ORDER
(Delivered by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Om Prakash VII, Member (J) Shri O P Gupta, learned counsel for the applicant and Shri Manoj Kumar Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents, were present at the time of hearing.
2. The instant original application has been filed seeking following reliefs:
i. to quash the Compulsory Retirement Order dated 9-3- 2004 (Ann A - 1) and appellate order dated 5-6-2006 (Ann A-2)
1
ii. to direct the respondents to reinstate the applicant in service at his own post with immediate effect.
iii. to direct the respondents to grant him seniority for the intervening period, treating the applicant in continuous service of the respondents and to pay him arrears of salary for the said period i.e. from 9-3-2004 to the date of actual reinstatement in service."
3. A compendium of the facts narrated in the OA is that the applicant while working as Charge Man Gr- II, was given a charge sheet consequent to an inquiry and he was punished with the penalty of Compulsory Retirement from service vide order dated 09.03.2004. Against the aforesaid order, the applicant filed an appeal before the Appellate Authority and the said authority vide order dated 05.06.2006, rejected the appeal. Several charges were leveled against the applicant viz., he refused to allow the Board Members of Annual Stock Taking Board to proceed with the stock checking on 06thand 10thMarch 2000, he misbehaved with the officers on duty and that he has been a habitual offender having been penalized for his wrongdoings earlier also. Subsequent to the issuance of chargesheet, the inquiry was conducted in the matter consequent to the culmination of which, the punishment was imposed upon him. Alleging the inquiry to be vitiated and one conducted in violation of the prescribed rules and procedures, the applicant has prayed for quashing of the aforesaid orders. He has also prayed for a direction to the respondents to reinstate him in service along with all the consequential benefits and to also grant him seniority for the intervening period. Applicant has also contended that blatant violation of the statutory provisions as enshrined in the statutes was done by the inquiry officer as the applicant was not given adequate opportunity of hearing during the course of inquiry.
4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.
2
5. Initiating his arguments, learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the applicant is not involved in the controversy he has been allegedly arrayed into. Chargesheet was supplied to him on the basis of false facts. The applicant only insisted for inspection by complete Board. Since on the date of incident, only a few members of the Board constituted for inspection had come for inspection thus due to this reason, the applicant requested for the inspection in the presence of all the members. It was further argued that inspection was also completed when the proper order for inspection was made by the authority concerned. It is next argued that earlier the OA was decided on 06.04.2011 setting aside the order passed by the respondents on 09.03.2004 and 05.06.2006. Respondents had approached before the Hon'ble High Court of Allahabad through Writ A No. 41699 of 2011 which was allowed on 02.03.2023 setting aside the order passed by the Tribunal and remitting the matter back to the Tribunal to decide it afresh on merits.
6. Learned counsel for the applicant further argued that inquiry officer while submitting the report did not take into account the submission of those witnesses who were supporting the applicant's case. At no point of time, the applicant abused any person nor extended threat. Referring to the article of charges, it was further argued that inquiry officer itself did not found charge no. 4 as proved. Charge No. 1 does not contain any misconduct. There is a contradictory submission of the witnesses regarding the charge no. 2 and 3. Referring to the charge no. 5, it was also argued that this charge is also liable to be quashed because the applicant has already been punished for the same charge. Only on this ground that no improvement has been made, the applicant cannot be penalized for the same fact twice. It was also argued that mandatory provision provided under Rule 14 (18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 has not been followed and thus the inquiry report, order passed by the Disciplinary Authority as well the Appellate Authority are vitiated. It is also argued that although earlier, this plea has not been taken at the end of the applicant but since it is a legal plea, it can be raised at any
3
point of time before the final disposal of the OA. It is also argued that all the defence witnesses named by the applicant have not been examined. Discretion cannot be exercised by the inquiry officer in picking up the witnesses cited on behalf of the applicant and thus, on this ground also, entire proceedings are vitiated. It was next argued that the applicant has not examined himself in the matter. Thus, it was incumbent upon the respondents to examine / interrogate under Rule 14 (18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Thus, it was prayed to allow the OA and to set aside the impugned order(s). In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the applicant has placed reliance upon the following case laws:
i. Judgment dated 18.09.1957 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Union of India Vs T R Varma reported in 1957 AIR 882.
