Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973,
  • Section 438 of the Code
  • Sections 65(a), 65(e), 66(1)(b), 68, 81, 83, 84, 86, 98(2) and 116-B of the Gujarat Prohibition Act.
  • Gujarat Prohibition Act.
  • Section Page 9 of 12 439(2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973,
  • Section 438 of the Code
  • Sections 65(a), 65(e), 66(1)(b), 68, 81, 83, 84, 86, 98(2) and 116-B of the Gujarat Prohibition Act.
  • Gujarat Prohibition Act.
  • Section Page 9 of 12 439(2)

    RAJU SURESH SINDHI @ RAJUBHAI SURESHKUMAR SINDHI (AIDASANI) v. STATE OF GUJARAT

    R/CR.MA/5090/2024 ORDER DATED: 23/07/2024

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION (FOR SUCCESSIVE ANTICIPATORY BAIL) NO. 5090 of 2024

    ========================================================== RAJU SURESH SINDHI @ RAJUBHAI SURESHKUMAR SINDHI (AIDASANI) Versus

    STATE OF GUJARAT

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR M M SHAIKIH(11314) for the Applicant(s) No. 1 MR UVESH M SHAIKH(11313) for the Applicant(s) No. 1 MR HK PATEL, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HASMUKH D. SUTHAR

    Date : 23/07/2024

    ORAL ORDER

    1. Rule returnable forthwith. Learned APP waives service of Rule for and on behalf of the respondent-State.

    2. By way of present successive bail application under Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the applicant-original accused has prayed to release him on anticipatory bail in the event of his arrest in connection with the FIR registered at Sardarnagar Police Station, Ahmedabad, being C.R No.11191040231761 of 2023 for the offences punishable under Sections 65(a), 65(e), 66(1)(b), 68, 81, 83, 84, 86, 98(2) and 116-B of the Gujarat Prohibition Act.

    3. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant has been falsely implicated in the offence. The allegation levelled against the applicant is only that the he has supplied the liquor to conspirator viz. Padma and Anand, except this no allegation is levelled against the present

    Page 1 of 12

    applicant. It is submitted that the present applicant has nothing to do with the offence and he is law abide citizen. It is further submitted that, he is ready and willing to join the investigation. He is implicated on the basis of the statement of co-accused. Even co-accused Padmaben has not stated about the role of the present applicant. In view of the above, the applicant may be granted anticipatory bail.

    Learned counsel for the applicant has also submitted that, present successive bail application is filed on the ground of parity as this Court has granted bail to co-accused and therefore, on the ground of parity , present applicant may be released on anticipatory bail.

    Learned advocate for the applicant, on instructions, states that the applicant is ready and willing to abide by all the conditions including imposition of conditions with regard to powers of Investigating Agency to file an application before the competent Court for his remand. He would further submit that upon filing of such application by the Investigating Agency, the right of applicant - accused to oppose such application on merits may be kept open.

    4. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing on behalf of the respondent - State has opposed grant of anticipatory bail looking to the nature and gravity of the offence. It is submitted that at the instance of the State, the raid was conducted, which is based on the private evidence. During the raid, 29 peoples were found at the spot for consuming the liquor,

    Page 2 of 12

    15 people caught red handed and remaining accused persons are remained absconder and out of reach. Even present applicant is, till date, out of reach and remained absconder accused and required to be arrested. It is submitted that present applicant has not cooperated with the investigation. It is submitted that huge small and big bottles of English liquor and beer tins, total number- 2675 and country made liquor 40 liters 300 ML worth Rs. 3,99,481/- were seized . It is submitted that co-accused are released on regular bail. The allegation against co-accused was only that they consumed liquor. It is submitted that co-accused have been released on regular bail, claim of parity does not arise and present application may not be allowed. It is submitted that they have purchased and supplied the liquor, from-where, Gujarat being a dry state, prohibition is there, at this juncture, subsequently to eliminate crisis of prohibition and considering the public health, the provision of law made being stringent by the State Government. Considering the aforesaid, he requested to dismiss the present application. Considering his involvement in the offences, custodial interrogation of the applicant is required, as there is a possibility of tampering of evidence and evasion of interrogation of the accused. The accused, who are directly connected with the crime under the Prohibition Act, which have significantly affected the society, may try to evade interrogation.

    In view of the above submissions, he submits that present application may kindly be dismissed.

