AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 MPHC-JBP 48918
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 3 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 65 A EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 62 EVIDENCE ACT
  • REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1951
  • SECTION 65 B EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 65 EVIDENCE ACT
  • Section 65-B(2) of the Evidence Act: (i)
  • Section 65- 9 B of the Evidence Act.
  • Sections 59, 65-A and 65-B of the Evidence Act,
  • Section 60 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act, 1999.
  • provisions of Section 441 (2a) of the Municipal Corporation Act, 1956,
  • provisions of the Evidence Act, namely, Sections 63
  • Section 69 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, 1984
  • section 65-B(4) of the Evidence Act.
  • Section 65-B,
  • Order 6 Rule 2 of C.P.C. read with Section 13(1) of Civil Court Rules, 1961
  • provisions of Section 65-B. Section 65-B
  • Section 441 of the Municipal Corporation Act, 1956
  • sub-section (4) of Section 65-B
  • Evidence Act, in view of Sections 59 and 65-A,
  • Section 65-A of the Evidence Act, read with Sections 59 and 65-B
  • Sections 65-A and 65-B of the Evidence Act
  • Section 65-B(2).
  • Section 151 of C.P.C.
  • Section 65-B. Section 65-B
  • Section 65-A, 65-B and Section 65-B (4) of the Evidence Act
  • Section 65-B(2) of the Evidence Act;
  • 23. Section 65-B(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 MPHC-JBP 48918
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 3 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 65 A EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 62 EVIDENCE ACT
  • REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1951
  • SECTION 65 B EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 65 EVIDENCE ACT
  • Section 65-B(2) of the Evidence Act: (i)
  • Section 65- 9 B of the Evidence Act.
  • Sections 59, 65-A and 65-B of the Evidence Act,
  • Section 60 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act, 1999.
  • provisions of Section 441 (2a) of the Municipal Corporation Act, 1956,
  • provisions of the Evidence Act, namely, Sections 63
  • Section 69 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, 1984
  • section 65-B(4) of the Evidence Act.
  • Section 65-B,
  • Order 6 Rule 2 of C.P.C. read with Section 13(1) of Civil Court Rules, 1961
  • provisions of Section 65-B. Section 65-B
  • Section 441 of the Municipal Corporation Act, 1956
  • sub-section (4) of Section 65-B
  • Evidence Act, in view of Sections 59 and 65-A,
  • Section 65-A of the Evidence Act, read with Sections 59 and 65-B
  • Sections 65-A and 65-B of the Evidence Act
  • Section 65-B(2).
  • Section 151 of C.P.C.
  • Section 65-B. Section 65-B
  • Section 65-A, 65-B and Section 65-B (4) of the Evidence Act
  • Section 65-B(2) of the Evidence Act;
  • 23. Section 65-B(1)
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Smt. Sangeeta Sushil Tiwari v. Smt. Nidhi Sunil Jain

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT JABALPUR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VISHAL MISHRA ON THE 23rdOF SEPTEMBER, 2024 MISC. PETITION No. 4297 of 2024

    SMT. SANGEETA SUSHIL TIWARI

    Versus

    SMT. NIDHI SUNIL JAIN AND OTHERS

    Appearance:

    Shri Mohammad Aadil Usmani - Advocate for the petitioner. Shri Varun Tankha - Advocate with Shri Banmeet Singh Sarna - Advocate for the respondent No.1.

    ORDER

    Assailing the order dated 20.07.2024 passed by the District Judge, Special Judge, Under Electricity Act, Sagar whereby the application filed by the petitioner under Section 151 of C.P.C. pertaining to objection of the petitioner for recording evidence of witness Vishal Yadav who prepare transcript from the pen-drive filed by the respondent No.1 marked as Exhibit P/9. Another application of the petitioner filed under Section 151 of C.P.C. taking objection that no witness can be examined and called in evidence to prove any speech by source of video clipping prepared copied from the pen drive on the ground that there is no authenticity for the translation without proving the source.

