...the decision reported as Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra 2011 3 SCC 1.15. When the case of...Girnar (3) was being considered, by the Constitution Bench, along with cases arising from other Acts, on a submission made by the learned Counsel that the...acquisition proceedings initiated under the MRTP Act. The State relied upon the decision of the Constitution Bench in the case of Girnar Traders (3) to contend that the MRTP Act is a code in itself...

...answered the reference on 11 January 2011 in the decision reported as Girnar Traders (3) v/s. State of Maharashtra and Ors.3. 15. When the case of Girnar (3) was being considered, by...relied upon the decision of the Constitution Bench in the case of Girnar Traders (3) to contend that the MRTP Act is a code in itself. The Division Bench (V.A.Naik and A.M.Badar, JJ), after considering... 26 WP Nos. 2827.14-1783.08 & 6728.15.doc vii of mrtp act as law in Girnar (3) is binding and advanced submissions accordingly. Mr. Aspi Chinoy, learned Amicus Curie expressed that amendment...

...answered the reference on 11 January 2011 in the decision reported as Girnar Traders (3) v/s. State of Maharashtra and Ors.3. 15. When the case of Girnar (3) was being considered, by...relied upon the decision of the Constitution Bench in the case of Girnar Traders (3) to contend that the MRTP Act is a code in itself. The Division Bench (V.A.Naik and A.M.Badar, JJ), after considering... 26 WP Nos. 2827.14-1783.08 & 6728.15.doc vii of mrtp act as law in Girnar (3) is binding and advanced submissions accordingly. Mr. Aspi Chinoy, learned Amicus Curie expressed that amendment...

Can't display summary as content is Scanned, Please open the judgment to see full content.

...No. 5351/2019 submitted that in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra, (2011.... Even the aspect of delay in completion of acquisition proceedings was taken care of by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its decision in Girnar-(3) (supra). It was urged that since beginning the Market...further. As regards the decision in Girnar-(3) (supra), it was submitted that even if Section 11A of the Act of 1894 was held inapplicable to proceedings under the Act of 1966, the ratio of that...

...Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra and ors. (2011) 3 SCC 1, the... Supreme Court in its decision in Girnar-(3) (supra). It was urged that since beginning the Market Committee was interested in acquiring the land in question with the objec...depositing the amount of compensation, the Land Acquisition Officer was not in a position to proceed further. As regards the decision in Girnar-(3) (supra), it was submitted that even if Section 11A of the...

...public purpose by taking recourse to the provisions of the said Act of 2013. However, relying upon several decisions including the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Girnar Traders (3...Bench extensively referred to what is held by the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in the case of Girnar Traders (3) (supra). The said decision of the Apex Court unequivocally holds that the...MRTP Act, the Constitution Bench in Girnar (3) then proceeded to analyse the doctrine of pith and substance and harmonious construction of the statutes. After a detailed analysis on...

...Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra...(2011) 3 SCC 1 [hereinafter referred to as Girnar Traders (3)], the question arising in these appeals should be referred to a Constitution Bench....concluding, we may notice the judgment of the Constitution Bench in Girnar Traders (3...

...)], Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra (2011) 3 SCC 1 [Girnar (3)] among other cases. We will advert to them in due course...Constitution Bench of this Court in Girnar Traders (3) (2011) 3 SCC 1, has taken note of the view of the majority judgment...(2013) 5 SCC 627)“45. In our view, the observations contained in para 133 of Girnar Traders (3...

...Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra (2011)...)“45. In our view, the observations contained in para 133 of Girnar Traders (3...Respondent 1.19. The relevant para 133 from Girnar Traders (3...

...Naolekar, JJ., is as under: [Girnar Traders (2) case (2007) 7 SCC 555 & 590, paras 3 & 67-68...Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra (2011) 3 SCC 1 [hereinafter referred to as “...as well as the detailed reasons given by us in Girnar Traders (3) (2011) 3 SCC 1, which reasoning would form part of this judgment, we...

...i) Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra, (2011) 3 SCC 1; ii...

...approved by the Constitution Bench in Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra (2011) 3 SCC 1.25. For...Girnar Traders (3) v. State of Maharashtra (2011) 3 SCC 1 (p. 80, para 178). The Constitution...Bench also referred to the doctrine of pith and substance in the context of challenge to some of the provisions of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 and observed: [Girnar (3) case...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...

.... 17. Mr Anturkar submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Girnar Traders (3) Vs. State of Maharashtra1would not apply because...the subject acquisition was not under the MRTP Act but the Land Acquisition Act. In any event, he submitted that Girnar Traders (3) (supra) applied only to acquisition under Chapter VII of MRTP Act...Girnar Traders (3) (supra), he submitted that references to the Old or New Land Acquisition Act under the MRTP Act were instances Page 18 of 49...