...to take a specific decision in light of the anomalous situation which is being caused in the Corporation itself. Grievance is that such proposals forwarded to the State by the...Government Order. Submission is that unless proposal of Corporation is considered an anomalous position would exist in the Corporation inasmuch as about 12000 employees would be... Court No. - 39 Case :- WRIT - A No. - 21300 of 2019 Petitioner :- Shamshul Haq Respondent :- State Of U.P. And 3 Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Rajesh...

...shareholder, namely, the Industrial Development Bank of India in the functioning of the Corporation. This situation was considered to be anomalous as the two institutions, that is, the Industrial...transactions would have to be backed by government guarantee. Furthermore, IDBI, which was a competitor of the Corporation, was a major shareholder in the Corporation and this had led to an ...situation. It is in this backdrop that the decision was taken to form a new company in order to get rid of these shackles and the object was not disinvestment on the part of the government or privatization. It was ...

...control of the managing committee. Such an interpretation would in our opinion, lead to anomalous situation.25. At this stage, it will be profitable to refer to a decision of the Supreme Co...judgment and order dt. Nov. 13, 1984 of B.C Basak J.2. The Bagnan Thana Agricultural Primary Co-operative Society Ltd., hereinafter referred to as ‘the said Society’, is a Society registered...in accordance with the provisions of the West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act, 1973, hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’. The said Society is a marketing Society within the meaning of R...

...thereagainst. He did not choose to do so.37. This case gives rise to an anomalous situation. The Corporation has been found to be liable to pay the amount of compensation claimed by the ...S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.2. The appellant was a driver of a bus belonging to Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation. He was driving the said...initiated against the driver of the truck. The Corporation denied and disputed the contention of the passengers that the appellant was driving the bus in a rash and negligent manner...

...the Act were to be interpreted in the manner contended for by the respondents it would lead to anomalous situation which are not conducive to the speedy administration of redressal justice by the Forums. To take one extreme...irrespective of where the cause of action, arose merely for the reason that the corporation may have a branch office functioning in the particular place where the complaint is instituted. If Section 11 of...reasonable to assume that in respect of complaint instituted against a corporation Parliament intended that the Forum before which a complaint is instituted should have either the nexus or accrual of the...

...concerned is located. That would create a totally anomalous and incongruous situation which is contraindicated by the factual data on record. There is a complete integrality of working of the empl...S.B Majmudar, J.— The Transport Corporation of India, which is a public limited company, incorporated under the Indian Companies Act, 1956, has brought in challenge the...' State Insurance Corporation and its officers is a short one. It is the contention of the appellant that even though its head office, being a registered office, situated at Secunderabad in the State...

...anomalous situation for every high court to exercise jurisdiction over every matter. Be it noted further that metal scrap trade corporation, though, has office at calcutta, but that does not mean and...was also deposited at vyzag and the contract to be executed at vyzag. No part, as such of the cause of action, far less a dominnt part of the cause of action has arisen within the territorial limit...has deprecated this exercise of jurisdiction in no uncertain terms and has awarded a cost against the party moving this court to the extent of rs. 50,000/ -. In another case reported in the same volume...

...Sanjib Banerjee, J.:— An anomalous situation has been brought about by the West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation Limited which the petitioner seeks to take advantage of and for which the petitio...meaningful industrial complex to be set up. Following a notice or a threat by the second respondent Corporation, the petitioner instituted W.P No. 416 of 2012 with the intention of preserving the....In April, 2014, the second respondent Corporation issued a notice to the petitioner that the yearly lease rent in respect of the property was being increased with retrospective effect...

...situation, transferer has to intimate the Corporation alongwith transferee. Same situation exists if the property is devolved upon a legal heir because Section 167(3) contemplates death of title holder...citizenry of that Corporation under different heads like property tax, service charges, etc.), and that would again create anomalous situation wherein the expenses of mutation proceedings of an...respondent/Corporation, it is not a case of unjust enrichment by imposing mutation fees per se, but it is procedural/incidental charges at best. 7. It is further submission...

...is accepted, it will lead to an absurd and anomalous situation wherein on one hand, the respondent No. 1, who was selected and appointed by the State Government for the KDM Corporation, though would be an employee ....45. We have no hesitation in holding that the intention of the legislature would not have been to lead to such an absurd and anomalous situation. A legislative intent cannot be t...2019, the General Body of the KDM Corporation also accorded sanction to hold departmental inquiry against respondent No. 1. Accordingly, the Commissioner of the KDM Corporation issued a notice dated 7...

