme, as and when the vacancy within 5% ceiling is available. (Mr. A. K....

...general circular/order in the absence of vacancy in any department/organisation, in such circumstances appointment on compassionate ground is required to be done wherever the va...The petitioners in this writ petition have called in question the order dated 27.08.2012 by which the claim of the petitioners for appointment on compassionate ground was turned down...an appointment on compassionate ground subject to the rules obtaining for such appointment. Therefore in the light of the endorsement issued that they would be offering an appointment to the...

...ground; andthirdly that the respondent-institute has no vacancy in Group C and, therefore, no appointment could be made in absence of any available vacancy....the Apex Court that no application for compassionate appointment can be entertained in the absence of any existing vacancy or when there is a ban on fresh recruitment. But, in the instant...was made and the Director of the Institute, after verification, recommended the case of the petitioners for appointment on compassionate ground in Group C as the application of the petitioner 1 wa...

Can't display summary as content is Scanned, Please open the judgment to see full content.

...liable to be rejected on this ground alone, yet respondents tried to consider his case. Simply because he was kept at Sl.No.1 in the wait list he cannot claim compassionate appointment as a matter of right if no ...department. However, the applicant could not be appointed on compassionate grounds for want of vacancy in the quota of compassionate appointment. They have further submitted that wait lis...on the judgment of Honble High Court reported in DLT 102 (2003) 414 DB. 3. Respondents have opposed this OA. They have submitted appointment on compassionate grounds is not a...

...liable to be rejected on this ground alone, yet respondents tried to consider his case. Simply because he was kept at Sl.No.1 in the wait list he cannot claim compassionate appointment as a matter of right if no ...department. However, the applicant could not be appointed on compassionate grounds for want of vacancy in the quota of compassionate appointment. They have further submitted that wait lis...relied on the judgment of Honble High Court reported in DLT 102 (2003) 414 DB. 3. Respondents have opposed this OA. They have submitted appointment on compassionate grounds is not a...

.... It is now a settled law that retrial benefits and other sources of income have also to be taken into consideration while granting appointment on compassionate grounds. In view of absence ...parties, it is appropriate to note certain basic parameters as laid down by the Apex Court, that are to be kept in mind while dealing with the cases of compassionate appointment. While considering the...case of compassionate employment, it is to be kept in mind that it is not unduly unfair to the rights of those other persons who are eligible to seek appointment against a post which would have been...

...seeking compassionate appointment on account of death of the bread winner of their family. In the meeting of Compassionate Appointments Committee of Western Region, GSI,...financial condition of the family can be considered as penurious. No vacancy exists for period ending 01/01/2007.The case can be considered for compassionate appointment for Group ‘D’ post as and whe...appointment in Group ‘D’ by the committee first met on 23.10.2007 and deprived him from being considered to seek compassionate appointment because of nonavailability of vacancy ...

...direct the respondent no. 3 to consider the claim of the applicants on priority basis for compassionate appointment in lieu of death of her husband, which has never b...for compassionate appointment. The case of applicant was again considered in light of the recommendation of the 7th CPC and now 61 points were awarded under different attributes to the applicant o...appointment on compassionate ground. Therefore the claim of the applicant was rejected on the ground that your case will be reconsidered in future and availability of the vacancies as well as on merit...

...applicant for appointment on compassionate ground as per the instructions prevalent at the time of his application with reference to the vacancy available for compassionate appointment "at that...reference to the vacancy available for compassionate appointment at that time". In view of the submission of the applicant that there were no vacancies available against which appointment...application with reference to the vacancy available for compassionate appointment at that time. That consideration was to be done within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a cert...

...compassionate appointment to the 2 applicant as the respondents themselves considered the case of the applicant and recommended the ca..., decided on 05.12.1990 reported in AIR 1991 SC 469 passed by a three Judges Bench wherein he shows that the Honble Apex Court has held that in the case of compassionate appointment when it is found...applicant. The respondents failed to give any appointment to the applicant though they have recommended her case for compassionate appointment due to lack of vacancy. Hence, the respondents are directed to...

...respondents. Under the Right to Information Act, the applicant has sought information from the respondents, wherein the respondents states that over the last twelve years, in absence ...confirms that the case of the applicant is under process and for want of vacancies under 5% quota defined for compassionate appointment and in the absence of vacancies, same could not be ...name of the applicant is in the list of the candidates, who would be considered for compassionate appointment and the cause of the applicant has not been rejected. It has been kept in abe...

...to be appointed against an inferior post. As held above, in the matter of compassionate appointment, the eligibility of the candidate cannot be altogether ignored nor can the authority be compelled to appo...a force of incompetent persons only because there is a scheme of compassionate appointment.6. As a matter of fact, the number of vacancy will always have a vital bearing ...vacancy exists on which the appointment of the petitioner could be made in C.I.S.F5. In a situation like this where the petitioner's right of consideration for appointment ...

...not consider the petitioner's case. It is nobody's case that even in the absence of vacancy she could be offered an appointment on compassionate grounds. Nor is it the case that she was the only...The Court: The petitioner in this WP under art.226 dated July 13, 2009 is seeking a mandamus commanding the respondents to offer her an appointment on compassionate grounds...wrote a letter dated July 8, 2009. She could not be considered, because there was no vacancy for the post of Follower (Peon) under compassionate quota. By a letter dated July 31, 2009 the Commandant of...

...petitioners for compassionate appointment on a Class III post and in absence of vacancy, on a Class IV post. While the name of petitioner No.1 appears at serial No.11 of the reco...petitioner No.2 appears at serial No. 13. Contrary to the recommendation of the District Compassionate Committee for appointment against Class III post in the Government that while petitioner No.1 was...Administrative Reforms, whereby the District Compassionate Committee was cautioned in not making recommendation for appointment on compassionate ground against the post of Panchayat Shikshak/Block Teacher...

...compassionate appointment, and the appointment is to be given in turn subject to availability of vacancy, the turn of the applicant would come according to her position in the wa.... However, on the basis of these judgments and orders as well as others quoted in the OA, it is not the case of the applicant that appointment on compassionate grounds could be granted in the ...applicants husband, the DoP&T Policy for appointment on compassionate grounds dated 30.06.1987 was in force, providing for priority and preference to cases of compassionate appointment against ot...

...employee and in the absence of any vacancy, the applicant was not offered appointment on compassionate grounds which action is in consonance with the instructions and law. The decision ...leaving behind his wife, three daughters and two sons, who are all unemployed. The applicant is the eldest child. The applicant made a representation in 2007 for appointment on compassionate grounds. He...was informed vide letter dated 20.3.2008 (Annexure P-7) that his name for appointment on compassionate grounds is at Sr. No. 34 in the seniority list and it will be considered as and when approval to...

...Education), who found her eligible for appointment and in the absence of any vacancy, directed to create a supernumerary post which was to be adjusted against the future vacancy. It is further sub...candidate. It appears that in the meantime, Smt. Mridula Singh, wife of Late Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh made an application for appointment on compassionate ground which was forwarded to the Director (Higher...about the existence of vacancy on the date when he made approval for appointment, therefore, without evidence being recorded by the court during trial, no finding can be given in such a matter under...