JUDGMENT
Amit Rawal, J. Present OP (CAT) is directed against the order rendered in OA No.387 of 2016 dated 15.11.2022 whereby the following prayer of the petitioners/applicants before the CAT has been rejected.
I. Call for the records leading to Annexure A9 and quashing the same.
2. to issue a direction to the 1strespondent to give retrospective effect to the Notification No.11031/10/2004 AIS
(II) A dated 5.7.2007 with effect from 1.1.2004, thereby review the cadre strength with effect from 1.1.2004 and refix the date of promotion /selection and grant the monetary benefits if any arising there from.
2. The necessary facts in brief, for adjudication of the controversy involved in the present OP(CAT) are extracted herein below:
3. Petitioners, five (5) in number, were on the roll of the Kerala State Service and were due for promotion as Indian Administrative Service (IAS) on the basis of the cadre review by the Central Government on the recommendations of the State Government. Rule 4(2) of the IAS cadre Rules envisages that the Central Government shall ordinarily at the end of every five (5) years re-examine the strength and composition of each cadre in consultation with the State Government or State Governments concerned and make such alterations as it deem fit with a proviso that nothing in that sub rule shall be deemed to affect the power of
4
the Central Government to alter the strength and composition of any cadre at any other time. Vide communication Ext.A3 dated 27.12.2004, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions sent a communication to the Chief Secretary, Government of Kerala regarding the composition and review of the strength of the Kerala cadre, notified as far as back on 10.6.1999, for sending the recommendations. The said letter was duly replied by the State Government vide Ext.A4 dated 23.3.2006 whereby the inconvenience was deeply regretted in not sending the names. Vide Ext.A5 dated 28.4.2007, it was submitted that the cadre review proposal was under process and by May 2007, it was sanctioned. It is only thereafter the applicants were conferred the designation of the IAS in 2008-2009.
4. The pith and substance of the grievance of the applicants as culled from the pleadings in the OA as well as the present OP is that on account of the fault of the State Government for not holding of the cadre review strictly as per the provisions of the Rule 4(2), ibid, they cannot be made to suffer for non availment of promotion and pensionary benefits. Considering that grievance in mind submitted a representation dated 19.2.2015, Annexure A7.
5. On non consideration of the representation, jurisdiction of the Administrative Tribunal was invoked, resulted into a direction
5
in 2015 to decide the controversy after passing a detailed order. It is only thereafter, ie., on 24.9.2015, the claim was rejected. After expiry of almost eight months, OA No.387 of 2016 was preferred in the month of May 2016. In support of the contentions, judgment of the Supreme Court in Union of India and Another v. Hemraj Singh Chauhan and Others (2010) 4 SCC 290 has also been relied.
6. The stand of the respondent has been that the Rule cannot be made applicable retrospectively and has to be prospectively. The petitioners have been remiss in not explaining the benefits they would have been entitled to. CAT vide order dated 15.11.2022 rejected the case.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioners/applicants assiduously argued that Rule 4(2), does not bar the department from considering the cadre review retrospectively. Applicants cannot be faulted with any lapse on their part, for, it was the State Government, despite the request of the Central Government way back in 2004, had not adhered to the request but had taken almost three years in submitting the list of the candidates after processing the cadres strength and were conferred the designation in 2008-2009. Had this exercise been undertaken well within time would have got further promotion and higher cadre of Additional Chief Secretary and would have been entitled to pension on retirement. Paragraph
6
47 of the judgment cited supra was also relied.
8. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent/Union of India supported the findings and submitted that the direction of the Supreme Court was under Article 142 and therefore cannot be applied uniformly in all cases. The said factor has been taken care of while passing the impugned orders as the error noticed in the judgment was of such nature where the direction was issued for considering the cadre review retrospectively and urged this Court for dismissal of the petition.
9. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and appraised the paper book. Rule 4(2) of the IAS cadre Rules reads as follows:
4. Strength of Cadres - xxx
(2) The Central Government shall, 4 [ordinarily] at the interval of every 4 [five] years, re-examine the strength and composition of each such cadre in consultation with the State Government or the State Governments concerned and may make such alterations therein as it deems fit.
Provided that nothing in this sub-rule shall be deemed to affect the power of the Central Government to alter the strength and composition of any cadre at any other time.
