CiteTEXT
.... However, UPSC recommended names of three candidates from out of the reserve list maintained by it. These two appellants who were next in the merit list had secured 305 marks, same as secured by one Rajesh Kumar Y...names of persons in the reserve list was that some of the candidates whose names had been forwarded by UPSC did not join the post for one or the other reason. DoPT in its Communication dated 20-11-2009...not the subject-matter of the aforesaid office memorandum. UPSC pleaded that it was the convention, followed throughout as a policy decision, that supplementary list is not to be issued except in two...
...list of recommended candidates, UPSC also prepares a consolidated reserve list. This consolidated reserve list is a wait list for filling the remaining 32 vacancies. It contained two para.... Similarly, for the years 2006 and 2007, UPSC is maintaining a consolidated reserve list of 116 and 192 candidates respectively, but DoPT has not sent any requisition for the second list as per Rule 16...recommended candidates, the Commission shall also declare a consolidated reserve list of candidates which will include candidates from general and reserved categories ranking in order of merit below the...
...recommended by UPSC on the basis of Civil Services Examination- 2008 (Reserve List) is available on this Department's website at link: https://cseplus.nic.in. Information specific to...stating as under:
"Since the relevant Physical file related to service allocation of the candidates recommended by UPSC under 'Reserve List' on the...allocation of the candidates recommended by UPSC under 'Reserve List' on the basis of CSE-2008 was not traceable in the Section', the CPIO is directed to revisit their records to...
..., the Reserve List maintained by UPSC for this specific and limited purpose ceased to exist after the requisitioned candidates from the Reserve List were released exhausting all the vacancies. She...careful consideration of the facts on record as well as from the contentions of the parties during the hearing that the conflicting interests of transparency in disclosure of the Reserve List and privacy of the not-recommended candi...1. The Appellant filed RTI application dated 14.12.2018 seeking information for the Central Armed Police Forces Examination-2016. He sought consolidated reserve list of all 44 candidates...
...candidates while the other does not show any such ranking. It is not clear if the UPSC prepares the Reserve List according to the rank of candidates. Since the appointment and subsequent seniority of the candidates recommen...based on their inter se ranking, it is unlikely that the UPSC should be preparing any list of candidates without any heed to their ranking. Therefore, we would...like the CPIO to revisit the original records and to find out if the Reserve List shown to the candidate was actually the genuine one. If the original Reserve List shows the ranking of the candidates...
...Consolidated Reserve List for appointment till now?"
4. The CPIO of the petitioner UPSC in response to the aforesaid forwarded to the respondent "A list...Consolidated Reserve List cannot be provided as the said list contains names of some of the non-recommended candidates also."
5. The respondent being dissatisfied, appealed to the First Appell...
which can be disclosed is the copy of the Reserve List severing from that the marks awarded to those candidates who had not been recommended by the ...
...all the names of the candidates included in the consolidated Reserve List maintained by the UPSC for this particular examination and (b) a categorywise list of candidates recommended for appointment out...consolidated Reserve List of candidates in respect of the CPF(AC) Examination 2008. CIC/WB/A/2010/000358SM Between the CPIO and the Appellate Authority, some information and clarification on.... Besides, he had also not provided a copy of the amended recruitment rule, if any, for not declaring the consolidated Reserve List of candidates along with the list of the recommended candidates. The CPIO...
...case of an empanelled person, the reserve list cannot be operated indefinitely. In various organisations, the life of reserve list is one year. According to the guide lines of the UPSC, the life of...applicant and several others responded to the advertisement. Interviews were conducted by the UPSC on 24.02.2014. In the merit list, that was prepared by the UPSC, the applicant figured at Sl. No.5..., being the next candidate in the merit list.
3
3. On behalf of the respondent No.1 i.e. UPSC, detailed reply is filed...
...wherein the applicant's candidature was placed in the Reserve Panel list at Sl.No.29 against the ST quota. The UPSC has recommended the names of the selected 55 candidates for appointment to the said....52 whose name has been recommended against the ST reserved vacancy has not joined and hence the respondents no. 2 & 3 have forwarded the requisition to operate the reserve list and on the said request of the respondents no.2 &a...its letter dated 16.10.2018 first time released the names of five candidates from the Reserve List. Thereafter the respondents 2 & 3, vide letter dated 13.12.2018 requested the UPSC second...
...and 2 to consider to send the demand letter to Respondent No. 3 (UPSC) for obtaining the name of Applicant who is next in the Reserve List for the post of Lecturer (Computer Engineering) for ....
(ii) Direct the respondents No. 3 (UPSC) to consider to extend the validity period of Reserve List of Lecturer (Computer Engineering) for appointment by the ...Commission, the validity period of Reserve List is two (02) years from the date of finalization of IBR. In the present case the date of finalization of IBR/date of finalization of the...