    2. It is the case of the petitioner that he is duly elected Mayor of Municipal Corporation Sagar. Petitioner was notified as a returned candidate in the gazette under Section 22 of the Act of 1956. Respondent No.1 Smt. Nidhi Sunil Jain who was a candidate from the Indian National Congress party contested the election conducted on 06.07.2022 for the post of Mayor in Sagar Municipal Corporation of

    1

    which elections results were declared on 17.07.2022. Since the respondent No.1 was not elected as a Mayor in the Municipal Corporation, Sagar, therefore, she filed an election petition on 04.08.2022 under Section 441 of the Municipal Corporation Act, 1956 for declaration of election dated 17.07.2022 to be void alleging corrupt practices.

    3. On notice being issued, the petitioner/defendant No.1 appeared and filed her written statement and denied the averments. He further alleged therein that the petitioner has failed to comply with the provisions of Section 441 (2a) of the Municipal Corporation Act, 1956, as well as the provisions of Representation of People Act, 1951. Subsequently, an application under Order 6 Rule 2 of C.P.C. read with Section 13(1) of Civil Court Rules, 1961 was filed which was allowed on 04.05.2023 and the respondents/plaintiff was directed to delete the provisions of law from the Election Petition which was subsequently deleted. 16 witnesses have been examined by the respondent No.1. PW-13 Anand Kumar Jain was examined who downloaded the alleged speech from the Facebook in his mobile. Copied it in his pen-drive from a computer shop. In his cross-examination, he has admitted that the original pen-drive has been destroyed. PW-15 Vishal Yadav who is a computer operator in the office of respondent No.1 was examined on 20.07.2024 and he said that he has prepared a transcript Ex.P/9 and P/10 by listening the video shown by Anand Jain whereas, in his cross-examination, he has admitted that a speech was not included in the video which he heard. Thereafter on the same day, the petitioner filed two applications under Section 151 of C.P.C. objecting the recording of evidence of Vishal Yadav as well as objection pertaining to call any other witness on record with respect to evidence related to video clipping of a speech copied in the pen-drive which has already been

    2

    destroyed. It is objected that since the pen-drive lacks credibility, the admissibility and reliance cannot be placed on a translated version. Especially in the condition when there is an admission on the part of the Anand Kumar Jain (PW-13) that the original has already been destroyed. The respondent No.1 opposed the application orally and the learned Trial Court after hearing the arguments of both the parties has rejected the applications filed by the petitioner and fixed the case for further evidence. The same is put to challenge by filing this present petition.

    4. It is the case of the petitioner that the transcripts Ex.P/9 and P/10 which he has prepared from the computer of Anand Kumar Jain which was the copy and original pen-drive has already been destroyed by him, therefore, no reliance should have been placed upon the translated version which has no source and calling the witness to prove the speech of the said transcript is per se illegal. The credibility and admissibility of such evidence is doubtful. The document Ex.P/10 that is the certificate prepared under Section 65 (b) (4) of the Evidence Act does not satisfy the requirement under the law. The person placing reliance upon the electronic evidence has to prove the source of the electronic evidence. Either he is required to file an affidavit in terms of Section 65 (b) of the Evidence Act, with respect to the electronic evidence or he has to submit the original instrument that is the original source from which such electronic evidence is being recorded. Nothing has been done in the present case. On the contrary, as admitted by PW- 13, that the original pen-drive from which the transcript has been prepared has been destroyed. The learned Trial Court was unjustified in rejecting the objections raised by the petitioner. Therefore, this petition has been filed.

    5. On notice being issued the respondents have marked their presence and has appeared before this Court. They have supported the impugned order. It is pointed out that on earlier occasion a similar objection was raised which was rejected by

    3

    this Court vide I.A. No.10/2023 which was rejected vide order dated 13.03.2024 to the effect that the pen-drive was produced by the plaintiff and two transcripts prepared by Vishal Yadav regarding the pen-drive which was produced as Ex.P/9 and P/10. It was contended that the transcripts were not prepared by the plaintiff, therefore, the said transcripts cannot be exhibited by the plaintiff Nidhi Jain and accordingly prays for correction of Ex.P/9. The same was duly objected.