9. No doubt, the aforementioned Rule does not debar the Central Government for consideration of the case of the authorities with retrospectivity. Vide Ext.A3 dated 27.12.2004, the contents of which are extracted herein below, would reveal that State Government was requested vide two letters which was responded
7
by the State Government vide Exts.A4 and A5, the contents of which are also extracted and on perusal reveal that the State Government had been remiss in not processing the cadre review. Annexure A3:
I am directed to say that the last review of the strength and composition of The Kerala Cadre of IAS was notified on 10th June, 1999. The next quinquennial cadre review has thus become due. However, No proposal in this regard has since been received from the State Government,
2 The Supreme Court in W.P. (C) No. 613/1994 (TNASOA Vs. UOI) has stated that the Central Government has the primary responsibility of making cadre reviews and to consider whether it is necessary or not to encadre long existing excadre posts. Delay in conducting the cadre review results in avoidable litigation as officers of the Slate Civil Service approach the Courts that the delay has stalled their promotional avenues.
3. It is, therefore, requested that the proposal for review of the strength and composition may please be furnished to this Department in the prescribed proformae along with the following information urgently:
(i) Recruitment levels of the Government of Kerala during the next5years:
( ) Based on the information at (i) above, details of the fieldⅱ posts and the cadre posts which are to be docadrod, if any, Annexure A4:
1. Your kind help is requested for please arranging holding the Quinquennial review of Kerala's IAS cadre review, at the earliest, for which the request was sent to Government of India vide letter No.3146/05/SPA1/GAD dated 19th October, 2005, for the review which was actually due on 1stJanuary, 2004. Inconvenience caused is deeply regretted. However, the intention of this request is to avoid hardships to eligible officers as proposal for cadre review is delayed not due to their fault
8
2 Shall be extremely grateful for your kind help in the matter
Annexure A5:
Sub:- IAS-Cadre Review Proposal pertaining to IAS Cadre of Kerala - Reg
Ref:- 1. State Government letter of even number dated 14-09- 2005 & 10-01-2007.
2. Lettor No. 11031/10/2004-AIS II, dated 30-03-2007 from Government of India, Ministry of Personnel Public Grievances and Pensions.
3. Please refer to the letters cited above. I am directed to forward herewith requisite information for processing the cadre review proposal of IAS Cadre of Kerala in the prescribed proforma as desired.
4. I am also directed to request that the proposed cadre review in respect of the IAS Cadre of Kerala may be given retrospective effect from 01-01-2004.
10. We are in total sympathy with the petitioners who had been left high and dry for non consideration of the cadre review. Had the exercise been done within time line as per the provisions of the Rule 4(2), ibid, they would have been conferred the designation much before and perhaps would have been entitled to higher pay grade or enhancement in the pay scale like Additional Chief Secretary etc, though the details of which are conspicuously wanting. We would also be failing in duty in not noticing the ratio of decidendi culled out in the judgment cited supra. Relevant paragraphs of the same reads reads thus:
46. In a somewhat similar situation, this Court in Union of India and Ors. vs. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah - (1996) 6 SCC
9
721, while construing Regulation 5 of the I.A.S. (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 held that the insertion of the word `ordinarily' does not alter the intendment underlying the provision. This Court in that case was considering the provision of Clause (1) of Regulation 5 of the IPS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations along with other provisions of Regulation 5. The interpretation which this Court gave to the aforesaid two Regulations was that the Selection Committee shall meet at an interval not exceeding one year and prepare a list of members who are eligible for promotion under the list. The Court held that this was mandatory in nature.
47. It was urged before this Court that the insertion of the word `ordinarily' will make a difference. Repelling the said contention, this Court held that the word `ordinarily' does not alter the underlying intendment of the provision. This Court made it clear that unless there is a very good reason for not doing so, the Selection Committee shall meet every year for making the selection. In doing so, the Court relied on its previous decision in Syed Khalid Rizvi vs. Union of India - 1993 Supp. (3) SCC 575. In that case the Court was considering Regulation 5 of the Indian Police Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 which also contained the word `ordinarily'. In that context the word `ordinarily' has been construed as:
".......since preparation of the select list is the foundation for promotion and its omission impinges upon the legitimate expectation of promotee officers for consideration of their claim for promotion as IPS officers, the preparation of the select list must be construed to be mandatory. The Committee should, therefore, meet every year and prepare the select list and be reviewed and revised from time to time as exigencies demand."
