Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Frank Gannett McAdam and Charles McAdam, III, individually as personal representatives of the Estate of Charles V. McAdam, Jr., and as trustees of The Charles V. McAdam, Jr. Revocable Trust, filed suit against Gunster, Yoakley Stewart, P.A. ("Gunster Yoakley"), one of its probate attorneys, and J.P. Morgan Trust Company, N.A. Plaintiffs alleged breach of fiduciary duty, constructive fraud, civil conspiracy, negligence, and unjust enrichment, contending that Gunster Yoakley wrongfully procured J.P. Morgan's appointment as corporate fiduciary, which caused the estate administration to become more expensive. Plaintiffs sought recompense for avoidable probate expenses and disgorgement of fees paid to Gunster Yoakley by the decedent.

After settling with J.P. Morgan, the plaintiffs proceeded against Gunster Yoakley and obtained a jury verdict awarding approximately $1.2 million. The trial court granted remittitur and entered a final judgment for $1,043,430, including interest and costs. Gunster Yoakley appealed, challenging liability, standing, and jury instructions, while plaintiffs cross-appealed regarding a family limited partnership claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Gunster Yoakley was liable to the estate for administration expenses or damages arising from the appointment of J.P. Morgan as corporate fiduciary.
  2. Whether the trial court erred in denying Gunster Yoakley's motion for partial summary judgment based on standing.
  3. Whether the trial court erred in submitting the qualified personal-residence trust issue to the jury.
  4. Whether the trial court erred in granting partial summary judgment in favor of Gunster Yoakley on the plaintiffs' family limited partnership claim (cross-appeal).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Gunster Yoakley)

  • Gunster Yoakley argued it was not liable for administration expenses or damages related to J.P. Morgan's appointment.
  • It contended the trial court erred in denying its motion for partial summary judgment on standing grounds.
  • It asserted the trial court erred in submitting the qualified personal-residence trust issue to the jury.

Appellees' Arguments (McAdam Plaintiffs)

  • Plaintiffs maintained that Gunster Yoakley wrongfully procured J.P. Morgan's appointment, increasing estate expenses.
  • They argued they had standing because their father's testamentary intent was frustrated by Gunster Yoakley's negligence, diminishing their legacy.
  • They contended the qualified personal-residence trust issue was properly submitted to the jury based on sufficient evidence.
  • On cross-appeal, plaintiffs argued the trial court erred in granting summary judgment on their family limited partnership claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Espinosa v. Sparber, Shevin, Shapo, Rosen Heilbronner, 586 So.2d 1221 (Fla. 3d DCA 1991) Allows testator's estate to maintain legal malpractice action against attorney for issues not remedied in probate court. Supported plaintiffs' ability to collaterally attack J.P. Morgan's appointment despite it being a probate issue.
Tibbs v. State, 397 So.2d 1120, 1123 (Fla. 1981) Verdict must be supported by substantial, competent evidence after resolving conflicts in evidence in favor of the verdict. Validated submission of qualified personal-residence trust issue to the jury and supported jury verdict.
Lane v. Cold, 882 So.2d 436, 438 (Fla. 1st DCA 2004) Action for breach of fiduciary duty may be maintained where a relationship is shown, including implicit agreement by attorney. Supported jury submission on whether Gunster Yoakley implicitly agreed to fund the revocable trust.
In re Amendment to Rules Regulating Fla. Bar, 605 So.2d 252, 309 (Fla. 1992) Rules of professional conduct are not a basis for civil liability. Supported denial of jury instruction requested by Gunster Yoakley and affirmed award under wrongful act doctrine.
Martha A. Gottfried, Inc. v. Amster, 511 So.2d 595, 598 (Fla. 4th DCA 1987) Costs and expenses, including attorney's fees, may be recovered as damages if wrongful act caused litigation with others. Supported award of damages for avoidable probate expenses caused by Gunster Yoakley's wrongful acts.
Baxter's Asphalt Concrete, Inc. v. Liberty County, 406 So.2d 461 (Fla. 1st DCA 1981) Quoted in support of recovery of litigation-related costs and expenses as damages. Provided foundational support for awarding damages related to wrongful act doctrine.
Hewko v. Genovese, 739 So.2d 1189, 1192 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999) Standing exists where plaintiff's legacy is diminished by attorney's negligence frustrating testator's intent. Supported denial of Gunster Yoakley's motion for partial summary judgment on standing grounds.
Asgrow-Kilgore Co. v. Mulford Hickerson Corp., 301 So.2d 441, 445 (Fla. 1974) While precise proof of damages is not fatal, speculative or conjectural claims are insufficient to survive summary judgment. Supported affirmance of summary judgment against plaintiffs' family limited partnership claim as too speculative.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed Gunster Yoakley's liability by first rejecting its assertion that plaintiffs could not collaterally attack the appointment of J.P. Morgan, citing precedent that allows legal malpractice claims to address issues unresolved in probate. The court found sufficient evidence that Gunster Yoakley implicitly agreed to fund the revocable trust, justifying submission of that issue to the jury. It also upheld the trial court’s denial of Gunster Yoakley's requested jury instruction and affirmed the award under the wrongful act doctrine, recognizing recoverable damages for litigation expenses caused by wrongful acts.