    6. After considering the objection, the learned Trial Court has held that the pen-drive was played in the Court. The transcripts appears to have been made from that pen-drive. Whether the said transcripts is admissible in evidence or not is a matter of evidence and merits, the same cannot be considered at this stage. Heavy burden of proving the transcripts is on the plaintiff. If the plaintiff files to prove those transcripts at the relevant time, the benefit will not be extended to the plaintiff, therefore, the learned Trial Court has rejected the application at this stage. The aforesaid order has not been put to challenge by the petitioner at any point of time and the same has attained finality. It is argued that now pen-drive is being produced for exhibiting which is heavily being objected on the ground that once the original pen-drive is not even in existence then a pen-drive which is being prepared from a computer will not be admissible in evidence.

    7. Counsel appearing for the respondents has placed reliance upon the judgment passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Bipin Shantilal Panchal Vs. State of Gujarat and another reported in (2001) 3 SCC 1 dealing with admissibility of evidence, placing heavy reliance upon para 13, 14, 15 and 16. It is argued that there is no harm in taking the relevant document or the instrument on record marking it as exhibit and considering the same at a later stage and the objections regarding admissibility of the material can always be done at a later stage. This will facilitate in expediting the proceedings of the Trial. Similar is the situation in

    4

    the present case, the Trial Court has not made any comment upon the merits of the material placed before the Court. Rather it has only been placed on record and the merits will be considered at a later stage. He has further placed reliance upon the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Arjun Panditrao Khotkar Vs. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and others reported in (2020) 7 SCC 1. Hence, he has prayed for dismissal of the petition.

    8. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused.

    9. The question that arises for consideration before this Court is whether the pen-drive which has been produced for exhibiting without showing the original source can be marked as exhibit and is admissible in evidence.

    10. With respect to the aforesaid, the provisions of Section 65 of the Evidence Act are required to be seen.

    11. The Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Kamal Patel Vs. Shri Ram Kishore Dogne (Election Petition No.24 of 2014) reported in 2016 1 MPLJ 528 has held as under :-

    11. In the case of Anwar P.V. (supra), compact discs were used for announcing objectionable matter, songs etc.; however, CDs from which the objectionable matter was played, had not been got duly seized by the petitioner through police or Election Commission. In these circumstances, the Supreme Court observed that had the CDs from which the objectionable matter was played, been got seized through police or Election Commission, they would have constituted primary evidence and could have been produced by the petitioner without the certificate as envisaged under section 65-B(4) of the Evidence Act. In the case of Anwar P.V. (supra) objectionable speeches, songs and announcement were recorded using other instruments and by feeding them into a computer, CDs were made therefrom, which were produced in the Court, without due certification. Therefore, Supreme Court held that such CDs could not be admitted in evidence because mandatory requirements of section 65-B, were not satisfied.

    12. In the case at hand, the objectionable matter formed part of the speeches made in the public meetings convened by the

    5

    respondent. Those speeches were recorded video-graphed by the Election Commission, presumably by using video cameras. Thereafter, the contents of the memory card of the video cameras must have been transferred to a computer and the CDs forming record of the Election Commission must have been prepared. Thus, even the so called original CDs in the record of the Election Commission, would not constitute primary electronic evidence of the speeches. Moreover, in the case at hand, the CDs supplied to the petitioner were copies of the record maintained in the Election Commission and annexures P/19 to P/25 are in fact the copies prepared from the copies supplied to the petitioner by the Election Commission. Thus, in order to ensure the source and authenticity of the electronic record, a contemporaneous certificate issued at the time of each transfer in terms of section 65-B (4) of the Evidence Act, would be required because the Supreme Court has specifically held that in the case of CD, VCD, chip etc, the same shall be accompanied by the certificate in terms of section 65-B obtained at the time of taking the documents, without which, the secondary evidence pertaining to that electronic record, is inadmissible.

    12. In the case of Adish Kumar Jain Vs. State of Punjab (CRR No.472 of 2019 (O & M) decided on 28.02.2019 reported in 2019 Supreme (P & H) 676 with respect to admissibility of electronic evidence, the High Court of Punjab and Haryana has held as under :-

    6. In the present case, the petitioner seeks to rely upon data recorded on a compact disc without there being any evidence regarding the source from which it has been recorded. In the absence of the said source i.e. the DVR and also evidence to the effect that the same was being maintained regularly and was not tampered with, the data recorded in the CD, may not be admissible.

