...& Ors.) held that refusal of compassionate appointment when the first wife and the second wife had shared the retiral benefits and the first wife and nobod...of second wife, was unjustified. Subsequently, with due reference to the aforesaid Railway Board's circular dated 2.1.1992 the Central Administrative Tribunal allowed the claim of ...Board's circular dated 20.1.1992, the sons and daughters of second wife are not entitled for appointment on compassionate ground unless the second marriage has been contrac...

...appointment, who were child of the second wife of the deceased employee were illegal and the respondents were directed to consider the cases of applicants who sought ...State Bank of India v. Raj Kumar, (2010) 11 SCC 661 has clearly held that compassionate appointment is traceable only to the scheme framed by the employer for ...who is son of late Ramesh Kumar Panthi, born from the second wife is entitled to get compassionate appointment.5. In this regard the learned counsel for the applicants has relied on...

...’) allowed the said Original Applications and held that the child of second wife of employee (married during the lifetime of first wife) also is entitled for compassionate ...January, 1992, the child of second wife cannot be given compassionate appointment.3. The learned Tribunal relying upon two Division Bench judgments of Patna High Court, del...Bihar (2005 (3) PLJR 458) held that rejection of the prayer of the appellant in those cases for compassionate appointment to child of second wife of employees were i...

...permitted consideration for the grant of compassionate appointment to the child of the second wife of the deceased Railway employee. Subsequently, several other judgments ...decided that children born to the second wife may also be considered for compassionate appointment even where the second marriage has not been specifically permitted by the administration. However, since ..., whereby the law regarding the eligibility of children born to the second wife has been made eligible for the compassionate appointment. 3. The respondents have...

...& Ors.). The relevant para 5 and 7 of this order is reproduced as under: 5 Facts are not in dispute. It is true that the decision of the Railway Board for not providing compassionate appointment to the ...ble Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India vs. Raj Kumar, (2010) 11 SCC 661has clearly held that compassionate appointment is traceable only to the scheme framed by the employer for such ...between the deceased employee and his first wife, Smt. Sunita Bai, giving of compassionate appointment to her will be against the provisions of Railway Board order No.01/92 dated 2.1.1992. The...

.... 892/2015 in two Central Railway cases that permitted consideration for the grant of compassionate appointment to the child of the second wife of the deceased Railway employee...Board's Circular No. E(NG)II/91/RC-1/136 dated 02.01.1992 (RBE No. 1/1992) referred to, it has now been decided that children born to the second wife may also be considered for compassionate appointment even whe...submitted his consent for appointment of his elder son Kunal Verma born from his second wife for appointment on compassionate ground. The applicant submits that the respondents have issued circula...

...filed OA No. 631/2018 claiming relief of appointment on compassionate grounds. Their claim was rejected on the ground that the 2ndapplicant is the child of second wife ...the applicants and Mrs. Vijaya Sagi, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents. 4. The question as to whether the child of a deceased employee, through a second wife, is entitled to be consi... Contempt Petition No. 21/0125/2019 in Original Application No.21/631/2018 st Hyderabad, this the 31 day of January, 2020...

...of the Apex Court dated 11.12.2018 in the case of the Union of India vs. V.R. Tripathi, (SLP(C) No. 32004/2016), permitted consideration of the grant of compassionate ...rejecting his claim for compassionate appointment, merely on the ground that he is the son of second wife/widow of the deceased government servant, does not hold good and should be quashed with th.... & Ors. decided by this Tribunal vide judgment and order dated 24.01.2020, the respondents in that case were directed to reconsider their earlier refusal to appoint a child of the second wife...

...of appointment on compassionate ground of a child born through second wife the request of applicant for appointment on compass light of order rejected the case .../2012 (Shri Deepak Kumar Rai) Honble High Court of Patna has also decided that the child born from second wife is not entitled for appointment on compassionate ground and therefore, claim for...Honble Supreme Court UOI & Another Vs V.R. Tripathi son through second wife can be granted compassionate appointment no more Res Integra now. The Honble Supreme Court in unequivocal terms has held that the ...

...that a child of a second wife of an employee could not be denied compassionate appointment on that ground alone. He also relied on the judgment of the High Court of Calc...Board circular that compassionate appointment cannot be granted to children born from the second wife of a deceased employee is legally sustainable. Having considered the matter, we have agreed with..., however, is whether the condition which has been imposed by the circular of the Railway Board under which compassionate appointment cannot be granted to the children born from a second marriage of a...

