AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shaik Mahaboob Subhani, v. The State of Andhra Pradesh,

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH : AMARAVATI

    THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI WRIT PETITION No.22792 OF 2024 Between:

    Shaik Mahaboob Subhani, S/o. Sk. Ameena Saheb, aged about 60 years, presently working as Forest Beat Officer, Chagollu Beat, Beat of Kavali Range, Project Tiger and Nellore District.

    … Petitioner

    And

    The State of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its Special Chief Secretary, Department of Environment, Forests, Science & Technology, A.P.Secretariat, Velagapudi, Amaravati, Guntur District and three others.

    … Respondents

    Counsel for the petitioner : Sri Gangisetti Uma Sankar Counsel for respondents : GP for Services-I

    ORDER

    Heard Sri Gangisetti Uma Sankar, learned counsel for the petitioner, and Sri R.S. Manidar Pingali, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Services appearing for respondents.

    2. Challenging the proceedings RC.No.1962/2024/A2 dated 22.09.2024 of the 3rdrespondent transferring the petitioner, forest beat officer, along with others the above writ petition is filed.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the petitioner was transferred to Chagollu Beat on 07.01.2022 from Kullurupadu Beat, Ongole Range. Even before the impugned proceedings, the petitioner made a representation dated 09.09.2024 seeking retention on medical grounds. Without considering his representation and the petitioner's age, the petitioner

    1

    was transferred to ITDA area Y.Cherlopalli Beat. The transfer of the petitioner is contrary to G.O.Ms.No.75 Finance (HR.I-PLG. & POLICY) Department dated 17.08.2024.

    4. Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Services produced record and note file. As seen from the note file, the last three working stations, the petitioner worked are, (1) Motupalli Beat, Ongole Range from 04.04.2007 to 31.08.2011; (2) Kukatlaplli Beat Ongole Range from 31.12.2011 to 31.08.2015 and (3) Kullurupadu Beat, Ongole Range from 01.09.2015 to 06.01.2022. Thereafter the petitioner was transferred to Chagollu Beat on 07.01.2022 and worked at that station till the date of transfer. Learned Assistant Government Pleader would submit that all the previous places worked are non-ITDA areas. On administrative exigency, the petitioner was transferred to the ITDA area. The transfer of the petitioner was made as per G.O.Ms.No.75 dated 17.08.2024. He would further submit that to achieve optimum productivity, efficiency, and accountability in administration by placing the right person at the right place the transfers were made and thus prayed to dismiss the writ petition.

    5. Now, the point for consideration is:

    Does, the transfer order dated 22.09.2024 (Ex.P1) suffer from any illegality warranting interference by this Court to exercise judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India?

    6. Before delving into the facts of the case, let the Court examine the scope of the writ petition regarding the transfer of employees. It is a settled law that an employee holding a transferable post cannot claim any vested right to work at a particular place as the transfer order normally does not affect legal rights. The transfer issue is a prerogative of the employer and normally Courts will not interfere with transfers. A transfer is not only an incidence of service but also an essential condition of the service. Normally courts are chary to interfere with an order of transfer made for administrative

    2

    reasons. However, if an order of transfer is found to be an outcome of a mala fide exercise of power; if the transfer is made in connection with departmental proceedings; for extraneous considerations or collateral purposes, the Court can interfere with such transfers.

    7. In Gujarat Electricity Board Vs. Atmaram Sungomal Poshani1, the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed thus:

    "Transfer of a Government servant appointed to a particular cadre of transferable posts from one place to the another is an incident of service. No Government servant or employee of public undertaking has legal right for being posted at any particular place. Transfer from one place to other is generally a condition of service and the employee has no choice in the matter. Transfer from one place to other is necessary in public interest and efficiency in the public administration."

    8. In Union of India Vs. H.N. Kirtania2the Hon'ble Apex Court observed as follows:

    "Transfer of a public servant made on administrative grounds or in the public interest should not be interfered with unless there are strong and pressing grounds rendering the transfer order illegal on the grounds of violation of statutory rules or grounds of malafide."

