AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (102 of 1956) (Indian Medical Central Act, 1970 and Homoeopathy Central Coun-cil Act, 1973). 15.6
  • Fundamental Rule 10, Ref Supplementary Rules 3, 4 and 4- A] 15.3 CATEGORIES
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (102 of 1956) (Indian Medical Central Act, 1970 and Homoeopathy Central Coun-cil Act, 1973). 15.6
  • Fundamental Rule 10, Ref Supplementary Rules 3, 4 and 4- A] 15.3 CATEGORIES
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DEEPAK YADAV v. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION (SSC)

    1

    Item No. 75/C-4 OA 597/2024

    Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench, New Delhi OA No. 597/2024

    This the 22nd day of April, 2024 Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J) Hon'ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)

    Deepak Yadav Aged about 21 years, S/o Sh. Birendra Kumar R/o Vill & Post - Budhsaini Distt - Baghpat, UP - 250606 …Applicant

    (By Advocate : Ms. Esha Mazumdar)

    Versus

    1. Staff Selection Commission Through its Chairman

    Northern Region

    Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003

    2. Delhi Police Through Commissioner of Police Delhi Police Headquarters Behind Parliament Street Police Station, New Delhi-110001

    3. Addl. Commissioner of Police, HQ-II Recruitment, Police Headquarters Jai Singh Road New Delhi-110001

    4. Border Security Force, Block No. 10

    Lodi Estate, Lodhi Rd. CGO Complex, Lodi Colony New Delhi - 110003 …Respondents

    (By Advocate :Mr. Amit Yadav, Ms. Annu Singh)

    2

    ORDER (ORAL)

    Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J)

    1. The present Original Application (OA) has been filed by the applicant seeking the following reliefs:-

    "A. Call for records of the case:

    B. Quash and set aside the order dated 22/01/2024 passed by Review Medical Board;

    C. Pass an order directing the Respondents to constitute an independent Medical Board;

    D. Pass an order directing Respondents to appoint the Applicant to the post of Constable (Exe.) Male with all consequential benefits including arrears, etc along with interest at GPF rates;

    E. Award cost of the proceedings; and

    F. Pass any order/relief/direction(s) as this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice in favour of the Applicant."

    2. There are identical cases filed by various counsels involving common facts and question of law, seeking similar relief(s).

    3. With the consent of all the parties, we proceed to dispose of the present OA at admission stage itself. Counter affidavit has already been filed in the present case. Learned counsel for the applicant states that since the matter is being disposed of, at the admission stage itself, she does not wish to file any rejoinder. It is further highlighted by learned counsel for the respondents that in all the matters reply could not be filed and seek's further time to file counter affidavit in remaining cases. However, the learned

    3

    counsel for the respondents says the issues are common , the averments made in counter affidavit would be the same in all cases , he may be allowed to adopt the same remaining cases also. For the sake of brevity, the facts from this OA are being referred and treated as a lead case. The decision in present shall follow the suit of the remaining OA (s).

    4. The issue involved in the present matter is rejection of the applicant's candidature on the ground of "faded but visible tattoo in right forearm, i.e., the saluting arm", which is prohibited under the rules and regulations of the respondents.

    5.SUBMSSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT(S):-

    5.1 As the subject matter of the present matter is rejection of candidature due to "tattoo", Learned counsel for the applicant would submit that issue invovled is covered by various decisions and relies upon the following judgments:-

    (i) Writ Petition(s) (Civil) No(s).444/2019, titled Dharamvir Singh v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.

    4

    (ii) Nihal Singh v. Union of India and Another, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 3264. Relevant part of the same reads as under:-

    "5. On enquiry from the petitioner, this Court has been told that the petitioner has fully removed the tattoo from his right forearm, the photograph after removing the tattoo is Annexure P-4 to the present petitioner. This Court also finds from the Detailed Medical Examination dated 17.05.2023 and the Review Medical Examination dated 17.05.2023 that barring the said tattoo, there were no other defects found in the petitioner."

    (iii) W.P.(C) 1762/2024, titled Sachin Kuman Vs. Union of India and Ors. and W.P.(C) 1789/2024, titled Dnyaneshwar DevarsheVs. Union of India and Ors. decided on 07.02.2024, by a common judgment, passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi;

    (iv) W.P.(C) No. 7786/2022, titled Pardeep Vs. Union of India & Ors. decided on 20.05.2022 by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi.