ii. Judgment dated 02.01.2017 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Allahabad Bank and Others Vs Krishna Narayan Tewari reported in 2017(1) ESC 83 (SC)
iii. Judgment dated 15.12.2022 passed by the Allahabad Bench of Central Administrative Tribunal in OA No. 162 of 2015 titled Mohd Sultan Vs Union of India and others
iv. Judgment dated 02.02.1998 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Ministry of Finance And Another Vs S B Ramesh reported in 1998 SCC (L&S) 865.
v. Judgment dated 05.09.2011 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No. 7448 of 2011 titled The National Textile Corporation ltd. Vs Naresh Kumar Badrikumar Jagad & Ors.
7. Learned counsel for the respondents vehemently opposed the prayer of the applicants' counsel and argued that since the OA had been decided earlier without going into the merit thus the Hon'ble High Court has set aside the order passed by the Tribunal directing it
4
to decide the matter afresh on merits. It is also argued that the applicant has been afforded ample opportunity by the inquiry officer to lead evidence and thus there was no requirement to examine the applicant under Rule 14 (18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. It was next argued that applicant misbheaved with the Board members (Inspection Team) and did not permit them to inspect the stock to proceed with Stock Checking on 06thand 10thMarch 2000. Thus, he had committed misconduct as defined under CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Charges leveled against the applicant are substantiated with the evidence adduced by the presenting officer. It is also argued that if some of the witnesses who were examined on behalf of the applicant have not supported the prosecution case then it shall not be presumed that witnesses who are supporting the prosecution case are lying or giving the false statements. Applicant has also extended threat to some of the employees. There are eye witnesses to his wrongdoing. Thus, inquiry officer has rightly proved the charge no. 1 to 3 as well as charge no. 5. It is also argued that the applicant was also punished for different charges and despite this, he did not amend himself and thus, charge no. 5 is also rightly proved against him. Punishment imposed upon the applicant is commensurate to the charges leveled against him. No illegality under Rule 14 (18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 was raised by the applicant in his appeal and thus for the first time, the applicant cannot be permitted to raise this issue in the OA at this stage of the argument. Thus, prayer was made to dismiss the OA as being devoid of merits.
8. Rejoinder has been filed by the applicants reiterating the same averments as have been given in the OA.
9. We have considered the rival contentions and gone through the documents on records.
10. Learned counsel for the applicant has relied upon the judgment passed by the Apex Court in the case of Nareshkumar Badrikumar Jagad (supra) the relied upon portion of which is quoted herein below:
5
"14. There is no quarrel to the settled legal proposition that a new plea cannot be taken in respect of any factual controversy whatsoever, however, a new ground raising a pure legal issue for which no inquiry / proof is required can be permitted to be raised by the court at any stage of the proceedings."