    7. During the course of arguments, the learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to a judgment of Hon'ble the Apex Court reported as 2016 (1) RCR (Criminal) 167 titled as Shamsher Singh Verma Vs. State of Haryana and has referred to paragraph No.16 of the same, which reads as follows:-

    16. We are not inclined to go into the truthfulness of the conversation sought to be proved by the defence but, in the facts and circumstances of the case, as discussed above, we are of the view that the courts below have erred in law in not allowing the application of the defence to get played the compact disc relating to conversation between father of the

    6

    victim and son and wife of the appellant regarding alleged property dispute. In our opinion, the courts below have erred in law in rejecting the application to play the compact disc in question to enable the public prosecutor to admit or deny, and to get it sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory, by the defence. The appellant is in jail and there appears to be no intention on his part to unnecessarily linger the trial, particularly when prosecution witnesses have been examined..."

    13. The three judges Bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Anvar P.V. Vs. P.K.Basheer and others reported in (2014) 10 SCC 473 has considered the scope of Section 65-A, 65-B and Section 65-B (4) of the Evidence Act and has held as under :-

    "14. Any documentary evidence by way of an electronic record under the Evidence Act, in view of Sections 59 and 65-A, can be proved only in accordance with the procedure prescribed under Section 65-B. Section 65-B deals with the admissibility of the electronic record. The purpose of these provisions is to sanctify secondary evidence in electronic form, generated by a computer. It may be noted that the section starts with a non obstante clause. Thus, notwithstanding anything contained in the Evidence Act, any information contained in an electronic record which is printed on a paper, stored, recorded or copied in optical or magnetic media produced by a computer shall be deemed to be a document only if the conditions mentioned under sub- section (2) are satisfied, without further proof or production of the original. The very admissibility of such a document i.e. electronic record which is called as computer output, depends on the satisfaction of the four conditions under Section 65-B(2). Following are the specified conditions under Section 65-B(2) of the Evidence Act:

    (i) The electronic record containing the information should have been produced by the computer during the period over which the same was regularly used to store or process information for the purpose of any activity regularly carried on over that period by the person having lawful control over the use of that computer;

    (ii) The information of the kind contained in electronic record or of the kind from which the information is derived was regularly fed into the computer in the ordinary course of the said activity;

    (iii) During the material part of the said period, the computer was operating properly and that even if it was not operating

    7

    properly for some time, the break or breaks had not affected either the record or the accuracy of its contents; and

    (iv) The information contained in the record should be a reproduction or derivation from the information fed into the computer in the ordinary course of the said activity.

    15. Under Section 65-B(4) of the Evidence Act, if it is desired to give a statement in any proceedings pertaining to an electronic record, it is permissible provided the following conditions are satisfied:

    (a) There must be a certificate which identifies the electronic record containing the statement;

    (b) The certificate must describe the manner in which the electronic record was produced;

    (c) The certificate must furnish the particulars of the device involved in the production of that record;

    (d) The certificate must deal with the applicable conditions mentioned under Section 65-B(2) of the Evidence Act; and

    (e) The certificate must be signed by a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to the operation of the relevant device.

    16. It is further clarified that the person need only to state in the certificate that the same is to the best of his knowledge and belief. Most importantly, such a certificate must accompany the electronic record like computer printout, compact disc (CD), video compact disc (VCD), pen drive, etc., pertaining to which a statement is sought to be given in evidence, when the same is produced in evidence. All these safeguards are taken to ensure the source and authenticity, which are the two hallmarks pertaining to electronic record sought to be used as evidence. Electronic records being more susceptible to tampering, alteration, transposition, excision, etc. without such safeguards, the whole trial based on proof of electronic records can lead to travesty of justice.

    17. Only if the electronic record is duly produced in terms of Section 65-B of the Evidence Act, would the question arise as to the genuineness thereof and in that situation, resort can be made to Section 45-A—opinion of Examiner of Electronic Evidence.

