Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965. 20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • provision of Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules.
  • Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • provision of Rule 9(21)
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985,
  • rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. 19. Perusal of Rule 14(18)
  • provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rule exist in Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • 5 Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965. 20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • provision of Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules.
  • Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • provision of Rule 9(21)
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985,
  • rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. 19. Perusal of Rule 14(18)
  • provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rule exist in Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • 5 Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    JHANNA LAL v. GENERAL MANAGER D.L.W., VARANASI

    Reserved on 28.05.2025 Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, Allahabad This the 30th day of May, 2025

    Hon'ble Mr. Justice Om Prakash VII, Member (J) Hon'ble Mr. Mohan Pyare, Member (A)

    Original Application No. 886 of 2015

    Jhanna Lal S/o Sri Kanta Prasad, R/o House No. 10/14-A, Village - Lakharawan, Post - Bajardeeha, Belupur, Varanasi, Posted in Diesel Locomotive Work (DLW) Varanasi as Electrical Grade - II, No.

    10596 (TAS).

    ……….. APPLICANT By Advocate: Shri V.K. Srivastava and Shri Abhishek Srivastava Versus

    1. Union of India through General Manager, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW), Varanasi.

    2. General Manager, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW) Varanasi.

    3. Chief Mechanical Engineer (P) (Mukhya Yantrik Abhiyanta), Revisional Authority, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW), Varanasi.

    4. Deputy Chief Mechanical Engineer / Loco Appellate Authority, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW) Varanasi.

    5. Work Manager (Karya Prabandhak / LTS) Disciplinary Authority, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW) Varanasi.

    .………RESPONDENTS

    By Advocate: Shri KK Ojha

    ORDER

    (Delivered by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Om Prakash VII, Member (J)

    Shri V K Srivastava, learned counsel for the applicant and Shri KK Ojha, learned counsel for the respondents, were present at the time of hearing.

    2. The instant original application has been filed seeking following relief:

    "i. issue an order or direction in the suitable nature to set aside the impugned orders dated 04.03.2014 passed by the Work Manager

    1

    (Karya Prabandhak / LTS) Disciplinary Authority, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW), Varanasi - respondent no. 5, appellate order dated 13.04.2015 passed by the Deputy Chief Mechanical Engineer / Loco Appellate Authority, Diesel Locomotive Works (DlW), Varanasi - respondent no. 4 and impugned revisional order dated 30.04.2015 passed by the Chief Mechanical Engineer (Mukhya Yantrik Abhiyanta), Revisional Authority, Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW), Varanasi - respondent no. 3 (Annexure No. 12, 19 and 20 respectively to this original application)

    ii. issue an order or direction in the suitable nature commanding the respondents to make the payment of salary in Electrical Grade - II 5200-20200 + 1800 Grade Pay with arrears thereof and to make the fixation and interest on delayed payment as the impugned orders had not been passed in the eyes of law.

    iii. issue any order or direction which this Hon'ble tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.

    iv. to award the cost of the Application to the applicant."

    3. A compendium of the facts as have been narrated in the present original application is that the applicant who is a permanent employee of the respondents department is aggrieved by the impugned order dated 04.03.2014 passed by the Disciplinary Authority of the respondents, order dated 13.04.2015 passed by the Appellate Authority of the respondents and order dated 30.04.2015 passed by the Revisional Authority of the respondents claiming that the entire inquiry on the basis of which the aforesaid orders were effected, was vitiated and illegal. Applicant has contended that a false and concocted case was prepared against him and upon the conclusion of the inquiry which was itself conducted in absolute violation of the prescribed rules and statutory provisions as contained in Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958, and subsequently the aforesaid punishment orders were imposed upon him. Alleging the aforesaid orders to be illegal, perverse and passed without application of mind, the applicant has sought the quashing of the same thereby directing the respondents to provide all the consequential benefits to him.

    4. We have heard learned counsels for the parties and perused the documents on record.

    2

    5. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the allegations leveled against the applicant are false. Relevant documents demanded by the applicant were not supplied to him. The inquiry was concluded hastily and hurriedly without following the prescribed procedure. It is also argued that it is a major penalty chargesheet case. The applicant has not examined himself in this matter as witness and thus it was incumbent upon the Inquiry Officer to have interrogated / placed all the evidence collected during the inquiry under Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 which is mandatory in nature. Thus, argued that on this ground itself the inquiry proceedings as well as the orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority, Appellate Authority and Revisional Authority are vitiated. To substantiate this argument, learned counsel for the applicant referred to the inquiry report, statement of the prosecution witness as well as the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority to supply the documents and further argued that since mandatory provision provided under the prescribed rule has not been followed in the case, thus the OA be allowed and the impugned order be set aside.