Similarly, learned counsel has relied upon the judgment passed by the Apex Court in the case of S B Ramesh (supra) the relevant portion of which is quoted herein below:
"It is necessary to set out the portions from the order of the Tribunal which gave the reasons to come to the conclusion that the order of the Disciplinary Authority was based on no evidence and the findings were perverse. The Tribunal, after extracting full the evidence of SW-1. the only witness examined on the side of the prosecution. and after extracting also the proceedings of the Enquiry Officer dated 18.6.91. observed as follows:-
"After these proceedings on 18.6.91 on the Enquiry Officer has only received the brief from the PO and then finalised the report. This shows that the Enquiry Officer has not attempted to question the applicant on the evidence appearing against him in the proceedings dated 18.6.91. Under Sub-Rule 18 of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. It is incumbent on the Enquiry authority to question the officer facing the charge, broadly on the evidence appearing against him in a case where the officer does not offer himself for examination as witness. This mandatory provision of the CCS (CCA) Rules has been lost sight of by the Enquiry authority. The learned counsel for the respondents argued as the applicant did not appear in response to notice. It was not possible for the Enquiry authority to question the applicant. This argument has no force because. on 18.6.91 when the inquiry was held for recording the evidence in support of the charge, even if the Enquiry officer has set the applicant ex-parte and recorded the evidence, he should have adjourned the hearing to another date to enable the applicant to participate in the enquiry hereafter/or even if the inquiry authority did not choose to give the applicant an opportunity to cross-examine the witness examined in support of the charge, he should have given an opportunity to the applicant to appear and then proceeded to question him under sub-rule 18 of Rule 14 of CCs (CCA) Rules. The omission to do this is a serious error committed by the enquiry authority. Secondly, we notice that the enquiry authority has marked as many as 7 documents in support of the charge. while SW-1 has proved only one document: namely, the statement of Smt. K.R. Aruna alleged to have been recorded in his presence. How the other documents were received in evidence are not explained either in the report of the Enquiry authority or in the proceedings. Even if the documents which were produced along with the charge sheet were all taken on record. unless and until the applicant had requested the Enquiry officer to mark certain documents in evidence on his side. the enquiry authority had no jurisdiction in marking all those documents which he had called for the purpose of defending himself on the side of the applicant while he has not requested for making of these documents on
6
his side. It is seen that some of these documents which is marked on the side of the defence not at the instance of the applicant. has been made use of by the enquiry authority to reach a finding against the applicant. This has been accepted by the disciplinary authority also. We are of the considered view that this is absolutely irregular and has prejudiced the case of the applicant. These documents, which were not proved in accordance with law should nor have been received in evidence and that, any inference drawn from these documents is misplaced and opposed to law, we further find that the enquiry authority as well as, the disciplinary authority have freely made use of the statement alleged to have been made by the statement alleged to have been made by Smt Kr Aruna in the presence of SW1 and it was on that basis that they reached the conclusion the applicant was living with Smt. K.R. Aruna and that, he was the father of the two children on Smt. K.R. Aruna. The S.W.1 in his deposition which is extracted above, has not spoken to the details contained in the statement of Smt. K.R. Aruna which was marked as Ex.1. Further it is settled law that any statement recorded behind the back of a person can be made use of against him in a proceeding unless the person who is said to have made that statement is made available for cross- examination, to prove his or her veracity. The disciplinary authority has not even chosen to include Smt. K.R. Aruna in the list of witnesses for offering her for being cross-examined for testing the veracity of the documents exhibited at Ex.1 veracity of the documents exhibited at Ex.1 which is said to be her statement.
Therefore, we have no hesitation in coming to the conclusion that the enquiry authority as well as, the disciplinary authority have gone wrong in placing reliance on Ex.1 which is the alleged statement of Smt. K.R. Aruna without offering Smt. K.R. Aruna as a witness for cross- examination. The applicant's case is that the statement was recorded under coercion and duress and the finding based on this statement is absolutely unsustainable as the same is not based on legal evidence. The other documents relied on by the Enquiry authority, as well as by the disciplinary authority for reaching the conclusion that the applicant and Smt. K.R. Aruna were living together and that they have begotten two children have also been not proved in the manner in which they are required to be proved."
Similarly, learned counsel has relied upon the judgment passed by the Apex Court in the case of Krishna Narayan Tewari (supra) the relevant portion of which is quoted herein below:
"7. We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions at the bar. It is true that a writ court is very slow in interfering with the findings of facts recorded by a Departmental Authority on the basis of evidence available on record. But it is equally true that in a case where the Disciplinary Authority records a finding that is unsupported by any evidence whatsoever or a finding which no reasonable person could have arrived at, the writ court would be justified if not duty bound to examine the matter and grant relief in appropriate cases. The writ court will certainly interfere with disciplinary enquiry or the resultant orders
7
passed by the competent authority on that basis if the enquiry itself was vitiated on account of violation of principles of natural justice, as is alleged to be the position in the present case. Non-application of mind by the Enquiry Officer or the Disciplinary Authority, non-recording of reasons in support of the conclusion arrived at by them are also grounds on which the writ courts are justified in interfering with the orders of punishment. The High Court has, in the case at hand, found all these infirmities in the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority. The respondent's case that the enquiry was conducted without giving a fair and reasonable opportunity for leading evidence in defense has not been effectively rebutted by the appellant. More importantly the Disciplinary Authority does not appear to have properly appreciated the evidence nor recorded reasons in support of his conclusion. To add insult to injury the Appellate Authority instead of recording its own reasons and independently appreciating the material on record, simply reproduced the findings of the Disciplinary Authority. All told the Enquiry Officer, the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority have faltered in the discharge of their duties resulting in miscarriage of justice. The High Court was in that view right in interfering with the orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority.