    5.2 Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the forearm tattoo is a temporary unfitness. The candidature of the applicant cannot be rejected under the garb of the alleged bar of having tattoo.

    5.3 It is further contended that the tattoo can be removed by way of appropriate surgery and the same would not come in the way of the applicant performing his/her official duties.

    5

    5.4 She further contends that time difference between conducting the medical and review medical was conducted within two three days, therefore, reasonable time was not afforded to the applicant for curing the such informity which is otherwise curable within short span of time by perfoming minor surgery.

    6.SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:-

    6.1 Opposing the grant of relief, learned counsel for the respondent would reiterates the averments made in the counter reply. Written submissions had also been filed during the course of the hearing.

    6.2 He draws our attention to Notification /Advertisment and relies upon the 13.1, 13.2, 14.2, 16.15and 21.1 of the same.

    6.3 He states that the terms and condition of the advertisement are sacrosanct and thus the same are strictly binding on applicant as well as respondents. While filing up the forms, the candidate specifically declared that

    "I have read the notice of the examination and accept the terms and condition of the notice of the examination."

    6.4 Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that any relaxation or deviation from the terms of the advertisement at this stage may cause injustice to those

    6

    who did not apply due to reasons such as having tattoos, blurred tattoos, or any such defect, disease, or deformity, etc.

    6.5 Further, the applicant did not request any modification or amendment of the terms of the advertisement before the commencement of the selection process and participated without and demur. But now by way of relief sought in paragraph 8, the applicant is indirectly seeking something to which he was not entitled. In support of his contention, he relies upon the following judgments:-

    (i) Abhishek Khandelwal Vs Union of India O.A No 1102/2022;

    (ii) Sh. Rajveer Singh Vs UPSC and Anr. O.A No.224/ 2014;

    (iii) Vidushi Gupta Vs Armed Forces Medical College W.P.(C) No.4521/2012

    6.6 He states that the present OA is not maintainable as the applicant did not follow the prescribed instructions on the subjects which states as under:

    (3) Re-examination only in case of possible error of Judgement It has been decided that there should be no right of appeal from the findings of a Civil Surgeon or an 'authorised medical attendant, but that, if Government are satisfied on the evidence - placed'before them by'the candidate concerned of the possibility of an error of judgment in the decision of the Civil Surgeon or the authorised medical attendant, it will be 'open to them to allow re-examination by

    7

    another Civil Surgeon or a specialist or by a Medical Board, as may be considered necessary. The fees for such examination, if any, will be paid by the candidate concerned. [M.H. OM No. F.7(1)-27/51 M-I1 dated the 18th January, 1952 and M.H.A. Endt. No. 38/5/52- Ests, dated the 1st February, 1962.1

    (4) -Evidence regarding -possible error of judgment must refer to original certificate With reference to the instructions contained in Order -(3) above, it has been decided that if any medical certificate is produced by a candidate or Central Government servant as a piece of evidence about the' possibility of an error of judgment in the decision of Medical Board/Civil Surgeon or other medical officer who had examined him in the first instance, the certificate will not be taken into consideration unless it contains a note by the medical practitioner concerned to the effect - that it has been given in full knowledge of the fact that the candidate has already been rejected as unfit for service by a Medical Board, a Civil. Surgeon or other medical officer. [M.H. OM No. F.7(1)-6/53, M-I1 dated the 27th March,

    1953.]

    6.7 Since the applicant while obtaining a medical certificate from a civil hospital did not even inform the medical practitioner that he was a candidate and has already been declared unfit. It is settled Law that once it is prescribed that something is to be done in a particular manner, then it has to be done in that manner and in no other manner. In support of his contention, he relies upon the following judgments:-

    (i) Sri Satya Sai University of Technology and Medical Sciences Sehore vs. Union of India and Ors.(14.08.2023-DELHC): MANU/DE/5236/2023

    (ii) State of U.P Vs Rahul, Manu/UP/0197/2016

    (iii) Mohan Kumar Gupta Vs State of U.P., C.M.W.P No.15502/2019, Manu/UP/4750/2019 .