    18. The Evidence Act does not contemplate or permit the proof of an electronic record by oral evidence if requirements under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act are not complied with, as the law now stands in India.

    19. It is relevant to note that Section 69 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, 1984 (PACE) dealing with evidence on computer records in the United Kingdom was repealed by Section 60 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act, 1999. Computer evidence hence must follow the common law rule, where a presumption exists that the computer producing the evidential output was recording properly at the material time. The presumption can be rebutted if evidence to the contrary is adduced. In the United States of

    8

    America, under Federal Rule of Evidence, reliability of records normally go to the weight of evidence and not to admissibility.

    20. Proof of electronic record is a special provision introduced by the IT Act amending various provisions under the Evidence Act. The very caption of Section 65-A of the Evidence Act, read with Sections 59 and 65-B is sufficient to hold that the special provisions on evidence relating to electronic record shall be governed by the procedure prescribed under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act. That is a complete code in itself. Being a special law, the general law under Sections 63 and 65 has to yield.

    21. In State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu [State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, (2005) 11 SCC 600 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1715] a two-Judge Bench of this Court had an occasion to consider an issue on production of electronic record as evidence. While considering the printouts of the computerised records of the calls pertaining to the cellphones, it was held at para 150 as follows : (SCC p.

    714)

    "150. According to Section 63, "secondary evidence" means and includes, among other things, 'copies made from the original by mechanical processes which in themselves insure the accuracy of the copy, and copies compared with such copies'. Section 65 enables secondary evidence of the contents of a document to be adduced if the original is of such a nature as not to be easily movable. It is not in dispute that the information contained in the call records is stored in huge servers which cannot be easily moved and produced in the court. That is what the High Court has also observed [Ed. : Reference is to State v. Mohd. Afzal & Ors. , (2003) 71 DRJ

    178] at para 276. Hence, printouts taken from the computers/servers by mechanical process and certified by a responsible official of the service-providing company can be led in evidence through a witness who can identify the signatures of the certifying officer or otherwise speak of the facts based on his personal knowledge. Irrespective of the compliance with the requirements of Section 65-B, which is a provision dealing with admissibility of electronic records, there is no bar to adducing secondary evidence under the other provisions of the Evidence Act, namely, Sections 63 and 65. It may be that the certificate containing the details in sub-section (4) of Section 65-B is not filed in the instant case, but that does not mean that secondary evidence cannot be given even if the law permits such evidence to be given in the circumstances mentioned in the relevant provisions, namely, Sections 63 and 65. It may be seen that it was a case where a responsible official had duly certified the document at the time of production itself. The signatures in the certificate were also identified. That is apparently in compliance with the procedure prescribed under Section 65-

    9

    B of the Evidence Act. However, it was held that irrespective of the compliance with the requirements of Section 65-B, which is a special provision dealing with admissibility of the electronic record, there is no bar in adducing secondary evidence, under Sections 63 and 65, of an electronic record.

    22. The evidence relating to electronic record, as noted hereinbefore, being a special provision, the general law on secondary evidence under Section 63 read with Section 65 of the Evidence Act shall yield to the same. Generalia specialibus non derogant, special law will always prevail over the general law. It appears, the court omitted to take note of Sections 59 and 65-A dealing with the admissibility of electronic record. Sections 63 and 65 have no application in the case of secondary evidence by way of electronic record; the same is wholly governed by Sections 65-A and 65-B. To that extent, the statement of law on admissibility of secondary evidence pertaining to electronic record, as stated by this Court in Navjot Sandhu case [State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, (2005) 11 SCC 600 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1715] , does not lay down the correct legal position. It requires to be overruled and we do so. An electronic record by way of secondary evidence shall not be admitted in evidence unless the requirements under Section 65-B are satisfied. Thus, in the case of CD, VCD, chip, etc., the same shall be accompanied by the certificate in terms of Section 65-B obtained at the time of taking the document, without which, the secondary evidence pertaining to that electronic record, is inadmissible.