9. The next question is whether the respondent would be entitled to claim arrears of salary as part of service/retiral benefits in full or part. The High Court has been rather ambivalent in that regard. We say so because while the High Court has directed release of service/retiral benefits, it is not clear whether the same would include salary for the period between the date of removal and the date of superannuation. Taking a liberal view of the matter, we assume that the High Court's direction for release of service benefits would include the release of his salaries also for the period mentioned above. We are, however, of the opinion that while proceedings need not be remanded for a fresh start from the beginning, grant of full salary for the period between the date of dismissal and the date of superannuation would not also be justified. We, therefore, allow this appeal but only in part and to the extent that while orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority shall stand quashed, and the respondent entitled to continuity of service till the date of his superannuation with all service benefits on that basis, he shall be entitled to only 50% of the salary for the period between the date of his removal from service till the date of superannuation. Retiral benefits shall also be released in his favour. The order passed by the High Court shall, to the extent indicated above, stand modified. The parties shall bear their own costs."
Similarly, learned counsel has relied upon the judgment passed by the Apex Court in the case of T R Varma (supra) the relevant portion of which is quoted herein below:
"Stating it broadly and without intending it to be exhaustive, it may be observed that rules of natural justice require that a party should have the opportunity of adducing all relevant evidence on which he relies, that the
8
evidence of the opponent should be taken in his presence, and that he should be given the opportunity of cross-examining the witnesses examined by that party, and that no materials should be relied on against him without his being given an opportunity of explaining them."
11. As the brief facts of the case have already been narrated above, the same are not reiterated for the sake of brevity. It is an admitted fact from the pleadings of the parties that applicant has not been examined in this matter as defense witness. The Inquiry Officer has also not interrogated the applicant under Rule 14 (18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. This is a mandatory provision to follow during the course of inquiry. To substantiate the same, it will be in the fitness of things to refer to the law laid down by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in its judgment dated 10.03.2011 passed in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 215 of 2009 titled Union of India and Anr Vs D S Manchanda, which is as follows:
"18. The next contention on behalf of the petitioner is about the noncompliance of the Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. According to the petitioners, Rule 14(18) was substantially complied with. Perusal of the record, however, reveals that it is an admitted case that the respondent did not examine himself as a witness. Since the respondent had not examined himself as witness, it was incumbent upon the enquiry officer to put evidence adduced against the respondent during the enquiry to him in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. The said rule had been enacted with a view that whatever evidence comes in the enquiry, explanation may be sought to rebut the circumstances, which would be in consonance with the principle of reasonable opportunity and audi alterm partum as inbuilt in the principles of natural justice. On perusal of the record, the order dated 6th April 1998 is categorical in stating that the respondent had neither examined any defense witnesses nor had he offered himself as a witness. Thereafter the respondent was generally examined by the Inquiry Officer, however whether or not the circumstances that came in evidence against the respondent was put to him has not been shown. In similar matters involving the same purchases, the charged officers were only put the charges which were framed against the charged officer. In the circumstances, in absence of any thing it is to be inferred that the evidence which was recorded during the enquiry was not put to the respondent in compliance with rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
19. Perusal of Rule 14(18) clearly reveals that it is obligatory upon the enquiry authority to question the delinquent officer on
9
the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence, for the purpose of enabling him to explain any circumstance. As there is no reference to the evidence brought on record or circumstances appearing against the applicant, hence the general examination, a copy of which has also not been produced despite ample opportunity to the petitioner, it is apparent there was not a valid compliance of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.