    6. Learned counsel for the respondents vehemently opposed the submissions of the applicant's counsel and by way of counter affidavit, he argued that the applicant was afforded the opportunity during inquiry and he availed the same. The documents demanded by him were also supplied, and the allegations leveled against the applicant in the charge sheet are proved. Inquiry proceedings will not be vitiated on non compliance of the provision of Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 as the applicant has cross examined all the witnesses examined on behalf of the prosecution. Shri R K Srivastava, the said complainant was also examined and thus grounds taken in the OA are not sufficient to allow it. Further, respondents have also filed their written submissions.

    7. Rejoinder has also been filed by the applicant reiterating the facts and grounds as have been narrated in the OA.

    3

    8. We have considered the rival contentions and gone through the documents on record.

    9. As the facts of the case have been recorded above in detail they are not reiterated. Inquiry Report submitted against the applicant are as follows:

    4

    A perusal of the above quoted inquiry report reveals that the entire inquiry was conducted on seven dates. On 24.01.2014, statements of prosecution witnesses were recorded. Nothing is mentioned in the inquiry report regarding the examination of the charged official as witness in support of defence evidence. Rule 9

    (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 provides that in case the charged official has not examined himself as witness, the Inquiry Officer will give the opportunity to the charged official to rebut the evidence collected during the inquiry. The provision contained in Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 is mandatory and non adherence to the same will vitiate the entire proceedings. The significance and relevance of the aforesaid Rule cannot be compromised with at any cost as doing the same would render the entire inquiry as vitiated and contrary to the statutory provisions. Furthermore, time and again, the relevance of

    5

    Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 which is often held as tantamount and analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985, has been highlighted by several courts across the country including the Apex Court. In this regard, it would be in the fitness of things to refer to the law laid down by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in its judgment dated 10.03.2011 passed in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 215 of 2009 titled Union of India and Anr Vs D S Manchanda, which is as follows:

    "18. The next contention on behalf of the petitioner is about the noncompliance of the Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. According to the petitioners, Rule 14(18) was substantially complied with. Perusal of the record, however, reveals that it is an admitted case that the respondent did not examine himself as a witness. Since the respondent had not examined himself as witness, it was incumbent upon the enquiry officer to put evidence adduced against the respondent during the enquiry to him in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. The said rule had been enacted with a view that whatever evidence comes in the enquiry, explanation may be sought to rebut the circumstances, which would be in consonance with the principle of reasonable opportunity and audi alterm partum as inbuilt in the principles of natural justice. On perusal of the record, the order dated 6th April 1998 is categorical in stating that the respondent had neither examined any defense witnesses nor had he offered himself as a witness. Thereafter the respondent was generally examined by the Inquiry Officer, however whether or not the circumstances that came in evidence against the respondent was put to him has not been shown. In similar matters involving the same purchases, the charged officers were only put the charges which were framed against the charged officer. In the circumstances, in absence of any thing it is to be inferred that the evidence which was recorded during the enquiry was not put to the respondent in compliance with rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.

    19. Perusal of Rule 14(18) clearly reveals that it is obligatory upon the enquiry authority to question the delinquent officer on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence, for the purpose of enabling him to explain any circumstance. As there is no reference to the evidence brought on record or circumstances appearing against the applicant, hence the general examination, a copy of which has also not been produced despite ample opportunity to the petitioner, it is apparent there was not a valid compliance of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.

    20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958. In the matter of Moni Shankar V. Union of India, 2008 (1) AJW 479, an enquiry proceeding was conducted in which the following questions were put to the Charged Officer:

    "please state if you plead guilty?" ; "Do you wish to submit your

    6

    oral or written arguments? ; "Are you satisfied with the enquiry proceeding" and "Can I conclude the enquiry?", were held to be not in compliance of Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 as such type of questions did not reveal the evidence adduced in support of charges against the charged officer.