Regarding standing, the court held that plaintiffs demonstrated a direct injury because their father's testamentary intent was frustrated by Gunster Yoakley's negligence, diminishing their legacy, thereby supporting the denial of partial summary judgment. The court also found sufficient evidence to support submission of the qualified personal-residence trust issue to the jury.

On plaintiffs' cross-appeal concerning the family limited partnership claim, the court agreed with the trial court that the claim was too speculative due to insufficient proof of damages or funding source, justifying summary judgment.

Holding and Implications

The court affirmed the final judgment against Gunster Yoakley in the amount of $1,043,430, including interest and costs, and upheld all other rulings on appeal and cross-appeal.

The decision confirms that legal malpractice claims may proceed to address probate-related issues not remedied in probate court, including challenges to fiduciary appointments. It affirms that plaintiffs have standing when negligence frustrates testamentary intent and diminishes legacies. The court’s ruling on the family limited partnership claim underscores the necessity of concrete proof of damages to survive summary judgment. No new precedent was established; the ruling applies established Florida law to the facts of this case, directly affecting the parties by upholding the substantial monetary judgment in favor of the plaintiffs.

GUNSTER, YOAKLEY STEWART, P.A. and Daniel Hanley, Appellants, v. Charles McADAM, III, and Frank Gannett McAdam, indi

POLEN, J.

Appellant Gunster, Yoakley Stewart, P.A. ("Gunster Yoakley") appeals a final judgment entered against it in the amount of $1,043,430. We affirm on all issues raised on appeal and cross-appeal.

Frank Gannett McAdam and Charles McAdam, III, individually, as personal representatives of the Estate of Charles V. McAdam, Jr., and as trustees of The Charles V. McAdam, Jr. Revocable Trust, brought an action against Gunster Yoakley, one of Gunster Yoakley's probate attorneys and J.P. Morgan Trust Company, N.A., ("J.P. Morgan"). In their complaint, plaintiffs asserted claims of breach of fiduciary duty, constructive fraud, civil conspiracy, negligence and unjust enrichment. The substance of these accusations was that Gunster Yoakley wrongfully procured J.P. Morgan's appointment as corporate fiduciary and caused the estate administration to be more expensive. As such, plaintiffs sought, among other things, recompense for all "avoidable probate expenses" and disgorgement of all fees paid to Gunster Yoakley by decedent Charles V. McAdam, Jr.

After settling their claims against J.P. Morgan, plaintiffs proceeded against Gunster Yoakley and ultimately won a $1.2 million jury verdict. The trial court, however, granted remittitur and entered final judgment of $1,043,430, including interest and costs. This appeal follows.