    Page 3 of 12

    5. Having heard the learned advocates for the respective parties, this Court has considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for both the sides and considered the material placed on record. It is well settled that, among other circumstances, the factors to be borne in mind while considering an application for bail are (i) whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to believe that the accused had committed the offence; (ii) nature and gravity of the accusation; (iii) severity of the punishment in the event of conviction; (iv) danger of the accused absconding or fleeing, if released on bail; (v) character, behaviour, means, position and standing of the accused. Though at the stage of granting bail execution and appreciation of evidence is not permissible. Having gone through the complaint, prima facie, it appears that the present applicant is involved in the offence. Considering the fact that present applicant is absconder and out of reach. Hence, custodial interrogation is required. It is worth to mention that, this is a successive bail application and approximately since last 11 months, the applicant is out of reach and not joined the investigation. Even in complaint also, he was shown as wanted. The applicant has supplied the liquor to the main accused Anand Rathod. In Gujarat being dry state and that too in a house, accused Anand along with his wife and others run private bar and indulged in illegal activities of selling of liquor. There is no change in the circumstances.

    5.1. Considering the fact that present applicant is named in the FIR and till date, he is out of reach. Total 29 accused persons are named in the FIR and

    Page 4 of 12

    15 were caught red handed and remaining accused till date are out of reach and they are required to be arrested. The allegations against the present applicant are that he is supplier of the liquor, under the Gujarat Prohibition Act. In view of above, the present applicant is involved in the illegal activity and supplied the huge quantity of liquor 2675 1MPL Bottles and 40 liters country made liquor and muddamal of Rs.7,12,591/- and prima facie, he has violated the law and it appears that there is no frivolity. The allegations levelled against the applicant is that he is having criminal past antecedents and investigation is at preliminary stage. Hence, custodial interrogation is required for more elicitation of fact and involvement of other accused persons and to reach up to core of the matter.

    6. The criteria to grant anticipatory bail and regular bail has been laid down by the Apex Court in various decisions. While criminal administration of justice disturbed, arrest is a part of investigation. After the arrest of the accused when substantial part of the investigation including remand gets over, then the Court has to exercise jurisdiction considering the evidence collected during investigation. It is needless to say that Section 438 of the Code is pre-arrest bail as there is a part of investigation and importance of the arrest is time and again discussed by the Hon'ble Apex Court. When the involvement of the accused is prima facie revealed and if allegation is not levelled that to defame him/them or to tarnish his/their image, the Court has to exercise jurisdiction, but to seek anticipatory bail is not an extraordinary jurisdiction and absolute right of the accused.

    Page 5 of 12

    7. Now coming back to the facts of the present case and looking to the material placed on record, it clearly transpires that the applicant remained absconder and out of reach. So no anticipatory bail granted to such absconder accused. Even otherwise, considering the facts and role of the applicant and co-accused has been granted regular bail, hence, no case is made out to extend the benefit of parity also and hence, question of parity does not arise. The applicant is also involved in the offence and in the instant case, role of the applicant as attributed as he has received and supplied of the liquor in huge quantity and it was very much within the knowledge of the applicant that Gujarat being a dry state, prohibition is there, however, he was involved in the illegal activity.

    8. Considering the fact that the present complaint is filed at the instance of the State Monitoring Cell and the accused persons are found in the illegal activity. The accused named in the FIR were found with the huge quantity of the liquor and made an arrangement to facilitate the accused persons and served the liquor to customers and operated permanent liquor stand. So far as the present applicant-accused is concerned, he has taken the stand that he is implicated on the basis of the statement of the co- accused. It is needless to say that accused-person is having past criminal antecedents and the statement of the co-accused is relevant during the course of investigation.

    9 Further, in the case of Mohd. Fasrin v. State the

    Page 6 of 12

    Intelligence Officer, rendered in Criminal Misc. Application No.296 of 2014, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under:

    "…….The confessions of a co-accused gives a clue to the investigating authorities as to how to investigate the matter and against whom to investigate the matter. Thereafter, it is for the investigating officers to collect evidence against the said person who has been named by the co- accused....."