48. The same logic applies in the case of cadre review exercise also.
49. Therefore, this Court accepts the arguments of the learned counsel for the appellants that Rule 4(2) cannot be construed to have any retrospective operation and it will operate prospectively. But in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Court can, especially having regard to its power under Article 142 of the Constitution, give suitable directions in order to mitigate the hardship and denial of legitimate rights of the employees. The Court is satisfied that in this case for the delayed exercise of statutory function the Government
10
has not offered any plausible explanation. The respondents cannot be made in any way responsible for the delay. In such a situation, as in the instant case, the directions given by the High Court cannot be said to be unreasonable. In any event this Court reiterates those very directions in exercise of its power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India subject to the only rider that in normal cases the provision of Rule 4(2) of the said Cadre Rules cannot be construed retrospectively.
11. On perusal of the aforementioned findings, it is irresistibly concluded that the directions to apply in exceptional cases was under Article 142. We have not been confronted with any exceptional case except the delay on the part of the State. But when confronted the counsel as to why the representation immediately on conferring of the cadre in 2008-2009 was not submitted. There is no such pleadings or any averments preventing the administrative Tribunal to decide. Mere direction of the administrative tribunal to the concerned department to take a call on the representation submitted in 2015 would not in fact result into condonation of delay of five year, which had already occurred. For the reason aforementioned we do not find any illegality in the impugned order. OP(CAT) is dismissed.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL, JUDGE
Sd/-
sab EASWARAN S., JUDGE
11
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 102/2023
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure.A.9 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT DATED 24-9-2015
Annexure.A.1 TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION NO.11031/10/2004-AIS-IIA DATED 5-7-2007
PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL GAZETTE
Annexure.A.2 TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION NO.11031/98/AIS(II) A7B DATED 10-6-1999 Annexure.A,3 TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT DATED 27-12-2004
Annexure.A.4 TRUE COPY OF LETTER ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT DATED 23-3-2006.
Annexure.A.5 TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT MAKING
RETROSPECTIVE EFFECT TO THE CADRE REVIEW
DATED 18-4-2007 Annexure.A.6 TRUE COPY OF THE GAZETTE NOTIFICATION
DATED 7-3-2006 Annexure.A.7 TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION SUBMITTED
BY THE APPLICANTS TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT
DATED 19-2-2015
Annexure.A.8 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL DATED 10- 6-2015.
Annexure. R.1(a) TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION DATED 7-3-
2006.
Annexure.R.1(b) TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION DATED 1-8-
2003.
Annexure.R.1(c) TRUE COPY OF SPEAKING ORDER DATED 24-9-
2015.
12
Annexure R.1(d) TRUE COPY OF T DEPARTMENTS LETTER DATED 22-12-2004
Annexure R.1(e) TRUE COPY STATE GOVERNMENTS LETTER DATED 19-10-2005.
Annexure R.1(f) TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 24-5-2006
Annexure.R.1(g) TRUE COPY OF ORDER OF THE HONOURABLE CAT IN O.A.NO.33 OF 2007 DATED 14-3-2007
Annexure R.1(h) TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 28-4-2007 Annexure R.1(i) TRUE COPY OF MINUTES OF CRC MEETING HELD ON 25-6-2007 .
Annexure. R.1(j) TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE3RD MEMBER(J)
OF MADRAS BENCH OF CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL IN O.A.NO.1762 OF 2014
Exhibit.P.1 TRUE COPY OF O.A.NO.387 OF 2016 FILED
BEFORE THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH DATED 13-5-2016 Exhibit.P.2 TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY
THE 1ST RESPONDENT IN O.A NO.
180/00387/2016 DATED 27-7- 2016 Exhibit.P.3 TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY RESPONDENTS 2 AND 3 DATED 17-8-2016
Exhibit.P.4 TRUE COPY OF THE SAID ORDER PASSED IN O.A NO. 180/00387/2016 OF THE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
DATED 15-11-2022