    9. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar3, observed thus:

    "4. In our opinion, the Courts should not interfere with a transfer Order which are made in public interest and for administrative reasons unless the transfer Orders are made in violation of any mandatory statutory Rule or on the ground of malafide. A Government servant holding a transferable post has no vested right to remain posted at one place or the other, he is liable to be transferred from one place to the other. Transfer Orders issued by the competent authority do not violate any of his legal rights. Even if a transfer Order is passed in violation

    1

    1989 SCR (2) 357

    2

    1989 SCR (3) 397

    AIR 1991 SC 532

    3

    of executive instructions or Orders, the Courts ordinarily should not interfere with the Order instead affected party should approach the higher authorities in the Department. If the Courts continue to interfere with day-to- day transfer Orders issued by the Government and its subordinate authorities, there will be complete chaos in the Administration which would not be conducive to public interest." (emphasis is mine)

    10. In State of Punjab vs. Joginder Singh Dhatt4, the Hon'ble Apex Court observed as follows:

    "3. … It is entirely for the employer to decide when, where, and at what point of time a public servant is transferred from his present posting …"

    11. In Union of India and Others vs. S.L. Abbas5, the Hon'ble Apex Court observed that the scope of judicial review is available when there is a clear violation of statutory provision or the transfer is swayed by mala-fide etc., It was observed as follows:

    "7. Who should be transferred where, is a matter for the appropriate authority to decide. Unless the order of transfer is vitiated by mala-fides or is made in violation of any statutory provisions, the court cannot interfere with it. While ordering the transfer, there is no doubt, the authority must keep in mind the guidelines issued by the Government on the subject..."

    12. In N.K. Singh vs. Union of India and Others6, the Hon'ble Apex Court considered the aspect of the transfer of an employee, the prerogative of an employer regarding transfer observed as follows:

    "23. … Assessment of worth must be left to the bonafide decision of the superiors in service and their honest assessment accepted as a part of service discipline. Transfer of a government servant in a transferable service is a necessary incident of the service career. Assessment of the quality of men is to be made by the superiors taking into account several factors including suitability of the person for a particular post and exigencies of administration.

    4

    AIR 1993 SC 2486

    5

    (1993) 4 SCC 357

    (1994) 6 SCC 98

    6

    Several imponderables requiring the formation of a subjective opinion in that sphere may be involved, at times. The only realistic approach is to leave it to the wisdom of the hierarchical superiors to make that decision. Unless the decision is vitiated by mala fides or infraction of any professed norm or principle governing the transfer, which alone can be scrutinized judicially, there are no judicially manageable standards for scrutinizing all transfers and the courts lack the necessary expertise for personnel management of all government departments. This must be left, in the public interest, to the departmental heads subject to the limited judicial scrutiny indicated."

    The Apex Court further observed that:

    "24. … Challenge in courts of a transfer when the career prospects remain unaffected and there is no detriment to the government servant must be eschewed and interference by courts should be rare, only when a judicially manageable and permissible ground is made out. This litigation was ill- advised."

    13. In the State of M.P. and another Vs S.S.Kourav and others7, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as follows:

    "The courts or tribunals are not appellate forums to decide on transfers of officers on administrative grounds. It is for the administration to take appropriate decisions and such decisions shall stand unless they are vitiated either by mala fides or by extraneous consideration without any factual background foundation. In this case transfer order having been issued on administrative grounds, expediency of those orders cannot be examined by the Court."

    14. In National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. Vs Shri Bhagwan8, it was observed as follows:

    "No government servant or employee of a public undertaking has any legal right to be posted forever at any one particular place since the transfer of a particular employee appointed to the class or category of transferable post from one place to other is not only an incident but a condition of service,

    7

    (1995) 3 SCC 270

    (2001) 8 SCC 574

    8

    necessary too in public interest and efficiency in the public administration. Unless an order of transfer is shown to be an outcome of mala fide exercise of power or stated to be in violation of statutory provisions prohibiting any such transfer, the Courts or the tribunals cannot interfere with such orders as a matter routine, as though they are the appellate authorities substituting their own decisions for that of the management, as against such orders passed in the interest of administrative exigencies of the service concerned."