    8

    6.7 Learned counsel for the respondents further states that even if there is medical report contrary to the reports of the respondents, the applicant is not entitled for any relief as this issue no more res- integra. While deciding the prayer of the petitioner for re- medical on the ground that subsequent medical opinion by other doctors was in the favour of the petitioner, various Hon'ble High Courts was pleased to decline the relief in the favour of the petitioner(s):-

    (i) Vijender Singh Vs Commisinoer of Police, W.P (C) No.3830/2019

    (ii) Rajesh Kumar VS Union of India LPASW No.105/2014,Manu/JK/0017/2015,

    6.8 Learned counsel for the respondents states that even if it is not serious ailment and the petitioner performed well in the physical tests, the Hon'ble Court cannot strike down a policy decision merely because it feels that another decision would have been fairer or wiser or more scientific or logical. Once no malafide are attributed and the Doctors of the force who are well aware of the demand of the duties of the forces, opinion of private / other Government Doctor cannot be accepted.

    6.9 Subsequent cure cannot be accepted as it is matter of fact at the time of original medical examination the

    9

    applicant was found medical unfit on the ground of ailment.

    (i) Amardeep Singh VS Union of India, W.P ( C ) No. 7711/2011 , Manu/ DE/6685/2011,

    (ii) Ashish Kumar Pandey Vs Union of India, W.P ( C ) No. 5847/2021

    (iii) Sharvan Kumar Rai Vs Union of India and Ors. W.P ( C ) No. 4558 /2020

    (iv) Sumit Vs Union of India , LPA No. 871/2022

    (v) Rishi Bhardwaj Vs union of India, W.P ( C ) No. 4743/ 2021 , MANU/DE/2367/2021

    (vi) Sonu Vs Union of India , W.P ( C ) No. 9669/2020, MANU/DE/0584/2021

    (vii) 13.1, 13.2, 14.2, 16.15and 21.1, W.P ( C ) No. 5712/2021, MANU/DE/2377/2021

    6.10 Concluding his arguments, learned counsel for the respondents states that so far, the issue of tattoos is concerned the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi and also the Hon'ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana was pleased to upheld the term of the advertisement.

    (i) Monu Vs Union of India and Ors. CWP No. 23003/2021

    6.11 That in absence of any rule no re- medical be conducted.

    (i) Tej Prakash Vs Union of India, W. P No. 14645/2022, Hon'ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Gwalior.

    (ii) Shiv Kumar Dwivedi Vs State of U.P, Writ A No. 32826/1993

    (iii) Shankar Raju Vs Union of India , W.P ( C) No.

    311/2019

    10

    7. ANALYSIS :- Having heard learned counsels for the parties at length and after perusing the written arguments filed by the respondents along with relevant case laws, we would deal the issue in hand as detailed hereto.

    7.1 It is not a matter of dispute as per the terms and conditions stipulated in the advertisement as well as the medical standards prescribed in terms of Clause 13.2 of the advertisement "tattoo" by itself is neither a taboo nor an embargo.

    7.2 In fact, what has been spelt out in Clause 13.2 is that tattoos on various parts of body are 'permissible' as per the details given below:-

    "13.2.1 Content - Tatoos depicting religious symbol or figure and the name, as followed in Indian Army, shall be permitted.

    13.2.2 Location - Tattoos marked on traditional sites of the body like inner aspect of forearm, but only left forearm, being non saluting limb or dorsum of the hands shall be allowed.

    13.2.3 Size - Size must be less than ¼ of the particular part (Elbow or Hand) of the body."

    7.3 We also find that it is the content, location and size of tattoo which have been stipulated and permissible, which we have already reproduced herein-above.

    7.4 Illustratively, we take a case as we are dealing with a case of Deepak Yadav, We find impugned Review Medical

    11

    Examination has opined in its final opinion that the applicant is unfit on account of „Faded but visible tattoo on vertical aspect of right forearm".

    7.5 On bare perusal of medical opinion there is no clarity and medical assessment that such a tattoo is beyond the parameters to what has been spelt out in Clause 13.2. There is nothing on record to show as to whether any safeguards were taken by the respondents or guidelines were framed regarding the procedure to be followed while reviewing the case of applicant. Nothing has been placed on record as to show whether the Review Medical Board was conscious of the fact about the such guidelines. Closely looking at the provisions as contended by the respondents bare perusal of the report itself, neither any observation has been made by the assessing doctors regarding the fact whether the applicant does not fall within the for corners of acceptability of the tattoo, i.e., content, location and size. Had such guidelines be framed prior at the time even assuming the tattoos, the applicants have to be rejected on the ground that they are having tattoo on the right arm. Necessary instructions ought to have been followed by the respondents by giving standard guidelines to the assessing officers to form a definite opinion whether the tattoo falls within the parameters, as stipulated in the advertisement itself. Ideally, it would have been that at initial stage itself in the application form there had been a declaration regarding the details of medical condition(s) or with regard to tattoo which could have been also

    12

    accompanied by a postcard size photograph to be signed by the candidate with name. Particularly, giving the size, language and significant of tattoo. Such declaration, ought to have been mandated at the initial stage itself. These guidelines ought to have been framed and would have been provided or notified at the time of advertisement itself.