...case of child of second wife for compassionate appointment. They have also quoted and enclosed a photocopy of RBE No. 42/2018 dated 21.03.2018 according to which neither widow ca...have shown their inability for giving appointment on ground that he is a son of second wife, and as such not entitled for such appointment under Railway Board order dated 02.01.1992. The applicants...declaring for impugned action of the respondents, by which applicant no. 3 has been deprived appointment on ground of his being son of the second wife. They have also requested for directing the...

...respondent for appointment on compassionate grounds in terms of the extant Rules. 2. Learned AGA appearing for the appellants argues that the private respondent being the child of the ...appeal papers we decline indulgence in the matter in as much as the same question as to the eligibility of children of the second marriage for appointment on compassionate ground is concerned, matter is no...others1. It hardly needs to be stated that a second marriage during the subsistence of the first may be illegitimate, but children begotten from such a marriage are...

...decision of Patna Bench at Ranchi of this Tribunal, wherein the Tribunal had held that the rejection of the prayer of the applicant in those cases for compassionate appointment, who were ...second wife of deceased, after almost 20 years from the date of death of deceased employee, claiming appointment on compassionate ground, being legal heir of deceased employee....settlement dues may be shared by both the widows but appointment on compassionate ground cannot be offered to the children born out of the second wife, unless the administration has permitted the ...

...submitted that vide RBE 77/2011 authorize the time barred cases of compassionate appointment up to 25 years from the death of the employee. of Honble Supreme Court in Kumar the applicant no prevailing jud...decided that children born to the second wife may also be considered for compassionate appointment even where the second marriage has not been specifically permitted by the administration. However, since ...preferred by others seems misplaced . representation in November 2017 whereas Court judgement granting consideration for compassionate appointment to the child of the second wife in R. Tripathi re...

...child of a second wife of an employee could not be denied for compassionate appointment on that ground alone and the said Judgment was followed in subsequent Judgments of the Hon...applied for compassionate appointment and the same was rejected on the ground that the petitioner is an illegitimate son of the deceased employee who was born through the second wife when his first...compassionate appointment cannot be granted to the children born from a second marriage of a deceased employee (except where the marriage was permitted by the administration taking into...

...again observe here that the said decision of Railway Board, not providing compassionate appointment to the child of second wife of the employee who contracted second mar...the son of the second wife is not entitled to the benefit of compassionate appointment. We fully agree with the said judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Basanti Devi'...Railway Circular RBE No. 1/92, son of the second wife of the employee is not eligible for compassionate appointment, the Division Bench of this Court in Basanti Devi's case in W.P(S) No. ...

...petitioner that the Railway Board has subsequently clarified the issue of appointment on compassionate ground to 2ndwife and her wards vide circular No.E(NG)II/2016/RC-1/CR/12(Pt) dated 30.12.2019. ..., the first wife and her children should not object for such compassionate appointment being given to the child born to the second wife and where the first wife opts for the ...directed the petitioners herein to consider the application of the 2ndrespondent for compassionate appointment. 2https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis 2...

... the eligibility criteria under RBE No. 218/2019 for a compassionate appointment. 15. applicant, being the child of th... 6. application for compassionate appointment, citing that appl born from the second wife of the deceased and was ... family. 8. compassionate appointment on the grounds of the applicant's birth from the second wife is...

...challenge to the rejection order. The learned CAT was also guided by the judgment rendered by this Court in W.P.C No. 4461 of 2008, 4495 of 2008 and other analogous case where it was held that child of a ...1. Heard learned counsel for the parties.2. The claim for compassionate appointment of the applicant who admittedly was born out of the second wife (present petitioner) ...been rejected on the ground that such offspring from the second marriage of the employee, contracted during life time of first wife cannot be eligible for compassionate appointment in terms ...

...involved therein was also the same namely eligibility of child of second wife of the employee (married during the life time of first wife) for appointment on ...O.A. No. 256 of 2005, O.A. No. 60 W.P.(S) No. 8078 of 2012 With Civil Review No. 2 of 2015 and 61 of 2006, in which the issue involved was the same as in the instant case namely entitlement of ...that the said decision of Railway Board, not providing compassionate appointment to the child of second wife of the employee who contracted second marriage in the life t...