    15. In Somesh Tiwari Vs. Union of India and others9, the Hon'ble Apex Court held thus:

    "19. Indisputably an order of transfer is an administrative order. There cannot be any doubt whatsoever that transfer, which is ordinarily an incident of service should not be interfered with, save in cases where inter alia mala fide on the part of the authority is proved. Mala fide is of two kinds - one malice in fact and the second malice in law.

    20. The order in question would attract the principle of malice in law as it was not based on any factor germane for passing an order of transfer and based on an irrelevant ground i.e. on the allegations made against the appellant in the anonymous complaint. It is one thing to say that the employer is entitled to pass an order of transfer in administrative exigencies but it is another thing to say that the order of transfer is passed by way of or in lieu of punishment. When an order of transfer is passed in lieu of punishment, the same is liable to be set aside being wholly illegal."

    16. Of late, the Hon'ble Apex Court in Sri Pubi Lombi Vs. The State of Arunachal Pradesh and Others10, reversed the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court and upheld the order of the learned single Judge, wherein the learned single Judge declined to interfere in a transfer. The Apex Court observed thus:

    "10. In view of the foregoing enunciation of law by judicial decisions of this Court, it is clear that in absence of (i) pleadings regarding mala-fide, (ii) non- joining the person against whom allegation are made, (iii) violation of any

    9

    (2009) 2 SCC 592

    2024 0 Supreme (SC) 225

    10

    statutory provision (iv) the allegation of the transfer being detrimental to the employee who is holding a transferable post, judicial interference is not warranted. In the sequel of the said settled norms, the scope of judicial review is not permissible by the Courts in exercising of the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India."

    17. Keeping in view the expressions of the Hon'ble Apex Court, let me delve into the facts of this case.

    18. The petitioner, a forest beat officer of the respondent department was transferred, by the proceedings impugned. In the transfer order, it was revealed that the transfer was made on administrative grounds/requests.

    19. The Government issued G.O.Ms.No.75 Finance (HR.I-PLG. & POLICY) Department dated 17.08.2024, framing guidelines/ instructions, in respect of transfers and posting of employees.

    20. In the Government Order, it was detailed that the Government is committed to the welfare of its employees and seeks to promote work-life balance while ensuring efficient and effective service delivery to the citizens. To achieve the same, it is required that the employees are posted at places where they can contribute to the best of their abilities for improved governance and efficient delivery of public services. Keeping the above laudable object, guidelines were issued in the aforementioned G.O. The guidelines or administrative instructions concerning the exercise of transfer of employees concerned, the same are intended to ensure that a fair procedure is adopted and the power is not exercised arbitrarily by the employer or his representative while effecting transfer of the employees. Uniform standards and procedures are put in place to secure fair play and transparency in the matter.

    21. Paragraph No.4 of the said G.O. prescribes Principles for Transfers and Postings. Paragraph No.4 (1) prescribes that the employees who have completed a period of continuous stay of 5 years at a station invariably transferred. Paragraph No.4 (2) prescribes that the employees, other than

    7

    those who completed 5 years of stay at a station, shall also be eligible for transfer on administrative exigencies or personal request. Such employees too shall exercise preferences for stations.

    22. As seen from the record, it may be a fact that the petitioner has not completed five years of service, however, the transfer was made on the administrative exigency. The guidelines referred to supra speak about the transfer of employees who have not completed five years in a station can be transferred on administrative exigency. It is not the case of the petitioner that the authority transferred the petitioner for extraneous considerations and that it is a mala fide exercise. It is also not the case of the petitioner that the transfer will affect prospects in employment. Unless the petitioner pleads, it is very hard for this court to visualize the case of the petitioner in those lines. Indeed, the petitioner made a representation dated 26.08.2024 (Ex.P4) seeking retention. Thereafter the proceedings impugned were issued by the authority.