    10. In view of decision rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court (3 Judge Bench) in case of G.R.Anand Babu Vs. State of Tamil Nadu & Anr. Reported in 2021 SCC Online 176, held as under:-

    "7. As a matter of fact, successive anticipatory bail applications ought not to be entertained and more so, when the case diary and the status report, clearly indicated that the accused (respondent No. 2) is absconding and not cooperating with the investigation. The specious reason of change in circumstances cannot be invoked for successive anticipatory bail applications, once it is rejected by a speaking order and that too by the same Judge."

    On the same ground, with speaking order, application was dismissed. Then after waiting more than 8 months, without joining investigation, the applicant remained on run and now present successive bail application is filed without change in the circumstances.

    11. In the case of Md. Shamim Khan Vs. The State of Jharkhand (Leave to Appeal (Cri.) No.9449/2021, the Hon'ble Supreme Court deprecated such practice of filing second application under Section 438 of the Code after the first being rejected.

    12. In so far the statement of co-accused is concerned, it provides clues to the investigating agency as to how to investigate the case and thereafter the investigating officer has to collect evidence against the person who has

    Page 7 of 12

    been named as the accused. In the light of the above provisions, there is no bar on considering the statement of co-accused for investigation purposes. At this stage, it is relevant to note that this Court has observed in the case of Mohmed Salim abdul Rasid Shaikh v. State of Gujarat, reported in 2001(2) GLR 1580, in para 12, as under:

    "...It is pertinent to note that the prosecution case rests mainly on circumstantial evidence and police has received a clue against the present applicant from the statement of co-accused, already arrested. Irrespective of the fact that statement of co-accused to police is not admissible in evidence before the Court, but police can certainly consider that statement as a clue while interrogating him further or other persons arrested or interrogated during the course of investigation…"

    13. In this background facts, this Court prima facie is of considered view that, there is a reasonable ground to believe that the applicant has committed the alleged offence. Considering the facts of the present case, it cannot be said that the applicant herein has been falsely implicated in the alleged offence. If the anticipatory bail as sought for is granted, then it will affect the investigation of the case. Therefore, custodial interrogation of the applicant is required.

    14. In the case of Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre vs State Of Maharashtra, reported in (2011) 1 SCC 694, the Hon'ble Court held that life and personal liberty are the most prized possessions of an individual but not at the cost of larger interest of society and public. This is not a case, wherein accused is falsely enraged in the offence with a view to tarnish his image. Considering the fact that the custodial interrogation is required.

    15. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Jai Prakash Singh Vs State of Bihar & Anr. reported in 2012 4 SCC 379, has been pleased to hold as

    Page 8 of 12

    under:-

    "Parameters for grant of anticipatory bail in a serious offences are required to be satisfied and further while granting such relief, the court must record the reasons therefore. Anticipatory bail can be granted only in exceptional circumstances where the Court is prima facie of the view that the applicant has falsely been enroped in the crime and would not misuse his liberty."

    16. The coordinate Bench of this Court in a case of Jigneshkumar Maheshbhai Patel vs State of Gujarat, (Criminal Misc. Application No.3122 of 2018) has observed as under :

    "15. This Court, in one of its judgments, in the case of State of Gujarat vs. Desai Jigisbhai @ Rajubhai Nagjibhai, Criminal Misc. Application No.23576 of 2015, decided on 4th February, 2016, observed as under;

    "25. When a Court is given a discretion, the statute confers upon it the power to act according to what may appear to be best and appropriate under the circumstances of the particular case. The discretion is not willful or arbitrary, but is regulated by well-known and well established principles. In many circumstances, the Judge has a discretion as to whether, and in what manner, to exercise his powers. Commonly encountered instances of judicial discretion are the discretion as to grant of bail in a non-bailable offence. However, no discretion is absolute and there may be a successful appeal to the Court of Appeal in relation to the exercise of a judicial discretion if the appellant can show that the judge exercised his discretion under a mistake of law, or under a misapprehension as to the facts, or that he took into account irrelevant matters or gave insufficient weight, or too much weight, to certain factors or that he failed to exercise his discretion at all.