...letter dated 22.01.2019 and in view of that development, a letter was addressed to the UPSC on the same day i.e. 22.01.2019, to recommend a name from the reserve list. The matter is said to be pending with the UPSC...to the UPSC on 22.01.2019 with a request to recommend a candidate from the reserve list. In all probability the chance must fall on the applicant, who is at Sl. No.1. Since the matter pertains to the...applicant was included in the reserve list at Sl. No.1. This OA is filed challenging the selection of the 4threspondent on various grounds.
2. The respondents filed a...
...... So, the controversy is whether the candidates appointed from the Reserve List, because of non-joining of the candidates initially recommended by the UPSC, would rank senior to..., the UPSC operated the Reserve List and on May 17,2016, made fresh recommendations of candidates including the respondent No.1 in W.P.(C) 14908/2022 Pallavi Gupta. So, it is the...respondent and informed that the petitioner had been supplementally and provisionally selected from the reserve list to the post of Drug Inspector. Accordingly, the petitioner was temporarily appointed...
...; file no. F.1/27(4)/2016-R.II; IBR No. 0021994. Have you appointed any candidate(s) from the reserve list prepared by UPSC w.r.t. Vacancy No. 16030502212; file no. F.127(4)/2016-R.II...; IBR No. 0021995. If No. Why the department has not appointed any candidate from reserve list.6. And various other information.Grounds for Second...also informed to the appellant. In respect of point no. 7 the appellant was informed that the reason could not be provided as the recruiting agency is UPSC. In respect of points no. 8 and 9, the...
...has been decided that in future, where a selection has been made through UPSC, a request for nomination from the reserve list, if any, may be made to the UPSC in the event of occurrence of a vacancy....”4. The learned counsel for the UPSC further submits that there is no provision in the Rules for maintenance of a Reserve List to cater to vacancies occasioned by candidates not joining or...with the release of its Reserve List on 20.11.2013 He submits that the examination was held for 656 vacancies as intimated by the Ministry of Home Affairs and not for 569 vacancies and no additional vacancy of 87 candidates was inti...
.... Pursuant to the vacancy advertisement No.10/2019 published by the UPSC, the applicant was placed at Sl. No.1 on the reserve/wait list panel for the post of...Notification had already been completed on 21.09.2022 and the proposal for operating the reserve list of the previous selection had been received later i.e. on 26.09.2022, hence, the UPSC was not required to...operate the reserve list of the previous selection.
11. Learned counsel for the applicant had also drawn attention to DOP&T's Office Memorandum dated 13.06.2000 as per which it has been directed...
...Tribunal (hereinafter, the 'Tribunal') has dismissed the Original Application filed by the Petitioner on the ground that vacancies notified have been filled up and the reserve list could not be operated thereafter.
...notified on 14.08.2019. Petitioner was not in the select list but was at serial No.5 of the reserve list. On 25.02.2021, four candidates out of the select list did not join and their candidature was cancelled. A re....
5. Out of the four candidates in the reserve list, one candidate joined and candidature of three candidates was cancelled because they failed to join within the prescribed period. Accordingly, on 14....
...:
"To direct the UPSC to recommend the applicant as per the Reserve List issued by the 1strespondent for the post of Assistant Professor in French and offer of appointment is...Vacancy. As per the reserve list notified by the 1 strespondent, the applicant is very much eligible to be appointed as Assistant Professor in French in the vacancy available and also to...being issued to the applicant based on the reserved list as notified by the 1strespondent in th eplace of BHAWNA who has been selected against Unreserved Vacancy (Recommended Against...
.... However, at no point of time have the respondents sought the reserve panel list from the UPSC.
5.2 In the interregnum, in order to improve the career progression in...the excessive number of APFCs already on the rolls of the EPFO, there was no question by the respondent department to seek additional candidates from the UPSC from the reserve panel list. Moreover, it...request for nomination from the reserve list, if any, may be made to the UPSC in the event of occurrence of a vacancy caused by non-joining of the candidate within the...
.... We heard their submissions.
3. The Appellant had sought a copy of the reserve list/panel prepared by the UPSC for the post of Director of Agriculture, Andaman and Nicobar Islands...
...28, 2016 recommended seven candidates for appointment. Further as the candidate recommended at serial No.4 in the Main List did not join the service, nomination/recommendation from the Reserve List was sought for by the pet....1 from the Reserve List, who joined the service on October 28, 2016. Subsequently, as the candidate at serial No.5 in the Main List refused to join, another nomination was sought from the UPSC, which...recommended respondent No.2 from the Reserve List. After completion of formalities, respondent No.2 joined the service from March 31, 2017.
4. On June 04, 2019, a provisional Seniority List fo...