    23. In Shilpi Bose case (supra), the Hon'ble Court observed that even if a transfer order is passed in violation of executive instructions or orders, the Courts ordinarily should not interfere with the order, instead the affected party should approach the higher authorities in the department. Of course, in the case, at hand, this court does not find any violation of the rules and regulations regarding the transfer. As discussed supra, the transfer of the petitioner was made on administrative grounds. A common proceeding was issued in respect of 17 employees by mentioning administrative grounds/requests. That itself, per se, will not vitiate the proceedings.

    24. Though it was argued by the learned counsel that the transfer is malafide, whenever allegations of mala fides are made, the persons against whom the same are leveled need to be impleaded as parties to the

    8

    proceedings enabling them to answer. In Ratnagiri Gas and Power Private Limited Vs. RDS Projects and others11, the Hon'ble Apex Court held thus:

    "… There is yet another aspect which cannot be ignored. As and when allegations of mala fides are made, the persons against whom the same are leveled need to be impleaded as parties to the proceedings to enable them to answer the charge. In the absence of the person concerned as a party in his/her individual capacity, it will neither fair nor proper to record a finding that malice in fact had vitiated the action taken by the authority concerned…"

    25. In the case at hand, none of the officers were impleaded as a party respondents to the writ petition enabling them to answer the charge. In the absence, this court does not find any merit in the said plea.

    26. It is settled law that to invoke the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, one must satisfy infringement of its right be it legal or statutory, and corresponding legal obligation on the part of the respondent. Thus, the existence of legal rights is a sine qua non for invoking jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    27. In State of U.P. and others Vs. Harish Chandra and others12, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as follows:

    "10. ... Under the Constitution, a Mandamus can be issued by the court when the applicant establishes that he has a legal right to the performance of legal duty by the party against whom the mandamus is sought and the said right was subsisting on the date of the petition."

    28. In Union of India Vs. S.B. Vohra13, the Hon'ble Apex Court considered a similar issue and held that for issuing a Writ of Mandamus in favour of a person, the person claiming must establish his legal right in himself. Then only a Writ of Mandamus could be issued against a person, who has a legal duty to perform, but has failed and/or neglected to do so.

    11

    (2013) 1 SCC 524

    12

    (1996) 9 SCC 309

    (2004) 2 SCC 150

    13

    29. In Oriental Bank of Commerce Vs. Sunder Lal Jain14, the Supreme Court emphasized the necessity to establish the existence of legal right and its infringement for the grant of Writ of Mandamus referred the principles stated in the Law of Extraordinary Legal Remedies by F.G. Ferris and F.G. Ferris, Jr.:

    30. In Mani Subrat Jain Vs. State of Haryana15, while considering scope of Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the Hon'ble Apex Court observed as follows:

    "9. … It is elementary though it is to be restated that no one can ask for a Mandamus without a legal right there must be a judicially enforceable right as well as a legally protected right before one suffering a legal grievance can ask for a mandamus. A person can be said to be aggrieved only when a person is denied a legal right by someone who has a legal duty to do something or to abstain from doing something. (See Halsbury's Laws of England 4th Ed. Vol I, paragraph 122); State of Haryana Vs. Subash Chander, AIR 1973 SC 2216;

    Jasbhai Motibhai Desai Vs. Roshan, Kumar Haji Bashir Ahmed, AIR 1976 SC 578) and Ferris Extraordinary Legal Remedies paragraph 198."

    31. In the case at hand, the transfer of the petitioner was made on administrative exigencies. An order of transfer of an employee will not visit the employee concerned with any grave consequence. He would be required to function from a different office or unit whenever subjected to such transfer. The rest of the conditions of his service remain intact. The petitioner failed to demonstrate infringement of either fundamental or statutory rights as also violation of guidelines. Thus, this Court has not been persuaded by the submission of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. In that view of the matter, this Court does not find any merit in this writ petition and the same is liable to be dismissed.

    14

    (2008) 2 SCC 280

    AIR 1977 SC 276

    15

    32. Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed at the admission stage. No costs.

    As a sequel, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.

    ___________________________ JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI Dated:.2024 SNI

    11

    THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI WRIT PETITION No.22792 OF 2024

    Dated:.2024

    SNI

    12

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shaik Mahaboob Subhani, v. The State of Andhra Pradesh,
    (Dec 10, 2024)