    26.In Puran v. Rambilas and Anr. (2001 (6) SCC 338) it was noted as follows :

    "11. Further, it is to be kept in mind that the concept of setting aside the unjustified illegal or perverse order is totally different from the concept of cancelling the bail on the ground that the accused has misconducted himself or because of some new facts requiring such cancellation. This position is made clear by this Court in Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.). In that case the Court observed as under (SCC p. 124, para 16) :

    "If, however, a Court of Session had admitted an accused person to bail, the State has two options. It may move the Sessions Judge if certain new circumstances have arisen which were not earlier known to the State and necessarily, therefore, to that Court. The State may as well approach the High Court being the superior Court under Section

    Page 9 of 12

    439(2) to commit the accused to custody. When, however, the State is aggrieved by the order of the Sessions Judge granting bail and there are no new circumstances that have cropped up except those already existing, it is futile for the State to move the Sessions Judge again and it is competent in law to move the High Court for cancellation of the bail. This position follows from the subordinate position of the Court of Session vis-a-vis the High Court."

    16. The presumption of innocence, by itself, cannot be the sole consideration for grant of bail. The presumption of innocence is one of the considerations, which the court should keep in mind while considering the plea for bail. The salutary rule is to balance the cause of the criminal defendant and the cause of public justice. Over solicitous homage to the criminal defendant's liberty can, sometimes, defeat the cause of public justice. Over a period of time, a feeling seems to exist in some quarters that the object of criminal law is to protect the rights of the accused and that the criminal justicing system is envisioned as a sentinel of the rights of the accused. It is not so. The law is the sentinel of rights of the society and of the individual. The rights of the criminal defendant will be as zealously guarded, as the cause of public justice. Pre-trial detention in itself is not an evil, nor opposed to the basic presumption of innocence. If liberty is to be denied to an accused to ensure maintenance of law and order and public health, then the courts should not hesitate in denying such liberty. Ensuring security and order including public health is a permissible non-punitive objective, which can be achieved by R/CR.MA/3122/2018

    JUDGMENT pre-trial detention. Where overwhelming considerations in the nature aforesaid require denial of bail, it has to be denied"

    17. Learned counsel for the applicant has relied on the order passed by the Apex Court in the case of co-accused, but here case of the prosecution is that, custodial interrogation is required and the applicant is out of reach since long and considering the active involvement and to unearth truth, ground of parity will not be applicable. Further, in view of Ashvin Rathod, earlier petitions were dismissed on merit and as there is no change in circumstance, no case is made out to extend the benefit of parity.

    18. It would be apposite to refer the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court rendered in case of Pratibha Manchanda vs. State of Haryana reported in

    AIR 2023 SC 3307, wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed thus:-

    "19. The relief of Anticipatory Bail is aimed at safeguarding

    Page 10 of 12

    individual rights. While it serves as a crucial tool to prevent the misuse of the power of arrest and protects innocent individuals from harassment, it also presents challenges in maintaining a delicate balance between individual rights and the interests of justice. The tight rope we must walk lies in striking a balance between safeguarding individual rights and protecting public interest. While the right to liberty and presumption of innocence are vital, the court must also consider the gravity of the offence, the impact on society, and the need for a fair and free investigation. The court's discretion in weighing these interests in the facts and circumstances of each individual case becomes crucial to ensure a just outcome."

    19. In view of the above decision and in view of the facts and circumstances of this case, custodial interrogation of not only the applicant, but also all other suspect/s is therefore imperative to unearth the truth. Hence, this is a not a fit case to exercise the jurisdiction in favour of the applicant.

    20. Considering the question of public health and adverse effect and impact in the society, in the larger interest of justice, the Court has to struck down the balance between the personal liberty and larger interest of the society. In view of above, if the present applicant is protected with this order, this Court is of the considered view that if the present accused is equipped with protective order, it would obviously affect the case of the prosecution and adversely the qualitative investigation. This is not a fit case, wherein accused is falsely enraged in the offence and it appears that there is no frivolity, with a view to tarnish his image. Considering the fact that the custodial interrogation is required.

    21. For the foregoing reasons as present application being successive bail application is filed without any changed circumstances and considering the

    Page 11 of 12

    law laid down in the above cited decisions of this Court as well as the Hon'ble Apex Court, this Court is of view that it is not a fit case to exercise the discretion under Section 438 of the Code in favour of the applicant. Accordingly, present application does not deserve any consideration and is hereby dismissed at the admission stage. Rule is discharged.

    (HASMUKH D. SUTHAR,J)

    SUCHIT

    Page 12 of 12

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RAJU SURESH SINDHI @ RAJUBHAI SURESHKUMAR SINDHI (AIDASANI) v. STATE OF GUJARAT
    (Jul 23, 2024)