We have considered the issues raised by Gunster Yoakley on appeal, including its contentions that (1) it was not liable to the estate for administration expenses or damages arising out of the appointment of J.P. Morgan, (2) the trial court erred in denying its motion for partial summary judgment which was based on the issue of standing, and (3) the court erred in submitting a qualified personal-residence trust issue to the jury. As to the first point, we hold that reversal is not merited on any of the grounds argued by Gunster Yoakley because:

• Plaintiffs sought relief not available to them in probate and therefore could, contrary to Gunster Yoakley's assertion on appeal, collaterally attack the appointment of J.P. Morgan. See Espinosa v. Sparber, Shevin, Shapo, Rosen Heilbronner, 586 So.2d 1221 (Fla. 3d DCA 1991) (holding testator's estate can maintain legal malpractice action against attorney who prepared the will of the deceased in order to address issues not remedied in probate court);
• The trial court did not err in submitting to the jury the question of whether Gunster Yoakley had a duty to fund a revocable trust during decedent's lifetime as there was sufficient evidence that Gunster Yoakley implicitly agreed to do so. See Tibbs v. State, 397 So.2d 1120, 1123 (Fla. 1981) ("[T]he concern on appeal must be whether, after all conflicts in the evidence and all reasonable inferences therefrom have been resolved in favor of the verdict on appeal, there is substantial, competent evidence to support the verdict and judgment."); see also Lane v. Cold, 882 So.2d 436, 438 (Fla. 1st DCA 2004) (holding action for breach of fiduciary duty may be maintained where, "A relationship exist[s] with respect to the acts or omissions upon which the malpractice claim is based," and a party may demonstrate this relationship by showing that his attorney implicitly agreed to undertake these responsibilities); and
• The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Gunster Yoakley's request for jury instruction, nor did the court err in making an award under the "wrongful act doctrine." See In re Amendment to Rules Regulating Fla. Bar, 605 So.2d 252, 309 (Fla. 1992) (providing that rules of professional conduct "are not designed to be a basis for civil liability"); see also Martha A. Gottfried, Inc. v. Amster, 511 So.2d 595, 598 (Fla. 4th DCA 1987) ("Where the wrongful act of the defendant has involved the claimant in litigation with others, and has placed the claimant in such relation with others as makes it necessary to incur expenses to protect its interests, such costs and expenses, including reasonable attorney's fees upon appropriate proof, may be recovered as an element of damages.") (quoting Baxter's Asphalt Concrete, Inc. v. Liberty County, 406 So.2d 461 (Fla. 1st DCA 1981)), quashed on other grounds, 421 So.2d 505 (Fla. 1982).

Regarding the second issue, we hold that the trial court did not err in denying Gunster Yoakley's motion for partial summary judgment as plaintiffs demonstrated they had standing to bring suit against Gunster Yoakley — Plaintiffs showed that their father's intent, as expressed in his will, was frustrated by the negligence of Gunster Yoakley and that, as a direct result of such negligence, their legacy was diminished. See Hewko v. Genovese, 739 So.2d 1189, 1192 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999). We also hold that the trial court did not err in submitting to the jury the qualified personal-residence trust issue as the jury's verdict on that matter was supported by sufficient evidence. See Tibbs, 397 So.2d at 1123.

Lastly, we address plaintiffs' argument on cross-appeal, i.e., that the trial court erred in granting partial summary judgment in favor of Gunster Yoakley on plaintiffs' family limited partnership ("FLP") claim. We agree with the trial court and conclude that any FLP claim was too speculative to withstand summary judgment because there was insufficient proof of damages or source of funding. See Asgrow-Kilgore Co. v. Mulford Hickerson Corp., 301 So.2d 441, 445 (Fla. 1974) (stating that although precise proof of damages is not fatal to recovery of compensatory damages, lack of proof supporting monetary loss, or a speculative or conjectural claim, is) (citations omitted).

Based on the foregoing, we affirm the final judgment and we also affirm as to all other issues raised on appeal.

Affirmed.

STONE and GROSS, JJ., concur.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

GUNSTER v. McADAM
(Oct 25, 2007)