    23. The appellant admittedly has not produced any certificate in terms of Section 65-B in respect of the CDs, Exts. P-4, P-8, P-9, P-10, P-12, P-13, P-15, P-20 and P-22. Therefore, the same cannot be admitted in evidence. Thus, the whole case set up regarding the corrupt practice using songs, announcements and speeches fall to the ground.

    24. The situation would have been different had the appellant adduced primary evidence, by making available in evidence, the CDs used for announcement and songs. Had those CDs used for objectionable songs or announcements been duly got seized through the police or Election Commission and had the same been used as primary evidence, the High Court could have played the same in court to see whether the allegations were true. That is not the situation in this case. The speeches, songs and announcements were recorded using other instruments and by feeding them into a computer, CDs were made therefrom which were produced in court, without due certification. Those CDs cannot be admitted in evidence since the mandatory requirements of Section 65-B of the Evidence Act are not satisfied. It is clarified that notwithstanding what we have stated herein in the preceding paragraphs on the

    10

    secondary evidence of electronic record with reference to Sections 59, 65-A and 65-B of the Evidence Act, if an electronic record as such is used as primary evidence [Ed. :

    The words "under Section 62 of the Evidence Act", directed to be deleted in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1] [under Section 62 of the Evidence Act], the same is admissible in evidence, without compliance with the conditions in Section 65-B of the Evidence Act."

    14. Another three judges Bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Arjun Panditrao Khotkar Vs. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and others reported in (2020)

    7 SCC 1 has held as under :-

    "21. Section 65 differentiates between existence, condition and contents of a document. Whereas "existence" goes to

    "admissibility" of a document, "contents" of a document are to be proved after a document becomes admissible in evidence. Section 65-A speaks of "contents" of electronic records being proved in accordance with the provisions of Section 65-B. Section 65-B speaks of "admissibility" of electronic records which deals with "existence" and

    "contents" of electronic records being proved once admissible into evidence. With these prefatory observations let us have a closer look at Sections 65-A and 65-B.

    22. It will first be noticed that the subject-matter of Sections 65-A and 65-B of the Evidence Act is proof of information contained in electronic records. The marginal note to Section 65-A indicates that "special provisions" as to evidence relating to electronic records are laid down in this provision. The marginal note to Section 65-B then refers to

    "admissibility of electronic records".

    23. Section 65-B(1) opens with a non obstante clause, and makes it clear that any information that is contained in an electronic record which is printed on a paper, stored, recorded or copied in optical or magnetic media produced by a computer shall be deemed to be a document, and shall be admissible in any proceedings without further proof of production of the original, as evidence of the contents of the original or of any facts stated therein of which direct evidence would be admissible. The deeming fiction is for the reason that "document" as defined by Section 3 of the Evidence Act does not include electronic records."

    15. Thus from the perusal of the aforesaid settled legal proposition of law with respect to admissibility of electronic evidence, it is clear that until and unless the

    11

    (VISHAL MISHRA)

    JUDGE

    source from which the said document or article is obtained is available or the original device is produced before the Court or certificate under Section 65-B with respect to original source is available, the document or the article or pen-drive in the present case, cannot be marked as exhibit. If the facts of the present case are considered in view of the settled legal proposition it is seen that the pen-drive which is being produced for marking in exhibit which is not the original pen drive or has not been copied from the original source, in absence of original source or certificate to the aforesaid effect in terms of Section 65-B of Evidence Act, the same is not admissible in evidence. The learned Trial Court has committed an error in allowing such application. Merely marking the transcripts as an exhibit and holding that whether they are admissible or not is a matter of evidence cannot be a ground to mark the pen-drive as an Exhibit which is heavily being objected as the same is not the original pen-drive.

    16. Under these circumstances, the order dated 20.07.2024 passed by the learned Trial Court is unsustainable. It is hereby set aside. The application filed for exhibiting the pen-drive as admissible in evidence is dismissed looking to the settled proposition of law. The application filed by the petitioner raising objection on exhibiting the pen-drive is allowed. The said pen-drive which is not original or is being copied from the original source cannot be exhibited.

    17. Accordingly, the petition stands allowed and disposed off.

    AM

    12

    13

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Sangeeta Sushil Tiwari v. Smt. Nidhi Sunil Jain
    (Sep 23, 2024)