    7.6 "Acceptability of tattoo" as a policy matter of permanent body of tattoo of the candidates aspiring to join the Delhi Police is not in dispute.

    7.8 From the angle of Delhi Police (Appointment and Recruitment Rules), 1980, we find the conditions prescribed in Rule 24 (2), which reads as under:-

    "24. Medical examination of candidates-

    (2) The medical examination shall be conducted in accordance with the instructions contained in Appendix-

    XXX. The medical officer shall test the eye sight, speech and hearing of the candidate, his freedom from physical defects, organic or contagious disease, his age or any other defects or tendency likely to render him unfit for police service. Candidate shall be rejected for any disease or defect likely to render them unfit for the duties of a police officer at any stage."

    7.9 It is very much clear that functional disability of a candidate has to be seen as the Delhi Police is a disciplined force. A strict parameters in so far as medical fitness in terms of Rule 24 (2) read with Appendix have to be followed. No such guidelines qua the tattoo have been assigned nor it is the case of the respondents themselves that the tattoos on various parts of body are not permissible. The instructions provide for giving a

    13

    finding in review medicial examination as to whether the applicant is "fit", "temproray unfit" or "unfit". There is no finding to said effect in re-view examination qua that the nature of tatoo is such that is to say "for any disease or defect likely to render them unfit for the duties of a police officer at any stage". The report is in a standard format without even dealing with any column of

    "temporary unfit". The review has been conducted in a mechanical manner.

    7.10 Learned counsel for the respondents has made an endeavor to pursue us by citing many case laws and tried to distinguish the present case of the applicant not only on the basis of the analogy that the terms and conditions are sacrosanct but also on the fact that various decisions rendered by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi relied upon by the applicant's counsel are directory in nature and does not lay down the law. He made an effort to clearly make out a case the order(s)/judgements passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi may be binding precedent over the other High Courts is not accordance with law of the land. The various decisions cited are as under:-

    (a) The judgment passed by Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in R/Special Civil Application No. 24720 of 2022 dated 08.12.2022 in the matter of

    Mahendra Chawla vs. Union of India.

    14

    (b) The judgement passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) No. 12184/2021 dated 26.11.2021 in the case of Vikash Kumar vs. Director General, Indo- Tibetan Border Police Force & Ors.

    (c) The judgment passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in W.P. (S) No. 4672/2023 dated 15.02.2024 in the matter of Pawan Kumar Mahto vs. Union of India.

    (d) The judgment passed by the Principal Bench of CAT in OA No. 327/2015 dated 15.10.2010 in the matter of Neeraj Kumar Malik vs. Staff Selection Commission.

    (e) The judgment passed by the Principal Bench of CAT in OA No. 121/2015 dated 09.08.2018 in the matter of Pankaj Beniwal vs. Staff Selection Commission.

    (f) The judgement passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) No. 1341/2021 dated 27.05.2021 in the case of Pooja vs. Union of India and ors. The aforesaid cases are the cases where distinction is sought to be made and also emphasis has been laid that the cases of tattoo has also been rejected. We do not dispute the proposition, the terms and conditions are sacrosanct, as held by catena of judgments not only by the Hon'ble High Court but also by Hon'ble Apex Court, which are binding upon the parties.

    15

    7.11 The case law relied upon by the respondents does not help the case of the respondents. We have also dealt with detailed aspect of re-medical examination while dealing with issue of visual acuity in terms of not only rules of instructions but also categorisation in OA No.823/2024- Salman"s case - batch cases. The relevant extracts are as re-produced as under :-

    "15.1 The procedure to be followed for recruitment to new appointments by laying the prescribed standards have to be in consonance with FR 10 read with Supplementary Rules 3, 4 and 4-A and Rules position thereto as the user department i.e Delhi Police falls within the administrative control and overall supervision of Ministry of Home affairs, Union of India.