    21. In Ministry of Finance v. S.B.Ramesh, (1998) 3 SCC 227 the Supreme Court had held the Rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985 to be mandatory. The Apex Court had upheld the decision of the Tribunal holding that the order of the Disciplinary Authority was based on no evidence and that the findings were perverse, on the reasoning that even if the Enquiry Officer had set the applicant ex parte and recorded the evidence, he should have adjourned the hearing to another date to enable the applicant to participate in the enquiry thereafter. Or even if the Enquiry Authority did not choose to give the applicant an opportunity to cross-examine the witness examined in support of the charge, he should have been given an opportunity to the applicant to appear and then proceeded to question him under Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. The omission to do this was construed to be a serious error committed by the Enquiry Authority. This also cannot be disputed that if the charged officer has examined himself as a witness then it will not be obligatory to examine the charged officer under Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. However, in the absence of any defense statement by the charged official, it was mandatory on the part of the enquiry officer to examine him under Rule 14(18), and the noncompliance of which will vitiate the enquiry proceedings."

    As is clear from the aforesaid quotation, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi had observed that provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rule exist in Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958. It was incumbent upon the Inquiry Officer to have strictly adhered to the provision of Rule 9(21) as quoted above while conducting the inquiry which he failed to do. Furthermore, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi while passing the aforesaid quoted judgment has also referred to the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Moni Shanker (supra) and highlighted the inflexible relevance of Rule 9(21) which is a must to be adhered to provision while conducting the inquiry.

    10. Furthermore, as regards to the written submissions filed by the respondents, reliance therein has been made to the judgment dated 14.02.2020 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No. 8071 of 2014 titled The State of Karnataka & Anr. Vs N.

    7

    Gangaraj. A careful perusal of the aforesaid judgment reveals that the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in that judgment, after relying upon several other judgments which have been explicitly quoted therein, has discussed the scope of judicial review in the cases pertaining to disciplinary inquiry and held that once the evidence has been accepted by the departmental authority, in exercise of power of judicial review, the Tribunal or High Court could not interfere with the findings of the facts recorded by appreciating evidence as if the Courts are the Appellate Authority. Here, it is pertinent to record that in the instant case of the applicant, we are not trying to act as an Appellate Authority or are not appreciating the evidence of any sort and in any way. As has been discussed in the preceding paragraphs, the very provision as enshrined in the Railway Servants (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 has not been adhered to by the Inquiry Officer while conducting the inquiry and as such, the entire inquiry proceedings cannot be held to be in conformity with the law and the statutory provisions. And that is why, in such a scenario, deeming the entire inquiry proceedings as vitiated, the impugned orders are liable to be set aside. Hence, the case law cited upon by the respondents do not hold any bearing with the instant case of the applicant and no relief whatsoever is admissible to the respondents' authority on that basis.

    11. Thus, in view of the aforesaid submissions and analysis and strictly rrelying upon the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi passed in the case of D S Manchanda (supra) and other case laws viz. Hon'ble Supreme Court's judgment in SB Ramesh (supra) and Moni Shanker (supra), which have been referred to by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the judgment of D S Manchanda (supra), we are of the considered opinion that if delinquent employee has not examined himself in the inquiry proceedings, it is mandatory for the inquiry officer to interrogate / examine the CO under the aforesaid rule putting all the incriminating materials collected during the inquiry before him to explain. In the present matter, this procedure has not been followed by the inquiry officer. Since provision of Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 is mandatory

    8

    and it has not been followed while conducting the inquiry thus it can safely be held that fair inquiry has not been made. Minimum procedure prescribed for conducting the inquiry has not been adhered to particularly the mandatory provision as provided under Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 and thus inquiry proceedings can be attributed as vitiated and impugned orders passed in this regard are illegal.

    12. Although several other grounds have been raised at the end of the learned counsel for the applicant but solely on the aforesaid ground which has not been followed by the inquiry officer we are of the view that the impugned order challenged in the matter is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, instant OA is allowed. The impugned orders are quashed and set aside. All the consequential benefits viz. the restoration of pay and payment of dues shall be extended to the applicant within a period of three months without fail. The matter is remanded back to the disciplinary authority, which, if deems fit, may initiate de novo inquiry from the stage of compliance of Rule 9 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 taking into consideration the observations recorded in the instant judgment.

    13. All associated MAs stand disposed of. No costs.

    (Mohan Pyare) (Justice Om Prakash VII) Member (Administrative) Member (Judicial) (Ritu Raj)

    9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    JHANNA LAL v. GENERAL MANAGER D.L.W., VARANASI
    (May 30, 2025)