20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19 (21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958. In the matter of Moni Shankar V. Union of India, 2008 (1) AJW 479, an enquiry proceeding was conducted in which the following questions were put to the Charged Officer:
"please state if you plead guilty?" ; "Do you wish to submit your oral or written arguments? ; "Are you satisfied with the enquiry proceeding" and "Can I conclude the enquiry?", were held to be not in compliance of Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958 as such type of questions did not reveal the evidence adduced in support of charges against the charged officer.
21. In Ministry of Finance v. S.B.Ramesh, (1998) 3 SCC 227 the Supreme Court had held the Rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985 to be mandatory. The Apex Court had upheld the decision of the Tribunal holding that the order of the Disciplinary Authority was based on no evidence and that the findings were perverse, on the reasoning that even if the Enquiry Officer had set the applicant ex parte and recorded the evidence, he should have adjourned the hearing to another date to enable the applicant to participate in the enquiry thereafter. Or even if the Enquiry Authority did not choose to give the applicant an opportunity to cross-examine the witness examined in support of the charge, he should have been given an opportunity to the applicant to appear and then proceeded to question him under Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. The omission to do this was construed to be a serious error committed by the Enquiry Authority. This also cannot be disputed that if the charged officer has examined himself as a witness then it will not be obligatory to examine the charged officer under Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. However, in the absence of any defense statement by the charged official, it was mandatory on the part of the enquiry officer to examine him under Rule 14(18), and the noncompliance of which will vitiate the enquiry proceedings."
12. The inquiry officer himself has opined that charge no. 4 was not found proved. As far as charge no. 5 is concerned, the same is as follows:
"Shri Gautam had earlier been penalized vide order No. A/97401/239/DGQA(Vig Cell) dated 1-10-96 on the
10
charge of being under the influence of alcohol in office. Despite the said penalty, Shri Gautam has not improved and continued to indulge in repeated misconducts as mentioned in Articles of Charge I to IV. It shows that Shri Gautam is an incorrigible and indisciplined person not amenable to discipline.
By his above act, the said Shri Gautam has acted in a manner of unbecoming of a Govt servant and thereby contravened Rule 3(1)(iii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules 1964."
Charge No. 5 is relating to previous conduct for which the applicant was punished. Only allegation in charge no. 5 is that despite punishment imposed upon the applicant in earlier disciplinary proceedings, he did not amend himself. In our considered view, contents of the charge no. 5 may be taken into consideration at the time of imposing the punishment as past conduct but it cannot be in the form of a charge as has been done in this matter. Thus, in our considered view, charge no. 5 leveled against the applicant is meaningless and it is not sustainable thus charge no 5 is liable to be quashed.
13. Since charge no. 1 2 and 3 are related to the present incident, provision provided under Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 have not been followed during the course of inquiry, thus we are of the considered view that the inquiry officer has erred in conducting the inquiry. If the charged official has not examined himself, it is mandatory for the inquiry officer to examine / interrogate him under the aforesaid CCS (CCA) Rule placing all the incriminating materials collected during the inquiry before him. Since in the present case, the aforesaid mandatory provision has not been followed during the course of inquiry, the entire inquiry cannot be said to have been done in accordance with stipulated rules and regulations. The inquiry report and the order(s) passed subsequent to it by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority are illegal and liable to be set aside on the aforesaid ground.
11
14. Accordingly, the instant original application is allowed. The Inquiry Report and Impugned Order(s) dated 09.03.2004 and 05.06.2006 are hereby quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed to reinstate the applicant into service with all consequential benefits including granting him seniority for the period he stayed out of service pursuant to the impugned orders. However, since no duties were performed by the applicant for the aforesaid period, he will not be entitled for any back wages. The aforesaid exercise must be completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. Furthermore, in case respondents deem fit, they may conduct de novo inquiry from the stage of Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and also in accordance with other prescribed rules and regulations and taking into consideration the observations made in this judgment.
15. All associated MAs stand disposed of. No costs. (Mohan Pyare) (Justice Om Prakash VII) Member (Administrative) Member (Judicial) (Ritu Raj)
12