    15.2 PART II :CHAPTER III of Fundamental Rules prescribe the GENERAL CONDITION OF SERVICE:

    F.R. 10 - Except as provided by this rule, no person may be appointed in India to a post in Government service without a medical certificate of health. The Central Government may make rules prescribing the form in which medical certificates should be prepared, and the particular medical or other officers by whom they should be signed. It may, in individual cases, dispense with the production of a certificate, and may by general orders exempt any specified class of Government servants from the operation of this rule. [ For rules made under the Fundamental Rule 10, Ref Supplementary Rules 3, 4 and 4- A]

    15.3 CATEGORIES FOR REPORTING THE

    FINDINGS BI' MEDICAL AUTHORITIES .The findings of the examining medical authority shall fit; recorded under one of the following three categories only :—

    (1 ) Fit

    (2) Unfit

    (3) Temporarily unfit.

    16

    15.4 RULES UNDER F.R. 10 & GOVT. OF INDIA

    ORDERS, prescribe that A medical certificate of fitness for Government service shall be in the following form :-

    `°I hereby certify that I have examined A.B.Candidate for employment in the _____________________Department, and cannot discover that do not consider wise), constitutional weakness or bodily infirmity exceptthis a disqualification for employment in the office of _______________."

    15.5 In the case of a female candidate appointed to a non- gazetted post (i) in Delhi the medical certificate shall be signed by an Assistant Surgeon Grade I (Woman) under the Contributory Health Service Scheme; and (ii) in any other place by a registered female medical practitioner possessing a medical qualification in- cluded in one of the schedules to the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (102 of 1956) (Indian Medical Central Act, 1970 and Homoeopathy Central Coun-cil Act,

    1973).

    15.6 In cases where the :rules for recruitment to new appointments -prescribe a fresh medical examination in respect of all candidates, all directly recruited/selected candidates, irrespective of whether they arc already in permanent or quasi-perma- nent Government service in the same or in other departments or are fresh appointees, should undergo a medical examination by the prescribed standard and by the prescribed medical authority, provided that a fresh medical examination will not be necessary in the case of—

    (a) a person who has already been medically examined -by the prescribed medical standard and the appropriate medical authority, irrespective of the fact whether that person was permanent, quasi-permanent or :temporary in his previous appointment, and

    (b) a person who is already in permanent, or quasi-permanent employ in the same line, and being eligible for promotion to the new appointment against -a promotion -quota of

    17

    vacancies, is actually so promoted. Exemptions ;under Supplementary Rule 4-A will continue to be granted in the same way as at present by the Ministry of Finance in consultation, where necessary, with the Ministries of Home Affairs and Health.[MOF. OM No. F.53 (8) -V/50, dated the 5th October, 1950 No. F.55 (11) -E.V/59, dated the 12th February, 1960, and No. F.15 (1) - EN (B) t!6.2 dated the 5th July, 1962 and U.O. No. 3617-E.(V)/B/63 dated the 25th January, 1964.]

    " ************

    15.8 We do not have any doubt in our mind that as a normal course, in cases where the :rules for recruitment to new appointments -prescribe a fresh medical examination in respect of all candidates, all directly recruited/selected candidates, irrespective of whether they are already in permanent or quasi-permanent Government service in the same or in other departments or are fresh appointees, should undergo a medical examination by the prescribed standard and by the prescribed medical authority. (MM. of Health OM No F'.5(11)-12/57 M-II (Pt. II) dated the 17th December, 1957), which cannot be overlooked that mandates a second appeal shall be permissible in doubtful cases and under very special circumstances.

    15.9 The present cases fall in category of doubtful cases and under very special circumstances in as much as firstly , the review medical board has been constituted within short span of time for the candidates who have come under zone of consideration in select list amongst large number of aspirants after crossing all stages of selection process and their candidature."

    In present case, one more aspect also needs to be seen is that the rejection is shown only with the aspect of "fit" or "unfit".

    However, specifically, the rules of the instructions prescribed that category of reporting of finding by the medical authorities and examining by it shall record one of the categories - "fit",

    18

    "unfit" or "temporarily fit. " (Ref : Tattoo can be removed-

    W.P.(C) 1762/2024, titled Sachin Kuman Vs. Union of India and Ors. and W.P.(C) 1789/2024, titled

    Dnyaneshwar DevarsheVs. Union of India and Ors. decided on 07.02.2024).