...the Appeal is allowed, then an anomalous situation would have arised for the Respondent Corporation. In such an event, a situation might have ....133, Gokulpeth, Nagpur - 440 010. ....... PETITIONER ...V E R S U S... 1] Nagpur Municipal Corporation, Behind Reserve Bank of India, Civil Lines..., Nagpur - 440 001, through the Municipal Commissioner. 2] Assistant Director (Town Planning), Town Planning Department, Nagpur Municipal Corporation, Behind Reserve Bank of India, Civil...

...anomalous situation was brought into effect as a result of the interim order granted by the High Court. An interim order is granted by the court to protect the right or interest of a party approac...Allahabad High Court in a special appeal under rules of the Court upholding the order dated 11-1-1992 passed by the learned Single Judge dismissing Writ Petition No. 24200 of 1988 as not pressed....3. The writ petition was filed for a direction to the State Road Transport Corporation to absorb the appellants as conductors as they were placed in a select list prepared by a duly...

.... In this regard he further submitted that the appointment of the Assistant Law Officer as the Certificate Officer has led to a highly anomalous situation. Learned counsel pointed out that for recovery...is evident that if the words ‘any officer’ in Section 3(3) of the P.D.R Act are read in their normal, larger meaning, it would lead to a completely anomalous and unacceptable situation. The only way...the Corporation in all but two appeals and Mr. A. Amanullah appearing on its behalf in those two appeals proceeded on the premise that Mr. O.P Singh was an employee of the Corporation and justified his...

....It was observed that such a position appears to be highly anomalous. The Law Commission recommend to amend Section 28 of the Act as under:“28. Every agreement -(a...) deals with remedy, whereas Clause (b) deals with right and the anomalous situation observed by the Law Commission was, thus, sought to be remedied.The above said provisions of Law have...’) after its amendment vide Indian Parliament Act No. 1 of 1997, notified on 08.01.2007 After the amendment in the Act, any condition in the contract which takes away right of a party to an agreement to...

...for the appointment of staff on compassionate ground upon demise of a member of the staff of the Corporation while in service. These instructions are statutory in character. Therefore, they have t...exercise of power cannot be interfered with. Shortly put, the Corporation cannot be directed by means of a mandamus to do something which is per se illegal.9. Learned counsel..., with the State Road Transport Corporation to ply his bus as nominee of the Corporation on the route in respect of which the permit was issued in favour of the Corporation for a period ...

....”We are in respectful agreement with the aforesaid view.10. So far the facts of the present case are concerned a very anomalous .... Reversion from a higher post to a lower post may be under exigencies of situation or by way of punishment. The expression “reduction in rank” occurring in Article 311(2) covers only such reversions...appointed as Upper Division Clerks by process of direct recruitment in the year 1963. So far the appellant P. Gangireddy is concerned, he had been appointed initially as a Lower Division Clerk. They were...

...about anomalous situation. 6. Sri A. Satya Prasad, learned Counsel for the petitioners, submits that once the 1st respondent had framed the Rules in exercise of its powers under the relevant Artic...cannot be treated as a clarification as contended by the learned Counsel for the Corporation. The judgment of the Supreme Court in O.P. Lather...affidavit that the Board of Directors of the Corporation have not accorded approval for the amendment of the Rules. The Corporation did not contradict this averment in the affidavit. Further a rea...

...occupied by a gentleman called Mool Chand Yadav who is described as General Manager of U.P State Sugar Corporation Ltd., Rampur Unit (‘Corporation’, for short). The dispute going on is whether Hari...Bhawan is a property which has vested in the Corporation and whether the Corporation is entitled to occupy it and whether a part of it can be used by the General Manager of the ...1. Special leave granted.2. The matter discloses a battle of wits rather than of any legal substance or injured rights. There is one room in Hari Bhawan which at present is...

...of supply to July, 1972, ,vhich letter was acknowledged by the defendant-Corpo ration by their letter of February 11, 1972. Meanwhile an anomalous situation arose as a result of the excise duty pr...-Company that the defendant-Corporation, under the cover of their letter of May 15, 1967, forwarded a draft agreement to the aforesaid firm. It is claimed on behalf of the plaintiff-Company that Clause 3..., the aforesaid firm Frontier Chemical Works addressed a letter to the defendant-Corporation on May 2, 1969, inquiring as to what the price of ammonia was. The defendant-Corporation by their letter of...

...could have preferred an appeal there against. He did not choose to do so. 23. This case gives rise to an anomalous situation. The Corporation has been found to be liable to pay the ...held that such an anomalous situation of contradictory findings cannot be countenanced. Instead, the Court should apply the comity, amity, or principles analogous to that. The discussion on this issue...passengers from the minibus the Appellant drove were awarded compensation after recording a finding about rashness and negligence on the part of the Appellant. She pointed out that though the Appellant...