    7.12 The medical re-assessment illustratively has highlighted above has already given finding with respect to either fit or unfit. No finding as to whether the applicant is temporarily unfit has been given, more particularly, in light of the fact when the tattoos itself are permissible. What are the grounds of rejection when it has not been spelt out either in the form of dimension or otherwise.

    7.13 When there is no definite finding as to whether the tattoo is beyond the prescribed parameters, the review medical examination is not conclusive proof of the applicant be declared unfit which tattoo's are permissible. We find that neither is a tattoo a nature of ailment nor a medical condition, which will affect the functionality and working as a Constable, of course, with a stipulation of the size/dimension, contents and language used thereto as stipulated in the advertisement.

    8. In pursuit to inquisitiveness and understanding , the concept of "Tattoo" , It's roots would reveal that the word tattoo, or tattow in the 18th century, is a loan word from the Samoan word tatau, meaning "to strike". The Oxford English Dictionary gives the etymology of tattoo as "In 18thc.

    19

    tattaow, tattow. From Polynesian (Samoan, Tahitian, Tongan, etc.) tatau. The American Academy of

    Dermatology distinguishes five types of tattoos: traumatic tattoos that result from injuries, such as asphalt from road injuries or pencil lead; amateur tattoos; professional tattoos, both via traditional methods and modern tattoo machines; cosmetic tattoos, also known as "permanent makeup"; and medical tattoos.

    "Tattoo culture have been around India since ancient times within the lower stratum or tribes."What was initially considered taboo in Indian culture became a trending fashion in recent years."

    Tattooing was practiced among the rival tribes to avoid the abduction of women from their community. It was a safe way protective cover. The Singhpo tribe followed a set of rules on tattooing for both men and women. The unmarried girls are not allowed to get tattooed and the married folk are allowed to wear tattoos on specific parts of their body. Tattoos are mostly used for tribal identity in the region during war times. One of the tribes in Orissa believed that getting tattooed with beautiful geometric facial tattoos helps them recognize each other once they enter the spirit world. They were called as "People Of Spirit World". In some regions it is believed that the god of death — Yama's displeasure and condemnation can be invoked in the absence of tattoos. (Ref: -Tracking Tattoo Culture From Indian Tradition to High Fashion article by Suja Dinesh, May 15, 2017 -Contemporary, Heritage, Voices)

    20

    Ink Of Life: An Artist Archiving India's Indigenous Tattoos- An article written by Mumbai-based tattoo artist Shomil Shah's (The Outlook Traveller magizine )- India Ink Archive aims to document and make accessible what remains of this ancient art form -

    "marked the beginning of India Ink Archive - a rich repository of stories, and a visual archive of India's indigenous tattoo traditions, deep under our skin and in our memories."

    7.15 To conclude, we draw a reference to observations of the Hon'ble Apex Court in W.P.(C) No. 444/2019 dated 10.10.2023 in the matter of Dharmvir Singh vs. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr., reads as under:-

    "it is true that the petitioner was examined twice and was found to be medically unfit. However, considering the nature of ailment and medical condition, the issue appears to be remediable and not permanent in nature."

    "15. Accordingly, the petition is allowed and the respondents are directed to again convene the Medical Board for re-examination of the petitioners and offer them appointment, if they are found fit to perform the duties of Constable GD in terms of the revised guidelines of 2015. The needful shall be done within a period of three months from the date a certified copy of this judgment is made available with the concerned respondent(s)."

    7.16 "In modern times, youth would not have imagined thirst for "mark of ink " would have lead to a quest to a legal war for securing life.". We find that there is no bar for re- consideration of case of the applicant(s), who are having tattoo for second medical re-examination.

    8. CONCLUSION :-

    In view of the above, we dispose of the present OA(s) by directing the respondents to get the applicant(s) re-medical

    21

    examination done by a duly constituted Medical Board which would include dermatologist who shall opinion in light of Clause

    13.2 as to arrive at a just conclusion whether the applicant(s) are functionally fit for appointment to post of Constable in Delhi Police. It is directed that the re-medical examination shall be undertaken within a period of 12 weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. Further, the respondents are directed to convey the decision to the respective applicant(s). In the event, the applicant(s) are found to be fit, further action shall be taken in accordance with law. No order as to costs.

    (Dr. Chhabilendra Roul) (Manish Garg) Member (A) Member (J)

    /akshaya/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DEEPAK YADAV v. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION (SSC)
    (Apr 22, 2024)